Yankees - DFAed Karsay
New York Yankees - Designated P Steve Karsay for assignment; recalled IF Robinson Cano
This is the much-discussed Yankee Shakeup, but I don’t really think this will be really have much of an effect on the team. The Yankees bench Bernie Williams, who can no longer throw or run, replace his bat with Cano’s in the lineup and shift Womack from being a below-average 2B to a leftfielder that would need to hit .330 to be league-average. Matsui becomes the new centerfielder where he’ll probably be surprisingly decent.
Now, it’s great that Cano gets a shot, but he’s still very young and despite a terrific start to the year with the Clippers (333/368/574), I’d still be surprised if he did much better than 270/320/380 this season with the Yankees.
Karsay will have a lot of phone calls the day he clears waivers. He hasn’t been healthy since 2002, but from 1999-2002, he was one of the premier relievers in the game and the upside is high enough that a minimum wage Karsay is worth a gamble. There are a number of possible destinations, from more likely ports of call like Boston, Cleveland, or San Francisco to lesser possibilities like the Mets or Padres.
Dan Szymborski
Posted: May 03, 2005 at 02:18 PM |
35 comment(s)
Login to Bookmark
Related News:
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Griffin (Vlad) Posted: May 03, 2005 at 02:37 PM (#1306990)Then Leo Mazzone made Wright look good, and the Yankkes gave him $20+M for nothing.
I wonder who's next? Mike Hampton? Dan Kolb? Chris Reitsma? Send them all up, Leo.
Russ Ortiz for $33M. Oh wait, that was the Diamondbacks.
Ortiz is such a flea ridden goat skin bag. It serves Joe Jr. and his idiotic yes-men right that they got cleaned in that signing. Effing Joe Jr.
I imagine that with more use he would have been much more useful for us as a reliever or as trade fodder.
Perhaps the Yankees are regretting chosing not to sign Polanco to the extent that they are just pretending that they did. Robinson Cano will hereafter be playing the role of Chase Utley.
If not, forget I said anything, and start sewing up the QUANTRILL 49 Rox jersey...
What the ####?!?
Bernie should be breaking in a firstbase mitt.
Russ Ortiz for $33M. Oh wait, that was the Diamondbacks.
Ummm...Ortiz for the Braves performed no differently than Ortiz for the Giants. If anything, he was a little better in 2001-2002.
Also, Karsay's short stint in Atlanta was worse than his previous 2.5 seasons in Cleveland. Karsay returning to the Braves wouldn't surprise me.
Ortiz has pitched 195+ innings for 6 straight seasons. He's had an ERA+ of 104 or higher for 5 of those 6 seasons. Wright, Pavano, Benson, Odalis Perez, Lowe, even Clement, and lord knows Milton (11 HR in 33 IP currently) don't have track records that good. And it's not like those guys are much younger (except Perez).
Now the baseball side of my brain says Clement, Perez, probably Pavano, maybe Benson before Ortiz. If I had DePo's super-secret evaluation algorithm, maybe it would convince me of Lowe. But mainly the baseball side of my brain says "thank god I wasn't desparate for pitching this offseason".
1-Regrets misreading the market on Leiber
2-He's not sold on Womack being the LF
3-Karsay's name was the first one on everyboy's mind...when it came to dropping someone.
4-The Bernie Williams move was tough to do...but his game dictated it.
1 - re: Lieber - he at least has recognized a mistake's been made, even though nothing can be done about it now.
2 - re: Womack - again with the mistake recognition, also it's a good sign that someone else will be in LF by midseason.
3 - re: Hearsay - of course he was, for the past 18 mos. Steve's been like Bigfoot, occassionally sighted but never documented. Easily the worst of what's been a lousy bunch.
4 - re: Bernie - it's sad to watch your favorites struggle, and one problem with the recent editions of the Yankees has been excess sentimentality to those that have been here a while, said another way - they've been dancing with the one that brung'em, even though some hotter younger debutaunts. It's time to look for new partners on the dance card.
# 25: 1) everyone misread the market on pitchers
2) Higginson in LF; or Preston Wilson in CF.
3) Nothing like being the $20m bum
4) Too late, too late for love
Well for one thing the Yankees don't get stuck carrying 12 Pitchers anymore. Well at least until Strutze comes back. It is really ridiculous that they couldn't figure this out duringin spring training.
Womack in LF sure beets Bernie in CF. I hate to say it as Bernie is one of my favorite players but he is done as a defensive OF. I don't know if his bat is strong enough to do a Mantle 67 at 1st.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main