|
|
|
|
|
Support BBTF
Thanks to Chicago Joe for his generous support.
Bookmarks
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Hot Topics
Newsblog: OMNICHATTER for MAY 25, 2013 (73 - 11:08pm, May 25)Last: GamingboyNewsblog: OT: NHL is finally back thread (381 - 11:07pm, May 25)Last:  PASTE Thinks This Trout Kid Might Be OK (Zeth)Newsblog: Davey Johnson says he won't shave until Nationals start hitting (4 - 10:49pm, May 25)Last: Walt DavisNewsblog: Raissman: Could 2013 be last year for John Sterling and Suzyn Waldman on Yankees radio broadcast? (11 - 10:48pm, May 25)Last: ChipNewsblog: Posnanski: KC and the little things (4 - 10:46pm, May 25)Last: Walt DavisNewsblog: Perry: Hawk Harrelson reacts to blown call by Angel Hernandez (29 - 10:44pm, May 25)Last: Petunia inquires about poniesNewsblog: FanGraphs: Cameron: The 2013 Cubs: Better Than We Think (46 - 10:31pm, May 25)Last: McCoy Wilfong for Money Newsblog: Flip Flop Fly Ball: Diamonds Aren’t Forever – Five Base Baseball? (8 - 10:23pm, May 25)Last: SoSH U at workNewsblog: McCoy: Brandon Phillips playing to Joe Morgan's level? (17 - 10:21pm, May 25)Last: Non-Youkilidian GeometryNewsblog: [OTP-May] Politico: Congressional baseball game, May 1, 1926 (4475 - 9:47pm, May 25)Last:  Jolly Old St. Nick Done Jumped The ShipNewsblog: Who Are the Top Baserunners in Baseball? | Articles | Bill James Online (28 - 9:40pm, May 25)Last: bobmNewsblog: OT: NBA Monthly Thread - May 2013 (1280 - 9:39pm, May 25)Last:  MaxwnNewsblog: SB Nation: The Rotation: The worst baseball conversations (21 - 9:22pm, May 25)Last: gef the talking mongooseNewsblog: HHS: Autin: Miguel Cabrera to the max (34 - 7:34pm, May 25)Last: MefistoNewsblog: Marchman: Why Even Have Baseball's Draft? (19 - 7:29pm, May 25)Last: YR Misses Reggie Bars
|
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. JJ1986 Posted: September 11, 2012 at 10:50 PM (#4233270)Cue Mike Francesa, from today's show: "The Red Sox have nothing to play for. If the Yankees only take 2 of 3 it will be a disappointment."
8 hours later, a stream of red comes flowing from the Fenway dugout.
How can someone be so clueless about what motivates professional athletes, 30 years in to covering them professionally?
Francesa: "Ok, we got it, we got it already, we got the idea."
I don't think the Red Sox hate Baltimore the way we do them... but we'll see :)
I thought the actual throw itself was great. Strong, accurate, on-line.
But watching carefully, Ichiro didn't really charge the ball at all. He kind of pulled up and allowed it to come to him. I am not saying his approach was wrong, necessarily -- perhaps he has a better chance to get off a more accurate and stronger throw this way, or, more likely, has a better chance to field it cleanly so that he can at least get off an attempt. But his approach seems to be _different_ from what I typically see major league outfielders do.
If he charges AND gets off the same throw, he may well nail Ciriaco, but the key there is that he would have to field the ball cleanly and get off the same throw. I am happy to cede to his judgment on this, as he knows how to play the game and I don't; I'm not criticizing him, just wondering if others had the same thought.
That took a ton of luck.
edit: *and* Ellsbury and Pedroia playing up to their abilities.
Kuroda didn't help matters either, twice giving up leads against an undermanned Red Sox lineup.
The Red Sox showed up tonight. The Yankees, I'm not so sure.
The great thing about this WC race is that, with so many teams still in the running, there are inevitably going to be a couple who stay hot through the rest of the month; which means anybody who has a bad week is probably done.
Can't overstate how awful this decision was. Sox down three, but start the inning off with three hits, have Benoit on the ropes and Ventura calls for his third (~) best hitter to bunt in front of a AAAA-outfielder who they grabbed off waivers a month ago(why said outfielder is hitting third is another question to ponder). Youkilis, who apparently does not have even ONE sac bunt in his major league career, predictably falls behind 0-2 before flailing at a pitch three feet outside. Absolutely killed the inning. Add that to Ventura's decision to bring Liriano into a one-run game, despite having a rested bullpen, and you've got an atrocious night from the skipper.
These AL races would also be really great without the second wild card. Or, the first.
I thought the actual throw itself was great. Strong, accurate, on-line.
