It's a little disconcerting that four years into the Huntington regime, they don't have a serious shortstop prospect in the organization.

It's a little disconcerting that four years into the Huntington regime, they don't have a serious shortstop prospect in the organization.

Why?

I don't see how you can rate Allie so highly. He might turn it around, but there's about a 95% that he's already a bust.

I agree with the excerpt. The system isn't bad by any stretch, but considering what they've spent and how aggressive they've been, its a bit disappointing. But many of them are young and that could be different a year from now.

Really like Josh Bell though. That was a huge coup.

I don't see how you can rate Allie so highly. He might turn it around, but there's about a 95% that he's already a bust.

They actually rated him really low. Grossman and Sanchez aren't any great shakes - though they have a chance to be useful regulars - and there isn't really anyone with a decent ceiling that would be ranked below Allie on this list. The 5% chance (and its higher than 5%) he has of having a Daniel Bard turn-around in the pen makes him more deserving of a top 10 spot than the Jordy Mercers or Quincy Latimores of the world.

Why?

I can't speak for the Babe and the Babe is probably nitpicking anyway, but "serious" SS prospects are not only where future "serious" ML SS come from but also a lot of "serious" ML 2B, 3B and CF. A lack of SS in the system kinda means a lack of IF in the system.

On the other hand, a lot of "serious" SS prospects are glove guys who will never hit enough for 2B, 3B or CF anyway or, if they hit well enough, get shifted early enough that they are never "serious" SS prospects but "serious" 2B/3B/CF prospects. That's where the nitpicking comes in.

It would also generally be a sign of a lack of "athletic" players in the system -- which might be a bad thing if athleticism is a good predictor of success.

And pardon me if I misremember the scuttlebutt (I don't really follow prospects) but wasn't Sanchez supposed to be a stud? What's he doing at #6?

EDIT: err.... #7

And pardon me if I misremember the scuttlebutt (I don't really follow prospects) but wasn't Sanchez supposed to be a stud? What's he doing at #6?

Not hitting.

Despite being a top 10 pick, Sanchez wasn't ever a true "hot prospect." He isn't any kind of elite talent, he was an overdraft to most people. He was, however, expected to a be steady regular at a key position - a cornerstone for the Pirates to rebuild around. A safe bet, lower ceiling kind of guy. Except maybe instead of being the decent hitter he is expected to be, he will be a non-hitter. He has a year to turn it around. He hits decently next year, he will probably start for the Pirates in 2013. If he continues to not hit he will still be big leaguer, but just a backup catcher.

He had a really similar profile, and year, to Christian Colon. Both very good college players at up the middle positions who were expected to be safe bets to move quickly... until they forgot how to hit.

Allie was another high pick Pirate (drafted with a lower pick than Sanchez but considered by many to be a better draft prospect, Allie got top 10 pick money) who fell on his face and dropped down the rankings as a result. Going into the year an educated guess for the Pirates prospects might have been something like....
1/2. Taillon/Whoever their #1 pick would be
3. Allie
4. Sanchez.

Sanchez hit well in A ball, was hit in the face with a pitch in 2010, and the hitting disappeared in AA last year. There's some thought that he might not have been full strength after having his mouth wired shut for a while.

. Except maybe instead of being the decent hitter he is expected to be, he will be a non-hitter. He has a year to turn it around.

He hit quite well in half a year in the FSL: .314/.416/.454 (league .255/.324/.364), of course 22 is not young for the FSL...
He was awful in 2011- so awful that I assumed injury... I had not heard of him getting hit in the face and having his mouth wired shut- that's scary, that can mess up a hitter psychologically as well as physically