User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
Vivid Seats is a sports ticket broker, concert ticket broker and theater ticket broker offering the best baseball tickets like Yankees tickets, Cubs tickets, and Red Sox tickets, as well as Police reunion tour tickets and Jersey Boys tickets. |
We have baseball tickets, the NFL schedule, college football tickets and Cowboys tickets. We have NBA tickets like Celtics tickets and Lakers tickets. Plus, buy Giants tickets, Patriots tickets and Colts tickets. Also check out our MLB baseball schedule |
Concerts Theatre NFL Angels Dodgers MLB Celtics Theater NBA Tickets Venues NHL Lakers Tickets NFL Yankees NHL Phillies NBA Wicked Marlins MLB Concerts Cubs Mets Red Sox Wicked WWE Red Sox Mets Yankees Dodgers |
Page rendered in 0.8394 seconds
81 querie(s) executed


Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
This is a classless move by Omar - no doubt about it. But I don't think it's even the most disgraceful act in Mets history! I'd give that award to Vince Coleman and his firecracker handouts or the trade of Tom Seaver.
a) 1919 World Series
b) CCNY point shaving
c) Pete Rose betting on his own team
d) Any number of thrown boxing matches
rate a bit higher than the firing of Willie.
or, you know, African-Americans being barred from playing professional sports for 80-some-odd years
As long as Robothal agrees with this basic premise, I have no problem with the rest of his rip. And there is no doubt at all that the long-term success of the franchise depends on Minaya -- or someone -- getting a handle on the dysfunction that rules the roost. But in reality, it makes little or no sense to blame Minaya for this issue, because the reality is that Jeff Wilpon is so determined to meddle and have his hand in things and so impatient that at the least sign of a bump in the road (and there are ALWAYS bumps in the road; it's the nature of the business . . . .), he will forget to just trust the guy in charge and go talk to one of the assistant GMs, or the pitching coach, or the director of scouting, and ask them whether the GM is doing X or Y or Z right, and the whole vicious cycle of backbiting and mistrust starts again. There isn't a GM in the history of the game who can succeed over the long haul with that going on.
Sure, he could have been more decisive here, and he should have been. Weeks ago. But that's the short-term, and it's not the fundamental issue.
So Met fans, does this spark the Mets or not?
Well, I truly believe Randolph had lost the clubhouse. The players' comments and Wagner's behavior, in particular, showed that. But them responding to Manuel is a whole different issue.
Get down! [dives]
It isn't that they fired him. It's how they did it. I don't think anyone (other than his immediate family, perhaps) disagrees with firing Randolph but the situation was handled like $hit.
It could be my Yankee bias, but I don't think Yogi had much of a chance to show what he could do.
you could make a case for Girardi and the Marlins. Any managerial move who's only explanation is "Jeffrey Loria is an asshat" has to rate pretty high.
50. Some slight improvement, owing mainly to the likelihood of being somewhat (but only marginally) healthier, but not really a spark. Happy?
Are you talking poorly executed, or just dumb.
As for unfair, I'd have to tab Tony Perez's shitcanning as being worse than Yogi's. Berra managed the year before and finished third, so he had some time. Plus he was working for a guy he knew had a short fuse with managers.
Perez got a 44-game stint as a rookie manager with the Reds before young pup Bowden pulled the plug.
I guess they could have fired him during the flight to California, had the plane land, and made him get off in Laramie.
MGL wrote something about this on his blog. Fired managers usually have multiyear guaranteed contracts, and I think Willie is no exception. He'll be getting a few million over the next few years to play gold, vacation with his family, or sit on his azz.
We should all be so oppressed.
Now that's some managerial depth in the organization.
And if there's one guy I turn to when I have questions on what is the best way to deal with my fellow man, it's MGL.
Well, the entire team was livid at him for not pitching Whitey Ford in games 1,4 and 7. Ford threw 18 shutout innings in the series, and the whole team thought Casey singlehandedly cost them the series. And, he was 70 years old.
