“I don’t think you see too many true long men on pitching staffs and in bullpens anymore because you can make a change to your roster overnight to get a fresh arm in here,” Farrell said.
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1.MM1f posted on October 05, 2012 at 11:37 AM #hit 0 | hit 0
I have been begging for the Braves to Johnny Wholestaff their play-in game all year. No reason not to. The Braves have a wealth of dominant relief arms and, unlike burning one of your best starters, using a reliever for 1-2 IP doesn't preclude your from bringing that guy back for 1-2 IP in Game 1 of the real playoffs.
2.escabeche posted on October 05, 2012 at 11:43 AM #hit 0 | hit 0
Orioles seem like the obvious team to do this, right? Their best starters are unavailable or hurt, and their bullpen is the strongest part of the team.
By the way, is there an original article this should link to?
Well, the quick hook makes sense, especially if your starter looks terrible, and there are walks and line drives all over the place. And this strategy makes sense if you didn't have time to set up your rotation and are going in with the #4 starter, or you don't really have a genuine staff ace to start the game.
But for the Braves to go in with this strategy would be absolutely lunacy. You want to have Kris Medlen throw fewer innings, and Cory Gearrin and Luis Avilan throw more innings? That's a recipe for losing, right there, even if it did work in a meaningless game 162 against a below-average offense that had nothing to play for.
6.TomH posted on October 05, 2012 at 01:53 PM #hit 0 | hit 0
yes, the O's need this, not the Braves.
7 innings of Saunders vs Darvish, Ranger offense vs Orioles offense, Tex home field; does NOT look good.
7.DKDC posted on October 05, 2012 at 01:55 PM #hit 0 | hit 0
I think the Orioles basically are doing this. They are starting LHP Saunders to get all the RHH in the lineup, and then they'll pull him at the first sign of trouble to bring in RHP Steve Johnson.
Then they have a bunch of lefties and righties that can go a couple innings and deploy in higher leverage situations as needed.
Which righties would Texas not want to face Steve Johnson -- Craig Gentry? Well, Michael Young I suppose, but he shouldn't face anyone. I don't think the Rangers are all that susceptible to lefties or pitcher platooning. Of course if David Murphy doesn't play at all or faces only lefties, Showalter gets a small victory.
9.DKDC posted on October 05, 2012 at 03:16 PM #hit 0 | hit 0
It's not about Steve Johnson being a righty killer (although he has been this year).
The idea is that if you sub in an opposite-hand pitcher early on, you are able to force Washington to either go to his bench early, or concede some platoon splits. It's probably not a massive edge against a balanced lineup like the Rangers, but it can't hurt.
If you're going with that strategy, it probably makes sense to go with the lesser pitcher first, and hope to get a couple of innings out of him before you go to the better pitcher.
I think the biggest advantage is that you can tell both all of your pitchers not to worry about pitching deep into the game. Put it all out there on every pitch and don't concede at bats.
I thought the whole idea of the coin flip game was to stress the wild-card teams so they would be weakened for the real playoffs. Then why give them a day off before and a day off after the game? And allow them to juggle their roster? Seems counter-productive. These teams should have played 163 right after the season ended and 164 the day after that. Are we hoping for fifth place World Champions?
12.JJ1986 posted on October 05, 2012 at 03:34 PM #hit 0 | hit 0
Then why give them a day off before and a day off after the game?
Day off before is in case they need to play a one game playoff for the division first. Day off after is because the division champ is playing on the road and don't know where they'll need to be.
Yeah, the 2-3 alignment in the DS is crazy too. The Braves get a day off, play a home game, another day off, then two home games against the same team that smoked them in the regular season (the Nats) to try to put a stranglehold on that series. I doubt this will doing anything to stem the flow of Wild-Card World Champions.
14.BDC posted on October 05, 2012 at 04:07 PM #hit 0 | hit 0
I've always liked 2-3 – you don't want to be home or away to start such a series, is the beauty of it – but I agree that using it in a year when you are trying to add to the value of being a division champion makes no sense.
When it goes back to 2-2-1, I wish they would make it so there's no off day for the Wild Card team. They win at night, then have to hustle their butts to the number 1 seed's city.
Day off before is in case they need to play a one game playoff for the division first. Day off after is because the division champ is playing on the road and don't know where they'll need to be.
I thought the days off was a fluke of this years schedule, and not the plan going forward?
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. MM1f posted on October 05, 2012 at 11:37 AM # hit 0 | hit 0By the way, is there an original article this should link to?
Also, I should have made a Katniss reference.
But for the Braves to go in with this strategy would be absolutely lunacy. You want to have Kris Medlen throw fewer innings, and Cory Gearrin and Luis Avilan throw more innings? That's a recipe for losing, right there, even if it did work in a meaningless game 162 against a below-average offense that had nothing to play for.
7 innings of Saunders vs Darvish, Ranger offense vs Orioles offense, Tex home field; does NOT look good.
Then they have a bunch of lefties and righties that can go a couple innings and deploy in higher leverage situations as needed.
The idea is that if you sub in an opposite-hand pitcher early on, you are able to force Washington to either go to his bench early, or concede some platoon splits. It's probably not a massive edge against a balanced lineup like the Rangers, but it can't hurt.
If you're going with that strategy, it probably makes sense to go with the lesser pitcher first, and hope to get a couple of innings out of him before you go to the better pitcher.
I think the biggest advantage is that you can tell both all of your pitchers not to worry about pitching deep into the game. Put it all out there on every pitch and don't concede at bats.
Day off before is in case they need to play a one game playoff for the division first. Day off after is because the division champ is playing on the road and don't know where they'll need to be.
Yeah, that's how I understand it. Next year this round becomes a best-of-seven, yes?
What, the play-in for the Wild Card becomes a best-of-seven? That tears it, I'm going to start following curling instead :)
I thought the days off was a fluke of this years schedule, and not the plan going forward?
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.