You’ll have to click through the article to see who topped his chart. FYI, it wasn’t Speedy Gonzales. Although he certainly had the speed and the strike zone to be an effective leadoff hitter. I have not been able to find any video that suggests he ever took up the sport.
I’m mostly certain when I suggest that speed produces runs in three main ways: by means of defensive range, baserunning (both via the stolen base and other manner of advancement), and infield hits/drag bunts. In the case of the first two elements (range and baserunning), speed alone isn’t even responsible for the entirety of the skill. There are excellent defenders, for example, whose range is due not only to footspeed but also to making good reads on, and taking straight paths to, batted balls. Likewise, there are players with merely average speed who, nevertheless, are above-average baserunners due to excellent decision-making. For the sake of this post, however, both elements will be considered purely as expressions of footspeed.
...
Here’s what I found:
For defense, the average top-10 leader has saved 15 runs, or 1.5 wins, relative to league average over the last five seasons. For baserunning, a top-10 leader has been worth ca. 8.0 runs per season over the last five years.
So, broadly speaking, we can say that the upside for a player with elite speed — in terms of defense and baserunning — is something like 20-25 runs, or 2.0-2.5 wins.
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. AROM Posted: November 08, 2012 at 11:31 AM (#4297897)Plus the very threat of that makes the infielders play closer in, helping the speedy player get a few extra hits through the infield. Tough to quantify, though, even if you had good positioning data.
But no matter.
As the article sort of notes, the combo of top defender and top baserunner is maybe not as common as we might think. Certainly a lot of the game's great base-stealers were pretty average defenders -- Brock, Henderson, Raines, Coleman. Even Ichiro had only 3 seasons of 8+ runs of base-running (b-r) and only one season above 1 dWAR. Of course I guess Ichiro's infield hits are folded into Rbat so he adds speed value there but the article doesn't seem to separate that speed impact. So, for his career, Ichiro has added about 9 wins via his combo of baserunning and defense or less than one win per year. (I don't think he's including Rdp here ... if he is, Ichiro adds another 5 wins!).
The article's premise isn't really about trying to measure speed's impact, it's "OK, Billy Hamilton is essentially pure speed, can he stick in the majors." By the end he decides that, if he can match Bourn's roughly 2 wins a year by speed, then Hamilton only needs to hit like Brendan Ryan to be an average player. I've got my doubts about that but sure, it's theoretically possible.
What about avoiding double plays?
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main