User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
Page rendered in 0.7113 seconds
64 querie(s) executed
|
| |||||||||
Dialed In — Tuesday, July 11, 2006Defensive Rankings by Position- American LeagueThe following data represent the defensive rankings for the American League players by position, with a minimum of 200 innings played. RSpt is Runs Saved for the playing time of the player above average for that much playing time. RS/150 is how many runs that would be in 150 games played. This is explained in the methodology here.Catchers Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 2 Ramon Hernandez BAL 77 74 638.3 5 11 2 Ivan Rodriguez DET 65 64 563.3 5 12 2 Gerald Laird TEX 31 26 236.3 4 23 2 Joe Mauer MIN 65 64 568.7 3 6 2 Jason Kendall OAK 72 72 647.3 2 5 2 Jose Molina LAA 41 40 337.0 2 9 2 Kenji Johjima SEA 81 74 659.7 2 5 2 Jorge Posada NYY 72 64 563.7 1 3 2 Vance Wilson DET 29 24 227.7 1 7 2 Rod Barajas TEX 62 62 540.7 1 3 2 John Buck KCR 63 60 519.3 0 1 2 Mike Napoli LAA 45 37 349.7 0 0 2 Paul Bako KCR 33 27 237.3 0 0 2 Gregg Zaun TOR 36 30 276.7 0 0 2 Jason Varitek BOS 68 64 569.3 0 -1 2 A.J. Pierzynski CHW 73 69 631.0 -1 -2 2 Toby Hall TBD 61 55 494.0 -1 -3 2 Josh Paul TBD 32 27 233.7 -1 -8 2 Kelly Stinnett NYY 31 22 205.7 -2 -10 2 Bengie Molina TOR 58 57 486.3 -4 -12 2 Victor Martinez CLE 77 73 644.7 -7 -15 First Base Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 3 Chris Shelton DET 86 82 737.0 12 21 3 Kendry Morales LAA 42 40 364.7 5 19 3 Doug Mientkiewicz KCR 82 74 656.7 5 11 3 Andy Phillips NYY 59 36 366.7 4 14 3 Justin Morneau MIN 81 80 707.7 2 4 3 Travis Lee TBD 69 57 518.3 2 6 3 Lyle Overbay TOR 72 71 620.7 2 4 3 Dan Johnson OAK 69 67 612.7 0 1 3 Kevin Youkilis BOS 77 72 623.0 0 -1 3 Mark Teixeira TEX 86 86 757.7 0 -1 3 Jeff Conine BAL 52 35 332.7 0 -2 3 Ben Broussard CLE 71 51 491.3 -1 -3 3 Richie Sexson SEA 87 86 758.7 -2 -4 3 Kevin Millar BAL 53 53 423.3 -3 -9 3 Jason Giambi NYY 44 44 337.0 -6 -26 3 Paul Konerko CHW 82 81 692.7 -9 -18 Second Base Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 4 Placido Polanco Det 74 73 652.0 12 25 4 Mark Grudzielanek KC 77 77 648.7 9 18 4 Brian Roberts Bal 68 67 586.7 9 20 4 Marco Scutaro Oak 34 30 277.7 6 29 4 Mark DeRosa Tex 26 26 223.7 5 33 4 Aaron Hill Tor 51 51 442.3 5 15 4 Mark Ellis Oak 52 51 447.3 2 7 4 Rob. Cano NYY 69 68 602.0 2 5 4 Ian Kinsler Tex 46 44 386.7 0 2 4 Ty Wigginton TB 39 33 297.3 -2 -10 4 Mark Loretta Bos 82 79 701.0 -2 -4 4 Jose Lopez Sea 86 85 757.0 -3 -4 4 Tad. Iguchi CWS 72 72 648.3 -4 -8 4 Adam Kennedy LAA 80 76 679.7 -5 -10 4 Ronnie Belliard Cle 83 81 711.3 -7 -13 4 Luis Castillo Min 75 75 647.3 -9 -20 4 Jorge Cantu TB 44 44 388.0 -10 -36 Third Base Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 5 Mike Lowell BOS 83 80 700.0 16 31 5 Brandon Inge DET 85 83 749.0 10 18 5 Adrian Beltre SEA 87 87 770.0 4 7 5 Tony Graffanino KCR 26 25 207.3 3 20 5 Dallas McPherson LAA 29 25 221.3 2 15 5 Hank Blalock TEX 83 82 727.7 2 4 5 Joe Crede CHW 84 81 705.0 2 3 5 Aubrey Huff TBD 60 60 480.7 2 4 5 Troy Glaus TOR 77 72 632.7 -1 -1 5 Alex Rodriguez NYY 83 83 737.3 -2 -3 5 Eric Chavez OAK 72 72 642.0 -3 -6 5 Aaron Boone CLE 80 79 682.0 -3 -6 5 Chone Figgins LAA 29 27 237.3 -3 -19 5 Mark Teahen