2006 Philadelphia Phillies
NOTE: After writing about the Phillies for 42 years, I decided to try
something different. The names are about the same from last year's
essay and not a whole lot would change from last year's essay, so I
thought why should I have all the "fun.”
A rough framework was
created at the BR
Bullpen and the preview was written as a group by various Phillie
Phollowers. For all we know, Pat Gillick added some insights. After
the initial input, I read through the final version, did some edits,
added some comments and purtied it up a little for BTF. Only maybe
1/3rd of the words are mine, though it runs under my byline. You can
actually see the process this took. To see the essay's history of
changes go
here. To update and add new insights go
here and click edit. Big Thanks to PhillyBooster and the other
contributors. We should go to a game this summer and I'll buy you a
beer.
===2005===
As you likely know, the Phillies finished two games back of the Braves
and one game back of the pennant-winning Houston Astros with an 88-74
record, their best since 1993. The Astros' ascension proved
particularly painful for Phillies fans, who watched their team lose
six out of six games to the eventual NL champs (one particularly
scarring game involved a ninth-inning David Bell throwing error that
lead to Billy Wagner coughing up a home run to Craig Biggio, an event
that was a GIDP and a back spasm short of perfectly summarizing Bell's
tenure in Philadelphia).
No matter how hard they try (often a matter of contention in
Philadelphia), the Phillies can't get up over 90 wins. They've won
86, 80, 86, 86, and now 88 games over the last five years. 2004's
slightly above average season resulted in the firing of firebrand
manager Larry Bowa and the hiring of player favorite Charlie "Cholly"
Manuel, while 2005's slightly above average season resulted in the
firing of GM Ed Wade and the hiring of Pat Gillick, late of the
Seattle Mariners.
====What went right in 2005====
Ryan Howard finally found PT and proved his worth. While many fans
clamored for the Phillies to trade Howard after a 2004 season that saw
him club 48 HRs between AA, AAA and the Majors (as he was blocked by
Jim Thome at 1st) keeping him in the organizational fold ultimately
proved clairvoyant, as Thome succumbed to injuries in 2005 (of course,
this likely had less to do with any particular amount of foresight on
Ed Wade's part, and more to do with a general organizational
philosophy in favor of letting young and promising players rot on the
bench or in sub-optimal roles. For more, see Madson, Ryan; Polanco,
Placido; and Gavin Floyd vs. Paul Abbott; and Utley, Chase). In any
event, Howard stepped in, played spectacularly down the stretch and
garnered Rookie of the Year honors. The sky's the limit in terms of
potential, and while a Sophomore Slump remains a possibility, a
sizzling March has many primed and expecting great things from Howard
in 2006.
Brett Myers converted all his talk into a very good season, based on
the addition of a cutter which got him tons of Ks. Always competitive,
always emotional, and (usually) in possession of excellent stuff,
Myers finally had the season many were hoping for after he outdueled
Mark Prior in his first Major League start. Affectionately known as
"Meathead" on certain Internet Boards, Myers' short temper and
combative attitude (not to mention boxing experience) make him, in
many ways, close to the consummate Philadelphia athlete. Maintaining
the progress he made last year likely makes him the Phillies best
starter; a step forward would catapult him into a realm of pitching
talent that Philadelphia has not seen since Curt Schilling.
Chase Utley finally got a full-time job and was probably the best
second baseman in the majors last year in my biased view. Pat Burrell
provided a reasonable, if not grat return on his contract and overall
the offense was strong finishing second in the NL in runs scored,
though adjusting for park probably knocks them down a couple of pegs.
An ordinary (if ERA+ is to be believed the Phillies were the fifth
best staff in the league) pitching staff was helped out by a strong
overall defense, esp. Bell and good numbers for Utley and the CF
platoon of Michaels and Lofton. They tied the Red Birds for second
best DER in the league last year. This trend should continue to take
heat off of the pitchers in 2006 with the addition of Rowand, Nunez,
and Victorino.
====What went wrong in 2005====
* Ugueth Urbina -- This happened during the 2005 post-season, but it
is never a good thing when your top setup man is under arrest for
attempted murder with gasoline and a machete.
