Killin flounder last night wouldnt have made sense as it would just confirm everything he said. This way theres a kernel of doubt. Admittedly i thought daryn would be the one to go as hes the one everyone agreed is human.
Flounder obviously can’t have killed himself last night. I think he realized he had played his hand too early and killed the one person already suspicious of him.
BourbonSamurai is not Fausto Carmona - 29 January 2012 02:03 PM
Killin flounder last night wouldnt have made sense as it would just confirm everything he said. This way theres a kernel of doubt. Admittedly i thought daryn would be the one to go as hes the one everyone agreed is human.
Well the wolf will run into the problem of there is a seer, who will claim at some point. If no one counters a seer claim, then you have to believe a seer claim. And with only one wolf left, he cannot claim.
CW hits the pinata for the candy - 29 January 2012 02:07 PM
Flounder obviously can’t have killed himself last night. I think he realized he had played his hand too early and killed the one person already suspicious of him.
And I would want to kill someone that isn’t clear? And I am not sure jlac even read my posts yesterady.
Flounder: Avowed enemy of inconvenience - 29 January 2012 02:12 PM
CW hits the pinata for the candy - 29 January 2012 02:07 PM
Flounder obviously can’t have killed himself last night. I think he realized he had played his hand too early and killed the one person already suspicious of him.
And I would want to kill someone that isn’t clear? And I am not sure jlac even read my posts yesterady.
CW hits the pinata for the candy - 29 January 2012 02:22 PM
Flounder: Avowed enemy of inconvenience - 29 January 2012 02:12 PM
CW hits the pinata for the candy - 29 January 2012 02:07 PM
Flounder obviously can’t have killed himself last night. I think he realized he had played his hand too early and killed the one person already suspicious of him.
And I would want to kill someone that isn’t clear? And I am not sure jlac even read my posts yesterady.
OK, what happened here is that I pasted some #### accidentally and outed one of our two secret people. I edited the post less than ten minutes later but, if anyone saw it, the game is moot.
Votes I see through post 412:
Flounder - CW in 395
Daryn - no vote
CW - CW in 397
Bourbon - maybe CW in 402
Accent - no vote
I don’t know what happened today but as far as I understand it one wolf and one seer are still alive. If that is the case, Flounder is right: unless someone else claims to be the seer we have to assume Flounder is the seer. If we’re wrong, we seems unlikely, we kill Flounder tomorrow.
So either we kill CW and the villagers win, or we kill CW tonight, have one of us die, then kill Flounder tomorrow. Of course, I can’t conceive of a scenario where CW is not the last lycanthrope.
You decide that a landlocked eastern European village doesn’t need an amphibious defense force after all, and dispatch CW with your finest pitchforks. Turning over his body, you realize he was…
Congratulations, humans. You win. Although the game was marred by poor officiating, there was some nice logical moves performed. Flounder was a very good seer, especially for a first-timer. There are things you lose playing this way vs. playing in reality, but the level of deduction is a bit more Holmesian in this medium.
If you saw my accidental outing of Flounder this morning, thanks for being quiet about it.
