|
|
|
|
Baseball Primer Newsblog— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand
Tuesday, February 12, 2013
Okay, the batted-ball sports no longer have the biggest gripe with the IOC.
IOC leaders dropped wrestling from the Olympic program on Tuesday, a surprise decision that removes one of the oldest Olympic sports from the 2020 Games.
The IOC executive board decided to retain modern pentathlon — the event considered most at risk — and remove wrestling instead from its list of 25 “core sports.”
The IOC board acted after reviewing the 26 sports on the current Olympic program. Eliminating one sport allows the International Olympic Committee to add a new sport to the program later this year.
...
Wrestling will now join seven other sports in applying for inclusion in 2020. The others are a combined bid from baseball and softball, karate, squash, roller sports, sport climbing, wakeboarding and wushu. They will be vying for a single opening in 2020.
|
Support BBTF
Thanks to Mike Emeigh for his generous support.
Bookmarks
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Hot Topics
Newsblog: OMNICHATTER for MAY 18, 2013 (55 - 6:22pm, May 18)Last: cardsfanboyNewsblog: SoE (Megdal): It's Time to Finally Believe in the Orioles (3 - 6:21pm, May 18)Last: AROMNewsblog: Holmes: Where does Miguel Cabrera rank among Tiger greats? (16 - 6:19pm, May 18)Last: Misirlou is bad, he's nationwideNewsblog: BBTF SOFTBALL GAME IN NEW YORK--AUG 17 (289 - 6:18pm, May 18)Last:  Dock Ellis on AcidNewsblog: Pinstriped Bible: Albin: Is Ichiro done? (45 - 6:15pm, May 18)Last: Walt DavisNewsblog: Josh Hamilton's allergies not linked to drug use, doctors say (34 - 6:06pm, May 18)Last: ellsbury my heart at wounded kneeNewsblog: PressBox: Boog Powell: Meat Of The Order (8 - 5:57pm, May 18)Last: Misirlou is bad, he's nationwideNewsblog: Powerball odds? Juan Pierre's homers are long shots, too (10 - 5:43pm, May 18)Last: BhaakonNewsblog: Babcock: Can The 2013 Cubs Channel The Turnaround Artists Of 1967? (6 - 5:39pm, May 18)Last: BhaakonNewsblog: [OTP-May] Politico: Congressional baseball game, May 1, 1926 (3265 - 5:31pm, May 18)Last:  Joe KehoskieHall of Merit: Most Meritorious Player: 1982 Discussion (46 - 5:07pm, May 18)Last: MontyNewsblog: Townsend: Troy Tulowitzki denies accusing Madison Bumgarner of doctoring baseballs (1 - 5:00pm, May 18)Last: KT's Pot ArbNewsblog: BPro: Listen to What the Heyman Said (186 - 3:15pm, May 18)Last:  David Nieporent (now, with children)Newsblog: Generation K: Baseball’s strikeout trend is growing at record pace (57 - 2:55pm, May 18)Last: Mike EmeighNewsblog: MLB: Talking past, present and future with Ryne Sandberg (14 - 11:58am, May 18)Last: Karl from NY
|
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
I'm assuming gender considerations factor into that?
Yep.
There has been women's freestyle wrestling at the last three Olympics. So probably no.
I was going to mention "nothing is more Olympics than wrestling...than nude wrestling."
Get in line. I mean, I WANT baseball to be in the Olympics, but it's not a necessity to either baseball or the Olympics. But wrestling NEEDS to be in the Olympics, and the Olympics NEED wrestling to be in it. It's a sport that often provides some of the best moments, and unlike some sports it isn't really dominated by any one country. Sure, Eastern Europe and the USA do the best, but Canada and the Mid-East do well too. As opposed to, say, table tennis, which is 100% Asian dominated, or rhythmic gymnastics, which basically is a showcase simply for Eastern Europe and occasionally China.
And, besides, WRESTLING HAS BEEN IN THE OLYMPICS SINCE ANCIENT ####### TIMES! I mean, jeez, why not remove Track and Field while you are at it?
I still say that the Olympics should be something like 20 sports that are always in and never are removed (and Wrestling would be one of them), and then 6+ sports (depending on finances and available venues) that can be left up to the host, so long as those sports have been "recognized" by the IOC.
So, like, if the USA had the Olympics, then baseball and softball would definitely be in while a sport like table tennis or handball might not be. On the other hand, though, if Turkey got the Olympics (they are in the running for 2020), then baseball and softball probably wouldn't be played, but other sports that are more popular or played more in Turkey could be.
http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=gymnasium&allowed_in_frame=0
QI is where I turn to get all my most accurate historical information.
I think they should have more swimming events.
Not really.
