User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
Page rendered in 0.8419 seconds
57 querie(s) executed
You are here > Home > Transaction Oracle > Discussion
Transaction Oracle
— A Timely Look at Transactions as They Happen
— A Timely Look at Transactions as They Happen
Tuesday, January 20, 2009
2009 ZiPS Projections - Pittsburgh Pirates
This is a Long Drive for Someone With Nothing to Think About, The Moon & Antarctica, Good News for People Who Love Bad News, We Were Dead Before the Ship Even Sank.Despite an organization that has slowly started to turn things around, the last 15 years of the Pirates have consisted of salting the earth, tilling the soil, and resalting, leaving an organization with a major league team that looks like the inspiration for a Modest Mouse album.
There's hope for the future, but it's hard to be too hard on fans that are skeptical about Rebuilding Plan #27. It's needed, since Rebuilding Plans #1-26 were criminally incompetent in execution, so Pirate fans are going to have little choice but to sit and wait, and hope yearly that the Steelers provide enough sports happiness to tide Pittsburgh fans over for the spring and summer. It's not like they can un-buy the beautiful monument to corporate welfare.
As for the team, they have a few above-average hitters, neither of whom are good defensively at their positions. Adam LaRoche is probably the only one that is adequate both offensively and defensively at his position. The pitching is worse. Andy LaRoche will get a chance to turn it around after a horrific 2008, but hand/wrist/arm injuries have a way of permanently derailing careers.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CATCHERS
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name P Age AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+ RNG
VERY GOOD
Ryan Doumit# c 28 .287 .343 .463 109 363 54 104 26 1 12 55 25 65 2 2 110 Fr
POOR
Jason Jaramillo# c 26 .240 .302 .333 112 408 35 98 18 1 6 33 33 75 0 1 67 Vg
Robinzon Diaz c 25 .267 .287 .333 88 333 25 89 14 1 2 26 9 29 3 2 65 Fr
Miguel Perez c 25 .221 .254 .296 81 267 16 59 8 0 4 23 9 55 1 1 46 Vg
Steven Lerud* c 24 .191 .247 .293 106 372 31 71 14 0 8 36 24 104 1 2 43 Vg
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FIRST BASEMEN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name P Age AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+ RNG
AVERAGE
Adam LaRoche* 1b 29 .268 .343 .485 141 497 67 133 34 1 24 81 57 117 1 1 115 Av
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FAIR
Andy Phillips 1b 32 .268 .327 .410 85 239 30 64 11 1 7 24 20 42 1 1 94 Av
POOR
Garrett Jones* 1b 28 .254 .304 .427 129 480 55 122 28 2 17 64 35 97 4 2 90 Av
Brandon Moss* lf 25 .251 .312 .403 135 471 49 118 30 3 12 57 42 124 5 3 87 Fr
Steven Pearce if 26 .245 .299 .407 133 474 53 116 30 1 15 67 32 89 11 3 86 Av
Andy LaRoche 3b 25 .232 .325 .363 131 427 53 99 18 1 12 50 57 69 7 2 82 Av
Ramon Vazquez* 3b 32 .250 .327 .362 91 268 33 67 14 2 4 22 31 58 1 1 83 Fr
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SECOND BASEMEN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name P Age AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+ RNG
FAIR
Andy Phillips 1b 32 .268 .327 .410 85 239 30 64 11 1 7 24 20 42 1 1 94 Pr