* David Bell -- By the end of April, 2005, it was clear that the
Phillies had two above-average major-league starters at second base --
Placido Polanco and Chase Utley. Polanco had over 300 games at 3rd
base on his major league resume, while Utley had proven in AAA that he
was not cut out for the hot corner. The solution was obvious -- move
Polanco to third, bench Bell, and proceed to the postseason. Instead,
they traded Polanco for Ugueth Urbina, whose production could have
easily been replicated in-house, and is currently playing for the
Venezuelan Penal League.
* The Middle Relievers -- Coming out of Spring Training, the Phils
bullpen consisted of Tim Worrell, Terry Adams, Rheal Cormier, and
Pedro Liriano. Worrell went on the DL for mental health issues after
blowing several 8th inning leads, Pedro Liriano and Terry Adams were
ineffective and demoted to Scranton, while Rheal Cormier limped along
with an ERA around 6.00 for the whole season. Giving GM Ed Wade an
ineffective bullpen was like leaving a kid unattended in a candy
store. Sickness ensues. (see, Polanco for Urbina trade, above).
* Jim Thome's Injury -- Not that it happened, since Ryan Howard filled
the hole without missing a beat, but that it took so long to diagnose.
A notoriously slow starter, Thome's April struggles were not
identified as a major problem until he had already accumulated 242
plate appearances of sub-par first base.
===Catcher===
*Mike Lieberthal. Currently Philadelphia's longest-tenured athlete, is
well removed from hitting 31 HR (1999) as well as the very productive
.313/.373/.453 line he posted in 2003. An aged and somewhat-overpaid
catcher, the Phillies may actually be hard pressed to replace him when
he as expected rides off into the sunset. Carlos Ruiz is likely the
best in-house candidate, but he, alas, is no Saltymachamachia. His
OPS+s over the last three years are 119, 100, and 91. That's a
worrisome trend under the best of circumstances, but for a 34-year-old
catcher with over 1000 games in his knees, that's extremely bad.
While he was a perfectly good hitting catcher last year, he could
collapse, and if he does that puts more pressure on his backup, who is
…
*Sal Fasano. A career back-up catcher. If Lieberthal does fall apart,
it could get ugly. 11 homers in 160 ABs with the Orioles last year
earned him the title "little bit of pop." Never mind the fact that
those 160 ABs produced only 9 walks, or that he hadn't seen the major
leagues since one plate appearance in 2002. Sal replaces 38-year-old
erstwhile Phillies backup Todd Pratt, who signed a 1-year deal with
the Braves (meaning a 30/30 season is no doubt in short order). Also
of note is that Fasano moves to the front of pack for all-star fu
manchu.
===First Base===
*Ryan Howard has been hitting home runs at a rate of three home runs
for every two at bats this spring and looks ready for a monster
season. He has always reminded me a bit of David Ortiz. He'll be
scrutinized this year to see how he deals with lefties, as a .148 BA
(.421 OPS) in 61 ABs have led some to worry that he's got a fatal flaw
that can be exploited. I have no idea what his first base defense is
like. The Fielding Bible apparently has him near the top of the heap,
but that certainly goes against his body type. One other thing to
keep in mind before declaring him the next Fred Luderus
(Philadelphia's games leader at first base) is his age. After too
many years in the minors he will be entering his age 26 year with just
351 major league at bats.
===Second Base===
*Utley for MVP. Although the story of Chase Utley and the Phillies has
a happy ending, it is worth remembering how unnececssarily convoluted
his road to success was. At the start of 2005, the Phillies faced a
daily dilemma after Placido Polanco unexpectedly accepted arbitration:
how to split Bell, Utley and Polanco between 2B and 3B. A more
rational organization, or at least one with more intestinal fortitude,
might have simply gone with the arrangement that gave them the best
chance to win - Utley at second, Polanco at third, and Bell squarely
on the bench. Instead, the Phillies embarked on a torturous game of
musical chairs, before Ed Wade succumbed to the inevitable and traded
for a middle reliever (Ugueth Urbina, who went on to blow six saves
down the stretch before taking the express train to crazy town during
the off-season) dealing Polanco to the Tigers. Polanco went on to hit
.338, while David Bell mustered a lusty .200 against righthanders on
the season (more on him later).
