|
|
|
|
Baseball Primer Newsblog— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand
Wednesday, July 11, 2007
It’s Hitting-Coach-As-Scapegoat Day!
The Mets will begin the season’s second half with a dramatic change in their coaching staff, Newsday has learned. Rick Down is out as hitting coach, and Rickey Henderson is in.
Down said that Willie Randolph informed him Wednesday night of the decision, and that he would be replaced by Henderson. A person familiar with the situation confirmed that Henderson, the future Hall of Famer who has never served as a coach, would take over as hitting coach.
When asked whether Randolph offered an explanation, Down replied: “Not really. Approach, I guess.”
NTNgod
Posted: July 11, 2007 at 11:36 PM | 101 comment(s)
Related News: General, NY Mets
|
My Bookmarks
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Hot Topics
|
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
Poker games and haircuts in the clubhouse for everyone! I love this. The closer to 1999 this team can get (sans Kenny Rogers), the happier I get.
This is seriously awesome.
Seriously though, do you guys think Rickey is going to be a good coach?
I can't wait for Pedro to comeback. That clubhouse would contain my three favorite baseball people of all time.
Not really a Mets fan, though, so I'm just looking forward to the quotes.
No. But he'll whip Jose into shape and he'll command instant respect. He's a good guy to have around.
Rickey is the greatest of all time.
"I'm back!""Rickey's back!"Fixed.
and i think, given his work as a special instructor, he deserves a shot at coaching.
The White Sox, unexpectantly in the midst of the 1990 pennant race, declined to activate Minnie Minoso for his 6th decade, supposedly due to a player revolt. It's not exactly the same situation, but if the Mets are in a race in September, I could see a player's objection.
I know Rickey still wants to play, but he's nearly in the Hall. A Sep cup of coffee delays that another 5 years. Wouldn't he enjoy being a HOFer more?
Is there any extra benefit to being offically elected to the HOF? If there isn't, why would that really matter? Everyone already knows Rickey is a HOFer. I agree with your other point though. Rickey shouldn't be activated if the Mets are in the middle of a pennant race.
Given how damn old much of the Mets' roster is, it's NOT the same situation :P
He may have an advantage in credibility. Fair or not, I suspect that players listen somewhat more attentively to a hall of famer than to a guy who didn't make it to the big leagues.
Is Rickey first unanimous? Me could see that. Of course if Aaron, Mays, Williams not unanimous, that obviously argue against. But what the case, other than ######## Simers argument?
Naw, Giammatti squashed the attempt to bring him back. Unless it was Fay Vincent. The commish took the bat out of Minoso's hands that year.
Expect hear from Meldrick.
EDIT: Really, the greatest! I don't even care about whether he's a good coach or not... I mean, has anyone ever heard positive stories about Rick Down? I was hoping that he'd be fired weeks ago (because you can't fire the players). Just having Rickey around more makes me really happy.
And plus, as mentioned, Reyes's completely ridiculous turn around in plate discipline after getting mentored by Rickey is all that I need to give him the benefit of the doubt.
This is the best move the Mets could have possibly made right now without making a "real" move.
I'm ready for games now!!!
1. Tony Phillips. Phillips was Rickey's teammate at the beginning of his career and for half a season in 1989. Phillips's offensive performance increased slowly but substantially over the course of his career. He adopted a crouch that in some ways resembled Rickey, and his walk totals and OBP kept increasing and increasing. The problem with assuming that Rickey had anything to do with it is that some of the biggest steps forward that Phillips took occurred around 1985-86 when Rickey was in New York and during 1990-93 when Phillips was in Detroit.
2. Lance Blankenship. Basically, he never could hit - but he used his patience and pitch recognition to somehow be a useful part-time player anyway. Owner of some of the weirdest-looking offensive stats you'll ever see.
He walked a ton in the minors, too, when Henderson was a Yankee.
It's just who he was.
This is how I feel too. I'm very happy that Rickey is back in OB, even if it's as a coach.
Even if he just coaches and talks, baseball is a better place with him in it.
It's Franco, by (at least) 4 months (August 1958 vs December 1958).
NJ.com
Babe Ruth has a total of 2,062 walks, but they did not keep records for how many were IBBs.
Barry Bonds currently has a total of 2,517 walks, of which 675 have been IBBs, leaving 1,842 UIBBs.