Memo to IOC: If someone can win 7 or 8 medals in the same Olympics, that's a bug, not a feature. It means you have too many events in that sport.
If only there were a world government so I could write my representative to complain.
So much this.
WRESTLING HAS BEEN IN THE OLYMPICS SINCE ANCIENT ####### TIMES!
One word: Pankration.
old ex-wrestler and coach so this cuts to the quick for me. i always tuned in olympic wrestling, both freestyle and greco=roman
sighn
Triathalon, rowing, sailing, shooting, archery, judo, modern pentathlon, canoeing/kayak, aquatics, athletics, equestrian, gymnastics, taekwondo, boxing, weightlifting, golf, fencing, cycling, volleyball, field hockey, basketball, handball, football (soccer), rugby, badminton, table tennis, tennis.
That's 27 sports plus wrestling. Guessing a couple of cases are merged but listed separately for some reason. Now, can someone explain why equestrian is there, or sailing? Both sports purely for the rich with minimal if any TV audience. Shooting? That makes golf look exhausting. Pentathlon is just a bizarre mix. Weightlifting should probably be removed due to the crazy level of PED use - the average weightlifter makes Barry Bonds look normal. The rest I can see an argument for (table tennis is very big in Asia for example) but those ones are just weird to keep over wrestling, baseball, squash and probably a few of the others in consideration.
If roller sports gets in though I'd have to say the IOC has really 'jumped the shark'...heck, jumped every shark there is.
Yeah, apparently it had a lot to do with the fact that Antonio Samaranch's son is a big-time name in Modern Pentathlon. Of course, Samaranch, if memory serves, was a "Big Olympics" kind of guy who didn't mind having lots of sports in the games. Compare that to Rogge, who is generally a "small games" kind of guy, and who basically drove the movement to have the amount of sports be capped. It'll be interesting to see who takes over for him, and whether he's a big games guy or a small games guy.
I agree with the principle behind it- it allows smaller countries to host Olympic games, for example- but that it forces all these sports to go against each other leaves a sour taste in my mouth. That's another reason why I like my idea of having 20 or so sports guaranteed and then a minimum of 6 added by the host: it could be the best of both worlds. If a city in a smaller economy like, say, South Africa, wants to have the games, they can just have 26. But if a Los Angeles were to get the games, they could conceivably have over 30 sports being played.
If a wrestling promoter creates an IOC-member character as a heel, I totally will watch.
Even then, wrestling seems an odd one to cut. You don't need a specialized arena for it. Kayaking OTOH...
#KICKHIMINTHEBALLS!!!
Why the heck have tennis or soccer in the Olympics? Those games are played in a worldwide sense all the time. Obviously this was done to make room for men's synchronized swimming.
IMO they should keep it big. But oddball stuff like adding trampoline, the dozens of similar events (multiple weight classes, the many lengths of running, etc.) could be cut back with 99% of people never noticing I suspect. Still trying to figure out 'dressage' for horses and how that remotely qualifies as a sport (you have your horse basically prance around the ring).
If cutbacks or limits are needed, I say have a number of venue limit so you don't add baseball or golf for that matter but keep things like wrestling which can share a venue with other sports. Figure out something that can make use of the cycling racetrack or get rid of it. That type of stuff would actually cut costs. Beach volleyball might be a one-off 'stadium' but given it is just a giant sandbox I doubt it is a killer cost and could technically be moved into any other arena... hmm, maybe put it at the center of the cycling stadium and have them doing beach volleyball with cyclists zipping around.
I assume tennis makes tv money? Maybe soccer, too. Though that's mostly a junior tournament in the Olympics (U-23's with 3 over-age players).
Getting rid of wrestling is kind of like McDonald's getting rid of fries.
Didn't they already do that when they merged the Winter Olympic Games with the Winter X Games?
Field hockey is mainly a men's sport outside the US, probably especially in countries that don't have ice hockey. From the wiki:
Men's hockey became a permanent feature at the next Olympic Games, the 1928 Games in Amsterdam.
The first women's Olympic hockey competition was held at the 1980 Summer Olympics in Moscow.
Anyway, I agree, wrestling is the sort of sport the Olympics are all about. I'd gladly drop basketball before wrestling.
And have they really dropped wrestling while keeping judo, etc?
Keeping things in perspective, I hate the NCAA more.
Istanbul is in the running for the 2020 Olympics, so I can't imagine that wrestling will be missing from the competition if they win the bid.
That would be like taking out ice hockey when Vancouver won the winter Olympic bid, or taking out soccer from the London summer Olympic games.
The IOC is definitely going to reverse course and put wrestling back in if Istanbul is selected.
Until shark-jumping becomes an Olympic sport.