What can we expect from Utley in 2006? 30 HR, 100 RBI, 100 R, 20 SB
and a .400 OBP don't seem out of the question. Production like that,
combined with (by most accounts) very good defense, would make an
excellent case again for Utley as the best second baseman in the
majors and a potential MVP candidate. As with Howard, keep in mind
that he enters his age 27 season with just 944 career at bats.
===Shortstop===
*Jimmy Rollins (J-Roll) -- Going into 2006, the only issue will be
"the streak" (currently at 36 games), which will almost certainly end
within the first week of the year. After that, the question will be
whether his play will justify his five-year/$40m contract, or whether
he was simply paid to continue to be the face of the Phillies in its
ad campaigns. With all his experience, it's easy to forget that
Rollins is only a month older than Chase Utley, and still has plenty
of time to have a breakout season (while also having plenty of time to
go Cristian Guzman, too). I'm not a big fan of the MVP voting
results, and I know that making comments about rankings down ballot is
a bit tedious, but is a hitting streak so important that Rollins
finishes tenth three slots ahead of Chase Utley?
*A-Gone (Alex Gonzalez, no, the other one) - You want to know how
important he is to his teams? His ESPN player page still shows him
wearing a Cubs hat. The Phillies are the fourth team he's played on
since then.
===Third Base===
*David Bell -- Bell's continuing back problems have kept him out of
Major League Spring Training camp for the most part, and it appears
unlikely he'll be ready by opening day. While in a vacuum many would
not see this as a problem, it is unclear that his backups will perform
significantly better. My scoresheet team has Bell as our starting
third baseman. My wife cackled wildly when I told her that. It is
going to be one of those years on the Beechhurst Beguilers, at least
until Alex Gordon comes up.
*Abraham Nunez -- Much like Alex Gonzalez, most Phillies fans aren't
exactly sure with Abraham Nunez they have signed. Is it the guy from
St. Louis and Pittsburgh, or that guy from Florida? That fact that
the Phils haves signed the better Abraham Nunez, however, does not
mean that he is an upgrade from David Bell.
*Tomas Perez -- Tomas Perez may be a great "club house guy", always
ready for a good pie-in-the-face trick, but it didn't warrant giving a
replacement level back-up a multi-year deal. This Spring, he has
passed through waivers, with no team willing to pay $700K for an
interchangeable part. He will either be traded, released, or start
the season as one of the highest paid Red Barons in Scranton.
===Outfield===
*Pat Burrell - Don't look now, but Pat Burrell's had two straight
years of offensive progress. He's a good bet to at least maintain his
previous level of offensive performance, and if he's ever going to
live up to the potential he showed during the last mid-term elections,
now would be the time. Back on the MVP vote. Burrell finished 7th in
2005. In 2002, his OPS+ was 149 in more plate appearances (compared
to 125 this year) and he finished 14th.
*Bobby Abreu - Abreu is hated by the talk-radio crowd as a non-hustler
and defensive liability. Irrespective of the sabremetric defensive
stats and Gold Glove, it is clear that Abreu has difficulty coming in
and going back on the ball. How it effects his zone rating is
irrelevant, as he simply looks ugly doing it. He turned 31 last year,
and his OPS+ dropped by 26 points to its lowest mark since he first
became a starter. He also was considerably worse in the second half
last year. He was on the block repeatedly during the off-season as
the only non-young player even remotely tradeable. Nobody offered much
for the remaining two years and $30m on his contract.
*Aaron Rowand - Aquired from the White Sox in the big Thome trade,
much of Rowand's value lies in his defensive play in CF. The Phillies
pitching staff contains three flyballers who started at least 13 games
last year, which would seem to bode well. But, one of them (Wolf) is
on the DL, and another (Tejada) really isn't a starter and was demoted
to start the season, and Ryan Franklin was sent to bullpen. Meanwhile
Myers, Lieber, Gavin Floyd, and especially Lidle and Ryan Madson are
groundball pitchers, so how much he helps is up for debate. That
said, my observational belief is that CBP plays very large in
centerfield and tight down the lines, so a grade A flycatcher in
center won't hurt. Offensively, he appears unlikely to repeat the
2004 season (.310/.361/.544), and really needs to get his OBP up over
.350 (career .337) to help the offense in a meaningful way.
