Newsday: Davidoff: Derek Jeter has a terrible VORP

“This is why I think all these newfangled stats are nothing but a bunch of garbage, invented by people who have too much time on their hands and a desperate need to prop up certain players while tearing down others."* (*from the engaging Davidoff the cuffers in the comments)

M-Crash asked me this morning to check Derek Jeter’s VORP, so I did. Here is his ranking among shortstops (13th overall). Here is his overall ranking (tied for 124th with J.D. Drew).

Of course, of course, it’s still early, and Jeter historically hits better in the second half. He also missed a week with a quad injury. But still, are any of you alarmed by Jeter’s lack of power? Wally Matthews discussed that with Jeter in his column today.

Here is the best explanation I’ve seen for how VORP is calculated. It’s a particularly relevant stat given the Yankees’ injuries. We’re seeing how much their lineup is hurt by the absence of Alex Rodriguez (who led all of baseball last year with a 96.6 VORP) and Jorge Posada (who was eighth overall, and first among catchers, with a 73.4). VORP doesn’t factor in defense _ for that, you need WARP, or Wins Above Replacement Player _ but right now, offense is the Yankees’ problem.