User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
Page rendered in 0.5471 seconds
41 querie(s) executed
|
You are here > Home > Hall of Merit > Discussion
| ||||||||
Hall of Merit — A Look at Baseball's All-Time Best Monday, January 22, 20071993 Results: The Mighty Triumvirate of Rose, Carlton and Jackson Are the Newest Hall of Meriters!In his second year of eligibility, hit king Pete Rose narrowly nabbed the top spot for HoM induction with a very strong 92% of all possible points, 28 points higher than his heavily boycotted innaugural candidacy. In his first year of eligibility, legendary southpaw hurler Steve Carlton was the second man elected with also a healthy 92% of all possible points. Last but not least, prolific home run hitter Reggie Jackson won the third spot for induction this “year” with an impressive 90% of all possible points. Famed knuckleballer Phil Niekro earned 82% of all possible points (the greatest percentage of any fourth-place finisher) and appears to be the #1 candidate for induction in ‘94. Rounding out the top-ten were: Quincey Trouppe, Nellie Fox, Jimmy Wynn, Edd Roush, Charlie Keller, and Rollie Fingers. RK LY Player PTS Bal 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 3 Pete Rose 1152 52 31 5 6 9 1 2 n/e Steve Carlton 1147 52 8 17 21 6 3 n/e Reggie Jackson 1120 52 12 17 10 13 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4 n/e Phil Niekro 1026 52 1 12 15 20 2 1 1 5 8 Quincy Trouppe 272 24 4 2 3 1 1 2 3 2 2 1 3 6 5 Nellie Fox 270 22 1 2 2 4 2 3 2 3 1 1 1 7 6 Jimmy Wynn 265 25 1 2 4 2 4 3 3 2 4 8 9 Edd Roush 262 22 1 1 4 4 1 1 4 1 1 3 1 9 7 Charlie Keller 261 21 1 3 4 2 3 2 1 1 2 2 10 10 Rollie Fingers 234 20 1 3 1 4 3 1 1 2 4 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11 12 Cannonball Dick Redding 228 20 3 2 3 3 3 2 2 2 12 4 Pete Browning 223 19 4 4 1 2 2 4 1 1 13 11 Jake Beckley 213 17 1 3 2 1 4 1 1 2 1 1 14 16 Bob Johnson 203 18 2 4 2 1 1 6 1 1 15 14 Bucky Walters 186 16 1 1 3 2 2 1 1 2 3 16 15 Tony Perez 179 14 3 3 1 3 1 1 2 17 17 Hugh Duffy 172 14 1 3 2 4 1 1 1 1 18 13 Charley Jones 168 13 4 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 19 18 Gavvy Cravath 157 16 1 1 3 2 2 4 3 20 19 Alejandro Oms 143 15 1 1 3 1 1 3 3 2 21T 23 Roger Bresnahan 128 11 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 21T 22 George Van Haltren 128 11 3 3 1 2 1 1 23 21 Tommy Leach 125 12 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 24 20 Burleigh Grimes 120 10 2 1 2 1 3 1 25 24 Rusty Staub 114 10 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 26 26 Luis Tiant 101 11 1 1 1 5 1 2 27 25 Orlando Cepeda 97 9 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 28 31 Norm Cash 92 9 1 1 2 1 2 2 29 32 Lou Brock 91 9 2 1 2 2 2 30 33T Ken Singleton 85 9 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 31 28 Dizzy Dean 85 8 2 1 1 1 2 1 32 29 Bobby Bonds 79 7 3 1 2 1 33 30 Larry Doyle 77 6 2 1 2 1 34 37 Tommy Bridges 75 7 1 2 1 3 35 33T Bob Elliott 67 7 1 1 1 3 1 36 40 John McGraw 66 5 3 1 1 37 27 Mickey Welch 64 6 2 1 1 1 1 38 39 Elston Howard 61 7 1 2 1 1 1 1 39 42 Phil Rizzuto 60 5 1 1 1 1 1 40 50 Sal Bando 56 6 1 4 1 41T 46 Carl Mays 56 5 1 1 2 1 41T 35 Vic Willis 56 5 1 1 1 1 1 43 41 Ben Taylor 53 5 1 1 2 1 44 43 