*Victorino -- Shane Victorino was the International League Player of
the Year in 2005, putting up a .911 OPS with solid, if unspectacular
defense. The trade of Jason Michaels promotes his from fifth to
fourth outfielder, and the team shouldn't lose a step in the process.
Victorino is on pace to become the greatest hitter in Major League
history to be born in Hawaii (current competition, Mike Lum, Lenn
Sakata, and Benny Agbayani).
===Starting Rotation===
While Lieber is nominally the ace, that could change if Myers
maintains his consistency for another year. In reality, Lieber is the
probably the first-among-equals on an underrated pitching staff that
starts off weak (compared to other staff aces), but really doesn't go
down much from there. It is also a deep staff, with Ryan Franklin and
Robinson Tejeda available to jump in if one of the five falter, and a
stocked rotation in Reading, some of whom may be only a year or so
away.
"Park factor" is an issue, with home runs (more than runs overall)
inflated, especially compared to the spacious parks populating the
rest of the NL East, but it is not impossible to project all of the
starter with an ERA+ between 100 and 110.
*Jon Lieber -- When healthy, he's a poor man's Don Sutton. Ten years
with at least 100 IP, and he's never had an ERA+ under 96, and never
higher than 119. Only twice has it been higher than 109, and he only
tossed 107 innings in one of those years. Can this dictionary
defintion of a good innings eater keep it up at age 36? Well, his
K-rate was the best it's been since the Clinton administration last
year, his K/W rate remains fantastic, and though he does give up his
share of gopher balls, with strong up-the-middle defense, he should
provide another solid 200+ innings.
*Myers - Took the big step forward last year, and should continue
forward. There is one concern, though. He's still young and he threw
about 400 more pitches than in any previous season. If you look at
the records of practically any young pitcher you like in history, and
they had some bumps on the way to success.
*Lidle - Exhibit A in the argument for Rick Peterson as a brillant
pitching coach, as he has yet to have a really good season away from
the ex-Athletic instructor. Has Lidle finally found a home in Philly?
If he lasts the year, it will be the first time this southpaw's lasted
beyond two years with any club. He managed to pull off a 100 ERA+,
but gave up a sizable number of unearned runs. If he'd allowed UER at
the same proportion to all runs as his teammates, his ERA would've
gone up to 4.78. Lidle is a control pitcher who needs to rely on his
defense, and the Phillies had one of the best Defensive Efficiency
Ratings in the game last year, and adding Rowand to the defense will
only help that. He'll be a servicable back-of-the-rotation innings
eater. A team's number three starter is generally only a league
average pitcher, and with this offense that's all the Phillies need.
*Gavin Floyd -- After getting a starter spot out of last year's Spring
Training, and proceeding to go Ankiel on the mound (both in
Philadelphia and in Scranton, where his ERA was over 6.00), Floyd has
performed well in Spring Training this year, and was announced as the
fifth starter the final week of Spring Training, pushing Ryan Franklin
to the bullpen.
*Ryan Madson -- Madson had not appeared in a game in relief since
Rookie Ball in 1998 when he was promoted to Philadelphia as a top
pitching prospect. While usually I support breaking in pitchers in
long relief, Madson was a victim of his own success -- becoming too
valuable to move into the rotation. He was also the victim of his
sole failure -- a disastrous lone start in 2004. An extra 100 or so
innings of Ryan Madson per year will certainly be a help to the
Phillies' pitching staff. The epitome of lanky, Madson throws a very
heavy ball leading to a 1.8 to 1 groundball-to-flyball ratio and
nearly 8 strikeouts per inning. I wouldn't be shocked to see a good
Kevin Brown or Derek Lowe season out of him very soon, especially
pitching in front of this defense.
