|
|
|
|
Baseball Primer Newsblog— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand
Monday, October 31, 2005
Epstein had done some agonizing soul-searching the past few days, torn between staying at the job he had always coveted since his childhood days in Brookline and leaving because of intra-organizational politics and power struggles that he ultimately decided he could not live with any longer.
Now do you guys believe me about the factions?
Thanks to the quick link by Keith Willoughby.
Dan Szymborski
Posted: October 31, 2005 at 05:47 PM | 350 comment(s)
Related News: Boston
|
My Bookmarks
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Hot Topics
|
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
This is an interesting idea. Sabes would actually be pretty good for the Sox as they seem to be going the Yankee "win with veterans and don't give young players a chance" route.
As to where Epstein ends up, I would say that McCourt's Boston roots may override Fat Tommy, Bald Plaschke and the boys. If Sabes leaves the Giants, I'd be happy with him.
Theo to the Dodgers
DePo to the As
Beane to Boston (for Youkilis, of course)
Yeah, that's what I was thinking myself. 300, 325 and 350 the last three years supposedly. That's nice money obviously, but it's not like he doesn't need to work. I'm not as close the nonsense surrounding the Sox, being outside Boston and all, but Lucchino better be a goddam magician at what he does to make it worth all the crap he stirs up. He's like Manny, but I have no idea if he's capable of a 1.000 OPS. Speaking of Manny...does this mean he's gone?
Boston Red Sox
Los Angeles Dodgers
Arizona Diamondbacks
Washington Nationals
New York Yankees
Baltimore Orioles
Anyone else?
The reason is not just because Theo is leaving, but rather the fact that there is great instability/stupidity in the Red Sox front office, shown by the CHB story leaked on Sunday. Why was this done?
I liked Theo very much, thought he did a good job, but certainly not perfect (see Jeremy Giambi, BK Kim contract, Edgar Renteria). I have not great loathing for Lucky Lucchino, and having a heavy in the front office certainly can be an asset, but he'd better damn well be a SMART heavy........which the CHB story seems to indicate he's not. Why do you trash someone you're supposedly about to re-sign? Could he really be THAT Machiavellian?
Particularly disgusting in this story is CHB's water carrying for the LL faction. He must have been sleeping in the Journalism & Ethics class at Holy Cross.
you really think beane would agreet to work for lucchino?
Seriously, this sucks for Boston, and baseball in general. We need more people like Theo in baseball, not less.
you really think beane would agreet to work for lucchino?
I was starting to wonder if personnel dynamics didn't have something to do with Beane's decision to stay in Oakland.
Boston Red Sox
Los Angeles Dodgers
Arizona Diamondbacks
Washington Nationals
New York Yankees
Baltimore Orioles
Anyone else?
New York Mets
Beane's a part-owner of the Athletics now. It's extremely unlikely he moves in a deal like this.
In my time as General Manager, I gave my entire heart and soul to the organization. During the process leading up to today's decision, I came to the conclusion that I can no longer do so. In the end, my choice is the right one not only for me but for the Red Sox.
My affection for the Red Sox did not begin four years ago when I started working here, and it does not end today. I will remain on the job for several days as we finalize preparation for next week's general managers meetings. Thereafter, I will make myself available to the organization to ensure a smooth and stable transition.
Brinks
-Boston Boy, knows all the writers, and more importantly knows how to work them.
-A sabermetrics guy, but also has a significant mainstream scouting background
-Still under contract with the Jays until after 2007, but a bit of a lame duck with contract extension talks on hold, would have to beg out of his current situation.
-Experience as a G.M., mixed results in a tough division.
At the end of the day, being from Beantown and having experience will matter, the question , would he work for Lucchino? Would anybody work for this guy?
Damn this, but there have to be other people out there who have half a clue about baseball.
I was hoping to have a nice easy relaxing off season.
He trashed Pedro in the media when Pedro was thinking hard about resigning.
New York Mets
I'd say the Mets actually finally have some order in their FO, but yeah, they would have been on this list for about 15+ years.
Imagine if Theo replaced Sabean in SF? The Bay Area would be all moneyball, all the time.
I would be very happy if this happened, because it's been 51 years and it's time for my other team to win the World Series.
Theo to the Dodgers
DePo to the As
Beane to Boston (for Youkilis, of course)
Beane's daughter is still out west, and he now owns part of the team, so no.
