Baseball for the Thinking Fan

Login | Register | Feedback

You are here > Home > Baseball Newsstand > Baseball Primer Newsblog > Discussion
Baseball Primer Newsblog
— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand

Sunday, November 04, 2012

The 25 Best – and Five Worst – Free Agent Values | FanGraphs Baseball

Another look at the free agent class. This one from’s David Cameron.

The goal here isn’t to provide the best value in terms of $/WAR, but to identify — at least, in my view — which contracts are likely to have the biggest magnitude of effect on a team’s chances of winning going forward. And, on the flip side, the contracts that could do the most harm to a team’s ability to contend over the life of the deal.

Here’s his top five:

1. Nick Swisher, OF: 4 years, $56 million
2. B.J. Upton, OF: 4 years, $52 million
3. Anibal Sanchez, SP: 4 years, $52 million
4. Zack Greinke, SP: 6 years, $114 million
5. Angel Pagan, OF – 3 years, $30 million

Jim Furtado Posted: November 04, 2012 at 09:07 AM | 8 comment(s) Login to Bookmark
  Tags: free agency

Reader Comments and Retorts

Go to end of page

Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.

   1. Dan Posted: November 04, 2012 at 11:29 AM (#4292574)
Greinke and Pagan are the only 2 of those 5 that seem believable. I guess those are the crowd sourced contract figures, but I don't think anyone doubts Swisher is a good deal at that price. Problem is that price is not happening for him.
   2. Infinite Yost (Voxter) Posted: November 04, 2012 at 11:29 AM (#4292576)
I don't agree with Cameron often, but he is spot on about DiceK -- statistically, and emotionally. The most excruciating pitcher in baseball.
   3. Danny Posted: November 04, 2012 at 01:51 PM (#4292654)
I'd be surprised if McCarthy gets 2/$20M. I don't think he'd get that much without the brain injury.
   4. bookbook Posted: November 04, 2012 at 02:11 PM (#4292663)
Yeah. The crowd sourcing experiment is interesting, but it probably needs a smart modifier of some sort. It does pretty well at the low end, but guesses low on the longer contracts to the top ten or so available talents.
   5. jmurph Posted: November 04, 2012 at 02:13 PM (#4292666)
3. Anibal Sanchez, SP: 4 years, $52 million

I have to think about 22 teams would take that deal, maybe more. Seems low and maybe even too short.
   6. Walt Davis Posted: November 04, 2012 at 03:50 PM (#4292733)
AT those prices, I'd probably put Sanchez #1 and maybe Pagan #2. Upton's at a fair price bug given how many bargains there were in that crowdsourced list, I'd move him further down on this one.

Napoli on the "no way" list doesn't make a lot of sense to me. OK, 3/$36 for him is actually realistic so I suppose he can't be a bargain like the others. Cameron notes the jump in K-rate but overstates it -- it was 30% vs. 25% career while 2011 was flukishly low. He notes he's an old man skills type which is true but virtually every C is (except for the ones that just have low BAs with no walks or power). The question about Napoli is what do you think of his C defense and how many games do you need him to C and is it useful to stick him elsewhere in the lineup when not catching. That makes him a good sign for an AL team with another C they are happy to give 80 starts, using a rotating DH and a LHB starting 1B. 80 games of above-average C and 50 games of average 1B/DH is worth $12 M. He's been fragile so it could turn out to be a bad deal but it's not a slam dunk.

OK, maybe it's the nature of that list. There were virtually no demonstrably bad deals. In the original thread, somebody pointed out an obvious potential flaw in crowdsourcing something like this -- the question isn't "at what price would you sign X?" but "what price do you think X will get?" These values are probably pretty good for estimates of what these players will actually produce but it only takes 1 confused GM or 2 competing GMs to overprice somebody.
   7. Avoid running at all times.-S. Paige Posted: November 04, 2012 at 08:09 PM (#4292885)
In the original thread, somebody pointed out an obvious potential flaw in crowdsourcing something like this -- the question isn't "at what price would you sign X?" but "what price do you think X will get?"