Vern Stephens 52 6 1 1 1 1 2 45 49 Wally Schang 45 4 1 1 1 1 46 38 Reggie Smith 42 4 1 1 1 1 47 47T Thurman Munson 40 5 1 1 3 48T 36 Pie Traynor 39 4 1 1 1 1 48T 51 Ed Williamson 39 4 1 1 1 1 50 45 Addie Joss 37 3 1 1 1 51 n/e Ron Cey 33 4 1 1 2 52 47T Bill Monroe 33 3 1 2 53 56T Jimmy Ryan 30 3 1 1 1 54 54 Ed Cicotte 28 2 1 1 55 61T Jim Kaat 27 2 1 1 56 53 Dave Bancroft 26 3 1 1 1 57 61T Fred Dunlap 26 2 1 1 58 52 Frank Howard 24 3 1 1 1 59T 58T Frank Chance 23 2 1 1 59T 63 Tony Oliva 23 2 1 1 61 44 Chuck Klein 22 2 1 1 62T 64 Lefty Gomez 21 2 1 1 62T 67T Urban Shocker 21 2 1 1 62T 67T Dizzy Trout 21 2 1 1 65 65T Ernie Lombardi 20 2 1 1 66T 65T Luis Aparicio 19 2 1 1 66T 56T Al Rosen 19 2 1 1 66T 60 Gene Tenace 19 2 1 1 69 55 Rabbit Maranville 18 2 1 1 70 71 Don Newcombe 16 2 1 1 71 72 Jack Quinn 15 1 1 72 58T Sam Rice 14 2 1 1 73 78T Wilbur Cooper 13 1 1 74T 69T George J. Burns 12 2 2 74T 76T Bus Clarkson 12 2 2 76T 73T Fielder Jones 12 1 1 76T 73T Sam Leever 12 1 1 76T 78T Tony Mullane 12 1 1 79T 73T Artie Wilson 11 1 1 79T 78T Tony Lazzeri 11 1 1 81T 85T Tommy Bond 10 1 1 81T 82T Dutch Leonard 10 1 1 81T 81 Cecil Travis 10 1 1 84 n/e Steve Garvey 9 1 1 85T 84 Kiki Cuyler 7 1 1 85T 69T Bobby Veach 7 1 1 85T 87T Mickey Vernon 7 1 1 Dropped Out: George Foster(92), Jim Fregosi(91), Hack Wilson(82T), George Kell(87T), Herman Long(85T), Bill Mazeroski(87T), Al Oliver(76T), Virgil Trucks(87T). Ballots Cast: 52
John (You Can Call Me Grandma) Murphy
Posted: January 22, 2007 at 09:10 PM | 39 comment(s)
Login to Bookmark
Related News: |
BookmarksYou must be logged in to view your Bookmarks. Hot TopicsMock Hall of Fame 2024 Contemporary Baseball Ballot - Managers, Executives and Umpires
(16 - 5:52pm, Nov 28) Last: reech Most Meritorious Player: 2023 Ballot (12 - 5:45pm, Nov 28) Last: kcgard2 2024 Hall of Merit Ballot Discussion (169 - 1:15pm, Nov 26) Last: kcgard2 Most Meritorious Player: 2023 Discussion (14 - 5:22pm, Nov 16) Last: Bleed the Freak Reranking First Basemen: Results (55 - 11:31pm, Nov 07) Last: Chris Cobb Mock Hall of Fame Discussion Thread: Contemporary Baseball - Managers, Executives and Umpires 2023 (15 - 8:23pm, Oct 30) Last: Srul Itza Reranking Pitchers 1893-1923: Results (7 - 9:28am, Oct 17) Last: Chris Cobb Ranking the Hall of Merit Pitchers (1893-1923) - Discussion (68 - 1:25pm, Oct 14) Last: DL from MN Reranking Pitchers 1893-1923: Ballot (13 - 2:22pm, Oct 12) Last: DL from MN Reranking Pitchers 1893-1923: Discussion (39 - 10:42am, Oct 12) Last: Guapo Reranking Shortstops: Results (7 - 8:15am, Sep 30) Last: kcgard2 Reranking First Basemen: Ballot (18 - 10:13am, Sep 11) Last: DL from MN Reranking First Basemen: Discussion Thread (111 - 5:08pm, Sep 01) Last: Chris Cobb Hall of Merit Book Club (15 - 6:04pm, Aug 10) Last: progrockfan Battle of the Uber-Stat Systems (Win Shares vs. WARP)! (381 - 1:13pm, Jul 14) Last: Chris Cobb Syndicate |
|||||||
|
About Baseball Think Factory | Write for Us | Copyright © 1996-2021 Baseball Think Factory
User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
|
| | ||||||
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. John (You Can Call Me Grandma) Murphy Posted: January 23, 2007 at 01:03 AM (#2284875)Browning took a big nosedive.