Theo to Dodgers, Sabean to Boston, DePo in SF, maybe, though I suspect Ned Coletti or maybe #### Tidrow would have the inside track to replace Sabes.
So that's why they signed Renteria to block Ramirez and Varitek to block Shoppach? It doesn't look to me like the Sox are at all interested in getting younger.
It's because of this article CHB wrote on Sunday, which everyone says was planted by Lucchino. Here's a highlight:
Is it general philosophy or just personalities and managerial style?
The Sox have Jonathan Papelbon, Dustin Pedroia and Kevin Youkilis set to join the starting roster next year.
I don't quite believe this talk of herding goats (or other non-baseball hobbies) for Theo. Sounds like talk to keep his leverage in other negotiations. Starting at 1.5M per, of course.
NY Daily News, 7/30/05:Providence Journal, 7/31/05:Denver Post, 8/1/05:Gammons, 8/3/05:
Yeah, that's why Jon Papelbon, who had about 30 innings of major league experience, was their primary set-up man in the playoffs.
Although I think he's getting screwed in LA, I still don't want to see DePo in SF. My money would be on Coletti getting the job, but if Sabes leaves, I would like to see a GM that appreciates the usefulness of younger players.
CHB is like the old sportswriters Comiskey would buy off with free booze and food, except Shank does it for the satisfaction of being an a##hat. He is an evil alien organism that survives on venom and hatred.
The quote following shows how disengenuous CHB is. What does going to the Final Four have to do with baseball? And it forgets that Theo worked full-time for the Pads while going to law school. If you are not going to be an attorney, there is a lot of free time at law school. And it ignores the fact that Lucky the Lobster does not have much of a baseball evaluation background, either.
This thing comes up every other week or so in the media here in Toronto. I don't think there's anything to it right now, for two reasons:
(1) Ricciardi's under contract and the Jays do not want to let him go right now. It's a sensitive point in the team's development and the Jays need continuity this offseason.
(2) Ricciardi's stock has fallen through the floor the last two seasons. I honestly think he's not much of a commodity right now.
I have never heard or read an intelligent and thoughtful defense of CHB. Nobody who has a clue likes the turd, and he has been doing it for years. If you feel like ####ing into the wind, here are the emails for the sports editor and shank:
jtsullivan@globe.com
dshaughnessy@globe.com
Of course, they yanked him out of the rotation for Fatty McBushlover, who was crap the rest of the season. He was the setup man in the playoffs because he was the best pitcher (other than Timlin or Wakefield) on the team at that point.
Right, because Papelbon was on the roster all year. It's not like they called him up because all of their veteran relievers sucked.
Globe, 10/26/05:Herald, 10/27/05:I should note, here, that a lot of people were very skeptical of the above Massarotti column. And not without reason - he had no sources to cite. I suggest, in hindsight, that he might have received the same leak Shaughnessy did, but chose not to run with it.
Globe, 10/27/05:Providence Journal, 10/29/05:Herald, 10/31/05:Herald, 10/31/05:
Actually, I've never thanked my lucky stars that I don't work in baseball. But I could.
However, this team will move on. Who knows they might discover another Theo from within...
No, no, not at all, Shoe. That quote's a small part of the BS that Lucchino fed CHB. The bulk of it was pseudo-psych crapola about Theo resenting Lucchiavelli the way a son resents his father, etc.
Theo HAD to read that and just say, "how the eff can I work for a guy who would put this nonsense out there? This is disingenous, calculating, malignant, and manipulative... and I'm not gonna stand for it anymore."
So: KUDOS TO THEO. THIS IS THE MOST PRINCIPLED STAND I'VE SEEN IN SPORTS--OR IN BUSINESS--FOR A LONG TIME.
I'm disappointed, shocked--and damned proud of Theo all at the same time.
Strangely, while it makes me anxious about the near-term fate of my Sox, I find it reassuring that there are young men of high ideals like Theo.
Anyhow, here is one Red Sox fan who is no longer a Red Sox fan. If there are any MLB owners reading, hire Theo and I'll become a fan of your team! (As long as you don't play in St. Louis or the Bronx, I still hate you #######).
Well, if he wanted the job he would have taken it three years ago.
Yes.
