Baseball Primer Newsblog
— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand
Friday, July 29, 2011
Pos, Bonds and the transfixed rate of Bob Costas.
My friend Bob Costas left a message for me yesterday. It was a very nice message—Bob is a great guy—but he also had a slight disagreement. Bob and I are very often on the same page when it comes to baseball, but he was reading a small essay I wrote in the magazine this week and he noticed this line:
”(Barry) Bonds and (Roger) Clemens are two of the best who ever played the game. If not for the steroid noise that surrounds them, you could make a viable argument that they are simply the two best ever.”
I should say that my thinking, when I wrote the line, was simply that if you took their numbers and performances at face value, you could make the viable argument that they are the two best ever. Bob, though, read it differently. He thought that I was actually saying without steroids Bonds and Clemens are two of the best ever, perhaps even THE two best ever. This did not bother him so much for Clemens, but it did bother him for for Bonds. He strongly disagrees.
We’ve had similar discussions before, and if I could summarize his thought, I think it goes something like this (and I am reworking this a little bit to get Bob’s opinion more precisely): Barry Bonds in 1998 was a great player. Truly great. But there was no argument to make for him as the best ever. In Bob’s words: He certainly wasn’t Ruth; he didn’t hit like Williams or Musial; as great an all-around player as he was he was not Mays and his career did not have the totality of Aaron. Bob thinks Bonds of 1998 could certainly be in the discussion as one of the 10 or 12 best non-pitchers of all time. But there was no argument for him as the very best. And there is no argument that can be made for him as the very best NOW either without steroids.
for his generous support.
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
: [OTP-May] Politico: Congressional baseball game, May 1, 1926
(4266 - 12:38am, May 24)Last:
: Mariners sending Jesus Montero to Triple-A
(64 - 12:35am, May 24)
: Mets’ Ike Davis On Struggles: ‘I Can’t Do Any Worse’
(24 - 12:28am, May 24)
: OT: NBA Monthly Thread - May 2013
(1216 - 12:12am, May 24)Last:
: Demystifying Red Sox Ownership - What Do They Do? (WEEI)
(27 - 12:06am, May 24)
Last: KT's Pot ArbNewsblog
: OMNICHATTER for MAY 23, 2013
(77 - 11:10pm, May 23)
Last: Los Angeles El Hombre of AnaheimNewsblog
: ESPN: Forging bond with Pete Rose has helped fuel Joey Votto's desire to be great
(127 - 11:03pm, May 23)Last:
Everybody Loves Tyrus RaymondNewsblog
: OT: The Soccer Thread, May 2013
(1123 - 10:55pm, May 23)Last:
: Richie Ashburn’s Widow in Tears Over His Endangered Gladwyne Grave
(2 - 10:09pm, May 23)
: Astros vendor brings snow cones into bathroom stall, gets fired
(21 - 10:03pm, May 23)
Last: Sunday silenceNewsblog
: Leyland breaks his own rule, lets Verlander get win after delay
(26 - 9:01pm, May 23)
Last: the Hugh Jorgan returnsNewsblog
: Daugherty: Brandon Phillips has been Reds' MVP so far
(18 - 8:14pm, May 23)
: Mitchell: Pedroia, Cano and Magical Thinking
(23 - 8:03pm, May 23)
Last: Robert in Manhattan BeachHall of Merit
: 2014 Hall of Merit Ballot Discussion
(86 - 8:02pm, May 23)
Last: Ivan Grushenko of Hong KongNewsblog
: FanGraphs: Cameron: The 2013 Cubs: Better Than We Think
(17 - 7:42pm, May 23)
Last: What did Billy Ripken have against Elroy Face?