HOF-not-HOM through 1993
1 Aparicio, Luis
2. Bancroft, Dave
3. Beckley, Jake
4 Bender, Chief
5 Bottomley, Jim
6 Bresnahan, Roger
7 Brock, Lou
8 Chance, Frank
9 Chesbro, Jack
10 Combs, Earle
11 Cuyler, Kiki
12 Dandridge, Ray
13 Dean, Dizzy
14 Duffy, Hugh
15 Evers, Johnny
16 Ferrell, Rick
17 Fingers, Rollie
18 Gomez, Lefty
19 Grimes, Burleigh
20 Hafey, Chick
21 Haines, Jesse
22 Hooper, Harry
23 Hoyt, Waite
24 Hunter, Catfish
25 Jackson, Travis
26 Johnson, Judy
27 Joss, Addie
28 Kell, George
29 Kelly, George
30 Klein, Chuck
31 Lazzeri, Tony
32 Lindstrom, Freddie
33 Lombardi, Ernie
34 Manush, Heinie
35 Maranville, Rabbit
36 Marquard, Rube
37 McCarthy, Tommy
38 McGraw, John
39 Pennock, Herb
40 Rice, Sam
41 Roush, Edd
42 Schalk, Ray
43 Schoendienst, Red
44 Tinker, Joe
45 Traynor, Pie
46 Waner, Lloyd
47 Welch, Mickey
48 Wilson, Hack
49 Youngs, Ross
HOM-not-HOF
1 Allen, Dick
2 Ashburn, Richie
3 Barnes, Ross
4 Beckwith, John
5 Bennett, Charlie
6 Boyer, Ken
7 Brown, Ray
8 Brown, Willard
9 Bunning, Jim
10 Carlton, Steve**
11 Caruthers, Bob
12 Childs, Cupid
13 Dahlen, Bill
14 Davis, George
15 Doby, Larry
16 Ferrell, Wes
17 Foster, Willie
18 Freehan, Bill
19 Glasscock, Jack
20 Gordon, Joe
21 Gore, George
22 Grant, Frank
23 Grich, Bobby
24 Groh, Heinie
25 Hack, Stan
26 Hill, Pete
27 Hines, Paul
28 Jackson, Joe*
29 Johnson, Home Run
30 Mackey. Biz
31 Magee, Sherry
32 McPhee, Bid
33 McVey, Cal
34 Méndez, José
35 Minoso, Minnie
36 Moore, Dobie
37 Pearce, Dickey
38 Pierce, Billy
39 Pike, Lip
40 Richardson, Hardy
41 Rogan, Bullet Joe
42 Rose, Pete*
43 Santo, Ron
44 Santop, Louis
45 Sheckard, Jimmy
46 Start, Joe
47 Stearnes, Turkey
48 Stovey, Harry
49 Suttles, Mule
50 Sutton, Ezra
51 Torre, Joe
52 Torriente, Cristobal
53 Wells, Willie
54 White, Deacon
55 Williams, Smokey Joe
56 Wilson, Jud
* not eligible for the HOF
**not eligible until 1994
The gap from 4 to 5 must be an all-time record gap within the backlog.
Carl Goetz: 18
Howie Menckel: 17
James Newburg16
Mark Shirk: 16
Andrew M: 15 (he did vote for Niekro, after all)
Chris Cobb: 15
Rusty Priske: 14
andrew siegel: 14
Mike Webber: 14
Devin McCullen: 14
Esteban Rivera: 14
...
John Murphy: 13
...
Jim Sp: 11
Jeff M: 11 (medians
...
OCF: 10
...