So, probably a move that had to be made.
Oh no, they're going to hire Jack McKeon, aren't they?!?
What's that? The team he GMs for has to suck while he's there and 5 years after that?
Randolph seems like a good and decent man, but I don't quite get the hysteria either. Everyone knows that the manager is the first to take the blame when a team is perceived as underperforming, fairly or not.
I thought the Yankees treatment of Joe Torre was more disgraceful than this was. It's not exactly as though Randolph is Connie Mack or something.
If he were Connie Mack, he'd have only himself to blame for the way his firing was handled.
Now Jerry Manuel and Charlie Manuel are both managers in the NL East.
As well as Manuel Acta.
Jack won a ring since leaving Cincy.
And on an interim basis I wager he gets results.
But then I am biased toward old b#stards who tell folks the facts of life whether they like it or not.
Player-manager Manuel Acosta seems more likely.
I don't know what the Nationals will do. They should just change their name to the Washington Mutuals. That's close enough.
(Acta doesn't count.)
If so, New York baseball this year ought to be a controlled substance.
They left him twisting in the wind for weeks, then fired him the day after a coast-to-coast road trip began. That's more the issue, not so much whether he deserved to be fired.
As for where it sits on "most disgraceful"...probably not top twenty. In addition to #7's post, I could name many atrociously refereed NBA games that were more disgraceful than this, plus OTTOMH Charles Martin, Marty McSorley, and Ben Christenson should all have done jail time; McSorley and Christenson should still be in jail AFAIC.
Que?
Well, the entire team was livid at him for not pitching Whitey Ford in games 1,4 and 7. Ford threw 18 shutout innings in the series, and the whole team thought Casey singlehandedly cost them the series. And, he was 70 years old.
So, probably a move that had to be made.
and, rumor has it, he was getting into the habit of asking for someone who hadn't been with the team for a couple of years to go in and pinch-hit
another double firing after winning the pennant was Yogi & Johnny Keane after the 64 season; both organizations had apparently already decided by September that they were going to fire the managers after the season, but then both teams got hot and won the pennant(s)
If only middle management was the problem.
Little Wilpon gives one greater appreciation for Little Stein.
Whether it's the Yankees or Mets or Knicks, what's up with the nepotism? I thought NYC was supposed to be the place you made it on your own?
I'm having a hard time seeing the evidence the Mets are that good. Willie Randolph aside, the fundamental truth is that their top-shelf talent is thin -- they don't have that much of it that is truly reliable or can provide enough production to matter. And when the players they have who are the most productive go down, or can't last enough innings (starting pitching), they don't have quality behind them, either in terms of the bench or in the bullpen, to provide quality performances that produce wins.
The 2005 Mets 83 games and they started no better than the 2008 Mets. This team is better than that one.
We disagree here, unless this is an argument on who the top-shelf talent is. It hasn't been Reyes/Wright/Beltran/Santana who have hurt the Mets. It's the RF/LF/1B/4/5 starting pitchers who have dragged the Mets down.
Richard Nixon would be proud.
Willie Randolph (2005-08)
3 years/$5.65M (2007-09), plus 2010 club option
fired 6/17/08
signed extension 1/07 (replaces final year of previous contract)
07:$1.4M, 08:$2M, 09:$2.25M, 10:$2.5M club option
unless you've got a deal that pays you $3.5M to do nothing for the next year and a half. From Cot's, of course.
That's three hitters and one pitcher. That's the very definition of "thin" top shelf talent. You cannot win with a line-up that goes three productive hitters deep. If you go into a season with a line-up where you are counting on Alou and Castillo and Delgado to be among your productive hitters, that might be OK, but you sure as hell better recognize that you MUST have a strong bench behind them, because they are old and rickety and they are going to miss significant time. And if you go into the season with a strong rotation, but one whose Achilles heel is that they don't go deep into games (because they don't throw strikes and because some of 'em are old as dirt), then you sure as hell better strengthen that bullpen behind them, because those relievers are going to get worked to death. That's what I mean when I say the front-line talent is thin -- in a variety of ways, it needs a lot of help behind it, and the team doesn't have that help.
