Baseball for the Thinking Fan

Login | Register | Feedback

btf_logo
You are here > Home > Baseball Newsstand > Baseball Primer Newsblog > Discussion
Baseball Primer Newsblog
— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand

Friday, November 14, 2008

Terry Pluto defends voting Joe Maddon No. 2 for AL Manager of the Year

Planet X’s wrong box?

Pluto voted Gardenhire No. 1 and Maddon No. 2, and joked he now has “many fans in Tampa” after getting more than 20 emails from puzzled Rays fans.

But here’s Pluto’s explanation:

Gardenhire’s Twins didn’t make the playoffs (they lost in one-game playoff with the White Sox for the AL Central title), but voting was done in the final week of the regular season. Pluto said he has absolutely nothing against Maddon, whom he has a lot of respect for. It was just a tough decision at the time.

“The voting is done in the final week of the season, so I did not have the playoffs to consider,” Pluto said. “If they did the voting after, certainly Joe would have got it. I had great respect for both men, and gave the edge to Gardenhire for keeping his team in contention after losing Santana, etc. I had no idea how anyone else was voting. I certainly didn’t set out to stiff Joe by being the lone voice not to have him No. 1.”

Pluto said, “I’m glad Joe won. Clearly after what he did in the playoffs, he deserves it. It’s just how it is.”

Pluto said he’s trying to respond to every email he’s received, which have included a one-word, “Idiot,” and even some from fans in Cleveland who love his work but were wowed by his vote.

Thanks to sm.

Repoz Posted: November 14, 2008 at 01:08 AM | 13 comment(s)
  Related News: GeneralClevelandMinnesotaTampa BayAwards

Reader Comments and Retorts

Go to end of page

Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.

Page 1 of 1 pages
   1. ?Donde esta Dagoberto Campaneris?  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 12:38 AM (#3008897)
I'm not overly concerned with who wins what award, but I think the Twins case is interesting in that after losing Santana, Hunter, and having Liriano start the year the way he did, it would have been very easy for the Twins to fold up their tent/baggy. I don't know if that makes Gardenhire's effort "better" than Maddon's, but I don't think you can go wrong giving Gardenhire his due. He's pretty damned good* and he has one hell of a track record.

I still would have voted for the guy with the funny glasses, but with his Angel pedigree- that's not saying much.

* I didn't realize just how good the Twins have been since Gardy took over. Someone give that man a toaster or something.
   2. Biff uses the power of mental thinking  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 01:27 AM (#3008909)
Who cares?
   3. Vegas Watch  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 01:31 AM (#3008912)
I'm amused by the idea that Joe Maddon earned this award with his flawless October performance.
   4. STEROIDS!!!!!  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 01:56 AM (#3008918)
None of us has any idea who is a good manager and who isn't. The whole award and voting process is completely pointless.
   5. caspian88  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 01:59 AM (#3008920)
Shouldn't they just rename it the "Most Surprising Team Award?"
   6. Harveys Wallbangers  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 05:35 AM (#3008929)
Shock:

Speak for yourself. Personally, I think it's a fairly straight line to determining who pushes their team one win beyond their "set point" and who does not.

A baseball manager is a people manager which gets lost in the haze of "tactics".

It's like judging the VP of Finance on his ability to keep the Fixed Assets ledger up to date.
   7. Trevor Crowe T. Robot (Dan Lee)  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 05:45 AM (#3008931)
I'd have probably voted for Maddon, but Gardy's a pretty defensible pick.

He won almost 90 games despite having somewhere between diddly and squat in the non-Morneau infield positions, a bad outfield, a starting rotation manned by guys like Livan Hernandez and Glen Perkins, losing Liriano for half a season, and not having Johan around. They looked for all the world like a fourth-place team before the season.
   8. Erik, Pinch-Commenter  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 06:40 AM (#3008933)
Why not give Scioscia the top spot for the huge difference in wins and run differential?
   9. Shooty Did Not Kill McGurk  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 07:39 AM (#3008942)
I think they should give it to Bob Geren because of his power of invisibility. He could totally hang out in the cheerleaders locker room while they showered if he wanted.
   10. Big Ed  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 09:25 AM (#3009013)
When did the issue of an award being unanimous become as important as the award itself? I doubt if the awardee will care very much in the future with the hardware on the mantle. What I see now is voters being affected by the idea that they might be singled out over a vote that's different, and modifying their opinions accordingly.

Not that this is important. Atention over this stuff is pushed by sports media.
   11. Fred Garvin, Collateral Damage  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 09:38 AM (#3009026)
I'm amused by the idea that Joe Maddon earned this award with his flawless October performance.


Same here. You have a guy who takes a perennial loser with MLB's worst record -- a team that has never won more than 70 games in its history -- and transforms them into a division winner, in the AL East to boot, with the 2nd best record in the AL.

Why does what he does in October make any difference?
   12. Superunknown Gary Geiger Counter  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 09:51 AM (#3009035)
Shouldn't they just rename it the "Most Surprising Team Award?"


My vote for this would go to the second-half Cleveland Indians. I know Wedge has done well in these awarsds in the past. How is he as a skipper.
   13. Slinger Francisco Barrios (Dr. Memory)  Posted: November 14, 2008 at 10:09 AM (#3009057)
Why not give Scioscia the top spot for the huge difference in wins and run differential?

Maybe the Angels shouldn't have had such a bad run differential and that was Sciocia's fault.
Page 1 of 1 pages

You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.

 

<< Back to main

Support BBTF

donate

Thanks to
TedBerg
for his generous support.

My Bookmarks

You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.

Vivid Seats is a sports ticket broker, concert ticket broker and theater ticket broker offering the best baseball tickets like Yankees tickets, Cubs tickets, and Red Sox tickets, as well as Police reunion tour tickets and Jersey Boys tickets.

We have baseball tickets, the NFL schedule, college football tickets and Cowboys tickets. We have NBA tickets like Celtics tickets and Lakers tickets. Plus, buy concert tickets, Patriots tickets and Colts tickets. Also check out our MLB baseball schedule

Baseball Bats

JustGreatTickets.com provides the best value for Chicago Cubs Tickets, MLB tickets including Red Sox Tickets, Yankees Tickets, SF Giants Tickets, LA Dodgers Tickets, Cleveland Indians Tickets. Get the best concert tickets like Jonas Brothers tickets and more Chicago Tickets.

Concerts Theatre NFL Angels Dodgers MLB Celtics Theater NBA Tickets Venues NHL Lakers Tickets NFL Yankees NHL Phillies NBA Wicked Marlins MLB Concerts Cubs Mets Red Sox Wicked WWE Red Sox Mets Yankees Dodgers

Major League Baseball: All Star Game, New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, LA Angels, Washington Nationals, Chicago White Sox, and the Chicago Cubs.

Find terrific deals on Yankees tickets for the new home, Cubs tickets for classic Wrigley, or Red Sox tickets for Fenway with OnlineSeats. We have seats for every baseball game, including Dodgers tickets.

Page rendered in 0.6003 seconds
82 querie(s) executed