Adam Schafer: 8
EricC: 8
Joe Dimino: 8
Michael Bass: 8
Mark Donelson: 8
KJOK: 7
rico vanian: 7
jimd: 7
karlmagnus: -3
(With yest not around karlmagnus gets to be out there all by himself. Note also the "dropped out" status of Hack Wilson and George Kell - they'll be back.)
TOP 25, ALL-TIME
BECKLEY.... 24318
VAN HALTREN 24007.5
DUFFY...... 23442.5
BROWNING... 20870.5
Childs..... 18484
Griffith... 17924
Waddell.... 17596
Jennings... 16976
WELCH...... 16320
Sisler..... 13892
REDDING.... 13630
Pike....... 13399
CJONES..... 13245
Sewell..... 12769
Mendez..... 12555
Thompson... 12349
BRESNAHAN.. 12223
TLEACH..... 12216
RYAN....... 12151.5
Bennett.... 11503
Moore...... 10904
Rixey...... 10789
Caruthers.. 10704
ROUSH...... 10598
Beckwith.... 9896
OTHERS IN THE TOP 25 ACTIVE
(Cravath 8139, Doyle 7942, Walters 7305, Grimes 7250, Monroe 6707, Trouppe 6635, Fox 6140, Schang 5744, Williamson 5612, Oms 5537, McGraw 5426, BJohnson 5299, Keller 5241, Willis 3960)
not quite
Joss 3845, Wynn 3455, Dean 3414, Elliott 3382
not quite
(Joss 3808, Elliott 3325, Dean 3329, Wynn 3190)
Catcher
5. Trouppe
21. Bresnahan
38. Howard
45. Schang
47. Munson
I can't prove that Trouppe is too high, just as his supporters can't prove that he's not. I like Howard and Munson myself, but other than the speculative nature of Trouppe's record and Schang's lack of peak, they're all pretty interchangeable.
Second Base
6. Fox
33. Doyle
Is that all there is? Is that all there is? A glove and a bat, a bat and a glove. Obviously we prefer the glove. I like them both about equally.
Shortstop
39. Rizzuto
44. Stephens
Is that all there...never mind. I guess we've elected everybody. Again, a glove and a bat, and a slight preference for the glove. I'm OK with that, Rizzuto is #15-20 just off my ballot these days.
Third Base
23. Leach--half CF
35. Elliott
36. McGraw
40. Bando
48T. Traynor and Williamson
And Cey just off at 51. Nice group, obviously we haven't elected enough 3Bs for the pool to remain this good. But we're all over the board. I personally like Williamson as the best combo of glove and bat. I don't give a rip how long he played in total, his prime was just as long as everybody else's.
Hard to believe that at these 4 positions Trouppe and Fox are the only guys who are really in the running. Given our shortage of 3Bs, one of them ought to be top 10 as well. Of course, if anybody decides to change their ballot because of the assertion, they're still not going to go to Williamson. Leach would not be the worst HoMer, not would any of these guys. Does Graig Nettles really slot in at the head of this group? I dunno. Maybe.
Rose (1): a majority
Carlton (1): OCF, rawagman, Howie Menckel, DanG, jhwinfrey, Esteban Rivera, jimd, Jeff M
Jackson (1): a dozen
Niekro (1): Got Melky
Trouppe (5): Eric Chalek, Juan V, Carl G, Chris Cobb
Fox (4): rico vanian
Wynn (5): Devin McCullen
Roush (4): sunnyday2
Keller (4): dan b
Fingers (4): Adam Schafer
Redding (5): ronw, Al Peterson, Ken Fischer,
Browning (5): Sean Gilman, Estaban Rivera, Max Parkinson
Beckley (2): karlmagnus (but you knew that already)
Johnson (5): DL from MN, Jim Sp
Walters (5): jimd
Perez (5): AJM, Thane of Bagarth, DanG
Duffy (5): rawagman
C. Jones (5): Rick A, Jeff M, favre
Cravath (5): Joe Dimino
Oms (6): Juan V
Van Haltren (6): DanG, Rob Wood, Ken Fischer
Bresnahan (5): John Murphy
Leach (7): Al Peterson, Sean Gilman