Except the Mets are 5th in the NL runs, and within shouting distance of being third. They are scoring more runs than the Braves, Sam.
Church is coming back soon as well. I don't think Sam is going to be happy until all the older players are gone even the productive ones.
The Mets have exactly one old starter in their rotation, Pedro Martinez. The rest are younger than 30.
The 2005 White Sox had just one productive hitter, two if you count Jermaine Dye. And one, maybe two top-shelf talent pitchers. Lotta middle-shelvers, though, true, particularly in the 'pen. The Mets aren't really that bad off so far, and the new manager bump could get them back in the thick of things.
What is astounding is that this is happening with no production from RF for about a month, and no production from LF for all but two weeks.
Now, that's not true. I'm just not going to be happy until the Mets show a willingness to give younger players a chance, and quit recycling ancient unproductive players like Easley and Tatis for absolutely no good reason whatsoever. It is because of the debacle that is the Mets' bench and bullpen that they have not been able to ride out the twin problems of (a) injuries to Alou and Church and (b) short stings by their starting pitchers.
For instance, I'm not the biggest Castillo fan in the world, but I think he's adequate for second base and (unlike Dial) don't even have a problem with him hitting second. It's not old I have an issue with per se. It's the fetishization of Proven Veteran™ status that this become this team's signature, and the utter absence of youth, energy, and opportunity.
It's the players on the periphery, the ones who I'd be surprised to still be here in 2010, those are the players of quality that we are missing.
Fair enough. Call it "solidly productive" talent rather than "top shelf" if you like. The Mets should have known that MANY of the players the Mets are/were counting on to be solidly productive -- the Alous and Delgados and Pedros and Ollies -- and thus critical to the success of the team could not be relied on for various reasons. Because of their unreliability due to age, or durability, or the way they pitch, the rest of the Mets roster had to be designed differently. With much better and different (and in many cases, yes, younger) players than they have.
keane wasn't fired. he jumped before he could be pushed, and went to the yankees. he didn't last long. had a bad year with the yanks in 65, fired in 66, died jan. 67.
didn't he get on the wrong side of ownership at some point? i read creamer's bio of him years ago, don't remember this part, except that at the time, casey said something like he'd never make the mistake of being 70 again ...
Absolutely. Hawk Harrelson was the worst GM in history. He canned LaRussa a few months after making him play Fisk in left (and that was despite trading away centerfielder Rudy Law, making the OF a real mess).
firing casey after the yanks lost in 60 was pretty lame. essentially the same team went on the win four straight pennants and a couple of WS.
Well, the entire team was livid at him for not pitching Whitey Ford in games 1,4 and 7. Ford threw 18 shutout innings in the series, and the whole team thought Casey singlehandedly cost them the series. And, he was 70 years old.
So, probably a move that had to be made.
And by some accounts Stengel had slipped a bit mentally. He wasn't senile, but his reputation was based on being the sharpest tack in the box, and that was gone. His experience with the Mets doesn't help him much either.
Also, they had Ralph Houk waiting and he was arguably the best regraded managerial prize in baseball at the time. If the Yanks didn't give him the job, someone else would've snatched him instead.
They also cleaned out George Weiss at the same time.
If it really was the same team, that's a knock against Stengel. They plyaed .642 ball from 1961-3, and they only played that well for one season under Stengel (in 1954).
The Yanks worst firing? Easy - letting George Stallings go because Hal Chase didn't like him. That's 63 different kinds of stupid.
Joe Altobelli was treateed exceptionally poorly on his way out the door in Baltimore. He won a title for them in '83 but when Weaver decided to comeback, Altobielli was reduced to wandering the hallways of the Orioles's front office asking people if they knew if he'd been fired.
