Smelly is so fluffy he’s gonna die - 01 February 2012 03:50 PM
I want to think on this and check Bourbon and Daryn’s posts to see if there is a commonality suggesting why they were offed by the wolves. At this point, I feel like I should utilize the George Costanza method to vote, as I was so sure about HCO.
Bourbon was on hco (ooops, but whatever, everyone was on a villager). He also made a cuople posts saying accent might be a good vote.
part of the reason I think that whoever is left tomorrow should vote accent.
Flounder: Avowed enemy of inconvenience - 01 February 2012 03:32 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 03:26 PM
Unless both werewolves somehow stayed off HCO during that first discussion, at least one of Accent or Smelly is a werewolf.
And it could be both if they played it that way.
Whoever the seer is did not intervene enough to protect HCO, and I’d be very surprised if he didn’t look at HCO in either of his two chances.
(Which means it’s not me.) Flounder never voted for HCO, so that’s still consistent with his claim… and Smelly is a reasonable choice for the recent viewing…. but why look at JGLB? If he looked at JGLB first (which he could have) why stay silent about him until now?
The goal is to have yuor peeks alive when you come out. I thought there was a good chance of you and daryn being nightkilled. I knew smellys role, I figured accent had a good chance of being wagoned (plus I was pretty confident he’s a wolf). That left jglb, who no one was really talking about. I was actually hoping to peek him villa, bc then I woul dknow for sure the wolf team.
ftr :
n0 - peek smelly villa
n1 - peek bourbon villa
n2 - peek jglb wolf
Smelly is so fluffy he’s gonna die - 01 February 2012 03:59 PM
Flounder: Avowed enemy of inconvenience - 01 February 2012 03:32 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 03:26 PM
Unless both werewolves somehow stayed off HCO during that first discussion, at least one of Accent or Smelly is a werewolf.
And it could be both if they played it that way.
Whoever the seer is did not intervene enough to protect HCO, and I’d be very surprised if he didn’t look at HCO in either of his two chances.
(Which means it’s not me.) Flounder never voted for HCO, so that’s still consistent with his claim… and Smelly is a reasonable choice for the recent viewing…. but why look at JGLB? If he looked at JGLB first (which he could have) why stay silent about him until now?
The goal is to have yuor peeks alive when you come out. I thought there was a good chance of you and daryn being nightkilled. I knew smellys role, I figured accent had a good chance of being wagoned (plus I was pretty confident he’s a wolf). That left jglb, who no one was really talking about. I was actually hoping to peek him villa, bc then I woul dknow for sure the wolf team.
ftr :
n0 - peek smelly villa
n1 - peek bourbon villa
n2 - peek jglb wolf
Why didn’t you peek HCO?
I had less of an idea about bourbons role than hco’s. In retrospect, yeah, I goofed, but I didnt think the wolves would kill bourbon.
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 03:55 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 03:50 PM
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 03:33 PM
I am definitively human, and I to vote to kill Flounder. It’s either me or him. I will now take questions from the rest of the village.
What about Flounder’s claim isn’t credible?
That I’m a wolf. What about his claim is?
Anyone can say that, including a werewolf. Why did he go after you?
And werewolves can claim to be seers. I can’t say why he went after me, that’s something he has to explain. Everyone will have to look at the voting records and decide who is the more lupine.
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 04:06 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 04:00 PM
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 03:55 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 03:50 PM
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 03:33 PM
I am definitively human, and I to vote to kill Flounder. It’s either me or him. I will now take questions from the rest of the village.
What about Flounder’s claim isn’t credible?
That I’m a wolf. What about his claim is?
Anyone can say that, including a werewolf. Why did he go after you?
And werewolves can claim to be seers. I can’t say why he went after me, that’s something he has to explain. Everyone will have to look at the voting records and decide who is the more lupine.
Looking at votng records doesn’t say much when only villagers have been voted out.
But now that you mention it, you voted hco, I didn’t.
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 04:06 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 04:00 PM
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 03:55 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 03:50 PM
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 03:33 PM
I am definitively human, and I to vote to kill Flounder. It’s either me or him. I will now take questions from the rest of the village.
What about Flounder’s claim isn’t credible?
That I’m a wolf. What about his claim is?
Anyone can say that, including a werewolf. Why did he go after you?
