Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
Also, a big BTF Happy Birthday to Laurie Reis. That has to be one of the most girly names in baseball history.
2. Dag Nabbit
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 10:53 AM (#3012963)
Trivia time:
In baseball history, there have been 22 different times a manager has lasted at least a dozen seasons with a team. On four occasions, he ended that stretch with a losing record. Can you name any of those four managerial stints of 12+ seasons with a sub-.500 winning percentage?
3. Uncle Willy
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 11:19 AM (#3012981)
Without looking it up, Connie Mack would have to be one. I'll have to give the others some thought.
Leafing through B-Ref, one thing I have learned is that stints of 12 consecutive years with the same team are awfully rare, good bad or indifferent.
Bucky Harris had three stints with the Senators that added up to 18 seasons at a .485 clip, but that probably doesn't qualify him as an answer to the question, I'm guessing.
I also found another answer, but since I looked it up I will shut up about it :)
8. Dag Nabbit
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 11:39 AM (#3013001)
10. Dag Nabbit
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 11:42 AM (#3013003)
Yes, Bruce Bochy is the third.
And then there was one.
11. DK near DC
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 11:43 AM (#3013005)
Earl Weaver?
12. Dag Nabbit
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 11:46 AM (#3013009)
Cute. No. Not Weaver.
13. Tom Nawrocki
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 11:48 AM (#3013011)
Jimmy Dykes managed some bad teams for long stretches of time, but I don't know that he last 12 years with any of them.
14. Dag Nabbit
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 11:52 AM (#3013017)
DING! DING! DING! DING!
Jimmy Dykes lasted a little over 12 years with the Whtie Sox. He is the only man to last that long without ever winning a pennant.
Tom Kelly had the lowest winning percentage of anyone in a 12+ year stretch with one team, .478 in 15 years in Minnesota.
Anyone want to try guessing the other 18 times a manager lasted at least 12 consecutive seasons with a team? Earl Weaver's been mentioned, leaving 17 more.
15. SoSH U at work
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 12:00 PM (#3013026)
Get some easy ones out of the way:
Bobby Cox
Joe Torre
Walter Alston
Tommy Lasorda
16. Dag Nabbit
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 12:03 PM (#3013032)
Yup to them. That's 9 out of 22.
The 9 mentioned: Dykes, Bochy, Mack, Kelly, Weaver, Cox, Torre, Alston, and Lasorda.
17. SoSH U at work
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 12:06 PM (#3013036)
34. Der Komminsk-sar
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 03:27 PM (#3013242)
Today's the deadline for guys to get added to 40 man rosters in order to protect them from next month's Rule 5 draft. One of the guys who look like they won't be protected is a fave of the intertubes, C - James Skelton - L/23 - .303/.456/.401 in 297 AB with 15 SB between Lakeland and Erie. I think his glove gets a bad rap (though it does need work), but worry that a high-walk, low-power guy will struggle as he moves up the ladder.
35. Der Komminsk-sar
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 04:39 PM (#3013317)
From the Red Sox, a pair of tweener OF, Corsaletti and Bell, are unprotected.
36. Dag Nabbit
Posted: November 20, 2008 at 04:48 PM (#3013323)
And, if anyone's curious (for partial seasons, I count it if he lasted over half a season):
50 years: Connie Mack
29 years: John McGraw
23 years: Walter Alton
19 years: Cap Anson, Bobby Cox (and counting), and Tommy Lasorda (though it's about 19.49999)
18 years: Wilbert Robinson
17 years: Sparky Anderson (with Detroit)
16 years: Fred Clarke
15 years: Tom Kelly, Joe McCarthy, Earl Weaver
14 years: Hughie Jennings
13 years: Tony LaRussa (and counting, in St Louis), Joe Cronin
12 years: Bruce Bochy, Jimmy Dykes, Miller Huggins, Red Schoendienst, Frank Selee, Casey Stengel, Joe Torre
11 years: Jim Leyland
10 years: Dusty Baker, WHitey Herzog, Lou Piniella, Bill Terry, Harry Wright
9 years: Felipe Alou, Sparky Anderson (Cincy), Billy Barnie, Lou Boudreau, Cito Gasto, Clark Griffith, Tony LaRussa (9.4999 with Oakland), Al Lopez, Bill McKechnie (Cincy), Mike Scioscia (and counting), Chuck Tanner
8 years: Frank Chance, Leo Durocher (Brkn), Leo Durcoher (NYG), Phil Garner, Mike Hargrove, Bucky Harris, Ralph Houk, Gene Mauch, Jim McAleer, Bill McKechnie (Boston), Bill Rigney, George Stallings, Patsy Tebaeu, Bobby Valentine
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
In baseball history, there have been 22 different times a manager has lasted at least a dozen seasons with a team. On four occasions, he ended that stretch with a losing record. Can you name any of those four managerial stints of 12+ seasons with a sub-.500 winning percentage?