I also suggest emailing the ombudsman in the midst of their "review" of Globe "conflicts of interest."
ombud@globe.com
Lucky that personality conflicts don't occur in non-baseball industries.
---
VLR's response is certainly not mine. I don't think anything could make stop being a Red Sox fan. I just thank god they won the World Series in '04, because I don't see things improving from this point, for a while.
I don't think I will start actively routing against them... but I certainly won't care as much.
Perhaps they'll interview him again.
I am so confused right now. A part of me is angry and wants to find out more about what about happened.
Another part of me is scared for the future of the team, while another just wants to find out who the hell is going to be the next friggin GM.
Sometimes I hate it, that I love this team so much.
I just told Lu and her first words were after "You have to be (forget)ing kidding me" were "So, I'll guess we'll be talking in a week"
There are exceptions, but one of Steinbrenner's strengths is that despite the clashes, he seems to have been able to maintain overall front office stability for the last decade or so in terms of continuity of personnel. I'd be surprised if Stick left. Cashman said getting him back was important, but he also said he could not gurantee Stick wanted to come back.
Where, crispy? And I'd love to know how the he11 Gammo would know. Reporters generally don't reveal their sources, especially to each other, so you'd have to guess Gammo is (once again) carrying Lucchiavelli's water.
If so, that'd be a huge miscalculation on Petey's part: This is gonna blow up big time for Lucchiavelli. He's always been too clever by half, too smarmy and lawyerly for his own good. Finally, it's gonna cost him, in that his true nature isn't hidden from the masses.
This is likely not to be received particularly well, but then tact has never been my strong suit.
For heaven's sake, he quit over THAT??
Look, big companies of all types have office politics. There is always, ALWAYS, one guy with a title (if not SEVERAL) who are pr*cks. B*stards. MFers. They revel in playing folks off one another.
Now, if you are going to play with the big kids you have to understand it. You do NOT have to ACCEPT it per se. But certainly you have to understand that it exists and if you have a PASSION about being someplace and BELIEVE you are the one who can make a difference you work through it.
Is it easy? No. Can it be stressful? Obviously. Do you risk becoming one of THEM? Perhaps, if you lose center trying to WIN as opposed to doing what's right.
But to pick up your marbles and go home? This is NOTHING. It's SOP for any organization experiencing success. Success has a million fathers while failure is an orphan. Anyone else remember that quotation?
Please tell me there is something else.
Cause kid, it don't get any easier.
Paulie got canned because he couldn't outmaneuver TOMMY LASORDA for CRISSAKES. And now Theo walks away. And I really don't understand why.
Principled??? More like perplexing.
I'm a Cubs fan.
oops
Larry "Scooter" Lucchino
Hey...I walked away from the Yankees 32 years ago after a tiff with the Boss...and I've never looked back, I'm gruesomely lonely during pennent races, but I stand by my assheadedness!.
Someone screwed up here and I'm thinking it wasn't Theo Epstein.
oops
Well, I can always hope that MacPhail will take this as an opportunity to dump Hendry and Baker.
That could happen. Right?
Alternatively, I should probably relearn how to enjoy rooting for a crappy team.
Sorry, Harvey, I couldn't disagree more.
Thinking that way is thinking like Lucchino.
When people fail to treat you with honesty and respect, and instead use the media to belittle you and establish their dominance, if you "understand" it and take their money to keep "understanding" it, you are making the world a worse place.
If, OTOH, you say "take your job and your unscrupulous nature and shove it," and you move on to a better place where people ARE honest and respectful, you are admirable, worthy, and doing what's right. Lie down with dogs, etc. etc.
I say again: Theo's principled stand is rare and worthy of praise. The good feeling I get from that far outweighs the momentary concerns about how the Sox will make out.
To be honest I think the Red Sox will be fine.
The person I think is going to end up regretting this is Epstein. He is probably never going to be in as good a situation. Office politics be damned. Few teams have the resources of the Red Sox. No town is going to give Epstein any kind of grace period like he would get now in Boston because of the World Series victory. Good luck to Epstein. I hope things work out the way he wants....
Maybe George can send them Connors and Emslie as a sort of leand-lease.
Hmmmm....
This is likely not to be received particularly well, but then tact has never been my strong suit.
- grinning
too true. but you are absolutely dead honest with zero BS and no sneaky or slimy. no backstabbing. which is why i like you.
