Boz pays homage to the gritty, gutsy, scrappy, first place 2013 underdog Yankees:
Read More...Perhaps for the first time in their history, the Yankees now epitomize exactly the kind of team that always used to try to beat them: a group of inspired-by-adversity, too-old-or-too-young, one-last-chance players who band together to prove that baseball is a team game, not just an aggregation of talent and fat contracts.
Put a few all-star seasons, such as Cano’s 31 RBI, Kiroda’s 1.99 ERA and Rivera’s 16 ...
Login to Join (0 members)
{/exp:tag:subscribed}Page rendered in 1.2475 seconds, 157 querie(s) executed
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. Walks Clog Up the Bases posted on September 27, 2012 at 11:31 PM # hit 1 | hit 0And sorry, Bucs fans, I think we're looking at a cool two decades of losing.
-De La Soul
In all of MLB history, quite a few, some even spent the entire season in the Majors. Here's the age-19 Total Base Top Ten:
Total Bases
Rank Player Year
1. Buddy Lewis 240 1936
2. Bryce Harper 235 2012
3. Mel Ott 228 1928
4. Tony Conigliaro 214 1964
5. Robin Yount 205 1975
6. George Davis 197 1890
7. Ken Griffey 191 1989
Bob Kennedy 191 1940
9. Al Kaline 175 1954
10. Phil Cavarretta 172 1936
Edgar Renteria 172 1996
Tyler Cloyd continued to look like Kyle Kendrick super-lite. He did pitch his 200th inning for the season last night, so the big hope for me is that he's tired at this point in the season. He looks like he knows what he's doing, but can't hardly get up to 88 MPH and has no out pitch that I can see. I'm guessing he's AAA fodder/6th/7th starter for a few years. He has a nice swing though and looks agile fielding his position.
Darin Ruf looks like a masher. He has shown pretty good discipline and the ball leaps off his bat. His laser shot over Harper's*** head last night was awesome. I haven't seen enough of him in LF, but at best he will be ponderous. Maybe he can be a Pat Burrell type in LF, who can't get to much but makes the right play when he finally tracks down the ball. He looks to be having a blast, which is always fun to see, even in a dreadful** season.
** compared to expectations.
*** I know he's a babe, but I don't see Harper as a career CF at this point. Doesn't seem to get good jumps and isn't THAT fast to make up the difference, say like Shane Victorino. He's got a long way to go though.
And I agree about Ruf; I was pretty impressed by what I saw. And if I were him I would put a Spinal Tappian umlaut over the letter "u", because it totally looks like it belongs there.
As for Bryce Harper in centerfield, I think he will make it. He's had to learn the position on the fly in-season under immense pressure (remember when Harper was drafted as a catcher? LOL), and given all that he has done a lot more than just 'creditably' well. With time and experience he's going to be a formidable all-around CF: fast enough to get around, and a strong enough arm to keep runners intimidated. Most of his problems right now are with judgment calls: not getting good breaks on balls and making questionable throws. Those can be overcome, especially by someone as driven as Harper.
That thread was on June 11 - on that morning Harper had a 889 OPS, and since that afternoon Harper has put up a 764 OPS.
He also says:
"Be optimistic, say he is 110 ops+ with plus's across the board. I'm not sure that makes him one of the best players at his position. We'll be generous and say he's a centerfielder. We'll even go say he's an above average fielder. Would a 110 ops+ centerfielder above average be considered top 5 at his position?"
The next comment bashes cardsfanboy for pulling a number out of his butt. Today Harper has a 113 OPS+.
But, are we all agreed that, at this point, Bryce Harper has become the odds-on favorite to win NL ROY? He really has come all the back from that dreadful mid-season slump. He made the 'adjustment.'
EDIT: Coke to PreservedFish
Wrong, and wrong.
Moreover, he absolutely NAILED what Harper would be ("110 ops+ with plus's across the board") - he just underrated what type of player that represented.
Is Harper top 50? I have no idea, but I bet it's close.
4.5 fWAR, 4.3 rWAR. Yes, Harper is one of the top 50 everyday position players in MLB right now, and by a fairly comfortable margin.
EDIT: Also, at the time of that thread Harper was still mainly a RF, right? A RF with a 113 OPS+ isn't nearly as exciting as a competent CF with the same hitting skills.
Yes, and despite this, Cardsfanboy gave him credit for not only being a CF, but being a good one. So again, he nailed Harper. This was much closer to the most accurate prediction in the history of the website than it was a poor one.
As to top 50 players in the game right now. Not in any particular order, just counting (and this isn't about who is having the better season, it's about how good they actually are) 1. Pujols, 2. Fielder, 3. Votto 4. Encarnacion 5. Cano 6. Utley 7. Pedroia 8. Cabrera 9. Wright 10. Headley 11. Beltre 12.Aramis 13. Zimmerman 14. Longoria 15. Tulowitzki 16. Reyes 17. Braun 18. Holliday 19. Beltran 20. Carlos Gonzalez 21. Alex Gordon 22. McCutchen 23. Kemp 24. Hamilton 25.Adam Jones 26. Granderson 27. Yadier 28. Posey 29. Mauer 30.Carlos Santana.... So top 50 might have been a stretch, kinda like the original comment as one of the best position players in baseball "right now".
Didn't include Chipper, Arod, Freese, Trout, Jeter, Bautista, Teix, Adrian Gonzalez, John Jay, Torii Hunter, Jay Bruce, Ethier, Wieters, Carlos Ruiz, and probably some others.
You didn't teabag Harper's balls, so of course Joey thinks you're doing it wrong.
Nasty Nate, a few minutes later: "Can you give me some stock tips?"
Cardsfanboy: "Take every penny you have and invest it in pets.com."
Thanks for the defense.
Well you do know that I never actually posted that stock tip that was supposedly quoted from me. Although it would have been a good joke if I would have thought of it.
Although I should have said he will finish the season as about a league average starter, not league average player. It might have clarified my position a little better. But of course as pointed out by others, a 110 ops+ above average defensive centerfielder is by definition an above average player.
Uh, whimper.
What was that you were saying, Joey?
Actually, I thought that you did post it and that it was an OK joke. Not exactly a belly laugh, though.
DRS gives him +13. TZ gives him +7. Use TZ and he is mid 40's in WAR.
I feel that I must step forward and defend the man. It wasn't even his most pathetic comment posted this week. You must have missed the "why couldn't you have been the one to have Dusty Baker's stroke?" quip, with the "you're a homo" followup.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.