Grimes (5): jhwinfrey, SWW
Staub (6): Thane of Bagarth
Tiant (6): DL from MN
Cepeda (6): jhwinfrey
Cash (6): Al Peterson
Brock (5): Daryn
Dean (5): Mark Donelson, dan b
Singleton (6): Brent
Bonds (8): Brent, Al Peterson
Doyle (5): OCF, David Foss
Bridges (8): andrew siegel
Elliott (6): Michael Bass
McGraw (6): David Foss, TomH
Welch (7): Daryn, Ken Fischer
E. Howard (10): Mark Donelson
Rizzuto (5): Brent
Willis (7): Rick A
Mays (8): Ken Fischer
Bando (7): ronw
Taylor (6): rawagman
Stephens (9): Ken Fischer
Schang (5): EricC
Smith (10): Al Peterson
Munson (8): Got Melky
Traynor (8): rico vanian
Williamson (7): Mark Donelson
Joss (5): karlmagnus
Monroe (6): Devin McCullen
Cey (11): Juan V
Ryan (8): Juan V
Cicotte (6): karlmagnus
Kaat (7): jimd
Bancroft (9): Chris Cobb
Dunlap (5): Michael Bass
F. Howard (12): Got Melky
Chance (9): TomH
Oliva (6): Tom D
Klein (6): rico vanian
Gomez (8): rawagman
Shocker (8): Joe Dimino
Trout (9): AJM
Lombardi (10): karlmagnus
Rosen (11): Mark Donelson
Tenace (8): KJOK
Aparicio (9): rico vanian
Maranville (10): Michael Bass
Newcombe (12): Chris Fluit
Quinn (6 and only): Joe Dimino
Rice (13): rico vanian
Wi. Cooper (8 and only): Eric Chalek
Burns (15): Andrew M, Max Parkinson
Leever (9 and only): karlmagnus
F. Jones (9 and only): jimd
Mullane (9 and only): Al Peterson
Clarkson (15): Chris Cobb, Devin McCullen
A. Wilson (10 and only): Jeff M [H. Wilson's friend was boycotting]
Lazzeri (10 and only): Juan V
Travis (11 and only): Adam Schafer
Leonard (11 and only): Patrick W
Bond (11 and only): sunnyday2
Garvey (12 and only): jhwinfrey
Veach (14 and only): rawagman
Cuyler (14 and only): Jeff M
Vernon (14 and only): EricC
Howie Menckel: 17
...
jimd: 7
karlmagnus: -3
With yest taking a walk, I'm 2nd to karlmagnus.
OTOH, another way of looking at it is, I'm halfway between karlmagnus and Howie.
Interesting.
First Base
13. Beckley--who?
16. Perez--not exactly a no-brainer but I don't think this is terribly over-rating the guy
27. Cepeda
28. Cash
43. Ben Taylor
Perez, Cepeda and Cash are certainly interchangeable enough. We'll have to see whether Doggie can maintain this edge on Cepeda and Cash.
Left Field
9. Keller
14. Bob Johnson
18. Charley Jones
29. Brock
Frank Howard not too far back. Nice to know we're not complete slaves to convention.
Right Field
19. Cravath
25. Staub
30. Singleton
32. Bonds
Oliva and Klein next. Nice to know we're not complete slaves to convention.
So Keller, Beckley and Bob Johnson are the top backlog hitters? I guess we have elected everybody.
7. J. Wynn
8. Roush
12. Browning
17. Duffy
20. Oms
21. Van Haltren
23. Leach
46. R. Smith
Ryan is close. I remember when we used to call it the CF glut. Well, the glut hasn't changed, but I guess we have. I'm Edd's best friend, he might go in pretty soon but it obviously depends on who forgets to vote in any given week.
Pitchers
4. P. Niekro--I don't know if he's a shoo-in, or a shoe-in? What do you think?
10. Fingers
11. Redding
15. Walters--glad to see we're not slaves to convention
24. Grimes
26. Tiant--Red Sox bias?
31. Dean--here I added him to my ballot and he fell from 28th to 31st, go figure
34. Bridges
37. Welch
41. Mays
42. Willis--under-rated
50. Joss--double under-rated
See-kaat and Kitty-kaat are close, Don Newcombe is not. I'm good with Niekro, Rollie and Cannonball. Hard to believe the next 3 guys, or maybe the next 8. Are we still short of pitchers?