But watching carefully, Ichiro didn't really charge the ball at all. He kind of pulled up and allowed it to come to him. I am not saying his approach was wrong, necessarily -- perhaps he has a better chance to get off a more accurate and stronger throw this way, or, more likely, has a better chance to field it cleanly so that he can at least get off an attempt. But his approach seems to be _different_ from what I typically see major league outfielders do.
If he charges AND gets off the same throw, he may well nail Ciriaco, but the key there is that he would have to field the ball cleanly and get off the same throw. I am happy to cede to his judgment on this, as he knows how to play the game and I don't; I'm not criticizing him, just wondering if others had the same thought.
I couldn't say, because by that point I was cowering in a closet with a pair of pillows strapped to my ears. When the Yanks' biggest "clutch hit" of the night was a ####### 250' popup that bounced over a low fence in front of the Pesky pole, it's not as if I was exactly expecting a happy ending.
Haven't seen the play but this is one of the toughest decisions while playing 1B. If you _know_ the 2B can get it, you definitely don't go for it and cover first. It's pretty common to see 1B screw up by going for balls they clearly should leave for the 2B. But if you only _think_ he can get it, then ouch!
Regardless the pitcher should move to cover first but whether it's the 1B getting a ball with momentum towards second then turning and finding the pitcher or it's the 2B on the move making a throw to a moving pitcher, this is a tough play.
If there's a force at second, go for the ball if you think you can reach the ball.
Either way, as you note, Logan should have been covering.
Agree. Sox fans have been *begging* RV to bunt at Cabrera these past two series - he can't field when he's healthy, and he's got two bum wheels...but in a lineup with De Aza, Wise, Ramirez, and Beckham (not to mention "grindy" guys on the bench), I'm not sure Youkilis - he of the zero lifetime sac bunt Youkilises - is the guy we had in mind.
Also, starting Viciedo against Fister was bad, but letting him face Valverde in the 9th - Viciedo is 223/266/348 career against RHP - was inexcusable.
And what was with Liriano coming out of the 'pen to start the 8th?
Ugh.
To be fair to RV re Dewayne Wise, he's riding the hot hand. And with Dunn's injury, I'm not sure he has any better options on the roster. But he probably shouldn't be hitting 3rd.
I would challenge you to a DUEL, sir... if I wasn't so ####### happy, right at this moment.
Ken Korach was in fine form tonight. What a treat this season has been.
I would mind being beaten up if I weren't so happy right at this moment myself. Totally worth it for the reverse jinx effect.
Care to elaborate on this, RDP?
Ummm ... what is a Ken Korach?
A's broadcaster (TV and radio). Pronounced "CORE-ack." He does good work.
Apparently, Brandon McCarthy called it first.
He's probably my favorite radio broadcaster out of the guys who haven't been there a thousand years since radio was new. I also like Jon Miller.
You, sir, are clearly a man of refinement and excellent taste.
Here is the number they are highlighting on the insipid postgame show: 2 for 10 with runners in scoring position. Shocked it was that high. This game was winnable twice: early and late. Sloppy swings by Kendry and Howie and Albert Pujols (who had a little redemption in the 9th but who is grandfathering it badly these days) added up to a turkey. And the only people giving thanks are the drum-beating hippies in green and gold up in Occupyland.
Nyum nyum nyum.
but i sure as heck didn't think it would evolve into them having to scrap it out with baltimore. what??
and the angels have to be frustrating. you a core of great players and then so much dreck it's dragging down the whole season
Okay, that's a lot of jinx I threw out there. Hope everyone can handle it.
I am now looking for you and I will find you and you will die screaming like a little girl who just saw a spider crawl out of her vagina.
And yes, I stole that last line verbatim from Louie. Sue me!
The old sidekick from Space Ghost: Coast to Coast? He was awesome.
That MLB.com headline on the O's game is just whack.
Did he actually do it? I believe he did.
edit: In the comments someone referred to this as a Green and Golden Shower, which is all kinds of awesome.
edit edit: Just one more edit...by WPA, Blevins' save last night was the second toughest in the last 10 years.
NO COUNTING OF CHICKENS! THE CHICKENS, THEY ARE NOT GOING TO BE ####### COUNTED!
And yes, yes, I agree. Such a rich, substantial, delightful taste to these tears. And I'm not even an A's fan, just a guy who cordially dislikes the Angels.
And the A's get 16 of the last 21 against playoff contending teams, not 18. The Angels aren't playoff contenders.
You guys get really down on your team--it's baseball and there's always another day. After getting swept at home and almost having the team's most popular player almost get killed on the field, the A's have won 5 in a row. I'd wait at least a couple of weeks before writing off a team as talented as the Angels.
Hilariously, I knew who you were linking to before I ran my cursor over your link: the redoubtable Rev Halofan.