Freddy Sanchez 2b 31 .285 .324 .398 129 498 65 142 31 2 7 55 25 56 0 1 88 Fr
POOR
Andy LaRoche 3b 25 .232 .325 .363 131 427 53 99 18 1 12 50 57 69 7 2 82 Fr
Ramon Vazquez* 3b 32 .250 .327 .362 91 268 33 67 14 2 4 22 31 58 1 1 83 Fr
Brian Bixler ss 26 .247 .311 .324 137 481 59 119 16 3 5 34 34 145 21 6 59 Av
Jim Negrych* 3b 24 .258 .309 .327 125 489 58 126 23 1 3 47 35 78 9 6 69 Fr
Shelby Ford# 2b 24 .228 .276 .340 98 394 45 90 21 4 5 33 20 67 18 3 60 Av
Andy Machado# 3b 28 .210 .293 .307 111 319 33 67 14 1 5 23 37 77 6 2 60 Av
Pedro Lopez ss 25 .237 .281 .320 119 413 42 98 17 1 5 39 25 70 4 3 61 Vg
Luis Rivas 2b 29 .224 .274 .324 94 299 32 67 11 2 5 26 19 43 6 3 59 Pr
Luis Cruz 2b 25 .232 .264 .337 139 501 49 116 27 1 8 45 19 54 7 4 58 Av
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
THIRD BASEMEN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name P Age AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+ RNG
FAIR
Andy Phillips 1b 32 .268 .327 .410 85 239 30 64 11 1 7 24 20 42 1 1 94 Pr
Freddy Sanchez 2b 31 .285 .324 .398 129 498 65 142 31 2 7 55 25 56 0 1 88 Vg
POOR
Andy LaRoche 3b 25 .232 .325 .363 131 427 53 99 18 1 12 50 57 69 7 2 82 Av
Ramon Vazquez* 3b 32 .250 .327 .362 91 268 33 67 14 2 4 22 31 58 1 1 83 Av
Jim Negrych* 3b 24 .258 .309 .327 125 489 58 126 23 1 3 47 35 78 9 6 69 Av
Neil Walker# 3b 23 .235 .275 .365 136 520 63 122 25 2 13 60 30 101 12 4 69 Av
Robinzon Diaz c 25 .267 .287 .333 88 333 25 89 14 1 2 26 9 29 3 2 65 Pr
Andy Machado# 3b 28 .210 .293 .307 111 319 33 67 14 1 5 23 37 77 6 2 60 Av
Luis Cruz 2b 25 .232 .264 .337 139 501 49 116 27 1 8 45 19 54 7 4 58 Av
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SHORTSTOPS
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name P Age AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+ RNG
AVERAGE
Andy Phillips 1b 32 .268 .327 .410 85 239 30 64 11 1 7 24 20 42 1 1 94 Pr
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Freddy Sanchez 2b 31 .285 .324 .398 129 498 65 142 31 2 7 55 25 56 0 1 88 Fr
FAIR
Ramon Vazquez* 3b 32 .250 .327 .362 91 268 33 67 14 2 4 22 31 58 1 1 83 Pr
Jack Wilson ss 31 .267 .317 .358 113 408 45 109 20 1 5 32 26 42 3 3 78 Av
POOR
Brian Bixler ss 26 .247 .311 .324 137 481 59 119 16 3 5 34 34 145 21 6 59 Av
Andy Machado# 3b 28 .210 .293 .307 111 319 33 67 14 1 5 23 37 77 6 2 60 Av
Pedro Lopez ss 25 .237 .281 .320 119 413 42 98 17 1 5 39 25 70 4 3 61 Vg
Luis Rivas 2b 29 .224 .274 .324 94 299 32 67 11 2 5 26 19 43 6 3 59 Pr
Luis Cruz 2b 25 .232 .264 .337 139 501 49 116 27 1 8 45 19 54 7 4 58 Av
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORNER OUTFIELDERS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name P Age AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+ LF RF
AVERAGE
Ryan Doumit# c 28 .287 .343 .463 109 363 54 104 26 1 12 55 25 65 2 2 110 Pr Pr
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nate McLouth* cf 27 .261 .342 .459 140 449 83 117 32 3 17 58 48 81 19 3 108 Av Av
POOR
Andy Phillips 1b 32 .268 .327 .410 85 239 30 64 11 1 7 24 20 42 1 1 94 Fr
Garrett Jones* 1b 28 .254 .304 .427 129 480 55 122 28 2 17 64 35 97 4 2 90 Av Fr
Brandon Moss* lf 25 .251 .312 .403 135 471 49 118 30 3 12 57 42 124 5 3 87 Av Av