Ryan Franklin - What good things can you say about a man who went 8-15
with an ERA over 5 last year? Well, he did only have two unearned
runs, so he's better than that ERA gives him credit for. He had
horrible run support in the first half last year, so he's better than
his W/L record. But he's still not good. He's pretty similar (though
inferior) to Cory Lidle actually, except that he gives up flyballs,
not grounders. He'll give up a bunch of long balls, but he should be
a servicable back-of-the-rotation starter/long-man.
*Randy Wolf (on DL) - It would take the marketers who brought you
"Weapons of Mass Destruction-Related Program Activities" to spin gold
out of Wolf's injury, and the Phillies just don't have that kind of
creativity. It is theoretically possible that Wolf could make a
dramatic comeback in August, picking up the slack after Ryan Franklin
and Cory Lidle have pitched themselves out of the rotation. What is
far more likely, however is that whatever baseball Wolf manages to get
his elbow around this year will be of the purely strength and
stamina-building variety, and will not carry the Phillies to the
promised land. The only question that remains, then, is just how the
Phillies will spend Wolf's $9 million salary in 2007?
===Relief Corp===
*Tom Gordon -- By most measures Billy Wagner formed his own tier.
Clearly worse that Mariano Rivera and the Hall of Famers, but clearly
better than the "average" ace closer. As a one-of-a-kind, he was
essentially irreplaceable, even by himself, as it was unlikely that a
long term deal would yield his more of his career ERA+ of 180 (let
alone his ERA+ of 300 in 2005). With limited options, Gordon was a
fine choice for a replacement, although he is certainly old.
*Arthur Rhodes. By some accounts, the Phillies were angling for Rafael
Betancourt in exchange for Jason Michaels, but settled for
Rhodes. While Michaels for Rhodes looks like a steal for Cleveland in
the abstract, the fallout is that Victorino replaces Michaels with
minimal loss of production, and Madson moves to the rotation, so the
team is improved, even if the trade itself is iffy. Rhodes is the
perfect cover-your-ass pickup: a veteran, with a long history in the
setup role and familiarity for Gillick, his acquisition is unlikely to
get anyone in the front office fired, no matter how he performs. While
his upside isn't tremendous, he was good when healthy last year (43 Ks
in 43 IP with an ERA+ of 197) and if his knees don't give him trouble
again (and Manuel doesn't overuse him) it's quite possible that he
will outproduce Urbina, who faded significantly down the stretch last
season.
*Rheal Cormier. Ever see that Star Trek episode when the Enterprise
was trapped in the endless time loop? We feel like that sometimes. Say
it with us now, "A CAREER YEAR BY A 36-YEAR-OLD MIDDLE RELIEVER IS NOT
A RELIABLE PREDICTOR OF FUTURE PERFORMANCE." 2003 was such a year for
Cormier, 38, earning him a payday from Ed Wade, who of course never
met an aging middle reliever he didn't like. The 242 ERA+ that Cormier
posted that year leveled off at a respectable 123 in 2004, before
crashing down to 77 during a horrendous and injury-plagued 2005. His
performance was in no way helped by Manuel's dogged insistence on
sending Cormier out during high-leverage situations, no matter how
many leads he coughed up. The 2.5 million ducats the Phillies will
give him in 2006 should help take away the sting.
*Aaron Fultz - About to meet gravity. After five consecutive middling
seasons with three different team, Fultz broke out last year allowing
less than a baserunner an inning, and an ERA near 2. He did it by
allowing hitters to a .207 AVG on balls in play. His career mark
(including last year) is .291. Check please.
*Geoff Geary -- Geary was a middling-prospect pitcher whose numbers
were always good enough, but who was always a little too old for his
level. He experienced his first AAA success at age 26, and improved at
age 27 to an ERA of 2.16, earning him some major league time. As a 30
year old, he's clearly too good from Scranton, but has yet to
translate that into consistent major league success, and will probably
spend another year hovering between replacement-level and average. At
just six-foot, 178 pounds, watching Geary come in from the bullpen is
bit like watching Robert Reich coming into testify before Congress.
*Rob Tejada -- A "B Prospect" coming up through the system, he got a
lot of attention as a fill-in starter in 2005, having great success in
a few limited starts. He's not as good as he was in 2005, but
probably isn't as bad as his Spring 2006 either. At this point, he
will start the season in Scranton, giving him plenty of innings for
future fill-in duty. Gone to the Rangers for Dellucci.