Whitewater kayak/canoe requires a course with enough rocks to be sufficiently challenging. Atlanta made a big deal out of using a real river instead of a man-made course. I love watching whitewater rowing on television.
Nothing shady with any of those countries!
But I basically sign off of the sentiment above, wrestling should stay (and I don't even like it as a sport).
Why this definition matters I don't know, but it does. Wrestling isn't being kept out by trampoline.
In that case, they'll probably make sure that Istanbul doesn't win, kind of like Chicago or Tokyo didn't win for 2016, which would have put tremendous pressure on them to re-instate baseball.
In London, 71 nations participated in wrestling, contributing 344 athletes. MP had 24 countries contributing 72 athletes. Europe had 13 countries and 45 athletes, as well as 4 of the 6 medal winners, so there's your answer.
Duck said it, but this move tells me Istanbul isn't getting the games.
And I'm with everyone else. Holy hell the IOC is crooked/stupid. Wrestling is an Olympic sport, period. I have no doubt lots of the little gimmicky sports require incredible skill and discipline but that isn't the point. I'm not sure what the point is, of course. The Olympics has the marketing and appeal to non-sports fans. There is probably no sport they could cut that would significantly cut ratings. They'd just tell different stories and folks would tune in.
But, to a sports fan, this is one of the dumber things I've ever seen.
Also, as said above, why cap the number of sports at all? I can see capping venues. I can see cutting sports that aren't traditional and aren't global or that have more prestigious competitions (I'm looking at you soccer, golf and tennis). But if all you need is a mat and jersey, have the freaking competition.
Juan Antonio Samaranch was as crooked as they come, and the IOC is no better.
The Larry O'Brien Championship Trophy. The men arrested at the Watergate break-in were in Larry O'Brien's office.
As for track cycling, well it is awesome and the world needs more velodromes. And they could be made portable if the IOC were really interested in cutting costs.
It's not certain to be gone. It just has very little chance of making the cut. It's now competing against baseball/softball, karate, roller sports, sport climbing, squash, wakeboarding and wushu for a slot.
EDIT: Think of it as being in a repechage.
I have to say that (as already mentioned) in recent games the wrestling has been generally dull, dour, defensive. Generally grinding out a low points victory. Maybe I shouldn't complain because that was the only way I ever won, but then I don't think anybody would have found my few bouts at all compelling.
But as dull as they've been, they've been a thrill ride next to the judo that's been on display in recent years.
Up next: Competitive Puppy Eating.
Ugh, tell me about it.
Yet.
some folks still call it 'wrestling' today! not that there's anything wrong with that.
wrestling falling by the wayside is the chickens coming home to roost from the idiotic media fascination with gymnasts like olga korbut and nadia comenici. gymnastics got popular with women viewers, then the IOC saw the ratings, and so stupid 'sports' like synchronized swimming gained traction.
agree with everyone who thinks this latest move is hella stupid and that the IOC sucks big ones.
Not to mention the Toronto Maple Leafs. Though I suppose I should say, the second-place Toronto Maple Leafs!
Hell, yes, a big MMA free for all. This should definitely happen.
Pfft. The streak isn't even 50 years old yet. That's chump change in the baseball universe.
figures they prefer boring shtt like golf - it must bring in more $$ and i guess wrestling doesn't get ratings or $$$. but ?? shooting??? how the **** is that a "sport"???!!!
i guess now it's just mens gymnastics and mens figure skating for me
If they remove Womens Beach Volleyball I will be unhappy.
yeh, i bet. asked husband bout that one once. he said - no boobs/no booty/no biggie
Apparently the the only safeguard for the athlete's health they had in Pankration was that in case of death the dead guy was declared the winner. Oh, and no eye-gouging.
Also, one of my friends looked at some of the documentation the IOC used to justify ditching wrestling and the places where wrestling scored badly were almost all things about the composition of the international governing board and other weird minor technicalities about behind-the-scenes stuff.
It's all a disgrace. FIFA, for its tremendous venality, at least doesn't set itself up as the moral guardian of all true sporting endeavors.
i feel safe in saying your husband's views are not representative of most male olympics tv viewers, especially when we're talking about the brazilians, if my memory is accurate ...
I can get behind Beach Volleyball some, because that's where the highest level of volleyball athletes play, isn't it?
I disagree about the addition of sevens. Nearly any country in the world can get together a quality team with the impetus that the Olympics will provide. There's no infrastructure needed, very little development time. You've seen the Carlin Isles videos, right? Who's against that, exactly?
I can get behind Beach Volleyball some, because that's where the highest level of volleyball athletes play, isn't it?
Ha.
I really don't like the beachball. The women's indoor game is exceptional, though.