For heaven's sake, he quit over THAT??
- well, he's not THAT old. what's wrong with saying there's too much bad with the good and you want to do something else with your life. there's a whole lot of things he can do where he's his own person and don't hafta spend most of his time playing politics. of course, there's lot of politics in social work. but maybe he likes what he'd be doing more.
arena recently (e-mail for details), I'm not at all surprised
he effed these negotiations up. Sheesh.
What a load of ####! There is no evidence Theo asked for $2.5M, Grady Little blew it, the Globe still does not understand the Jamesian theory of reliever usage, and Theo has shown he has talent for putting together a team that finds cheap talent and builds the minors so going to LAD or PHI with $80M would not be an impossible task.
This was more true in the past, and even then soem but I think very few high profile folks actually quit on him. He was more likely to fire you--Howser, Martin, Lemon, Yogi, etc. I think Gabe Paul left to got to Cleveland.
Steinbrenner is difficult day to day, but I think he has a strong streak of human kindness and even graciousness that shows itself often enough that his charges find him almost endearing. Enough, when coupled with the money and prestige, it keeps people around.
Where did you hear this? I'm not doubting you. With Cashman returning, it wouldn't surprise me if Michaels stayed. He still has three years remaining on his contract but there were reports just four days ago that he was requesting a buyout because he was upset over being stripped of postseason scouting duties and the demotion of his top two aides. Still, Steinbrenner never lets anyone leave, even those he doesn't listen to; Brian Sabean and Bob Watson are I think the only FO people who have left over the past 15 years. My dream of Michaels leading the Red Sox FO is probably farfetched.
HW,
I'm with OleProf on this one.
When you are at the top of the game, and Theo is, he can write his own check - he doesn't need to share anything with Lucchino - the Dodger job, the Phillies job.
I mean, Theo brought a WS title to Boston! Do you have any idea how impossible that was? Those losers? The biggest choking dogs I've ever laid eyes on?
Theo *knows* there are politics everywhere, but he also knows he can *pick* his politics right now.
It was a great move.
Of course they will. Boston didn't win the World Series because of their sabermetric acumen, though it played a part; they won it because they had the resources to outspend almost everyone else in the league and benefit from a salary dump.
I'm just curious--why was Epstein's initial contract only two years? It seems like most GMs (DePodesta, Ricciardi)typically get three or more years (I think those two got 5 year contracts). Does anyone know if it was Lucchino or Epstein that wanted to first deal to be so short?
Mueller.
Ortiz.
Getting Dave Roberts.
Having the sack to trade Nomar.
Theo did other great stuff, and other than having a little too much faith in Matt Clement [money], never really made any DUBIOUS moves.
But as a Yankee fan, I must say, awesome job Lar. Lar... heh.
Bollocks. If that was the case, the Yankees would have won the Series.
The Red Sox won because they got David Ortiz for nothing, while every other team in baseball had its thumb up their butts.
man, that's harsh.
It was 3 years. He started in November 2002
That's an idealized world you live in my friend. Not trying to sound like Kissinger here but you can't make a place better from the outside. You gotta be IN the sandbox to build the castle.
You can either work to raise folks up or let them beat you down.
Now some might respond that if Theo doesn't have the passion to get past this stuff then he should walk. And I would retort that if he loses his mettle in these circumstances then maybe he's not designed to be a power broker like some have claimed.
LL is pretty run of the mill stuff from what I have followed from afar. If you can't finesse your way around this level of stooge might as well accept your lot as the next GM in Kansas City or Pittsburgh. Where "getting by" will win you an "Exce of the Year" award from MLB and free lunches for a year from the Rotarians.
Yipee.
62 percent on yahoo sports say this is indeed a bad omen.
38 percent say he can be replaced.
The NY Post--a dubious source if ever there was one, I admit--reported that:
Personally, I think George would rather pay Stick his full salary for three years rather than let him go to Boston, but that's me.
IMHO, he's one of the bigger jerks in MLB, HB.
he was on espnews.
Not that I'm not surprised by the tone of it, but it's also practicly word for word from the AP article which is on ESPN.com. So I don't necessarily think it's part of the PR spin.
Sad day for the franchise. Good luck to Theo. LL seems like the modern day Haywood Sullivan.
Stop talking about Mariano Rivera.
:)
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main