Delgado is .272/.346/.488 over the last 44 games with 8 HR (and .306/.370/.490 the last two weeks)--not world beating to be sure but that'd be Babe freakin' Ruth on the Blue Jays.
Of course, after checking his situational hitting maybe he still is a Blue Jay.
Best Regards
John
And if WKRP in Cincinnati has taught us anything, he was fired, rather than resign.
I have no problem with either Castillo or Alou, but counting on both is just foolishly risky. The Alou debacle could easily have been the Castillo debacle instead - both are productive when healthy, but you can't count on them to be healthy.
Schneider or Castillo is okay. But if you have both, then basically Omar's conceding that the lineup will accomodate 2 slots where we could get sub .350 SLG production (3 slots if counting the pitcher). That's why we were in the bottom of the league in HRs at the beginning of the year.
As we've said many times before here, it wasn't a single move that sank the Mets, but the series of move in conjunction which left this team vulnerable.
5 things I learned from WKRP
1. White loafers do not go with plaid suits.
2. Brunettes are hotter than blondes.
3. Cocaine does not cure athlete's foot, it only numbs the itching
4. Walls are a state of mind
5. TURKEYS CAN'T FLY!
I think Ricciardi is Italian for Minaya--Brad Wilkerson and Kevin Mench anyone while Adam Lind rots in AAA?
Best Regards
John
The Mets don't have anyone like that.
That's an idea, the Mets should offer Delgado (+ $) to Toronto for Lind & Overbay (less toasty than Delgado)- and exchange headcases Perez for Burnett...
Only one team has ever had three World Series winning managers who also won over 1000 games individually in their career manage them in the same season. The 1990 Cards.
Only one other team has ever had three World Series winning managers run the team in the same season. The 1929 Cards.
Oh, and I just remembered what the worst managerial hiring of all-time was: the Cubs firing Joe McCarthy with a handful of games left in the season in order for Rogers Hornsby to take the reigns. McCarthy had turned the team around (they were in last place the year before he showed up) and took them to their first pennant in over a decade in 1929. He went to New York and continued with a peerless career as skipper. Hornsby was one of the worst managers in baseball history, and just plain was the worst ever at dealing with and communicating with players.
Other departures of note I haven't seen mentioned yet:
Davey Johnson 1995 Cincy
Davey Johnson 1997 Balt
Davey Johnson 2000 LA
Al Lopez 1956 Cle
Dusty Baker 2002 SFG
Bobby Cox 1985 Tor (did he resign or something?)
Buck Showlater 1995 NYY
Bob Lemon 1978 CWS (surprised by this one? Ask a Sox fan about the '77 South Side Hit-Men)
Bill McKechnie 1926 Pit
Larry Dierker 2001 Hou
He's not Lind, but what the heck does Pascucci have to do to earn a shot?
There is a flock of wild turkeys near where I live, about two year sago I was driving down the street, towards the setting sun, and there were all these large blobs in a tree (late fall)...
I couldn't make out what they were until the tree was no longer silhouetted- Turkeys, I slowed down, wondering, how did such big birds get into the tree? Just then, a big male by the side of my car stuck his wings out (Big effing wing span) and took off (no running start either- like vultures need)at a 45 degree angle into the tree. You could hear the whoosh as it pushed air with its wings...
I was impressed, I really did not think they could do it, since then I've seen a few others fly. They prefer to walk because they are really big and heavy animals, and flying for them is a lot more strenuous than for lighter birds- but so help me they can fly.
They are more concerned about the Maple Leafs' GM search.
Dick Howser got fired by the Yankees after winning the division in 1980.
Danny Murtaugh left the Pirates after winning the 1971 WS; I assume he retired, although he came back later.
The Dodgers fired Charley Dressen after winning back-to-back pennants in 1952-53.
Dick Williams left the A's after winning the 1973 WS.
It's funny how many managers have left teams immediately after taking them to the World Series.