Jeff Salazar* cf 28 .246 .325 .380 120 358 50 88 19 4 7 37 40 73 8 4 85 Vg Vg
Andrew McCutchen cf 22 .261 .337 .362 142 556 67 145 25 2 9 43 60 100 35 17 84 Vg
Steven Pearce if 26 .245 .299 .407 133 474 53 116 30 1 15 67 32 89 11 3 86 Fr
Andy LaRoche 3b 25 .232 .325 .363 131 427 53 99 18 1 12 50 57 69 7 2 82 Av
Craig Monroe lf 32 .240 .294 .433 91 300 38 72 20 1 12 42 23 74 1 2 89 Av Av
Nyjer Morgan* lf 28 .262 .315 .318 108 390 58 102 16 3 0 22 23 68 36 11 68 Vg Vg
Jose Tabata rf 20 .240 .287 .310 111 445 45 107 14 1 5 41 25 76 20 5 59 Fr
Andy Machado# 3b 28 .210 .293 .307 111 319 33 67 14 1 5 23 37 77 6 2 60 Av Av
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CENTERFIELDERS
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name P Age AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+ RNG
VERY GOOD
Nate McLouth* cf 27 .261 .342 .459 140 449 83 117 32 3 17 58 48 81 19 3 108 Pr
FAIR
Brandon Moss* lf 25 .251 .312 .403 135 471 49 118 30 3 12 57 42 124 5 3 87 Pr
Jeff Salazar* cf 28 .246 .325 .380 120 358 50 88 19 4 7 37 40 73 8 4 85 Av
Andrew McCutchen cf 22 .261 .337 .362 142 556 67 145 25 2 9 43 60 100 35 17 84 Vg
Craig Monroe lf 32 .240 .294 .433 91 300 38 72 20 1 12 42 23 74 1 2 89 Pr
POOR
Nyjer Morgan* lf 28 .262 .315 .318 108 390 58 102 16 3 0 22 23 68 36 11 68 Vg
Jose Tabata rf 20 .240 .287 .310 111 445 45 107 14 1 5 41 25 76 20 5 59 Fr
* - Bats Left
# - Switch Hitter
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STARTERS
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name Age ERA W L G GS INN H ER HR BB K ERA+
MIDDLE THIRD
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Paul Maholm* 27 4.53 9 11 30 30 180.2 194 91 21 60 120 95
BOTTOM THIRD
Tom Gorzelanny* 26 4.67 9 11 29 29 152.1 159 79 18 65 108 91
Ian Snell 27 5.05 8 12 31 31 169.1 192 95 21 74 148 85
Jeff Karstens 26 5.18 5 9 20 19 104.1 119 60 17 30 59 82
Zach Duke* 26 5.27 7 11 28 27 148.2 190 87 15 42 75 82
Ross Ohlendorf 26 5.60 4 9 34 17 117.1 148 73 16 33 78 76
Daniel McCutchen 26 5.65 6 11 22 20 114.2 133 72 24 29 69 76
Ty Taubenheim 26 5.87 4 9 24 21 102.2 123 67 17 44 60 73
Jimmy Barthmaier 25 5.88 4 9 27 24 113.1 135 74 15 59 74 73
Phil Dumatrait* 27 5.88 4 10 24 19 104.0 122 68 14 52 61 73
Donald Veal* 24 5.95 5 10 26 26 124.0 137 82 22 69 85 72
Yoslan Herrera 28 6.19 5 12 26 26 123.2 161 85 18 46 55 69
Daniel Moskos* 23 6.66 4 10 29 20 100.0 130 74 17 47 46 64
Brad Lincoln 24 7.34 3 13 19 19 92.0 128 75 25 19 39 59
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RELIEVERS
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name Age ERA W L G GS INN H ER HR BB K ERA+
TOP THIRD
Matt Capps 25 3.27 5 3 65 0 71.2 66 26 7 13 55 132
MIDDLE THIRD
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
John Grabow* 30 4.12 4 3 70 0 63.1 60 29 8 29 56 104
BOTTOM THIRD
Denny Bautista 28 4.62 3 4 53 0 64.1 64 33 4 43 50 91
Tyler Yates 31 4.79 3 4 69 0 67.2 69 36 7 37 61 89
David Davidson* 25 4.79 2 3 40 0 62.0 64 33 6 37 41 88
T.J. Beam 28 4.81 3 4 50 0 73.0 78 39 9 27 50 88
Craig Hansen 25 4.82 3 5 54 0 71.0 73 38 4 45 51 88
Jesse Chavez 25 4.96 3 5 55 0 81.2 91 45 11 33 66 85
Evan Meek 26 5.03 2 3 39 6 78.2 85 44 7 43 53 85
Jason Davis 29 5.03 5 8 37 13 98.1 114 55 7 45 49 85
Sean Burnett* 26 5.13 2 2 58 0 54.1 59 31 7 31 33 82
