Baseball Primer Newsblog
— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand
Wednesday, October 10, 2012
Ross Moschitto…you’ve been screwed again!
20. Don Mattingly, 39.8
Not surprised that Mattingly rates in the top 20, even considering his short career, but I am a bit surprised about some of the players that are ahead of him, like Combs, who is generally accepted as one of the weaker center fielders in the Hall of Fame. But, that’s one of the features (or failings, depending on your POV) of WAR – it gives bonus points to players who man important defensive positions. Mattingly was a first baseman and DH for pretty much his entire career. In looking back at Donnie Baseball’s career I am a bit surprised that he only had four seasons in which he was a great ballplayer. The rest of his career was borderline All-Star quality, especially for a first baseman. I watched him play, and I remember thinking that he was very good for a few years, but that he was never scary good like George Brett or Mike Schmidt or even Jim Rice.
17. Roy White, 43.0
It’s fashionable to call White “underrated” – and in fact I can email you 3-4 articles from The Sporting News from the 1970s that mention White and use the word “underrated” a lot. When I did my player rankings he kept coming up ahead of Jim Rice, no matter how I tweaked the formula.* When I emphasized park effects, White would be ahead of Rice. When I de-emphasized career and emphasized peak performance, Rice nudged real close or even surpassed Roy, but White wasn’t far behind at all. It doesn’t seem like Roy White could possibly have had a more valuable career than Jim Rice (44.3 WAR), but it’s quite possible he did when you factor that Jim Ed was a DH for a long time. By the way, White was almost an exact match for Lou Whitaker as an offensive player.
5. Derek Jeter, 69.3
Jeter contributes 4.3 WAR per 162g and he’s still humming along. However, and this is a part of WAR I wonder about – he gets “credit” for being a shortstop even if he’s obviously one of the worst defensive shortstops in baseball. Yes, dWAR “subtracts” WAR from him for his lack of range, but there’s still a positional adjustment. Someone who lives and breathes WAR is invited to explain to me how that makes sense. Seeing as how Jeter is now getting only about 2 WAR per season, if the Yankees move him to another position (say left field), he would be basically a marginal major league player, at least according to this stat. If he somehow keeps getting that 2 WAR per, he could skip past Joltin’ Joe, but he has no chance of getting any higher on this list.
*Used my Super-Umbrakinesis Power to darken.
for his generous support.
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
: OTP 16 Jan. 2017: The ‘honor’ Trumps politics in scheduling Cubs’ White House visit
(1918 - 2:42am, Jan 22)Last:
You Know Nothing JT Snow (YR)Sox Therapy
: The Kids Are or Are Not Alright
(18 - 1:56am, Jan 22)
Last: Nasty NateNewsblog
: Ex-Astro Luis Valbuena reportedly agrees to deal with Angels - Houston Chronicle
(19 - 1:51am, Jan 22)
: Chris Russo thinks the latest selections have ruined Hall of Fame
(77 - 1:36am, Jan 22)
Last: David Nieporent (now, with children)Newsblog
: Jayson Stark: Casting my 2018 Hall of Fame ballot ... today
(82 - 12:51am, Jan 22)
Last: cardsfanboyHall of Merit
: 2018 Hall of Merit Ballot Discussion
(113 - 12:41am, Jan 22)Last:
Michael J. Binkley's anxiety closetNewsblog
: OT - December 2016 NBA thread
(1215 - 12:07am, Jan 22)Last:
: Mets' Jay Bruce problem: Ex-GMs weigh in on what team should do - NY Daily News
(1 - 12:02am, Jan 22)
: Hall of Fame's Rule of 10 should be changed | MLB.com
(75 - 11:25pm, Jan 21)
Last: cardsfanboyHall of Merit
: Most Meritorious Player: 2000 Discussion
(26 - 11:09pm, Jan 21)
Last: DL from MNNewsblog
: MLB Tonight: Jorge Posada | MLB.com
(30 - 11:03pm, Jan 21)
Last: Jose is El Absurd PolloNewsblog
: 2017 Baseball Hall of Fame election results | MLB.com
(201 - 10:28pm, Jan 21)Last:
Ziggy: The Platonic Form of Russell BranyanHall of Merit
: Most Meritorious Player: 2000 Ballot
(2 - 8:52pm, Jan 21)
: OT - NFL stretch drive/playoffs (December 2016 - February 2017)
(622 - 4:12pm, Jan 21)Last:
: The Trumbo agreement, the ripple effect and what's next - School of Roch
(3 - 12:52pm, Jan 21)
Last: RMc's Yelling Mob of Hackmen