Yes. The Dodgers only gave out one year contracts to managers then, and so I guess technically Dressen wasn't fired--he wasn't re-hired. He asked for a 3 year contract and O'Malley said no and went with Walter Alston (who, despite managing for 23 years, also never got a multi-year contract).
Women, can't live with'em, can't stick'em in a sack and leave'em in the closet when talkin' money.
Beat the crap out of two of his pitchers in a drunken bar fight.
Dick Howser got fired by the Yankees after winning the division in 1980.
See 90.
Dick Williams left the A's after winning the 1973 WS.
Hated Charley Finley's guts.
Oh, and the runner who got nailed at the plate? Yup, Willie Randolph.
In retrospect, no, but the Reds did win the division the first year he was gone.
The Tigers waited about 50 games into the '79 campaign to fire their first-year manager, Les Moss, so they could snap up Sparky. Moss waited his whole life for the job, lasted a couple months, was never really heard from again. Tough business.
Sparky promised us Tiger fans a WS winner within 5 years and delivered.
George had the temerity to claim that Howser was "resigning" becuz of these wonderful "real-estate opportunities" that he (Howser) wanted to pursue
(gutless (forget))
Not play for an Omar Minaya GM'd organization?
Seriously, Pascucci is not some hidden diamond, he's got power, but as an everyday player in the majors he'd probably STRUGGLE mightily to clear .250, but he's willing to take a walk, and he bats righty whereas Delgado bats lefty and can't hit lefties to save himself- so hauling up Pascucci to spell Delgado makes sense to me when the Mets seem to be carrying three catchers for some mysterious reason....
Huh. I learned this from Charlie's Angels.
Casey Stengel and George Weiss were told in late September this was the end of the line. Topping never really cared for Stengel and Webb faded in support. They eliminated his instructional camp in 1958. Ralph Houk had a job offer from Kansas City. I don't think the Yankees would have done as well if he stayed (Bouton says players got tired of newspaper stories always being about Zack Wheat and Uncle Robbie instead of what they did). But he and Weiss did rebuild the team on the fly. Houk also did things like start Whitey Ford every 4th day.
Yogi went into the meeting after the 1964 world series planning on asking for a two year deal after losing the world series in seven games without shortstop Kubek, Ford after game one and reliever Pedro Ramos wasn't acquired before September 1st (according to Bill Veeck it was ownership and not GM Houk who made the deal to get the Cuban Cowboy). He was shocked to get the pink slip and a few weeks later was in Queens with Stengel and Weiss.
Anyone ever hear why Hank Bauer was fired in mid 1968? He wins first world series for the organization in 65 years. Gets fired although the Orioles did replace him with Earl Weaver. Maube he was too much "these players aren't tough like we were on Okinawa". Golenbock's "Dybasty" talks about him being disillousioned managing minor leaguers in early 1970s.
Of course this was a poorly handled firing but what else can you expect from an organization that is tight with Lupica? Yjey have no brains or sense of smell.
He didn't retire nor was fired. He took a different job in the organization. I think he had a chronic heart problem. That's both why he kept coming & going with the Pirates, and why he died so young. The team never fired him.
Similarly, Houk became GM after leading the Yanks to 3 straight Series from 1961-3.
Anyone ever hear why Hank Bauer was fired in mid 1968? He wins first world series for the organization in 65 years. Gets fired although the Orioles did replace him with Earl Weaver. Maube he was too much "these players aren't tough like we were on Okinawa". Golenbock's "Dybasty" talks about him being disillousioned managing minor leaguers in early 1970s.
Well, they win in 1966. Then they flounder in 1967, and were stuck at .500 in 1968. He didn't live up to expectations.
Yep, some of them like to spend time in trees - and they don't climb up there, I promise.
I have about a dozen of 'em living down the street from me. They spend most of their time on 3 or 4 different front lawns. If they are in the road, don't expect them to run/fly away quickly. They move at their own chosen speed.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main