KCR 56 52 465.3 -4 -11 5 Melvin Mora BAL 88 88 755.3 -5 -9 5 Tony Batista MIN 50 50 434.0 -7 -21 Shortstop Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 6 Juan Uribe CHW 75 70 632.0 10 21 6 Alex Gonzalez BOS 68 67 591.3 6 13 6 Bobby Crosby OAK 77 77 677.0 5 9 6 Carlos Guillen DET 79 78 680.0 4 7 6 Tomas Perez TBD 25 23 200.3 2 15 6 Orlando Cabrera LAA 84 84 724.7 2 4 6 Jason Bartlett MIN 23 23 203.0 2 11 6 Julio Lugo TBD 60 59 516.3 2 4 6 Michael Young TEX 87 87 761.0 1 2 6 Russ Adams TOR 36 31 271.0 0 2 6 Jhonny Peralta CLE 84 83 729.3 0 0 6 Yuni. Betancourt SEA 87 87 759.3 -1 -3 6 Aaron Hill TOR 34 31 281.7 -2 -11 6 Juan Castro MIN 50 48 408.0 -5 -15 6 Miguel Tejada BAL 83 83 719.7 -5 -10 6 Derek Jeter NYY 78 78 680.0 -6 -12 6 Angel Berroa KCR 80 79 687.7 -9 -18 Left Field Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 7 Carl Crawford TBD 82 80 702.7 7 14 7 Emil Brown KCR 69 67 574.7 4 10 7 Marcus Thames DET 32 32 244.7 3 17 7 Reed Johnson TOR 56 32 328.0 3 11 7 Nick Swisher OAK 65 63 573.7 3 6 7 Craig Monroe DET 59 52 474.3 2 7 7 Lew Ford MIN 40 24 240.7 2 13 7 Raul Ibanez SEA 86 86 768.7 2 4 7 Jeff Conine BAL 33 32 256.3 1 4 7 Scott Podsednik CHW 79 73 669.0 1 1 7 Garret Anderson LAA 60 60 518.0 1 1 7 Shannon Stewart MIN 34 34 286.0 1 2 7 Jason Michaels CLE 62 61 539.0 -1 -2 7 Hideki Matsui NYY 30 30 251.0 -1 -8 7 Frank Catalanotto TOR 61 55 433.0 -3 -10 7 Melky Cabrera NYY 46 45 401.7 -5 -17 7 Brad Wilkerson TEX 67 66 572.3 -6 -14 7 Manny Ramirez BOS 82 82 685.3 -12 -23 Center Field Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 8 Vernon Wells TOR 81 79 689.0 8 16 8 Corey Patterson BAL 80 71 639.0 7 15 8 Torii Hunter MIN 84 84 730.7 6 11 8 Brian Anderson CHW 68 54 490.0 5 15 8 Johnny Damon NYY 72 71 607.3 5 10 8 Curtis Granderson DET 86 80 738.0 4 7 8 Grady Sizemore CLE 87 87 755.3 3 6 8 Darin Erstad LAA 27 25 220.7 3 20 8 Chone Figgins LAA 40 37 332.0 1 5 8 Joey Gathright TBD 68 62 546.0 1 1 8 David DeJesus KCR 36 33 281.7 0 -1 8 Jeremy Reed SEA 64 55 507.3 -2 -5 8 Rocco Baldelli TBD 27 25 233.0 -2 -12 8 Willie Bloomquist SEA 26 23 200.3 -2 -14 8 Mark Kotsay OAK 78 76 680.3 -2 -5 8 Rob Mackowiak CHW 43 34 308.0 -3 -14 8 Coco Crisp BOS 44 43 390.7 -5 -17 8 Gary Matthews TEX 73 72 628.7 -8 -16 Right Field Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 9 Alex Rios TOR 70 59 547.7 5 13 9 Ichiro Suzuki SEA 88 88 778.7 4 7 9 Bobby Kielty OAK 27 25 231.0 4 24 9 Mark DeRosa TEX 29 29 251.0 4 22 9 Casey Blake CLE 60 60 526.3 3 6 9 Reggie Sanders KCR 61 58 495.7 2 6 9 Vlad. Guerrero LAA 78 78 661.7 1 3 9 Milton Bradley OAK 27 27 232.0 1 7 9 Jay Payton OAK 39 36 330.0 1 4 9 Damon Hollins TBD 55 34 341.7 1 3 9 Nick Markakis BAL 56 32 321.3 0 -1 9 Magglio Ordonez DET 79 79 696.0 -1 -1 9 Russell Branyan TBD 40 32 264.3 -1 -7 9 Trot Nixon BOS 75 68 610.7 -2 -5 9 Jerm. Dye CHW 78 77 662.0 -2 -5 9 Jay Gibbons BAL 44 44 349.7 -3 -11 9 Michael Cuddyer MIN 67 62 560.7 -3 -7 9 Kevin Mench TEX 52 52 447.7 -6 -18 9 Bernie Williams NYY 43 39 326.0 -6 -26 For outfielders, there is presently no added bonus for throwing runners out. At this point in the season, there are very few outside of +/- 1.1 runs. Most are less than that. The exceptions are: Melky Cabrera (+1.4) and Frank Catalanotto (+1.3). |