Jeffrey Sues 26 5.43 2 4 37 0 56.1 57 34 12 27 47 79
Juan Mateo 26 5.48 3 6 38 0 69.0 78 42 14 22 44 78
Romulo Sanchez 25 5.78 2 4 45 1 62.1 71 40 10 29 31 73
Brian Slocum 28 5.91 3 5 23 10 67.0 76 44 11 37 48 72
Mariano Salas 28 5.93 2 4 50 0 57.2 64 38 11 32 39 72
Chris Bootcheck 30 5.98 1 3 42 1 61.2 75 41 7 32 50 72
Daniel Haigwood* 25 6.52 2 5 29 12 78.2 91 57 14 55 56 66
Ron Uviedo 22 6.83 1 2 35 0 58.0 71 44 17 18 33 62
* - Throws Left
---------------------------------------------
Player Spotlight - Nate McLouth
AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+
Projection .261 .342 .459 140 449 83 117 32 3 17 58 48 81 19 3 108
Top Near-Age Offensive Comps: Daryl Boston, Ruppert Jones, Oddibe McDowell
ODDIBE
Offense %
Top Quintile 38
2nd Quintile 25
Mid Quintile 24
4th Quintile 10
Low Quintile 3
OPS+ % OBP % 3B % Hits %
160+ 0 .400+ 1 10+ 0 200+ 0
140+ 4 .375+ 9 5+ 16 150+ 0
130+ 13 .350+ 38
120+ 25 .325+ 76 2B %
110+ 49 .300+ 95 45+ 2
100+ 70 30+ 63
90+ 88
80+ 97
60+ 99
BA % SLG % HR % SB %
.350+ 0 .550+ 3 50+ 0 70+ 0
.325+ 0 .500+ 15 40+ 0 50+ 0
.300+ 6 .450+ 53 30+ 3 30+ 7
.275+ 28 .400+ 92 20+ 29 10+ 96
.250+ 68 .350+ 100 10+ 93
(Based on Projected PA)
---------------------------------------------
Player Spotlight - Adam LaRoche
AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS OPS+
Projection .268 .343 .485 141 497 67 133 34 1 24 81 57 117 1 1 115
Top Near-Age Offensive Comps: Paul Sorrento, J.T. Snow, Dave Nilsson
ODDIBE
Offense %
Top Quintile 15
2nd Quintile 29
Mid Quintile 21
4th Quintile 23
Low Quintile 12
OPS+ % OBP % 3B % Hits %
160+ 2 .400+ 1 10+ 0 200+ 0
140+ 11 .375+ 11 5+ 3 150+ 9
130+ 26 .350+ 38
120+ 41 .325+ 76 2B %
110+ 63 .300+ 96 45+ 6
100+ 80 30+ 77
90+ 92
80+ 98
60+ 100
BA % SLG % HR % SB %
.350+ 0 .550+ 10 50+ 0 70+ 0
.325+ 1 .500+ 35 40+ 3 50+ 0
.300+ 10 .450+ 76 30+ 19 30+ 0
.275+ 39 .400+ 98 20+ 70 10+ 0
.250+ 78 .350+ 100 10+ 100
(Based on Projected PA)
---------------------------------------------
Player Spotlight - Tom Gorzelanny
ERA W L G GS INN H ER HR BB K ERA+
Projection 4.67 9 11 29 29 152.1 159 79 18 65 108 91
Top Near-Age Comps: Ross Baumgarten, Bobby Ojeda, Wilson Alvarez
ODDIBE
ERA %
Top 1/3 13
Mid 1/3 49
Bot 1/3 37
ERA+ % BB %
>150 1 >25 0
>140 1 >34 0
>130 3 >42 2
>120 6 >51 13
>110 13 >59 36
>100 30 >68 65
>90 56
>80 84 HR %
>70 97 >12 18
>17 50
K/9 % >22 79
>152 2 >27 93
>135 8
>118 26
>101 62
(Based on Projected IP)
---------------------------------------------
Player Spotlight - Paul Maholm
ERA W L G GS INN H ER HR BB K ERA+
Projection 4.53 9 11 30 30 180.2 194 91 21 60 120 95
Top Near-Age Comps: Ken Brett, Jim Abbott, Joe Saunders
ODDIBE
ERA %
Top 1/3 20
Mid 1/3 51
Bot 1/3 30
ERA+ % BB %
>150 1 >30 1
>140 2 >40 5
>130 4 >50 23
>120 9 >60 57
>110 20 >70 83
>100 40 >80 94
>90 65
>80 89 HR %
>70 98 >14 20
>20 53
K/9 % >26 81
>181 1 >32 94
>161 2
>140 12
>120 47
(Based on Projected IP)
---------------------------------------------
ODDIBE (Odds of Important Baseball Events)
OPS+ >140
LaRoche 11
Doumit 4
McLouth 4
OBP >.400
Doumit 2
LaRoche 1
McLouth 1
SLG >.550
LaRoche 10
Doumit 4
McLouth 3
BA >.325
Doumit 8
Sanchez 5
Phillips 1
2B >45
LaRoche 6
McLouth 2
Sanchez 1
3B >10
Ford 2
HR >30
LaRoche 19
Jones 3
McLouth 3
SB >50
Morgan 6
McCutchen 6
ERA+ >140
