bads85 - 16 February 2012 06:32 PM

So let’s review what we do have:

1) nothing is revealed is the opening pleasantries (I don’t think AG’s cow “shelter” was anything other than not knowing what dopey Europens, dead for centuries, did about werewolves.

2) JGLB makes the scene, complaining about Day One and what I deem a rather odd rules clarification. He continues to grumble about Day One, convincing me that he is protesting too much, so I accuse him of being a wolf. He throws it back on me, saying something like I am setting it up so my partner wolf will finish the kill later.

3) I remind him that I am always aggressive on Day One, so that isn’t inconsistent with my behavior; and I find his clarification request weird. At that point, HCO chimes in, saying I’ve killed innocent people with “Weird” before. This is odd because we have all killed innocents before, and in one of the early games, HCO embarked on a think aloud about myself perhaps being a ghost because I am weird, and no one can get a handle on me (I was a human that game, and If I recall, I died shortly after that exchange—HCO was human that game and died later).

My accusation today against JGLB was a shot in the dark. If he is a wolf, he did a good job of silencing the village by placing suspicion on a later accuser. No one seems to have put any merit in suggestion that I am wolf, but the village dialogue has dwindled. If JGLB is not a wolf, the two wolves are playing in silent, unless HCO’s “Weird” burp was a wolfy attempt to add some momentum to JGLB’s shot accross my bow.

At this point I am going to retract my vote for JGLB because I think the wolves are lying in silence. The quiet one are the one’s we must watch for. Bourbon is much, much quieter this game than he has been in games past.

Pretty much everyone is being quieter this game. (I definitely include myself here).  Judging people by what their real life schedule happens to be is not a particularly good way of finding wolves.  That said, hco’s post where he kinda implied you were wolfy without getting too committed hit me as not villagery.

Corrected Vote Totals:

I am very sick with a sinus infection, hence my quietness. I have been to the doctor, who was no help. So I am having sushi with lots of wasabi.

No one has really done anything to arouse my suspicions, which normally someone does.

And we’ve all been quiet. Hopefully our seer has learned something today b/c we’re more or less in the dark thusfar.

BourbonSamurai is not Fausto Carmona - 16 February 2012 07:19 PM

I am very sick with a sinus infection, hence my quietness. I have been to the doctor, who was no help. So I am having sushi with lots of wasabi.

No one has really done anything to arouse my suspicions, which normally someone does.

MUNB

Drunken accusation!

Vote kill bads!

My money is on the Jigglebee or bads, given their earlier conversation.

This being day one, whatever whatever, but I feel that with both of them lashing out, one of them is a lycanthrope.

Accent Shallow - 16 February 2012 09:59 PM

My money is on the Jigglebee or bads, given their earlier conversation.

This being day one, whatever whatever, but I feel that with both of them lashing out, one of them is a lycanthrope.

Lashing out?! He voted to kill me, I’m not being HCOed.

I vote to kill hco.

JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 16 February 2012 10:26 PM

Accent Shallow - 16 February 2012 09:59 PM

My money is on the Jigglebee or bads, given their earlier conversation.

This being day one, whatever whatever, but I feel that with both of them lashing out, one of them is a lycanthrope.

Lashing out?! He voted to kill me, I’m not being HCOed.

I retracted that vote—- it was just first day, throwing #### on the wall to see what sticks. In the games I have played, silence on the first day help the wolves on the second day, even if the villagers get lucky on the first day.

Flounder: Avowed enemy of inconvenience - 16 February 2012 10:35 PM

I vote to kill hco.

Based on what?

So are most of us voting for ourselves?

bads85 - 16 February 2012 11:03 PM

So are most of us voting for ourselves?

Man, I don’t know what to do. I guess I’ll vote to kill Flounder, since he randomly made an accusation and doesn’t seem to have an acrostic explaining himself.

Well.

I vote to kill Flounder.

So here is who I have as possible suspicious:

JGLB
HCO
and possibly Bourbon—although that is very flimsy. In fact, all three are flimsy. This leads me to believe that the wolves are silent, but too many have been silent to point fingers.

I already discounted JGLB, which could have been a mistake. HCO doesn’t seem to last long enough for me to get a handle on.

Accent Shallow - 16 February 2012 11:12 PM

Well.

I vote to kill Flounder.

Why did you switch from JGLB or me?

Running out of time here—suspicion returning to JGLB. My initial claims might have not held water, but getting accused of being on a wolf alone on Day One shouldn’t be a reason to vote to kill another villager. His only defense seemed to be to put the wolf back on me. This could mean I guessed lucky and spooked both wolves.

I wish Accent Shallow had given an explanation for his vote.

Vote Totals:

Smelly is so fluffy he’s gonna die - 16 February 2012 11:29 PM

Vote Totals:

Name     Total    Voted_For
Bourbon    1        Bourbon
Flounder   1        Accent
HCO        2        Flounder,HCO
Bads       2        JGLB,bads
Accent     0        -
Answer     1        AG
JGLB       0        - 

Are those final?

I voted for Flounder due to the random, undiscussed accusation of HCO. I still think JGLB and bads’ BSing was suspicious, though.

Please see the post at the top of the page.  Hco made a veiled accusation that I found to be wolfy.

bads85 - 16 February 2012 11:30 PM

Smelly is so fluffy he’s gonna die - 16 February 2012 11:29 PM

Vote Totals:

Name     Total    Voted_For
Bourbon    1        Bourbon
Flounder   1        Accent
HCO        2        Flounder,HCO
Bads       2        JGLB,bads
Accent     0        -
Answer     1        AG
JGLB       0        - 

Are those final?

nope, just a running total.  Per rule number two, until a majority is reached, the round continues.

HCO, Transgressive Herbivore - 16 February 2012 02:34 PM

bads85 - 16 February 2012 02:32 PM

JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 16 February 2012 02:13 PM

Awfully quick to the gun there bads. That’s suspicious to me, if you’re a werewolf is your accomplice going to wait until the 2nd or 3rd vote to pile on?

That is just the way I roll on Day One. I throw things out there and see how people react. Wanting to know if you can cast a vote for everyone seemed weird to me.

“just seemed weird to me” is a line you have used on innocent people before.

This is the post btw.  It feels like accusing without being too overt about it.  At the time I voted, no one else had done anything I deemed worthy of a vote.

Flounder: Avowed enemy of inconvenience - 16 February 2012 11:48 PM

HCO, Transgressive Herbivore - 16 February 2012 02:34 PM

bads85 - 16 February 2012 02:32 PM

JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 16 February 2012 02:13 PM

Awfully quick to the gun there bads. That’s suspicious to me, if you’re a werewolf is your accomplice going to wait until the 2nd or 3rd vote to pile on?

That is just the way I roll on Day One. I throw things out there and see how people react. Wanting to know if you can cast a vote for everyone seemed weird to me.

“just seemed weird to me” is a line you have used on innocent people before.

This is the post btw.  It feels like accusing without being too overt about it.  At the time I voted, no one else had done anything I deemed worthy of a vote.

Ah, I see. I see my vote hasn’t been counted yet anyway