This is My*T*Fine on a grand goofiness scale…but then again I feel the same way about occasional Constant Mongrel droppings.
With action from the 2012 presidential campaigns heating up and the November 6th election right around the corner, your pleasant and care-free daily internet musings are soon likely to be inundated with images of electoral maps and ‘battleground’ strategies marked by smatterings of red, blue and undecided purple states. To comfort you during all this, I’ve prepared a map of America that mercifully is not color-coded along the lines of pointless partisan-bickering, but instead according to baseball’s most prestigious and elegant statistic, WAR.
Using both batter and pitcher WAR totals from the infinitely-resourceful Baseball-Reference, I’ve grouped the career WAR of each player in MLB history by their birth state in an effort to see which states are strongest in the Union and which states should secede from the nation in shame…
...Montana (26.2), you may have noticed, is home to the fewest WAR in the nation and has produced just 7 players with career WAR totals above 0 and 15 additional players with career totals at or below replacement level. Dave Mcnally was Big Sky Country’s best offering to date with a combined 22.2 WAR from 1962-1975. John Lowenstein of Wolf Point and Ed Bouchee of Livingston added just 8.1 and 7.1 WAR respectively, yet they still rank 2nd and 3rd amongst Montana’s top contributors.
One might have expected a state like Alaska (87.2) to have fared just as poorly in this sort of contest considering it is much colder, crueler, and lonelier. As it turns out, your tempered expectations would not have been misguided at all were it not solely for the efforts of a one Curt Schilling of Anchorage and the 76.1 lifetime WAR he added to his home state. The next highest contributor for The Last Frontier is Shawn Chacon, also of Anchorage, at 5.4 WAR. Interestingly, there have been just two non-Anchorage, Alaskan-born ballplayers in baseball’s past—Tom Sullivan (0.0) of Nome and more recently Chad Bentz of Seward (-0.7).
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. AROM Posted: August 09, 2012 at 10:40 AM (#4204211)Good idea though.
I'm putting my money on Donora, Pa.
New York's a big state too, but it would be interesting to see how that region did over time. My guess is most of the WAR from NYS is coming from the early days, before professional baseball was played in other places.
Alabama has all of those guys beat: 1800+ in WAR, 4.8 million in population.
It beats Florida in WAR alone.
That seems like a good guess :p I was thinking more at the state level myself on the per capita front, at least.
#8: That's true, and actually a WAR/capita over time would be even more interesting to see (i.e., whether more players began as cities expanded or as the country expanded or where the threshold was or whatever).
The Narrows, GA - the former birthplace of Ty Cobb is essentially unincorporated territory.
Also, it uses the town of each player's High School, which is usually a more accurate way of determining where a player is from. This way, Roger Clemens doesn't count towards Ohio, and Joe Morgan doesn't count towards Texas, etc.
Some serious backwoods stuff.
I'd be curious to see the position player/pitcher split by state. OK would be incredibly position player heavy - it's got Mantle, Bench, Stargell, the Waner brothers, and a bunch of other guys who were at least really good as hitters, but its best pitcher (by a good margin) is Allie Reynolds.
In the comment section the author has a link to a google doc of state WAR per 2011 population.
Tops are DC (0.42 WAR per 1000 people), PA (0.40), MO (0.38). Bottom are MT (0.03), UT (0.02), NV (0.02).
That should be better in a few years.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main