Page rendered in 0.5311 seconds
43 querie(s) executed
Hall of Merit
— A Look at Baseball's All-Time Best
Tuesday, December 02, 2003
WARP3’s systematic flaws with 19th Century players
I’m going to do an overhaul on pennants added this week (hopefully, if you want to volunteer for some data entry, let me know!), including revising for the WARP 2003 numbers (I’ll leave the old ones up, for reference), and adjusting for the overrating of fielding by setting the replacement level too low.
One thing I noticed, that troubles me from the Prospectus glossary:
This means that WARP3 systematically overrates 2B and underrates 3B from this time period. It also underrates 1B, who were at least as valuable as LF and RF defensively probably a little more valuable.
If I had the time, I could adjust this defensive spectrum, and re-rate the fielding component for each player, but that ain’t happening any time soon.
What I’d suggest is this: Using the same total of runs 39-38-34-30-26-20-20-12, I’d portion them this way, pre 1930:
39 C, 38 SS, 34 3B, 26 2B, 25 CF, 21 1B, 19 LF, 17 RF.
You could tweak that to your own specifications, but I think I’m being pretty conservative, you could easily make the case that 1B was equal in value to CF, though I won’t.
Doing that, you get an adjustment (using a 9.7 R/W converter) of:
3B: 34-26 = 8; 8/9.7 = +.82 W/season
I think that if you do this, you’re going to come out with rankings much more in line with the generally accepted historical rankings, especially with players like Jimmy Collins and Bid McPhee.
I’m not saying that WARP should be eliminated from the tool box when discussing 19th Century players. Just that it needs to be tweaked somewhat.
The mistake that Prospectus is making is that they think (implied by their formulas) that if Jimmy Collins were playing in 1990 he’d be a 3B. But most likely he’dve played 2B, because that’s where the more skilled fielder played after 1930. That’s the only way to explain how 3B outhit 2B after 1945, and 2B outhit 3B before 1920. From 1920-42 they were about even (who cares about 1943-45 :-)
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Most Meritorious Player: 1902 Ballot
(8 - 10:39am, Mar 03)
2016 Hall of Merit Ballot Discussion
(84 - 9:44pm, Mar 01)
Last: Kiko Sakata
Most Meritorious Player: 1902 Discussion
(36 - 10:05pm, Feb 26)
(66 - 10:20am, Feb 20)
Last: Kiko Sakata
(23 - 9:13am, Feb 18)
Last: Bourbon Samurai
Troy Glaus and Garret Anderson
(13 - 10:27am, Feb 07)
Most Meritorious Player: 1901 Results
(3 - 1:00pm, Feb 06)
Last: Chris Fluit
Most Meritorious Player: 1901 Ballot
(21 - 12:01pm, Feb 05)
Last: DL from MN
The Baseball Hall of Merit Plaque Room: Home Page
(1465 - 1:08pm, Feb 03)
(8 - 3:51pm, Feb 02)
Last: The District Attorney
Ken Griffey Jr.
(49 - 8:40am, Feb 02)
(15 - 7:31pm, Jan 28)
(15 - 2:32am, Jan 28)
(17 - 2:20am, Jan 28)
(12 - 1:40am, Jan 28)