This is my first year playing fantasy ball, and I’m actually doing okay. it’s a 5x5 head to head league. On draft day I got Posada, I Rod and Mauer, giving me some pretty good flexibility at catcher. However, I did not do a very good job drafting pitchers. On draft day I was offered Matsui for Gomes, but I turned it down, partly because I want to limit the number of Yankees on my roster, and party because I think Gomes has a higher ceiling than Matsui.
So now I’ve got the Matsui and Arroyo for Gomes and Posada deal. I’m skeptical that Arroyo can keep up what he’s doing, but that said, I do need pitching help. So, I’m tempted to counter offer with Posada straight up for Arroyo. Any thoughts?