*Ricardo Rodriguez. What price, Vicente Padilla? Ricardo Rodriguez,
apparently, is the answer, as the Phillies traded Padilla for him
straight-up. Rumors abound about why the inconsistent but talented
(and affordable) Padilla was unceremoniously shipped out of town,
however, most of these rumors involve variations on a drinking
problem, as well as reports out of his native Nicaragua that Padilla
may have, on several occasions, "played roosters clandestinely."
Rodriguez was released in the last week of spring training. So in
actuality, they traded him for nothing.
*Chris Booker -- A Rule 5 pickup who has been hampered by injuries
this Spring, and poor performance when he was on the mound. The
bullpen is likely not deep enough to hide a player who can't be used
for the season, but a trip to the DL to start the season will give the
Phils more time to decide.
===On the Farm===
Not much hear or see here, please move along.
The Phillies had the 68th (Cole Hamels, this rating is a gift as
Hamels was injured most of last year) and 73rd (Gio Gonzalez) best
prospects according to Baseball America. Not a good haul and if you
weight the rankings, they are pro
*Greg Golson -- Toolsy outfielder who did very little in the Sally
last year. Lots of tools and a first round pick, so he'll get as many
chances as Marlon Byrd did.
* The Reading Rotation -- The Reading Phillies will put out pitching
staff this year of Dan Haigwood, Gio Gonzalez, Cole Hamels, and Scott
Mathieson, four names who should all arguable be among the Phil's top
prospects. (Hamels will start off the year in Clearwater until the
weather warms up, due to his injury status, and there is talk in the
organization of him skipping AA and moving straight to AAA, depending
on his health and how he performs). Haigwood and Gonzalez are the
minor league booty from the Thome Trade.
*Michael Bourn -- lead-off CF, lost a lot of walks in the move to AA
last year, still being pushed to AAA. Thome deal reaps Gonzalez and
Haigwood, instantly a top 3 and top 12 prospect, respectively, for
this organization
Even though the Phillies do appear to have pretty slim pickings, any
organization that has produced Madson, Howard, and Utley is short
order has done all right through its farm system.
===Field Manager===
Charlie Manuel was blasted in the press when the Phillies got off to a
slow start (10-14 in April), but unlike Phillies teams of recent
years, they actually were playing their best ball in August and
September going 33-23 down the stretch. I just went to find stats to
back up this impression, and it is flat out wrong. The Phillies under
Bowa actually played very well down the stretch including several
18-win Septembers (though a 2-7 finish in 2003 killed their wildcard
hopes for that year). Guess I can't make the point that Bowa flogged
them too much too early. Manuel has a very easy demeanor with the
players and they seem to like that. I don't see him as a tactical
genius. He falls squarely in the people person camp as a manager.
===Front Office===
"Retail" Ed Wade never saw a sticker price he wouldn't pay. Some in
the Philadelphia area believe that the Phillies are a cheap
organization. However their payroll has been near the top of the NL
since the new park opened. Wade just was never very good at spreading
his resources around. The Phillies have a good number of moderately
above average players, but they pay them all what they are worth in a
good season. Aside from the young guys there aren't any important
players you would say are exceeding expectations or are making less
than they are worth.
Pat Gillick came in and basically found there was nothing he could do.
No one wanted the Phillies corner outfielders or third baseman. He
got as much as he could for Thome, dumped Padilla, and let Billy
Wagner walk. I don't know if he was trying to insulate himself from
blame or motivate the team, but he essentially said they weren't good
enough to win at the start of the year. An interesting gambit, but
I'm not sure that it will work.
I'm not sure what I would have done in hindsight. Trading Polanco was
a costly error, and I think they will regret signing Rollins to a big
contract just like they probably regret signing Burrell, Wolf,
Lieberthal, and Bell to theirs. If your farm system isn't producing
you have to be shrewd with the waiver wire, trades and free agent
signings. The Phillies haven't done that.
