Baseball Primer Newsblog— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand
Friday, August 10, 2018
This is a fascinating piece, breaking down Baez’s swing rates by pitch type, and the (mostly favorable) results.
You may be surprised to learn that the article only underscores Baez’s uniqueness.
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. Master of the Horse Posted: August 10, 2018 at 05:13 PM (#5724893)That said, to quote the article, "It still feels like Baez’s approach should be somehow exploitable."
While I too would like more than 1 NLCS MVP awards, 1 seems to indicate his approach has been fine.
In 2015, he had 5 big PA in round 1 and went 1 for 10 in round 2. Still, overall he was 5 for 15 with 1 HR, 2 SBs and 4 Ks.
In 2016, he was excellent in the first two rounds, winning (sharing?) NLCS MVP then stunk in the WS. Still, overall 18 for 68 with 4 doubles, 2 HR, 8 RBI, 2 BB and, gulp, 21 Ks, mostly in the WS. Overall that was a BA of 267 and SLG of 411, nothing to be embarrassed about.
In 2017, he was just terrible at 2 for 26 across two rounds, with 11 Ks. The bright side is both hits were HRs.
So he's had 4 terrible series and 2+ outstanding ones with one MVP. If they gave out LVPs, he'd probably have gotten it for the 2017 NLDS at 0 for 14 and 2 GDPs.
This just in, Javy Baez is a highly variable player. That postseason performance is fairly reminiscent (but better by rate stats so far) of the one of his most obvious offensive comp Alfonso Soriano. He had big series in 2001 ALCS and 2003 ALDS and absolute stinkers in 2002 ALDS, 2003 ALCS and both appearances for the Cubs.
Well, sort of. His slash line before this year is seriously pulled down by his 214 AB in 2014 at the age of 21. That year he was 169/227/324. And it’s not really just using selective endpoints since that year the Cubs did not make the playoffs and since then, they have.
This is my favorite Javy video clip
Soriano hit 32 HR at age 36, and 34 at age 37, with OPS+ above his career average both years. He wasn't worth 18 million a year because he had no value on defense, but I wouldn't say he aged badly, all things considered.
Player Year SLG OBP PA
Javier Baez 2018 .578 .328 452
Juan Gonzalez 1995 .594 .324 374
Matt Williams 1994 .607 .319 483
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 8/12/2018.
Sure (although that total is suppressed by a bad partial season in his last year, from '08 to '13 it was 5.8 WAR in 812 games, which is... still not great). But he was 32 in 2008. To pick a player who had similar capabilities at his peak and also a similar name (and shares Baez's multi-positional deployment), Edgardo Alfonzo was out of the league after his age 32 season.
Back to Soriano and cherry-picking, from ages 34-37, he had 5.7 WAR, -1.7 WAA in 2300 PA. That's not bad. Moreover, it was defense pushing him below average as it was 7.7 oWAR. I think we can all agree that if Javy is a poor LF by his early 30s then his long-term projection is not promising.
They're hard to comp directly because Soriano didn't get to play until 25 but in that year he had -1.3 dWAR on his way to -10.3 for his career. Javy is at 0.9 this year already, following 1.1 last year and 2.0 the year before and 4.1 career. Soriano is not a defensive comp for Javy. Barring a significant injury or adding 30 pounds some offseason, there's no reason to think Javy won't be at least an average defensive 2B/3B in his early 30s.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main