Does this mean that Rickey has to officially retire? I do not think he has yet.
And what does this do to him wanting to sign a one day contract with the A's before retiring. I doubt he can do that now.
Curious if anybody knows.
In June 1999, when Henderson was playing with the Mets, he saw reporters running around the clubhouse before a game. He asked a teammate what was going on and he was told that Tom Robson, the team’s hitting coach, had just been fired.
Henderson said, “Who’s he?”
I bet they won't have to. Rickey will activate Rickey. He'll just grab a bat from the rack, tap the on-deck batter on the shoulder and take his place.
doesn't prove much either way, but I thought this was funny:
Henderson, who caught a foul ball on Monday at AT&T;Park, where he was watching the Mets play the Giants, kept the ball instead of handing it to a young fan.
"Everybody was asking me for the ball," Henderson said Tuesday, according to the Star-Ledger of Newark. "I said, 'You're not getting this ball. I always wanted to get a foul ball. This one's going on a shelf at home."
The young fan didn't go home empty-handed, though, as Henderson signed another ball the fan already had.
http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=2865084
Cito Gaston was the hitting coach in 2000 (and 2001). Mike Barnett came aboard as hitting coach for the 2002 season and served through mid-2005, including Delgado's second MVP-calibre year in 2003.
This is classic Rickey. Maybe he's cultivating an image, but he seems to genuinely love baseball and what baseball fan hasn't wanted a foul ball. You have to think that if not for the long, HOF career, he'd have caught a lot of foul balls by now.
Hitting coaches are much less influential than thought, IMO. I think the best thing they can do is teach a hitting approach, but the actual hitting of the ball isn't a greatly teachable thing. In this, Rickey should have some good things to say. Still, as in any situation, if a student doesn't want to learn, there isn't much a teacher can do. So, my guess is that Rickey has good info to impart to the Mets players. If they listen to him and want to learn, it should work out.
Did he shoot Alou in the quads?
This a risky move for a team in first place. Hope it works out.
The player objection will be led by Julio Franco, not wanting to lose playing time to the young man.
According to one online biography Delgado was "quick to credit" new hitting coach Gaston with his turnaround during the 2000 season after he slumped during the first few weeks. However, who knows how much help Gaston really was? Gaston is a "look for your pitch and hit it" type and doesn't emphasize the walk or working the count like some coaches do. In light of Delgado's specific struggles, maybe he's not the best fit in NY. However, his methods must have got results. I can't believe he would have lasted 7 years as hitting coach (1982-1989) and then been promoted to interim manager if he was completely or even mostly ineffective.
Barnett is also an interesting case as he never played baseball beyond college and worked his way up through the college and then minor league coaching ranks until the Jays gave him a chance in the majors. He was praised a lot during his first year, especially for getting some natural free-swingers to control the strike zone better, but after the disasterous 2004 season and the slow start in 2005 the team basically had to get rid of him. He is currently the hitting coach for the Royals, IIRC.
This might pull the discussion in a different direction, but it would seem to me that pitch recognition is essential for every type of hitter. A hitting coach that stresses patience and pitch recognition is helping both Punch-and-Judy hitters and monster sluggers to identify the pitch(es) they can do something with. At some point, it's up to the player to use his God-given talent with the lessons he's taught (which is why a good number of hitting coaches are fairly interchangable).
The man does have 297 career homers (so far), despite being a little fella. I suspect he knows a few things about power hitting.
Question: Why isn't Phillips considered a fringe HoF candidate?
During BP his first night, he came upon John Olerud shagging balls abound the 1B bag.
Rickey: "Yo! I used to play with a dude in New York kept his helmet on all the time too!"
C - Mike Piazza
1B - Mark McGwire
2B - Roberto Alomar
SS - Alex Rodriguez
3B - Carney Lansford
OF - Manny Ramirez
OF - Dave Winfield
OF - Tony Gwynn
DH - Edgar Martinez
SP - Pedro Martinez
SP - Phil Niekro
SP - Ron Guidry
SP - Orel Hershiser
RP - Dennis Eckersly
RP - Trevor Hoffman
RP - Eric Gagne
(solid team)
1B - Mark McGwire
2B - Roberto Alomar
SS - Alex Rodriguez
3B - Carney Lansford
OF - Manny Ramirez
OF - Dave Winfield
OF - Tony Gwynn
DH - Edgar Martinez
Paul Molitor at 3rd? When they were teammates in Toronto Molitor was the DH, but still. And John Olerud should have a spot on this team.
