The Best Shape of His Life
Those spring puff pieces about the right fielder who added ten pounds of muscle and the fourth starter who trained harder than ever and is experimenting with a new grip on his slider, they’re a running joke in baseball. But I love ‘em. There are two reasons – first is that spring training is when fans are supposed to start imagining what could happen if Ryan Sweeney finally developed the power scouts projected or if Dan Bard made a seamless transition to starting. Puff pieces and optimism are called for in spring.
Second, and more importantly, you know who isn’t in the best shape of his life? Carl Crawford. John Lackey. When a guy is in the best shape of his life, that means he’s not injured, and he’s not out of shape. Injuries will kill even a very good club, and when you hear that a player is in the best shape of his life, what you learn from that is that he isn’t injured and he’s in shape to play baseball. Even if you don’t want to succumb to the joys of unfettered spring optimism, note that you didn’t know with any confidence before reading the article that this player was healthy and in shape to play, and now you do. That’s good news.
Two days ago, Pete Abraham reported that Clay Buccholz showed up for camp in the best shape of his life. (And attired like an aspiring Tough Enough contestant.) Does that mean Buccholz is going to throw 200 innings and finally realize the strikeout numbers that observers of his stuff have always projected for him? First, yes, of course it means that. Second, ok, whatever, but it does mean that Clay Buccholz’s back is not currently injured. That’s good news. I didn’t know that before I read the article.
The Sox don’t have the depth in the rotation to handle significant injuries to their top starters, so it’s particularly important that Buccholz, Lester, and Beckett (who showed up the same day as the truck and is reportedly in good shape and throwing easy) are collectively in the best shape of their lives, or at least not injured, here in February.
Matt Clement of Alexandria
Posted: February 17, 2012 at 10:18 AM |
37 comment(s)
Login to Bookmark
Related News:
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. Matt Clement of Alexandria Posted: February 17, 2012 at 10:21 AM (#4063222)uhh, part of the running joke is that we get pretty much no information from the 'best shape of his career' puff pieces. E.G., You can find lots of such stories about Matsuzaka last year, and he was 7 starts away from Tommy John surgery.
I do share the spring optimism, though. I already have a bunch of tickets, and may get some more tomorrow because I "won" the opportunity to by Monster seats (although I would be getting Monster standing room).
A player who is currently known to be injured is very different from a player who is currently not known to be injured. When we learn we can slot Clay Buccholz into the latter camp, we gain information and we learn good news.
It's true that saying he's "not injured" is overstating our knowledge, but I think "pretty much no information" is wrong, too. Last spring, JD Drew showed up dogged by multiple injuries and never got it together. There was nothing about him being in the best shape of his life, because he was always currently known to be injured.
right, but he was injured before that, so if all those "best shape..." articles indicated that he wasn't injured, it was bad info.
Be careful with what you write. Darren will say you're a jinx!
Hence the admittedly fraudulent reports...or are they? Darren will be responsible for deciding if it's a jinx...or a reverse jinx!
That's good. I can actually see a scenario where CFBPS gets depressed and puts out numbers that are far too low - say even lower than the previous track record of a player, which would be a ridiculous projection.
You are wise. From you I could learn much.
Link
All that said, he was one of the 25. Another one down. Who will be the last man standing, I wonder? Arroyo, I suppose...
Yikes! Not being a Sox fan, that one isn't ingrained in my brain, but that's a crazy one.
What's wacky to me is that that postseason doesn't seem like THAT long ago, yet it's coming up on eight years. What the hell is happening here?
Also, MCoA, nice intro. Fun to read.
Mattbert, the jury's still out on you. Don't mess it up!
Well there's that. 12 days 'til Jose hits Ft. Myers. That Carl Crawford is not going to play while I'm there has to bode well for his season.
Wifebert gave it to me for Christmas. It is three deep in the To Read pile, but I might have to bump it up now that spring training is already upon us.
Bob McClure, it turns out, is very good with the media and Alex Speier (new best beat writer in town) has an awesome discussion with McClure covering the new pitchers and the starter conversions. Some highlights:Also, Silva looks great and so does Padilla.
RED SOX
Jose Iglesias SS
Che-Hsuan Lin RF
Ryan Lavarnway C
Josh Kroeger DH
Will Middlebrooks 3B
Lars Anderson 1B
Jason Repko CF
Oscar Tejeda 2B
Alex Hassan LF
Pitching: RHP Alfredo Aceves
More From PeteAbe; "In our unending quest to bring you coverage of today's crucial B game, we can report that the order of Red Sox pitchers will be Aceves, Bard, Mortensen, Carlson, Pena, Wilson, Britton, Inman and Thomas."
EDIT: So, apparently, this is a Josh Kroeger. Got to the high minors at 20, cuppa coffee at 21, and stuck in AAA for nearly a decade since. Weird career, appears to have peaked at 21.
From Pete Abraham at the Globe, on Bobby Valentine bringing new energy to Red Sox spring training:I think Abraham gets it right in the comparison to Francona. There wasn't anything wrong with Tito's approach, but after seven years of low-key, Valentine's new energy and added focus on skills, instruction, and training is a good thing. Valentine's approach should have an expiration date, as well, but I expect it to pay dividends in the short- and hopefully medium-term.
Also, apparently Padilla threw his semi-ephus in his first outing yesterday. He's in midseason form, obviously.
This hasn't gotten nearly enough play in discussion here. The last few seasons the Red Sox really did half ass spring training, and came out of the gate slow each time. Last year was the worst of those, and while the September collapse overshadows it, if the Red Sox hadn't spent the first 2 weeks of the season doing stuff they should've gotten done in spring training, the lead would've been even bigger by September anyway. The 2011 Red Sox spent their first 2 weeks of the regular season looking so rusty and unprepared to play baseball that they might as well have skipped ST entirely.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main