— A.L. Central thoughts from a White Sox fanatic and baseball zealot
Indians Today, March 24, 2006
And then there were three. The Tribe sent Andrew Brown and Fausto Carmona to Triple-A Buffalo Wednesday, thinning out the competition for the final spot in the bullpen. Carmona was never more than a longshot to make the club out of Spring Training despite a 0.75 exhibition ERA, but some people *COUGH*me*COUGH* had Brown penciled in as the favorite. It looks like it’s now a three-way race between Jason Davis, Steve Karsay, and Danny Graves for work as the sixth righty out of the pen.
The man who once dubbed himself The Franchise is losing ground in his fight to win the utility infielder job. Brandon Phillips has been on the shelf all week with a viral infection, giving Ramon Vazquez a clear shot at winning the job. The franchise is out of options on The Franchise, meaning his days as an Indian are likely numbered if he doesn’t make the team. Fan favorite and folk hero Lou Merloni is also hanging around camp, but he’s a 35-year-old who hasn’t played shortstop regularly in three years, and is coming off a major injury. Loumer’s only going to make the team if Bob Wickman gets hungry and eats the other utilityguys.
Speaking of which, Andy Call reports in the Canton Repository that Wickman lost some weight over the winter (Registration required). Wick says he lost 10 or 12 pounds, but the real story here is that Wickman says that last year was great and fun. We agree, Bob, but it was only great and fun when you weren’t in the game.
Wickman wasn’t the only Indian that drove me absolutely insane last year. Somehow, Ben Broussard will return as the everyday first baseman this year, and the Plain Dealer’s Dennis Manoloff reports he’s got a whole new approach. Broussard says he’s watching video and keeping a journal. Hey, anything to avoid getting benched again in favor of Jeff Liefer.
Jason Michaels is excited. He’s got an everyday job for the first time, and he says he’s eager to prove he belongs. Michaels says he doesn’t want to get labeled a platoon player, and who can blame him? Of course, it’s much easier to win an everyday job when your main competition is from Todd Hollandsworth and Jason Dubois.
The Sportstime Ohio train is chugging along slowly but surely. STO added Comcast in Lake and Lorain Counties this week, as well as Cox in the western suburbs of Cleveland. That brings them up to 1.7 million subscribers out of the 2.8 million they’re aiming for. Columbus is still largely in the dark, as two of the three cable systems in the capital city have yet to come to an agreement to carry the Tribe.
Mark Shapiro tells Indians.com’s Anthony Castrovince that he’s in position to make a high-profile trade this year, if necessary. With the payroll at about $55 million and the budget at $60 million, there’s plenty of wiggle room if the Indians need an impact player at the trade deadline. Shapiro says he had planned to spend the money on free agents, but once his targets signed elsewhere, he wasn’t going to spend just for the sake of spending.
Ronnie Belliard is back in camp and ready to go (RR) after his adventure on the Dominican Republic’s bench at the World Baseball Classic. Sheldon Ocker reports Belliard asked Eric Wedge to play in every inning of every exhibition game the rest of the way, but that’s not likely with the positional battle going on between Vazquez and Phillips.
Eric Wedge either: knows something we don’t, is dumb, is trying an unusual motivational technique, or has some sort of brain damage. With just more than a week left before the start of the season, Einar Diaz and Kelly Shoppach are in a dead heat for the backup catcher job (RR). Diaz hasn’t had an OPS+ above 61 since 2001, but is apparently using the same Vulcan mind control technique that he’s used for the last ten years to stay in the running for a job. A dollar says his luck runs out this year.
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
Good lord, it's gotta be Davis, right? I mean they wouldn't actually put Graves in the pen would they?
Have fun in Florida.
Good lord, it's gotta be Davis, right? I mean they wouldn't actually put Graves in the pen would they?
Yeah, you'd think so. I wouldn't have a huge problem with Karsay getting the job, if he's healthy. As I see it, it's a battle between a guy we know can't pitch (Graves), a guy who sort of looks like maybe he can't pitch (Davis), and a guy who's always been very, very good when healthy (Karsay).
Actually, I'd rather they go with 11 pitchers and keep an extra bat off the bench.
Expected move?
Expected move?
Yeah, absolutely. Boone's under contract for this year at $3.75M, so he always had the inside line on the job.
I think the plan is that if Boone plays well, that's great - they get one more year of Marte on the back end. If Boone tanks, they'll reassess, but my hunch is they'll at least make an effort to make it to about the beginning of August before giving Marte the job. That way they can avoid Super 2 status.
And as much as it causes me physical discomfort to say, Boone was actually halfway decent in August and September last year.
Great quote from that article in the PD:
Broussard's struggles last season forced him to acknowledge that the pitchers evidently knew more than he did when it came to their confrontations
How can Graves get a job in our pen? Does Shapiro/Wedge not remember the Tribe absolutely crushing him last year? He had absolutely nothing. Frankly, Jason Davis doesn't exactly make me feel much better than Graves. I am fearing this season's bullpen. We are going from the most dominant pen in the game to one that makes me very nervous. If only Cabrera could pitch every relief inning I'd be a happy man.
I have actually been somewhat underwhelmed by the offseason Shapiro has had. The Michaels/Rhodes deal was a good one and the Marte/Crisp trade probably is too, but this team still has some huge holes at 1B, RF, and maybe 3B that just weren't addressed. There is little chance of the pitching staff matching what they did last year and we seem to be banking on winning more 1-run games and the White Sox regressing.
You obviously haven't heard his album.
Okay, actually that's a bit harsh. It's halfway decent but nothing all that great or memorable...much like his baseball career.
Nope but it wouldn't suprise me.
I still think he's the last one I'd like to see, but I've got faith in Shapiro and company.
Another thing to note is that I assume - despite Graves being (I would assume) the mopup man every game this year will matter. It would not surprise me that in October one of the Twins, ChiSox or Indians finish 1 game out of first. Every game that Graves is on your roster instead of a presumptively better pitcher like Brown or Davis makes it more likely that they will lose that game, and that game may be the difference between golfing and playing baseball in October.
According to the must-read Hey Hoynsie column in Sunday's PD:
"Graves, at the moment, is the reliever to beat. "
*sigh*
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main