Capps 44
Grabow 13
Bautista 3
K/9 >9
Yates 22
Grabow 19
Snell 16
BB/9 <1.5
Capps 50
Lincoln 30
McCutchen 10
HR/9 <0.7
Capps 47
Yates 40
Grabow 25
All figures in % based on projection playing time - Min. 300 PA/50 IP for inclusion
Disclaimer: ZiPS projections are computer-based projections of performance.
Performances have not been allocated to predicted playing time in the majors -
many of the players listed above are unlikely to play in the majors at all in 2009.
ZiPS is projecting equivalent production - a .240 ZiPS projection may end up
being .280 in AAA or .300 in AA, for example. Whether or not a player will play
is one of many non-statistical factors one has to take into account when predicting
the future.
Players are listed with their most recent teams unless Dan has made a mistake.
This is very possible as a lot of minor-league signings are generally unreported in
the offseason.
ZiPS is projecting based on the AL having a 4.44 ERA and the NL having a 4.38 ERA.
Players that are expected to be out due to injury are still projected. More information
is always better than less information and a computer isn't what should be projecting
the injury status of, for example, a pitcher with Tommy John surgery.
Positional offense is ranked by RC/27 and divided into quintiles based on what the
most frequent starting players at each position did in 2006-2008. Excellent is the top
quintile, Very Good the 2nd quintile and so on.
ZiPS Frequently Asked Questions
ZiPS 2009 Archive
Phillies
Orioles
Nationals
Mets
Marlins
Mariners
Indians
Giants
Dodgers
Diamondbacks
Cubs
Cardinals
Brewers
Braves
Blue Jays
A's
Astros
Angels
My Bookmarks
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Hot Topics
About Baseball Think Factory | Write for Us | Copyright © 1996-2008 Baseball Think Factory
User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
Reader Comments and Retorts
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
That Jack Wilson projection kinda makes it clear why he has no trade value, eh? Double ouch.
And that's before you start looking at the pitchers. It's a good thing the Steelers are going to win the Supe for my friends in Pittsburgh.
LOL!
Also, the Pirates suck.
Would give up Ian Snell, Zach Duke & Matt Capps for Luis Castillo.
New Pittsburgh regime:
Would only give up Duke & Capps...
No.
I guess we can rule you out as a ground-ball pitcher for the Pirates!
Actually, Phillips shouldn't be rated at short. I think I stuck in an extra PR and didn't catch it later.
I think that projection is about as good as you can expect from Moss. If anything, I'd take the under. Moss doesn't make contact consistently enough to justify anything better.
-- MWE
....Thank you for your time.
Paul Maholm? "#1 Starter"?
This conversation was had the other day. LaRoche did most of his damage in Triple A in Vegas (home park). If you saw him in person last season you would have wondered how this guy ever got to the major leagues. He wasn't just overmatched. He was overwhelmed. He was a 12 year old bat boy being asked to fill in for someone on the local American Legion team.
ZiPS has no idea as to the effects of LaRoche quick rehab and return from a torn wrist (and chipped bone) that had to be sutured back together.