My BookmarksYou must be logged in to view your Bookmarks. Hot Topics |
||||||||
|
About Baseball Think Factory | Write for Us | Copyright © 1996-2008 Baseball Think Factory
User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
|
| Page rendered in 0.7113 seconds | |||||||
Reader Comments and Retorts
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
Smart move, ghost-buster. Now go and get another reliever.
I've always thought he was halfway decent, and it appears the numbers back me up.
He's only been at second for 22 games, so we'll have a better handle on this at the end of the year.
First Base
Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150 UZR
3 Chris Shelton DET 86 82 737.0 12 21 12
3 Kendry Morales LAA 42 40 364.7 5 19 20
3 Doug Mientkiewicz KCR 82 74 656.7 5 11 12
3 Kevin Millar BAL 53 53 423.3 -3 -9 -4
3 Jason Giambi NYY 44 44 337.0 -6 -26 -33
3 Paul Konerko CHW 82 81 692.7 -9 -18 -9
Second Base
Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150
4 Placido Polanco Det 74 73 652.0 12 25 21
4 Mark Grudzielanek KC 77 77 648.7 9 18 22
4 Brian Roberts Bal 68 67 586.7 9 20 14
4 Ronnie Belliard Cle 83 81 711.3 -7 -13 -7
4 Luis Castillo Min 75 75 647.3 -9 -20 -24
4 Jorge Cantu TB 44 44 388.0 -10 -36 -30
Third Base
Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150
5 Mike Lowell BOS 83 80 700.0 16 31 28
5 Brandon Inge DET 85 83 749.0 10 18 8
5 Adrian Beltre SEA 87 87 770.0 4 7 6
5 Mark Teahen KCR 56 52 465.3 -4 -11 -12
5 Melvin Mora BAL 88 88 755.3 -5 -9 -1
5 Tony Batista MIN 50 50 434.0 -7 -21 -20
Shortstop
Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150
6 Juan Uribe CHW 75 70 632.0 10 21 18
6 Alex Gonzalez BOS 68 67 591.3 6 13 15
6 Bobby Crosby OAK 77 77 677.0 5 9 6
6 Miguel Tejada BAL 83 83 719.7 -5 -10 -5
6 Derek Jeter NYY 78 78 680.0 -6 -12 -13
6 Angel Berroa KCR 80 79 687.7 -9 -18 -18
Left Field
Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150
7 Carl Crawford TBD 82 80 702.7 7 14 9
7 Emil Brown KCR 69 67 574.7 4 10 18
7 Marcus Thames DET 32 32 244.7 3 17 5
7 Melky Cabrera NYY 46 45 401.7 -5 -17 -16
7 Brad Wilkerson TEX 67 66 572.3 -6 -14 -5
7 Manny Ramirez BOS 82 82 685.3 -12 -23 -23
Center Field
Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150
8 Vernon Wells TOR 81 79 689.0 8 16 13
8 Corey Patterson BAL 80 71 639.0 7 15 14
8 Torii Hunter MIN 84 84 730.7 6 11 8
8 Rob Mackowiak CHW 43 34 308.0 -3 -14 -20
8 Coco Crisp BOS 44 43 390.7 -5 -17 -24
8 Gary Matthews TEX 73 72 628.7 -8 -16 -3
Right Field
Pos First Last Team GP GS INN RSpt RS/150
9 Alex Rios TOR 70 59 547.7 5 13 -1
9 Ichiro Suzuki SEA 88 88 778.7 4 7 5
9 Bobby Kielty OAK 27 25 231.0 4 24 19
9 Michael Cuddyer MIN 67 62 560.7 -3 -7 -14
9 Kevin Mench TEX 52 52 447.7 -6 -18 -4
9 Bernie Williams NYY 43 39 326.0 -6 -26 -28
R. Adams has been the worst (he and M. Young) defensive SS in baseball for several years now, according to UZR. I also have him as better at SS this year than 2B, but in such a small sample, it doesn't mean anything (48 chances at 2B and 83 at SS). I haven't seen him play much over the years, but given his UZR numbers, I would think that he is a statue at any IF position. 3B may be better suited to him, although I don't know what his arm is like.