The IOC is a self-perpetuating body of individuals, not countries and federations, some of the places (45 out of 115) are earmarked for athletes, federation people and national olympic committee heads, 15 of each. But most are just general big-wigs.
There are pro leagues in Europe and Brazil.
Japan too. Also, since the AVP went belly-up a couple of years ago, I don't know how much money there is in beach volleyball anymore.
I didn't know this. I just knew Karch Kiraly made a *$(#load of money in a pro beach volleyball league.
Thanks for the reminder that the monetized sports world doesn't end at the US border. >.<
men's diving has some absolute jaw-droppers.
weightlifting is great if you're into bigger men.
i have a huge soft spot for distance runners, especially when they're dripping with sweat coming off a track.
but losing wrestling would be a devastating blow to the sex-appeal of the summer olympics.
The bigger issue is the IOC's self imposed restrictions on only '25' core sports. It is arbitrary, capricious and designed to screw over sports that don't 'play'.
but losing wrestling would be a devastating blow to the sex-appeal of the summer olympics.
And you people want to remove tennis! Anyone can get something out of watching a few minutes of Federer or Nadal or Tsonga.
Montreal
Lake Placid
Moscow
Los Angeles
Sarajevo
Soeul
Calgary
Barcelona
Albertville
Lillehammer
Atlanta
Nagano
Athens
Salt Lake City
Sydney
Turin
Beijing
Vancouver
London
Moscow
Rio
I'm not sure if I see a current trend in there that's all that different from past history.
EDIT: speaking of which, my local airport has a sale on for £13 flights to Barcelona from now until April. I hear it's a pretty cool place, anyone been and have some pointers?
Edit: Is there a narrow line between so many spikes being defendable and every spike being a point? I might totally watch a larger court version of badminton-volleybal, where the ball has a tail that makes it drop slower. More dramatic-looking saves?
I also want to put forward the notion that if anyone ever has to die in a terrorist attack in the future, I hope it's the executive board of the IOC who were working out a lucrative graft deal with Sepp Blatter.
Beach volleyball requires more mobility and a more all-around game. Indoor is a lot more specialized. Top-level women's generally has more rallies. Men's is much more difficult to play defense. Both nets probably need to be raised, although it would be more helpful in women's then men's (it would really be difficult to slow the men's game down).
Badminton is there because it is actually pretty damn popular in East Asia, especially China, and Indonesia, 2 countries with obviously very large populations. Furthermore, an Olympic gold is the pinnacle for individual play in badminton; the traditionally most important competitions in badminton, men and women, are the Thomas & Uber cup, which are both team competions. So it makes sense from that standpoint. It isn't a case of the top players not showing up, as in soccer or baseball. There is little chance of badminton getting kicked out, and little justification for kicking it out.
Field hockey used to be very popular India and Pakistan, less so now, due (partially) to misadministration by governning bodies. However, it probably has got enough of a globally diverse support, especially in western Europe, that it won't get kicked out.
Also, weightlifters are probably the most heavily tested group of athletes in any sport. And actually they aren't all that muscular. They cfan't be, given the nature of the weightclasses. Except for the superheavies, any additional non-functional muscle, any additional muscle that doesn't contribute to getting the weight overhead is a liability. For example, big biceps are a liability. Big pecs, also. Go look at for example some of the male Iranian lifters from the 85, 94, 105 kg classes, medalists at the Olympics, world championships. See for examle, Kianoush Rostami, 84 kgs, or Saeid Mohammadpoour Karkaragh, 94 kgs. On a side note, Saeid is one of my favourite lifters: on stage, he has the demeanour of a serious little kid. They look no more muscular than the typical non-endurance athlete. Certainly no more muscular than the typical elite sprinter (which isn't that surprising: nowadays elite sprinters often do some of the same exercises than weightliters do)
Men's soccer, is aside from modern pentathlon, the sport that most needs to be kicked out, given that baseball is already out. Not only do the best players not show up, the existing structure, under 23 with 3 overaged players, is not used in soccer at all,. Outside of the Olympics, and Olympic qualifying, there is no under 23 competition in soccer. That is an age group that isn't used at all. And this is deliberate, by FIFA. FIFA doesn't want the Olympic soccer competition to ever challenge any of its own competitions for popularity.
Which is great if you go for that, though: when they were younger, my "bear" softball team were almost universally crushed out on Eric Heiden.
i like watching women's beach volleyball for the obvious shallow reasons, and i enjoyed some of the women's indoor, and then i happened to catch the men to give them a fair shake of my viewing time and was frankly shocked to see how awesome they were as athletes.
2018 is in Korea.
I have been many times, my favorite city in Europe; IM me if you want advice at length, though it would help to know what sort of pointers you are looking for.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main