Baseball for the Thinking Fan

Login | Register | Feedback

btf_logo
You are here > Home > Baseball Newsstand > Baseball Primer Newsblog > Discussion
Baseball Primer Newsblog
— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand

Tuesday, March 20, 2001

ESPN.com - Major League Baseball - Yanks’ second thoughts mean move to left

The speculation is over: Knobby is no longer a secondbaseman. No, he will not put up the big slugging numbers like Hill or Rodrigues would. However, if he can approach his mid 1990’s numbers as a leadoff man the Yankees will be extremely difficult to beat.

The Original Gary Posted: March 20, 2001 at 03:17 AM | 2 comment(s) Login to Bookmark
  Tags:

Reader Comments and Retorts

Go to end of page

Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.

   1. Robert Posted: March 20, 2001 at 12:20 PM (#66082)
Making Knoblauch the regular LF and taking playing time away from Rodriguez, Hill and Spencer is not going to help the Yankees' offence or defence.

I think this decision is a little premature. I'd keep him at 2nd until he proved that he was costing me a significant number of runs. Of course I'd bring in a defensive substitution later in the game on a very regular basis.

The argument that Knoblauch must be in the lineup because he bats leadoff and has a very good OBA is not convincing in my eyes. Posada is likely to have an even higher OBA and moving Jeter to leadoff will give him some extra PAs.

I can hear all of you exclaim that Posada's too slow and strikes out too much. To me the strikeouts are a plus because it means he avoids the GIDP. As for speed, it's overrated at the 2 hole. The best lineup is one which puts guys on for the 3,4, and 5 hitters.

As it stands right now, putting a slow guy in the 2 hole regardless of his OBP is considered radical, and since Torre likes the hit and run I doubt he'll even consider it.

So it looks like Knoblauch at LF/DH and batting leadoff when in the lineup, with Justice playing the field occasionally and the other guys coming into the mix at various points. If Torre bats Soriano at the top of the lineup when Knobby's not in it, it will be a big mistake.

Soriano is going to mean a big drop is offence. The Yankee offence has become a 6-man unit unless Martinez can somehow re-ignite his career. That's without considering Paul O'Neill's (very likely) further decline. A platoon in RF and LF looks like the way to go. If you think about it, there are only 4 good hiters in the lineup (Justice, Jeter, Posada, Williams)

I wouldn't release Knoblauch - I think he'll be good for a productive 250 PA. A trade will be difficult - who wants an aging error-prone 2B who can't (seemingly) play the position anymore.
   2. Robert Posted: March 20, 2001 at 12:20 PM (#66342)
Making Knoblauch the regular LF and taking playing time away from Rodriguez, Hill and Spencer is not going to help the Yankees' offence or defence.

I think this decision is a little premature. I'd keep him at 2nd until he proved that he was costing me a significant number of runs. Of course I'd bring in a defensive substitution later in the game on a very regular basis.

The argument that Knoblauch must be in the lineup because he bats leadoff and has a very good OBA is not convincing in my eyes. Posada is likely to have an even higher OBA and moving Jeter to leadoff will give him some extra PAs.

I can hear all of you exclaim that Posada's too slow and strikes out too much. To me the strikeouts are a plus because it means he avoids the GIDP. As for speed, it's overrated at the 2 hole. The best lineup is one which puts guys on for the 3,4, and 5 hitters.

As it stands right now, putting a slow guy in the 2 hole regardless of his OBP is considered radical, and since Torre likes the hit and run I doubt he'll even consider it.

So it looks like Knoblauch at LF/DH and batting leadoff when in the lineup, with Justice playing the field occasionally and the other guys coming into the mix at various points. If Torre bats Soriano at the top of the lineup when Knobby's not in it, it will be a big mistake.

Soriano is going to mean a big drop is offence. The Yankee offence has become a 6-man unit unless Martinez can somehow re-ignite his career. That's without considering Paul O'Neill's (very likely) further decline. A platoon in RF and LF looks like the way to go. If you think about it, there are only 4 good hiters in the lineup (Justice, Jeter, Posada, Williams)

I wouldn't release Knoblauch - I think he'll be good for a productive 250 PA. A trade will be difficult - who wants an aging error-prone 2B who can't (seemingly) play the position anymore.
   3. Robert Posted: March 20, 2001 at 12:20 PM (#66882)
Making Knoblauch the regular LF and taking playing time away from Rodriguez, Hill and Spencer is not going to help the Yankees' offence or defence.

I think this decision is a little premature. I'd keep him at 2nd until he proved that he was costing me a significant number of runs. Of course I'd bring in a defensive substitution later in the game on a very regular basis.