He is quite the drama queen/troll.
I will take this moment to put in the obligatory plug for the Nationals' radio team, Charlie Slowes (who's been calling games on the radio since Day 1 in '05) and Dave Jaegler. I know I'm a homer and all, but outside the Hall of Fame Legends (Scully, Miller, Uecker, etc.) I really think they're in absolute upper tier of announcers. Great -- GREAT, especially Slowes -- radio voices, skilled game-calling, and obvious chemistry. Also, an excellent and thorough post-game show.
Bonus: one of my favorite Charlie Slowes calls of all time, it's one of those sad moments that hardcore Nationals fans remember from the Bad Old Days: the Nook Logan debacle.
But watching carefully, Ichiro didn't really charge the ball at all. He kind of pulled up and allowed it to come to him. I am not saying his approach was wrong, necessarily -- perhaps he has a better chance to get off a more accurate and stronger throw this way, or, more likely, has a better chance to field it cleanly so that he can at least get off an attempt. But his approach seems to be _different_ from what I typically see major league outfielders do.
Ray, like you, I probably shouldn't question how Ichiro! played the ball, but I think you're right. I think he dind't charge fully because he took a bad line to it. It looks like the ball got to him quicker than he thought so he was in danger of over-running it. So he slowed up and adjusted to his left.
Either way, I'm not sure he could have played it in such a way to get the runner. He might have made it close and, hey, you never know, but I don't think he was getting the runner either way.
And, of course, I could be way off on what he was doing/thinking.
What was the toughest?
Ya know it!
*moves like Bernie*
According to BB Ref. Honestly, I don't understand WPA enough to know how it's calculated. Here's the all time list someone else generated so I can't completely vouch for it's accuracy.
Belvins' WPA for the game was 0.651 which, thankfully, overcame Grant Balfour's -0.615.
According to BB Ref. Honestly, I don't understand WPA enough to know how it's calculated.
I don't know how WPA is calculated either, but it looks like Sonnanstine came into the game in the exact same situation as Blevins: 1st and 3rd, nobody out, up by one run. But check out who Sonnanstine had to face:
1. Brian Barden - Backup shortstop, 26 OPS+ in 2010, 52 OPS+ for his major-league career.
2. Anibal Sanchez - A pitcher pinch-hitting for another pitcher, and he's a bad hitter even for a pitcher (for his career: .245(!) OPS, 1 extra-base hit, 105 K in 276 PA).
3. Dan Uggla - OK, Uggla was very good in 2010.
Gaby Sanchez, not a particularly fast runner, was on first. (He did steal a base in the inning.)
Blevins, on the other hand, faced:
1. Kendrys Morales - Good power hitter; career line of .282/.334/.490 (slightly worse this year but his OPS+ is better).
2. Howie Kendrick - Career .291 average, doubles power, reasonably fast (but does ground into a lot of DPs).
The runner at 1B was Peter Bourjos, maybe the fastest guy in the league.
I'd say Blevins' save was more difficult. Sonnanstine had two near-automatic outs before Uggla came up, and Uggla batting with two outs is easier to survive than Morales with no outs or Kendrick with one out.
The best save I can remember was not actually a save because the game was tied (which is even tougher, really): John Rocker in Game 3 of the 1999 NLDS against the Astros: http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/HOU/HOU199910080.shtml
Bottom of the 10th, tie game, Russ Springer loads the bases with no outs and Rocker is summoned to replace him. The first batter he faces (Carl Everett in his best season) hits a grounder to first base; the runner is thrown out at home. The next batter (Tony Eusebio, decent hitter for a catcher) hits a grounder to shortstop; the runner is again thrown out at home. Rocker then strikes out Ricky Gutierrez to extend the game. His WPA, however, was "only" 0.587. But given the circumstances (extra innings, playoff game) I'd say Rocker out-Blevinsed Blevins.
King and Greenwald both deserve it.
Am I remembering right that Walt Weiss made a spectacular diving play on the grounder that he fielded? I remember Weiss doing that with Atlanta in a big spot, not sure if this was the one.
1) They're better than you.
2) You're not as good as you thought.
Both are true for the Angels. Given how high the expectations were for them before the season, I'll say it again: this season hurts more than 1995.
According to a game report "the second out was courtesy of a shortstop Walt Weiss, whose diving, game-saving stab permanently etched his name in the lore of Houston Astros infamy."
Oh, he'd have to do some steppin' to catch up with Garry Maddox or Jesse ####### Orosco in 'Stros infamosity.
Amazing.
(Well, the Redskins still have 15 games to go and I hope they lose all 15 of them, but that new kid at QB was a wonder to behold down in New Orleans, and they've got an easy schedule.)
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main