If I had to guess (and it will probably prove untrue) at a theory for the kind of player who is likely to be overpaid, I would imagine a players' past prospect status plays a part. So I'm thinking someone like Upton is going to get a bigger contract than people expect because there is more of a likelihood of a GM or people in an organization being in love with his tools. Somone who has the career path of an Angel Pagan, I think, someone who has sort of settled into being a nice player after not being a big prospect, is more likely not to be overpaid.
   8. Walt Davis Posted: November 04, 2012 at 09:08 PM (#4292925)
I would imagine a players' past prospect status plays a part.

No idea if it's true (that they get more) but it makes sense for the reason you state and related stuff like he's probably the sort of player that some hitting coach somewhere thinks he can fix. (Dwayne Murphy would probably have him hitting 35 bombs within a year.) I certainly expect him to do much better than Pagan (3/$30 is probably about right although somebody could go all GMjr about him) and Victorino. I have no idea what to think about Bourn, I think I'm still stunned he turned out this good. Same with Pagan really -- seemed a decent enough 4th OF when he was with the Cubs but no more. Which is the pro-Upton argument in reverse.

You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.



<< Back to main

BBTF Partner

Support BBTF


Thanks to
greenback changed his travels
for his generous support.


You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.

Hot Topics

NewsblogThe Blue Jays Should Rebuild | FanGraphs Baseball
(45 - 5:41pm, Oct 22)
Last: Walt Davis

Gonfalon CubsNLCS Game 6 Chatter
(3 - 5:38pm, Oct 22)
Last: Andere Richtingen

NewsblogOTP 2016 Oct 17: Politics, Sports, and the 'League of Legends' World Championship
(1953 - 5:35pm, Oct 22)
Last: Guy Heckler's Veto

NewsblogBeating Clayton Kershaw is Cubs' biggest barrier to 1st pennant since 1945 - Chicago Tribune
(10 - 5:17pm, Oct 22)
Last: Moses Taylor, Unwavering Optimist

Sox TherapyThe Post Mortem Begins - A Look at the Infield
(19 - 5:03pm, Oct 22)
Last: Nasty Nate

NewsblogOT: NBA 2016-17 Preseason Thread
(225 - 5:01pm, Oct 22)
Last: tshipman

Gonfalon CubsThe Long Wait
(117 - 4:57pm, Oct 22)
Last: Kiko Sakata

NewsblogThe Oral History of Baseball on 'Seinfeld' | Complex
(71 - 4:52pm, Oct 22)
Last: Random Transaction Generator

Newsblogred sox - Inside story of David Ortiz's injury: 'He was essentially playing on stumps' - WEEI | Rob Bradford
(27 - 4:32pm, Oct 22)
Last: Golfing Great Mitch Cumstein

NewsblogA well-rested Kenley Jansen makes Cubs’ task more daunting | New York Post
(2 - 3:38pm, Oct 22)
Last: The Yankee Clapper

NewsblogESPN: Stark: Why super teams don't win the World Series
(1 - 3:25pm, Oct 22)
Last: Mark Armour

Sox TherapyThe Post Mortem Concludes - Not Players
(3 - 3:00pm, Oct 22)
Last: Jose Remains The Most Absurd Thing on the Site

Sox TherapyThe Post Mortem Continues - Outfield, Catcher and DH
(9 - 2:51pm, Oct 22)
Last: Dan

NewsblogCharlie Sheen Responds to Indians Fans Demanding he Throw the First Pitch at the World Series
(58 - 2:42pm, Oct 22)
Last: What did Billy Ripken have against ElRoy Face?

NewsblogWhat we learned: The Dodgers can't hit Jon Lester
(28 - 1:49pm, Oct 22)
Last: Jose Remains The Most Absurd Thing on the Site

Page rendered in 0.1560 seconds
47 querie(s) executed