Baseball for the Thinking Fan

Login | Register | Feedback

You are here > Home > Hall of Merit > Discussion
Hall of Merit
— A Look at Baseball's All-Time Best

Thursday, September 23, 2004

Stan Coveleski and Carl Mays

Which one do you like better?

John (You Can Call Me Grandma) Murphy Posted: September 23, 2004 at 02:08 PM | 6 comment(s) Login to Bookmark
  Related News:

Reader Comments and Retorts

Go to end of page

Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.

   1. OCF Posted: September 24, 2004 at 06:58 PM (#875174)
As I've explained before, I have Coveleski (or Kowalewski, the name I've been using in voting for him) clearly ahead of Mays. The comparisons I'm going to have a hard time with are Coveleski with Vance, Rixey, Faber, and Ruffing. Since Coveleski and Vance both have about 3000 IP, they're a pair to be compared.
   2. Dr. Chaleeko Posted: September 24, 2004 at 08:16 PM (#875331)
They look incredibly evenly matched.

SC: 127
DV: 125

SC: 3082
DV: 2966.7

DV: 66
SC: 22

SC: 193
DV: 171

SC: Never best pitcher in league
DV: 1924 (36); 1928 (32); 1930 (26)

SC: 1918 (29); 1919 (27); 1920 (32)
DV: 1927 (25)

SC: 90/142
DV: 94/139

SC: 88/142
DV: 77/124

SC: 84.2/77.8
DC: 88.9/80

And there's two other relevant questions I think:
1) Why do both pitchers have several missing years early in their career?
2) Are there any league-difficulty issues to be aware of?
   3. OCF Posted: September 24, 2004 at 08:26 PM (#875362)
Vance had arm trouble early in his career, a sore elbow. As Bill James tells the story in the NBJHA, some random bump turned a chronic pain into an acute pain in the elbow and led to a not-well-documented operation on Vance's elbow. (James speculates it might have involved removing bone chips.) Somehow, after that operation, Vance could throw without pain and set about the career he had as an extreme strikeout pitcher.

I would treat Vance's missing years the same way I treat Joss's missing years, or Dean's missing years. It's injury or illness. He wasn't a great pitcher during that time because of the injury or illness. The fact that the injury comes before his career is a bit strange, but that's what it is.
   4. Dag Nabbit at Posted: September 24, 2004 at 09:15 PM (#875439)
Vance vs. Coveleski. Vance not only had far far worse offensive support, he also had worse defensive support. Also, I've dumped in Dr Memory's K+, BB+, & K/BB+ numbers on my site (too lazy to link - just go & click on the appropriate places to figure what they are) - Vance has the best adjusted K-rate & K/BB ratio of any pitcher ever.
   5. andrew siegel Posted: October 31, 2005 at 02:52 PM (#1712466)
I want to restart discussion of Mays (and to a lesser extent Wilbur Cooper). Both ranked in the top 5 pitchers in their league 7 or 8 times by most measures and put up at least 200 wins. Mays obviously had great help from his teammates, but also switched leagues at almost the exact wrong moment, guaranteeing that he was pitching in the tougher league for almost the entirety of his career. Plus any calculation of Mays's peak needs to project 1918 and 1919 out to a full schedule. On further review, I have Mays ahead of Walters (who's about 28) and behind (but not lapped by) Ferrell and Lemon (who I see as about 4th and 6th on the next ballot).
   6. Dr. Chaleeko Posted: November 01, 2005 at 03:40 PM (#1714358)
I'm a FOWC. He's solidly within my group of best 75-best-ever hurlers for the HOM.

You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.



<< Back to main

BBTF Partner

Dynasty League Baseball

Support BBTF


Thanks to
for his generous support.


You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.

Hot Topics

2019 Hall of Merit Ballot Discussion
(122 - 7:34am, Jun 22)
Last: theorioleway

Cannonball Dick Redding
(157 - 7:29am, Jun 22)
Last: theorioleway

Latin American Players and Pitchers Home Page
(78 - 1:49pm, Jun 20)
Last: Dr. Chaleeko

Most Meritorious Player: 1944 Discussion
(10 - 12:16pm, Jun 19)
Last: MrC.

George Shively
(11 - 5:16pm, Jun 12)
Last: Dr. Chaleeko

Most Meritorious Player: 1943 Results
(7 - 6:46pm, Jun 08)
Last: Chris Fluit

Most Meritorious Player: 1943 Ballot
(15 - 4:05pm, Jun 06)
Last: DL from MN

Luis Aparicio
(70 - 9:21am, Jun 06)
Last: Bleed the Freak

Most Meritorious Player: 1943 Discussion
(13 - 10:45am, Jun 03)
Last: Chris Fluit

Don Newcombe
(107 - 1:22pm, May 24)
Last: . . . . . .

Hank Thompson
(20 - 9:02pm, May 09)
Last: Dr. Chaleeko

Artie Wilson
(47 - 8:58pm, May 09)
Last: Dr. Chaleeko

Most Meritorious Player: 1942 Results
(6 - 6:17pm, May 03)
Last: Chris Fluit

Silvio Garcia
(23 - 5:08pm, May 03)
Last: Dr. Chaleeko

Bus Clarkson
(233 - 5:06pm, May 03)
Last: Dr. Chaleeko


Page rendered in 0.2309 seconds
61 querie(s) executed