Tom Kelly is another.
Jim Leyland only lasted 11 years in Pittsburgh. Gene Mauch never lasted longer than 9 years in any stint.
Halfway there.
Bucky Harris had three stints with the Senators that added up to 18 seasons at a .485 clip, but that probably doesn't qualify him as an answer to the question, I'm guessing.
I also found another answer, but since I looked it up I will shut up about it :)
And then there was one.
Jimmy Dykes lasted a little over 12 years with the Whtie Sox. He is the only man to last that long without ever winning a pennant.
Tom Kelly had the lowest winning percentage of anyone in a 12+ year stretch with one team, .478 in 15 years in Minnesota.
Anyone want to try guessing the other 18 times a manager lasted at least 12 consecutive seasons with a team? Earl Weaver's been mentioned, leaving 17 more.
Bobby Cox
Joe Torre
Walter Alston
Tommy Lasorda
The 9 mentioned: Dykes, Bochy, Mack, Kelly, Weaver, Cox, Torre, Alston, and Lasorda.
McCarthy
McGraw
The 12mentioned: Alston, Bochy, Cox, Dykes, Kelly, Lasorda, Mack, Torre, Weaver.
Miller Huggins
Wilbert Robinson
Red Schoendheist
Bill Terry
Dusty Baker?
You got the other four -- and I thought Schoendienst might be the last one guessed.
16 mentioned so far: Alston, Anderson, Bochy, Cox, Dykes, Huggins, Kelly, Lasorda, Mack, McCarthy, McGraw, Robinson, Schoendienst, Stengel, Torre, Weaver.
Mentioned so far: Alston, Anderson, Bochy, Cox, Dykes, Huggins, Kelly, LaRussa, Lasorda, Mack, McCarthy, McGraw, Robinson, Schoendienst, Stengel, Torre, Weaver.
Just 5 more to go.
Edit: And Hughie Jennings.
You're only missing two more.
20 mentioned so far: Alston, Anderson, Anson, Bochy, Cox, Cronin, Dykes, Huggins, Kelly, LaRussa, Lasorda, Mack, McCarthy, McGraw, Robinson, Schoendienst, Selee, Stengel, Torre, Weaver.
Only one to go!
21 mentioned so far: Alston, Anderson, Anson, Bochy, Clarke, Cox, Cronin, Dykes, Huggins, Kelly, LaRussa, Lasorda, Mack, McCarthy, McGraw, Robinson, Schoendienst, Selee, Stengel, Torre, Weaver.
Alston, Anderson, Anson, Bochy, Clarke, Cox, Cronin, Dykes, Huggins, Jennings, Kelly, LaRussa, Lasorda, Mack, McCarthy, McGraw, Robinson, Schoendienst, Selee, Stengel, Torre, Weaver.
That's 31502 wins, a .548 winning percentage, 95 pennants, and 44 World Series trophies.
Edit: I guess you didn't.
50 years: Connie Mack
29 years: John McGraw
23 years: Walter Alton
19 years: Cap Anson, Bobby Cox (and counting), and Tommy Lasorda (though it's about 19.49999)
18 years: Wilbert Robinson
17 years: Sparky Anderson (with Detroit)
16 years: Fred Clarke
15 years: Tom Kelly, Joe McCarthy, Earl Weaver
14 years: Hughie Jennings
13 years: Tony LaRussa (and counting, in St Louis), Joe Cronin
12 years: Bruce Bochy, Jimmy Dykes, Miller Huggins, Red Schoendienst, Frank Selee, Casey Stengel, Joe Torre
11 years: Jim Leyland
10 years: Dusty Baker, WHitey Herzog, Lou Piniella, Bill Terry, Harry Wright
9 years: Felipe Alou, Sparky Anderson (Cincy), Billy Barnie, Lou Boudreau, Cito Gasto, Clark Griffith, Tony LaRussa (9.4999 with Oakland), Al Lopez, Bill McKechnie (Cincy), Mike Scioscia (and counting), Chuck Tanner
8 years: Frank Chance, Leo Durocher (Brkn), Leo Durcoher (NYG), Phil Garner, Mike Hargrove, Bucky Harris, Ralph Houk, Gene Mauch, Jim McAleer, Bill McKechnie (Boston), Bill Rigney, George Stallings, Patsy Tebaeu, Bobby Valentine
53 terms by 49 guys.
The Braves have left Eric Campbell and Kaiihuie unprotected. KK might be picked up by some team lookin for a power pinch hitter.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main