Did he shoot Alou in the quads?
This a risky move for a team in first place. Hope it works out.
How risky can it be? They are in first, yes, but they're 10th in the league in runs (after finishing 3rd a year ago). Even if Rickey doesn't help matters, is there really that much at risk in replacing Down?
This may be the most high-profile thing that happens with the Mets today, but it sure as hell isn't the most important. The return of Lastings Milledge -- and what surely must be the critical phase of his future as a Met -- begins today. How that unfolds will affect the future of the team a heck of a lot more.
Robin Ventura.
Yeah we'll put Molitor and Edgar in a rotation for 3b and DH and drop Carney off the team
Question: Why would you consider Phillips a fringe HoF candidate?
These seem to be pretty closely related, don't they? I suspect that from the Mets perspective, Rickey's tenure as a coach is going to be judged primarily by how good Lastings Milledge turns out to be. I'm not a Mets fan so maybe I'm way off, but they seem to be a good match - in terms of both personality and also in terms of baseball skill set. I suspect that Rickey will be a good mentor for Milledge, but of course there's no way to know that from where we sit.
Strong fielder at multiple positions with the largest amount of games at 2B.
Lifetime .374 OBP, 103.5 WARP3
Also, I think he's cool.
Team OPS+ for each stop Rick Down has had as hitting coach:
-----
Yankees 1993-95
2 years prior .. 094 106
in his tenure .. 112 119 104
2 years after .. 099 109
Notable additions: Paul O'Neill and Wade Boggs for 1993, Darryl Strawberry mid-1995 (and again in mid-1996), Tino Martinez and Tim Raines for 1996, some Jeter kid for 1996.
Notable departures: Don Mattingly after 1995.
-----
Orioles 1996-98
2 years prior .. 098 096
in his tenure .. 107 103 107
2 years after .. 105 100
Notable additions: Bobby Bonilla mid-1995, B.J. Surhoff and Roberto Alomar for 1996, Eddie Murray mid-1996, Eric Davis for 1997, Geronimo Berroa mid-1997, Albert Belle for 1999.
Notable departures: Harold Baines, a bunch of times. Bonilla and Murray after 1996. Davis after 1998.
(Worth noting that 1996 was Brady Anderson's 50-HR season. Team OPS+ was 104 in 1996 without him.)
-----
Dodgers 1999-00
2 years prior .. 108 093
in his tenure .. 101 107
2 years after .. 107 104
Notable additions: Gary Sheffield in May 1998. Shawn Green for 2000. LoDuca, effectively in 2001.
Notable departures: Piazza in May 1998. Raul Mondesi after 1999. Sheffield after 2001.
-----
Red Sox 2001
2 years prior .. 099 092
in his tenure .. 102
2 years after .. 111 118
Notable additions: Carl Everett for 2000. Manny Ramirez for 2001. Johnny Damon for 2002. Ortiz for 2003.
Notable departures: Everett after 2001.
(Varitek & Nomar were injured most of 2001.)
-----
Yankees 2002-03
2 years prior .. 100 102
in his tenure .. 116 117
2 years after .. 114 111
Notable additions: Soriano 2001, Giambi 2002, Matsui 2003, A-Rod and Sheffield 2004, Cano 2005.
Notable departures: Knoblauch and Tino and O'Neill after 2001, Soriano after 2003.
-----
Mets 2004-06.5
2 years prior .. 098 086
in his tenure .. 092 099 108 107
I'm tired of looking at the transactions, but methinks the addition of Wright (2004), Beltran (2005), Delgado (2006), and Alou (2007) have been a significant part of the improvement.
-----
Without fail Down's first year with a team was been a significant improvement over the prior year. But the cause of that is unclear. He has often arrived with some new bats: Boggs/O'Neill in 1993, Alomar/Surhoff in 1996, Ramirez in 2001, Wright in 2004. In his stints with the Dodgers and Mets he may have arrived just after a "down" year. There's enough variation in the year-to-year numbers that it's hard to say how much of the change is due to him and how much is due to random fluctuation.
Similar to the first manager he served under, Buck Showalter, perhaps he's someone who makes a difference early on but whose style tends to annoy players after a while. I don't know; he hasn't had a terribly long tenure anywhere.
rickey played on the 96 padres with mvp 3b ken caminiti.