I was too dismissive of the Dodgers for not giving LaRoche more of a chance - I hadn't realized at the time just how bad his injury was.
His combined translations and major league time:
2005: 260/322/424
2006: 275/361/443
2007: 243/329/411
2008: 210/308/306
So, what one thinks of LaRoche depends on how affected by the wrist you think he was. If you believe he was hampered by the wrist, one would expect him to beat that projection but if one believes that he sucked apart from wrist issues, one would expect him to be somewhere around that projection.
LaRoche's major-league BABIP last year was .176, FWIW. You have to wonder if the thumb injury (torn ligament) last spring was the cause of his troubles. His power really faded last year even before reaching the majors. ISO in Las Vegas from 2006-08 - .228, .280, and then post-injury, .146. ISO in the majors last year was .090. I wonder if the Dodgers had the same people "helping" him that worked with Jayson Werth on his wrist injury.
Maholm and Snell and pray like hell!
But knowing the consistency of pirates pitching, Maholm will probably fall apart, snell and gorzelanny will continue to suck, and Zach Duke will resurrect himself and carry the staff.
Zach Duke and the pirates pitching makes me want to puke!
I predict that Duke has an era of 5.00 and then gets traded for Nick Punto and Denard Span. And the only good pitcher on the Pirates this year will be Ross Ohlendorf, who will then completely fall apart and be retired by 2013.
That was true of pretty much the entire Pirates staff so I was fond of pointing a finger at the pitching coach (who I believe did get canned).
If you believe he was hampered by the wrist, one would expect him to beat that projection but if one believes that he sucked apart from wrist issues, one would expect him to be somewhere around that projection.
Or if one thinks he hasn't/won't recover from the wrist issues ...
I didn't realize he'd been hurt that badly. Maybe he has more hope than I give think.
Anyway, any team that has a starting 3B and SS who don't project to be an better than Ramon Vazquez needs some help. How come nobody's mentioned the Tabata projection yet?
In looking over his minor league resume 590 of his 1800 at bats came while playing for Las Vegas. He had pretty strong peripherals in Jacksonville as a 22 year old as well, and that's not a strong hitting environment. His 2006 translation looks pretty spot on to me as far as what to expect long-term, but perhaps I'm underestimating that wrist...I'm not a Pirate fan, but I actually feel like this was one addition they made that makes sense. I'll bet the over.
You're confusing plate discipline with walk rate.
LaRoche is too passive at the plate; he's always waiting for the perfect pitch. When the pitcher makes a mistake, he drives it - but when the pitcher doesn't, he makes weak contact and hits a lot of lazy flies and easy-to-field grounders. A hitter of this type will draw enough walks to keep his OBP respectable, usually, but his in-play BA and ISO will be relatively low (and people will hark back to his minor league career and point out how *unlucky* he's been). LaRoche has to learn to swing the bat more often earlier in the count to keep the pitchers honest.
-- MWE
On the other hand, the Pirates have a C and CF that would make decent corner OFers. Too bad there's nothing to go with them.
"Building Nothing Out Of Something: the Story of the 1993-2009 Pittsburgh Pirates" would be a fun book to read, as a sort of negative version of shuerholz's "Built to Win"...
dan, if you please, how did romak rate?
As far as the projections - yeah, it will be that bad. Despite what Bob Nutting wants to think or expects for 2009.
CHONE *really* hated Romak, 199/281/353!
The Whale Song
And I don’t understand how anyone could truly believe “Good News for People who love Bad News” is anything less than a great album. You’ve got The World at Large, Bukowski, Black Cadillacs, Blame it on the Tetons, Float On, The View, Satin in a Coffin, and One Chance. In my view [McCarver’ed] those are all excellent songs, and I think The World at Large is a masterpiece. A lot of people really, really hate “We were dead before the Ship Even Sank”, and while I think it falls short of “Good News”, it definitely isn’t a terrible album by any means. “Parting of the Sensory” and “Education” are great songs, for instance. Anyway, I guess I have lower standards than some people. I’d take the “We were Dead” album over 95 percent of the other stuff currently out there. I’m fully expecting the next album to be a return to form. I would be disappointed if it’s another “We were Dead” kind of effort, but even A-Rod has an off year now and then…
As for the Pirates, well, they just have no direction home.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main