The argument that Knoblauch must be in the lineup because he bats leadoff and has a very good OBA is not convincing in my eyes. Posada is likely to have an even higher OBA and moving Jeter to leadoff will give him some extra PAs.

I can hear all of you exclaim that Posada's too slow and strikes out too much. To me the strikeouts are a plus because it means he avoids the GIDP. As for speed, it's overrated at the 2 hole. The best lineup is one which puts guys on for the 3,4, and 5 hitters.

As it stands right now, putting a slow guy in the 2 hole regardless of his OBP is considered radical, and since Torre likes the hit and run I doubt he'll even consider it.

So it looks like Knoblauch at LF/DH and batting leadoff when in the lineup, with Justice playing the field occasionally and the other guys coming into the mix at various points. If Torre bats Soriano at the top of the lineup when Knobby's not in it, it will be a big mistake.

Soriano is going to mean a big drop is offence. The Yankee offence has become a 6-man unit unless Martinez can somehow re-ignite his career. That's without considering Paul O'Neill's (very likely) further decline. A platoon in RF and LF looks like the way to go. If you think about it, there are only 4 good hiters in the lineup (Justice, Jeter, Posada, Williams)

I wouldn't release Knoblauch - I think he'll be good for a productive 250 PA. A trade will be difficult - who wants an aging error-prone 2B who can't (seemingly) play the position anymore.
   4. Robert Posted: March 20, 2001 at 12:20 PM (#67668)
Making Knoblauch the regular LF and taking playing time away from Rodriguez, Hill and Spencer is not going to help the Yankees' offence or defence.

I think this decision is a little premature. I'd keep him at 2nd until he proved that he was costing me a significant number of runs. Of course I'd bring in a defensive substitution later in the game on a very regular basis.

The argument that Knoblauch must be in the lineup because he bats leadoff and has a very good OBA is not convincing in my eyes. Posada is likely to have an even higher OBA and moving Jeter to leadoff will give him some extra PAs.

I can hear all of you exclaim that Posada's too slow and strikes out too much. To me the strikeouts are a plus because it means he avoids the GIDP. As for speed, it's overrated at the 2 hole. The best lineup is one which puts guys on for the 3,4, and 5 hitters.

As it stands right now, putting a slow guy in the 2 hole regardless of his OBP is considered radical, and since Torre likes the hit and run I doubt he'll even consider it.

So it looks like Knoblauch at LF/DH and batting leadoff when in the lineup, with Justice playing the field occasionally and the other guys coming into the mix at various points. If Torre bats Soriano at the top of the lineup when Knobby's not in it, it will be a big mistake.

Soriano is going to mean a big drop is offence. The Yankee offence has become a 6-man unit unless Martinez can somehow re-ignite his career. That's without considering Paul O'Neill's (very likely) further decline. A platoon in RF and LF looks like the way to go. If you think about it, there are only 4 good hiters in the lineup (Justice, Jeter, Posada, Williams)