BTW, what do Manny's supporters think about his defense these days? Have y'all accepted that he's probably a true -25 yet?
Where can I get gb/fb numbers for pitchers? If I'm not mistaken, Boston's staff has more fb guys than gbs. Not a great combination with our OF defense.
Does anyone actually support Manny's defense? I think the real debate was whether any player could be -40, if I remember correctly. I think the consensus was that he's probably more around -25... and lo and behold.
From Hardball Times (hopefully the formatting works)
R/G ERA FIP DER LD% GB% IF/Fly K/G BB/G HR/G HR/Fly SLG LOB%BOS 4.80 4.54 4.62 .701 18% 42% 12% 6.9 3.1 1.3 13% .436 72%
They appear to be about average in GB%, allow a fairly low LD% and a lot of IF%.
Thanks for this, Chris.
Oh, yeah, I guess that wasn't the argument. IMHO, it's possible for someone as bad as manny to be a true talent -25 and also put up a -40 season (which at 10 runs per SD is only 1.5 SDs below his true talent - equivalent to a hitter stinking a la paul konerko 2003). but that's neither here nor there. I also recall being frustrated that my position was ridiculed as if I believed he was a true talent -40, which no one that I'm aware of has ever said.
I think the true question is whether it's possible to be -40 in left field. Given that Bernie and Griffey frequently grade out that poorly or worse while playing outfield, and no one questions those rankings, seems possible to me. If its possible to do, Manny's the guy to do it :)
Is the same true for his NL rankings? Any disagreement between the systems that stands out there?
Again, thanks to both Chris and mgl for the work.
yeah i remember it pretty much the same way, but i would add that part of the debate was whether manny's "impossible" -40 uzr was a reason to throw uzr out the window entirely.
Paul Konerko 2003 seems like a good analogy for Manny's defense that year. I think if people saw it that way-- he's a very bad fielder who had a terrible year-- they might be less resistant to the idea. It's just hard to get one's head around the idea that a leftfielder could cost his team 40 runs in a season, especially with half his games in Fenway. Not saying it's wrong at all, just that it's a little counter-intuitive.
His arm is awful. It's the reason he moved to 2B from SS in the first place. The minor leagues may be better suited to him.
Everyone must keep in mind that a half year of UZR or Dial ratings can easily (10-20% of the players?) be far from their true defensive talent (such as Bonds and Crisp). In 50 or 100 chances, only 5 or 10 really make a difference. One player could have 5 easy to catch balls in any one zone and another player could have 5 hard to catch balls in that same zone.
catchers are based on CS, SBA, E, PB.
You are correct - it isn't a ZR-based rating.
Is it really possible that a 1Bman could be that much more valuable than the best defensive CF in the league?
yes. It says that teams are more willing to have a poor fielder at first base than they are in CF. So the overall talent in CF is closer than the talent is at 1B wrt fielding the position.
In general, I think 3B has the widest range of talent. Some teams believe it is a sluggers spot, defense be damned. Some teams believe it's a glove spot; some teams balance it.
Why not? Erstad hasn't played much, he's as good as Shelton on a per-game basis. And there are some real butchers -- Giambi, Konerko -- pulling the 1B average down. Throw in some random noise and we shouldn't be surprised.
Konerko's not that bad of a fielder. He doesn't have much range, but he makes the plays he needs to.
You'll find out very shortly.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main