And werewolves can claim to be seers. I can’t say why he went after me, that’s something he has to explain. Everyone will have to look at the voting records and decide who is the more lupine.
Looking at votng records doesn’t say much when only villagers have been voted out.
But now that you mention it, you voted hco, I didn’t.
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 04:06 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 04:00 PM
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 03:55 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 03:50 PM
JGLB, Future King of a Future State - 01 February 2012 03:33 PM
I am definitively human, and I to vote to kill Flounder. It’s either me or him. I will now take questions from the rest of the village.
What about Flounder’s claim isn’t credible?
That I’m a wolf. What about his claim is?
Anyone can say that, including a werewolf. Why did he go after you?
And werewolves can claim to be seers. I can’t say why he went after me, that’s something he has to explain. Everyone will have to look at the voting records and decide who is the more lupine.
Looking at votng records doesn’t say much when only villagers have been voted out.
But now that you mention it, you voted hco, I didn’t.
I suppose there’s more than one way to play seer. My first instinct would to confirm or refute hunches, whether mine or someone else’s. Looks like flounder, per his account, seemed to use it to fill complete knowledge gaps instead. In his defense I too was surprised by Bourbon’s nightdeath.
I suppose there’s more than one way to play seer. My first instinct would to confirm or refute hunches, whether mine or someone else’s. Looks like flounder, per his account, seemed to use it to fill complete knowledge gaps instead. In his defense I too was surprised by Bourbon’s nightdeath.
My general rule is, if the person isn’t giving you enough info to make an educated guess as to their role, peek them. Its real bad if you get to the final 3 and you ahve no idea where anyone stands.
I actually almost peeked jglb with my second peek.
I suppose there’s more than one way to play seer. My first instinct would to confirm or refute hunches, whether mine or someone else’s. Looks like flounder, per his account, seemed to use it to fill complete knowledge gaps instead. In his defense I too was surprised by Bourbon’s nightdeath.
My general rule is, if the person isn’t giving you enough info to make an educated guess as to their role, peek them. Its real bad if you get to the final 3 and you ahve no idea where anyone stands.
I actually almost peeked jglb with my second peek.
Flounder: Avowed enemy of inconvenience - 01 February 2012 04:14 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 04:11 PM
I suppose there’s more than one way to play seer. My first instinct would to confirm or refute hunches, whether mine or someone else’s. Looks like flounder, per his account, seemed to use it to fill complete knowledge gaps instead. In his defense I too was surprised by Bourbon’s nightdeath.
My general rule is, if the person isn’t giving you enough info to make an educated guess as to their role, peek them. Its real bad if you get to the final 3 and you ahve no idea where anyone stands.
I actually almost peeked jglb with my second peek.
And also you had high suspicions of Accent, who you also didn’t peek.
Smelly is so fluffy he’s gonna die - 01 February 2012 04:27 PM
Flounder: Avowed enemy of inconvenience - 01 February 2012 04:14 PM
Answer Guy - 01 February 2012 04:11 PM
I suppose there’s more than one way to play seer. My first instinct would to confirm or refute hunches, whether mine or someone else’s. Looks like flounder, per his account, seemed to use it to fill complete knowledge gaps instead. In his defense I too was surprised by Bourbon’s nightdeath.
My general rule is, if the person isn’t giving you enough info to make an educated guess as to their role, peek them. Its real bad if you get to the final 3 and you ahve no idea where anyone stands.
I actually almost peeked jglb with my second peek.
And also you had high suspicions of Accent, who you also didn’t peek.
true, but I can’t peek everyone. And I felt more confident that accent was wolf than bourbon was either wolf or villager.
Wow, what a mess. Let’s see if I can help clear things up.
I am the seer.
My peeks have been:
AG (villager)
Smelly (villager)
Flounder (wolf)
I voted HCO since he was acting suspiciously, I peeked Smelly since I figured it was either him or HCO, and after HCO’s death, I peeked Flounder, since he was beating the drum for yours truly.
I think JGLB may be the second wolf, but why wait when I KNOW who one of them is.
So the first letter of Flounders posts do check out. Did he own up to that last game too? That is awfully sneaky to set it up in a game, not use it, and then end up using it in a second game where you happen to be nominated as a wolf.