===Citizen's Bank Park===
CBP has been derided as Coors West since it opened. It is true that
it is a bit cozy down the lines and it does give up a few cheap home
runs. Overall, the park was a slight hitter's park in 2004 and a big
hitter's park in 2005. For 2006, they have removed the first few rows
in left field (don't worry the flower boxes remain), which should
reduce the number of pop fly home runs. One issue that I don't think
gets enough play in the park factor issue is the other parks in the
division. With the unbalanced schedule the Phillies play about forty
road games in Shea, Pro Player, RFK, and Turner. Additionally, during
interleague play they hosted the Red Sox and Rangers and traveled to
Oakland and Seattle. Basically the deck was stacked for a high park
factor. I suspect it will play more normally this year.
===Doug Glanville===
The Phillies hosted Doug Glanville day in 2005. Glanville, who
briefly was in Yankees camp last spring, called it quits as a Phillie.
Glanville spent the 2004-2005 off-season in Africa on an engineering
project with his Penn undergraduate advisor. I don't know what the
future holds for Glanville, but I know that my wife, Sylvia, will miss
reading stories about him.
===Overall Assessment===
Well, the offense still looks fantastic. For
every guy looking to fall back (Lieberthal, Abreu), there's another
good candidate to rise up a notch (Howard, Burrell, Utley). It the
phront office can get its head out of tuckus it can hopefully trade
for an actual third baseman to round out the offense. The offense
will get them in the hunt, and it's the job of the pitchers to keep
them there.
Pitching's always a tricky issue to count on for any team (just ask
your friendly local neighborhood Cubs fan) but especially so for the
Phillies. One pitcher is unproven in the bigs. Another has only had
one good year, and if his arm's still recovering from last year, he
might fall back. Two of their starters are unusually dependent on
their defense to save them on balls in play. That means their most
reliable bet in the rotation is a 36-year-old who missed all of 2003.
Still, the defense should hold up for those that need it, Lieber is a
horse, and Myers could be the real deal. Betting against Bobby Cox
and the Braves is a fool's game, but betting against this Phillies
team in the post-Mazzone era isn't wise either. They're a good shot
for either the division or wild card.
I'll edge them up one win to 89-73 and once again one game out.
2006 ZiPS Projections - Philadelphia Phillies
Name P G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS AVG OBP SLG
Abreu* rf 161 586 99 170 42 1 23 93 124 134 27 10 .290 .415 .483
Howard* 1b 152 533 81 150 29 1 34 98 60 190 1 1 .281 .357 .531
Utley* 2b 146 533 84 150 36 4 26 91 65 103 12 4 .281 .365 .510
Burrell lf 150 552 72 148 28 1 29 95 99 160 0 0 .268 .379 .480
Rowand cf 151 525 80 151 33 3 14 72 33 100 14 5 .288 .346 .442
Rollins# ss 162 701 110 197 42 9 14 79 65 87 33 10 .281 .342 .427
Lieberthal c 124 439 46 115 26 0 13 56 37 55 0 1 .262 .332 .410
Victorino# lf 130 495 83 135 17 5 12 58 41 85 13 11 .273 .332 .400
Wathan c 81 248 35 63 10 0 6 30 20 45 1 2 .254 .339 .367
Coste c 114 415 50 109 22 1 11 52 26 73 2 2 .263 .315 .400
Gonzalez 3b 116 390 49 98 23 1 12 52 32 96 2 2 .251 .311 .408
Kata# 2b 113 413 53 113 23 4 6 42 25 66 3 3 .274 .316 .392
Nunez# 3b 131 359 50 100 12 2 4 36 32 57 1 2 .279 .337 .357