I wouldn't release Knoblauch - I think he'll be good for a productive 250 PA. A trade will be difficult - who wants an aging error-prone 2B who can't (seemingly) play the position anymore.
   5. The Original Gary Posted: March 21, 2001 at 02:14 PM (#66085)
Jorge Posada has had one season in which his OBP surpassed .360. Granted he had a great year last year, one more fitted for the 3 hole than the 2, but that by no means convinces me pencil him in for another .400 plus OBP. Knoblauch, IF he can approach his mid 1990's numbers, is the ideal option for leadoff. Read that again:IF he approaches his mid 1990's numbers. IF he gets on base at a .400 clip, sets the table for the Posada, Williams, Justice group, he is a better option than Hill, Rodriguez or Spencer. If Knoblauch meanders at a .360 OBP then no, he is not a better option. My money says that now that he is free of his second base woes, he will relax at the plate and produce like he used to. I am not saying he will hit .330 with a .440 OBP and steal 60 bases. I think a .310 average, .400 OBP and 35 stolen bases is not out of the question.
   6. The Original Gary Posted: March 21, 2001 at 02:14 PM (#66345)
Jorge Posada has had one season in which his OBP surpassed .360. Granted he had a great year last year, one more fitted for the 3 hole than the 2, but that by no means convinces me pencil him in for another .400 plus OBP. Knoblauch, IF he can approach his mid 1990's numbers, is the ideal option for leadoff. Read that again:IF he approaches his mid 1990's numbers. IF he gets on base at a .400 clip, sets the table for the Posada, Williams, Justice group, he is a better option than Hill, Rodriguez or Spencer. If Knoblauch meanders at a .360 OBP then no, he is not a better option. My money says that now that he is free of his second base woes, he will relax at the plate and produce like he used to. I am not saying he will hit .330 with a .440 OBP and steal 60 bases. I think a .310 average, .400 OBP and 35 stolen bases is not out of the question.
   7. The Original Gary Posted: March 21, 2001 at 02:14 PM (#66885)
Jorge Posada has had one season in which his OBP surpassed .360. Granted he had a great year last year, one more fitted for the 3 hole than the 2, but that by no means convinces me pencil him in for another .400 plus OBP. Knoblauch, IF he can approach his mid 1990's numbers, is the ideal option for leadoff. Read that again:IF he approaches his mid 1990's numbers. IF he gets on base at a .400 clip, sets the table for the Posada, Williams, Justice group, he is a better option than Hill, Rodriguez or Spencer. If Knoblauch meanders at a .360 OBP then no, he is not a better option. My money says that now that he is free of his second base woes, he will relax at the plate and produce like he used to. I am not saying he will hit .330 with a .440 OBP and steal 60 bases. I think a .310 average, .400 OBP and 35 stolen bases is not out of the question.
   8. The Original Gary Posted: March 21, 2001 at 02:14 PM (#67671)
Jorge Posada has had one season in which his OBP surpassed .360. Granted he had a great year last year, one more fitted for the 3 hole than the 2, but that by no means convinces me pencil him in for another .400 plus OBP. Knoblauch, IF he can approach his mid 1990's numbers, is the ideal option for leadoff. Read that again:IF he approaches his mid 1990's numbers. IF he gets on base at a .400 clip, sets the table for the Posada, Williams, Justice group, he is a better option than Hill, Rodriguez or Spencer. If Knoblauch meanders at a .360 OBP then no, he is not a better option. My money says that now that he is free of his second base woes, he will relax at the plate and produce like he used to. I am not saying he will hit .330 with a .440 OBP and steal 60 bases. I think a .310 average, .400 OBP and 35 stolen bases is not out of the question.

You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.

 

 

<< Back to main

BBTF Partner

Support BBTF

donate

Thanks to
Sebastian
for his generous support.

Bookmarks

You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.

Hot Topics

NewsblogWho is the best player in baseball? The most overrated? We poll 117 major leaguers to find out.
(7 - 9:19pm, Mar 31)
Last: Danny

NewsblogNeyer: Ortiz isn't a bad guy -- or a Hall of Famer
(8 - 9:19pm, Mar 31)
Last: cardsfanboy

NewsblogWhite Sox offer $29 early-season plan
(18 - 9:18pm, Mar 31)
Last: Dag Nabbit is a cornucopia of errors

NewsblogMacnow: Phillies' Ryne Sandberg is wrong man for wrong team
(32 - 9:16pm, Mar 31)
Last: Jose Is The Most Absurd Thing on the Site

NewsblogRays denied consideration of re-negotiated lease by St. Petersburg City Council
(46 - 9:16pm, Mar 31)
Last: The Yankee Clapper

NewsblogSean Doolittle's girlfriend will buy your tickets to A's Pride Night
(21 - 9:11pm, Mar 31)
Last: RickG

NewsblogAn Analysis of a Broken Bat Home Run
(1 - 8:54pm, Mar 31)
Last: dr. scott

NewsblogOT: Monthly NBA Thread - March 2015
(1512 - 8:51pm, Mar 31)
Last: Spivey

NewsblogGrantland (Keri): 2015 NL East Preview
(17 - 8:35pm, Mar 31)
Last: Steve M.

NewsblogDefiant CC Sabathia doesn’t give a ‘f–k’ about poor spring outings | New York Post
(249 - 8:29pm, Mar 31)
Last: Ziggy

NewsblogOTP - March 2015: You’re out, tobacco: Bill would ban products at all California baseball venues
(3770 - 8:26pm, Mar 31)
Last: Rickey! is just here so he don't get fined

NewsblogReds open breast-feeding suite at the ballpark
(97 - 8:25pm, Mar 31)
Last: Jean Claude Vander Wal (Pokey1228)

NewsblogCubs send Bryant to minors
(89 - 7:52pm, Mar 31)
Last: Squash

NewsblogOT: Wrestling Thread November 2014
(850 - 7:24pm, Mar 31)
Last: Chokeland Bill

NewsblogChicago Cubs Kris Bryant and the service-time game | FOX Sports
(167 - 4:52pm, Mar 31)
Last: Misirlou was a Buddhist prodigy

Page rendered in 0.2218 seconds
47 querie(s) executed