I thought this story had been debunked as being made up by Robin Ventura? Rickey seems like a current day Yogi; people will make up quotes and attribute them to him. Not that I mind, I think its hilarious.
I think my favorite Rickey story is either the foul ball story already mentioned here, or one where he isn't directly involved. Bill Simmons told a story about how one time he had a radio interview with Kevin Towers about 6 or 7 years ago, when Rickey was on the Padres, and his entire goal in the interview was to ask Towers a question that would lead him to respond "Thats just Rickey being Rickey." Needless to say, it wasn't that difficult to do.
This is probably true of most hitting coaches. Teams having "up" years generally don't fire their hitting coach.
There's enough variation in the year-to-year numbers that it's hard to say how much of the change is due to him and how much is due to random fluctuation.
You'd really need to compare him with other hitting coaches. I suspect there's a general tendency for teams to do better under new hitting coaches, simply because teams that hire new hitting coaches were under-performing when they fired the last guy.
The version of that story that I heard had them playing cards in the clubhouse when Rickey said that.
O'Neill's OPS+ in Cincinnati, ages 25-29: 102, 123, 105, 127, 102.
O'Neill's OPS+ in New York, ages 30-34: 134, 177, 138, 122, 138.
Roberto Alomar went from 116 and 108 OPS+ in 1994-95 to 137 and 134 under Down.
Down's record is quite good, IMO.
Quite a few Yankees of the 30's could probably beat that. Especially if they played elsewhere too. Here's Dixie Walker
C Dickey
1B Gehrig
2B Robinson
SS Appling
3B Vaughan
OF Ruth
OF Snider
OF Kiner
SP Lyons, Pennock, Gomez, Ruffing
Not the greatest pitching staff, however. There's likely a better choice.
Yeah, but then you have to add in Dixie Walker v. Rickey. Doesn't that kind of spoil it for Walker's team?
C Cochrane
1B Foxx
2B Collins
SS Chapman or Sewell
3B Sewell or Dykes
OF Cobb
OF Simmons
OF Ruth
SP Young
SP Johnson
SP Grove
SP Wood
SP Covaleski
C Ivan Rodriguez
1B Raphael Palmeiro
2B Jeff Kent
3B Mike Schmidt
SS Omar Vizquel
DH Frank Thomas
OF Sammy Sosa
OF Manny Ramirez
OF Albert Belle
SP Pedro Martinez
SP Greg Maddux
SP Bert Blyleven
SP Nolan Ryan
SP Steve Carlton
RP Kevin Brown
RP Tom Glavine
RP John Smoltz
RP Norm Charlton
RP Phil Niekro
BENCH
Pete Rose
Jim Thome
Wade Boggs
Eddie Murray
Albert Belle
Gary Sheffield
If we expand to the 40-man, it gets sick. Some guys who didn't make the list (along with Andruw et al mentioned above) - Orel Hershiser, Bartolo Colon, Tim Raines, Juan Gonzalez, Fred McGriff, Jose Canseco, Brett Butler, Charlie Hough, Jamie Moyer, Goose Gossage, Robin Ventura, Kenny Lofton, Dennis Martinez, Ken Caminiti, Chipper, Billy Wagner, Delgado, I'm sure some others that I missed.
Fair enough, he played with a lot of these guys when their careers were on the downswing, but still...
OF Sammy Sosa
OF Manny Ramirez
OF Albert Belle
I feel bad for that pitching staff.
I mentioned this to a friend today. Reyes could reach 100 steals this year.
isn't rickey the alltime leader in leadoff homeruns? the guy had a power stroke.
Yeah, outfield defense is kinda brutal. I suppose with the multiBelles (see below), you could leave Belle1 on the bench and put in Tim Raines. Also, recall that I left Andruw and Beltran off the list - if they can live up to expectations for the rest of their respective careers (ie, normal age-related decline, rather than Beltran's one-year-great-one-year-goodish pattern of the last few years or Andruw's what-foul-hex-has-been-here-wrought pattern of this year), then that turns into a pretty fine defensive outfield.
And anyway, given that that offense would put up about infinity runs per game, a few dying quails dropping in isn't going to kill them.
I hate guys like Albert Belle and Chris Truby who can be in two places at once.
So a spot's open for Rickey!
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main