“Piazza! Piazza!” Little RICO Act.
Barry Bonds in recent years has been a heated debate. Should he or shouldn’t he get in the HOF? And if the answer is yes, should Barry be a first ballot HOF? C’mon man! This guy was unbelievable, PED’s or whatever! There is one thing you need to ask yourself, “Is Barry Bonds and his performance on the field during his career worthy of HOF entry? As my son would say (he’s 8 years old), “Duh!” ‘Nuff said. Barry is simply one of the best to ever play this great game. No maybe, no but what about the help he might have gotten, and no, well, lets put him in but make him wait. I see clearly now, the powers that be are playing HOF God? C’mon man! If Barry is not an automatic, in any era, no matter what help he might have gotten, Hall of Fame baseball player, than I’m done with this Cooperstown thing.
Listen, Mike Piazza, best known probably for his monster seasons in New York as a Metropolitan, is a HOF baseball player. He is either in the hall or not in the Hall. It’s a no-brainer for this MLB alumnus. The political aspects involved with the HOF are exactly what are wrong with its processes. People, powerful baseball people, decide official entry on what criteria? Is it statistics? Is it championships? Is it longevity and strong character and personal make-up?
...There are no levels in the Hall, no, no and no. There are no gold-stamped first ballot HOF players either, no, no and no. It’s a simply yes he is, or no he is not!
...Last thing, when people mention that Keith Hernandez is one of the best all-time 1B, ever, doesn’t that mean he is a HOF caliber baseball player? I think so. And the same exact argument can be made for “Donnie Baseball” (Mattingly). Hall of Fame baseball players are easily sighted and easily identified. C’mon man!
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. Non-Youkilidian Geometry Posted: July 29, 2011 at 11:47 AM (#3888118)As Rorschach said in "Watchmen" when tricked into a police trap, "STUPID, stupid, stupid! You're so stupid!"
Can we count on that as a promise? Will you sign The Pledge?
You THINK so? C'mon man! Either he's a HOF or not!
Today's headline was brought to you by the Tautology Club.
Rico, as a reward for that splendid analysis and argument, I will now make you qualified for the Hall of Fame:
Rico Brogna is one of the best all-time 1B, ever.
There. I mentioned it. I hope you'll do the same for me in your induction speech.
It's easy to laugh, but I wish more HOF voters understood this fairly simple point.
Ah, but the operative word was 'people'. One isn't enough... unless you have multiple personality disorder.
It's easy to laugh, but I wish more HOF voters understood this fairly simple point.
Ain't that the truth.
Clearly the function of the headline is to mollify any constructive matematician* reading the article.
*) Except a hypothetical ultrafinitist that can't count to 200.
P ? ¬P
If that is not a tautology, nothing is.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main