Football: “a game of action that discourages thought and reflection”..after that, much like Chico, California in ‘22…it’s raining rocks in Oldcootersville.
On Saturday, the longtime Kansas State University history professor returned to Kansas Wesleyan, this time to discuss the effect of baseball to the health of the American form of government.
“It’s the game that drives me, and it’s still the greatest game devised by human beings,” Robert Linder said.
Historically, baseball has functioned as one of the key avenues for teaching each new generation the values that hold the country together, Linder said, and to be a successful player requires mental agility as well as physical strength. Now football, “a game of action that discourages thought and reflection,” is increasingly popular, he said.
...“Why Baseball is Better than Football, Especially for Republicans: The Presentation that Nobody will Publish” was the title of Linder’s address, which he read from a manuscript he wrote and submitted to a leading history of baseball journal in 2008.
Linder said the essay was termed “inappropriate” and was not published, and the remarks written by the journal’s reviewers included the question: “Who is this crazy old coot anyway?”
...“There’s sufficient separation on the field between players that they can’t hide from individual responsibility in a crowd—as they do in football or in Congress,” Linder said.
In baseball, each player’s skill is highlighted, and there is a faith in the individual, he said. Individual merit and self-reliance is the “bedrock of baseball,” and the value of the individual is also the driving force in civilization that keeps government intrusion into private lives at a minimum, Linder said.
Repoz
Posted: April 01, 2012 at 05:51 AM |
24 comment(s)
Login to Bookmark
Tags:
history
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. Weekly Journalist_ Posted: April 01, 2012 at 07:54 AM (#4094093)While almost all football players are also immensely talented athletes, there is a requirement to dedicate one's body to the violence and health risk that weeds out certain people.
The idea that you can hide on a football field and not do your job is ridiculous. I guess since it's a sport that requires acknowledging the existence of other people and teammates in order to complete the task, it's not fair to Republican sensibilities. The statheads also seem to like that a player can get his hits and go home and sip his martinis at his mansion even if the team is going to hell, he's "done his job."
It's not that it's partisan, it's that it's incoherent. Its title is "Why Baseball is Better than Football, Especially for Republicans", but the values he celebrates are largely communal, and he warns against our becoming an "imperial" nation. He seems to be in favor of things like school prayer, which I suppose is something that Republicans drool over, but the last Republican I remember who warned about the dangers of "empire" was Robert Taft**. Not to mention that "greedy owners" and "television moguls" are hardly the sort of Republican talking points one generally hears these days.
**Libertarians are a completely different story on that topic, but they're not included in his title.
Um.
Linder then ordered everyone to get off the green place around his home.
Holy hell, this guy might be my father-in-law ... oh wait, no, this guy likes baseball. Never mind.
Like the United States', it was issued by a British local authority.
...however, it's still not as good as 'fetch,' the greatest game devised by dogs."
Academics see in anything whatever they want to see.
"They impact youth with high drama seldom found in the school classroom," he(Lindler) said
This man is a monster!
OTOH since nobody in his right mind would want to take ownership of such a weird and self-contradictory thesis, at least it won't lead to a BTF bloodbath. I give it fewer than 10 more posts before it croaks of its own accord.
For instance, yesterday a piece went up on The New Republic about how baseball has less class warfare and racial tension and economic exploitation than other sports.
That said, baseball is self-evidently better than football, because I like baseball better than football, and the ball is round.
Yes. Whoever designed a "ball" this is not round is truly history's greatest monster.
Baseball is great, but it's no Calvinball.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main