Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
“As a reliever, your innings obviously ain’t as many, so if you give up a couple runs here and there, your ERA will become inflated. Inherited runners is probably more important. Hits allowed and strikeouts-per-innings-pitched are two more you look at.”
I like KOs the best, actually; since when does a gyu who leads the legaue in KO have anything BUT a good year?
One of those questions that has no good answer on a multiple-choice list of single metrics, since the best per-PA metrics do not account for durability.
You could almost pick a stat at random and it would be a better indicator of quality than wins...
KO minus BB would be even better, but once you get into calculated [sic] metrics, I'll just say I like WAR (becuase this is what it's good for)
Whatever its flaws, however, WAR is still a better indicator than wins.
The K - BB list is much more representative of this year's best pitchers than the wins list. Makes sense. If you're limiting it to one stat, go with a counting stat that's based on the stuff pitchers do that best indicate one's actual skill level.
Instead, I believe that there is a difference between a statistic that simply counts what happened and a calculation which attempts, based on assumptions, to determine the value of what occured.
The problem is K - BB is just a different way of dressing up two counting stats.
The dumbest thing would be limiting yourself to a single stat. Why would anyone do that?
Sort of echoing #18, isn't wins just a different way of dressing up IP, ER and team outcome? It's a more complicated calculation than K - BB.
although I would really prefer ra+ so that the Curt Schillings of the world don't get ripped off
Rk Player IP Year Age Tm
1 Clayton Kershaw 190.1 2013 25 LAD
2 Adam Wainwright 189.2 2013 31 STL
3 Felix Hernandez 178.2 2013 27 SEA
4 Justin Masterson 175.2 2013 28 CLE
5 James Shields 174.2 2013 31 KCR
6 Max Scherzer 172.1 2013 28 DET
7 Cole Hamels 172.0 2013 29 PHI
8 Matt Harvey 171.2 2013 24 NYM
9 CC Sabathia 171.1 2013 32 NYY
10 Hisashi Iwakuma 171.0 2013 32 SEA
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
Login to Join (8 members)
Page rendered in 0.4055 seconds, 41 querie(s) executed