Baseball Primer Newsblog
— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand
Sunday, November 25, 2012
Malcolm with the final say on the Cabrera/Trout dust-up…or: Baby the Reign Must Fall (doff’s Murray way).
And in the case of the 2012 AL MVP, virtually all of the intrigue in it stems from the fact that one system ranked Mike Trout’s non-offensive value at such an extreme level that it made the comparison with Cabrera into something egregiously lopsided. Our suspicion is that the 28 voters entrusted to decide the AL MVP (and—hey, really? just twenty-eight?? is that not one of the most ridiculously small sample sizes ever for such an important honor???) may well have looked at the various “advanced numbers” as part of their decision-making process. Trout was touted heavily in the MSM while his performance was at its peak from late July-mid August, and at least a smattering of those voters are known to reference those numbers.
...Let’s close with a thought about what would have happened if the hard-sell harping on that outrageously high gap between Trout and Cabrera hadn’t turned away some voters who may have been receptive to shifting their vote. If eight voters had shifted from Cabrera to Trout, we’d wind up in a virtual tie: that vote tally would shift from 362-281 to 322-321. Then, if the inestimably unmentionable Sheldon Ocker of the Akron Beacon Journal hadn’t been the lone wingnut deviation from the Cabrera-Trout binary (either voted 1-2 or 2-1 by 96% of the voting population), we mighta coulda (shoulda?) had a tie in this MVP race, something that traditionalists and the various flavors of Stalinists in the little world of numberology might have found a way to live with—a kind of benevolent whitewash to the watery bloodbath that will now continue to divide rather than unite.
(In any event, we sure as hell would like to have seen a much larger BBWAA voting population involved in this result…with technology and analysis being what it is today, the notion of limiting the voting population to league beat writers and a few other random chimps is as outmoded as the Model T. We wonder what a full BBWAA membership vote on the 2012 MVP might have looked like.)
That day is further off, and while in the real world it’s the “bad guys” who are keeping that from happening, here in this little sub-region of “reality” it’s the “good guys” who are doing same. And the “good guys” should know that it’s much more possible—and much more feasible—to have “co-MVPs” than “co-Presidents.” Keeping that dichotomy in mind might keep things in better perspective.
for his generous support.
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
: OT: Monthly NBA Thread - July 2015
(626 - 12:49am, Jul 07)Last:
: Cubs, Theo Epstein won't necessarily be buyers at trade deadline - Chicago Tribune
(72 - 12:45am, Jul 07)
Last: Spahn Insane says "Chinga tu pelo."Newsblog
: OMNICHATTER 7-6-15
(122 - 12:44am, Jul 07)Last:
: OTP - July 2015: Winning the Political Game: Politics is More Like Baseball Than Football
(1010 - 12:44am, Jul 07)Last:
: The stories behind Dodgers’ deep-seated Yasiel Puig resentment | New York Post
(81 - 12:41am, Jul 07)
Last: The Yankee ClapperNewsblog
: Full All Star Team Rosters
(39 - 12:19am, Jul 07)
: Fewer walks and bunts, more shifts among midseason trends - MLB
(3 - 11:57pm, Jul 06)
: 538: Baseball's Kids Are All Right
(21 - 11:51pm, Jul 06)
Last: Walt DavisNewsblog
: Neyer: Where There's Smoak, There's Fire
(23 - 11:43pm, Jul 06)
: Nationals, Astros WPB Spring Training Site Approved
(2 - 10:25pm, Jul 06)
Last: The Yankee ClapperNewsblog
: OT: Soccer June 2015
(1033 - 10:04pm, Jul 06)Last:
: Scioscia Reigns and Dipoto Resigns: What the Heck Is Going on With the Angels? «
(41 - 9:46pm, Jul 06)
Last: A New LeafNewsblog
: New York Mets, David Wright don't have surgery as a top option | Newsday
(27 - 8:31pm, Jul 06)
Last: Adam StarblindNewsblog
: Recreating Memorable Trading Cards
(2 - 8:29pm, Jul 06)
: Primer Dugout (and link of the day) 7-6-2015
(20 - 7:19pm, Jul 06)