Bell 3b 143 525 52 130 29 1 12 61 52 74 0 1 .248 .319 .375
Garrett# rf 134 505 68 132 25 2 13 63 34 112 12 8 .261 .312 .396
Bergeron* cf 102 378 51 105 14 4 3 31 31 71 9 7 .278 .332 .360
Kroeger* rf 138 475 70 120 30 2 14 57 25 117 9 3 .253 .295 .413
Sandoval ss 125 481 61 134 27 1 6 48 39 65 13 14 .279 .335 .376
Scales# 2b 112 337 39 80 18 2 6 38 39 86 5 3 .237 .323 .356
Bourn* cf 129 492 79 125 15 6 5 44 50 124 32 9 .254 .324 .339
Roberson cf 130 485 70 126 18 4 9 49 32 114 22 14 .260 .315 .369
Thurston* 2b 132 454 65 123 17 3 8 53 22 58 5 8 .271 .309 .374
Ruiz c 99 337 39 84 17 4 7 36 21 44 4 4 .249 .297 .386
Fasano c 75 207 23 45 7 0 11 34 10 49 0 0 .217 .265 .411
Perez# 3b 100 208 23 49 13 1 3 22 16 43 0 1 .236 .291 .351
Name W L ERA G GS INN H ER HR BB K
Flash 8 3 3.26 77 0 80.0 60 29 6 32 83
Madson 7 4 3.64 69 0 84.0 75 34 9 22 74
Rhodes* 3 2 3.68 49 0 44.0 37 18 4 18 45
Geary 4 3 3.81 51 1 78.0 73 33 7 24 61
Fultz* 3 2 3.88 61 0 65.0 57 28 7 24 49
Santana 5 4 4.04 44 0 49.0 40 22 5 23 53
Cormier* 5 3 4.04 69 0 69.0 64 31 7 23 47
Lieber 14 13 4.17 32 32 205.0 213 95 29 35 133
Lopez 4 4 4.20 58 0 75.0 68 35 12 23 74
Myers 12 10 4.21 33 33 201.0 188 94 27 65 178
Lidle 13 12 4.36 32 32 198.0 205 96 22 54 120
Booker 4 5 4.50 52 0 60.0 50 30 6 35 69
Wolf* 8 8 4.53 23 23 143.0 139 72 20 49 114
Hernandez 5 6 4.83 47 1 69.0 68 37 8 32 58
Tejeda 6 8 4.85 29 21 128.0 118 69 15 69 111
Hamels* 1 2 5.00 6 6 27.0 25 15 3 17 24
Rodriguez 5 8 5.02 21 19 113.0 121 63 20 38 60
Franklin 8 14 5.14 32 31 198.0 214 113 32 66 102
Floyd 7 11 5.22 31 28 169.0 175 98 20 83 113
Condrey 5 10 5.27 25 24 135.0 157 79 24 33 65
Sanches 3 4 5.29 47 2 80.0 84 47 16 28 63
Haigwood* 6 10 5.41 24 24 133.0 134 80 18 73 107
Cameron 4 7 5.63 45 7 96.0 95 60 17 52 80
Brito* 4 8 5.73 37 16 110.0 117 70 20 53 79
Lee 3 6 5.80 27 15 104.0 114 67 22 42 74
Mathieson 3 10 6.11 24 24 131.0 156 89 28 49 76
Pratt* 3 7 6.20 34 16 103.0 101 71 17 79 100
Bucktrot 2 8 6.94 16 16 83.0 102 64 21 39 41
Segovia 3 15 6.98 27 27 147.0 196 114 37 52 50
Disclaimer: ZiPS projections are computer-based projections of performance.
Performances have not been allocated to predicted playing time in the majors -
many of the players listed above are unlikely to play in the majors at all in 2006.
ZiPS is projecting equivalent production - a .240 ZiPS projection may end up
being .280 in AAA or .300 in AA, for example. Whether or not a player will play
is one of many non-statistical factors one has to take into account when predicting
the future.
Sean Forman
Posted: April 05, 2006 at 09:24 AM |
14 comment(s)
Related News:
Philadelphia
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
This is cool. I didn't know that.
When I wrote that I thought Franklin was one of their starters, so adjust that thought accordingly.
That's a lot of wild pitches. (Yeah, I know you meant per nine innings)
I'm a big Doug Glanville fan. I think he could find a nice second career as a baseball analyst.
You can read Doug Glanville's letter about his engineering trip to Africa in the "Dougout".
Screw analyst. Glanville should've been the next GM.
The more Glanville can use his Penn education and the further away he stays from the Phils' leadoff spot, the better for us all.
Looks like you trailed off there ... great article, though.
Since when has Lidle become a southpaw? Did I miss something?
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main