The 1993 election also tied for the least number of players getting 20% support, only nine. This happened once before, in 1989. The most players getting 20% was 19, in 1920 and 1938.
Trouppe, Fox, Wynn, Roush and Keller are in a dead heat in the race for the next backlog HoMer, perhaps as soon as 1995, definitely by 1996.
What I actually HOPE someone can post is a "voter A is best friend of voter B" table. Who am I most like? Whose ballot is really far from mine? Which ones of us are mimicked by the most other voters? Do we have "circles" of voters, groups of 3 to 6 who are alike, sort of like the "Similarity Scores" on BB-ref?
Niekro is the only one listed on at least half the ballots. (surpassing the record by one, iirc)
There was a clear gap between Cravath and Oms, demarcating what I would happily have called the viable backlog, 16 players, Rose to Cravath. The gap closed a little, so it is no longer easy to by happy; call it 17 players, Niekro to Oms.
P G B : Pitcher, "Glove", "Bat" per Marc sunnyday; "Glove"={C, 3B, SS, 2B}
------
4 2 11; all viable
------
1 1 1 ; Negro Leagues & Latin America
3 1 10; MLB
------
0 0 4 ; mlb 19th century
0 0 2 ; mlb 1900s-20s
1 1 2 ; mlb 1930s-50s
2 0 2 ; mlb 1960s-date
Arms
Bats--1B, LF, RF, (DH)
Gloves--C, 2B, SS
Hybrids--It started with CF. It seemed unfair that they should have to hit like cornermen but they don't have the defensive value of SSs or Cs either. And then I added 3B (yesterday and today). It didn't seem fair that they should have to hit like a 1B but it also seemed unfair that a SS should have to hit like a 3B, while at the same time on defense 1B < 3B < SS. Now I suppose I should have Larry Doyle in this group and Ed Williamson among the gloves, maybe Traynor? That will have to await another iteration.
He's jumped all over the top 15 foe the last few elections. I think it's just the nature of where his support lies. A lot of high-ballot and low-ballot support means his totals fluctuate wildly depending on how many new "no-brainer" candidates show up in a given year.
I expect the backlog rankings in general to be extremely volatile over the rest of the project.
deadball (pre 1920) in italics, time in NgLg in bold
-C Simmons Bresnahan/Munson
SS -----------------
2B ------------ Monroe
3B McGraw -------- Elliot
1B Beckley Chance
OF ---- VanHltrn Wynn
OF - Johnson Keller
-P - Walters - Tiant/Sutton
-P Niekro Redding
-P ---------- Fingers/Grimes
P G B : Pitcher "Glove"={C, 3B, SS, 2B} "Bat"
7 6 6 ; all
1 1 0 ; Negro Leagues & Latin America
6 5 6 ; MLB
------
0 1 1 ; mlb 19th century
0 1 2 ; mlb 1900s-20s
2 1 2 ; mlb 1930s-50s
4 2 1 ; mlb 1960s-date
self-analysis: I am far less bat-heavy than most. I do seem to have a lot of bats in my 20-30 range.
People let me tell you 'bout my best friend,
He's a tough-as-nails backstop who dominated his era...
:-)
Thanks, OCF!
I pulled the guys out of the list who the HOF will eventually elect through the 2007 BBWAA vote (how do I know they will elect them? Because I have "the gift") and also removed Jackson and Rose. Then I assigned the 33 leftover HOM-not-HOFers each a decade.
We have elected:
-1 1860s guy they won't elect
-7 1870s guys they won't elect
-6 1880s guys they won't elect
-3 1890s guys they won't elect
-2 1900s guys they won't elect
-1 1910s guy they won't elect
-2 1920s guys they won't elect
-2 1930s guys they won't elect
-1 1940s guy they won't elect
-2 1950s guys they won't elect
-5 1960s guys they won't elect
-1 1970s guy they won't elect.
The reason I was thinking about this question was because I wondered if the closer-to-today decades would have a much higher rate of HOM election than HOF election compared to other decades. I'm wondering this due to the sheer volume of potentially strong not-HOF candidates who will appear on the ballot soon who have gotten some talking here and there on our site:
-Simmons (1970s)
-Nettles (1970s)
-Jim Rice (1970s)
-Dw Evans (1970s)
-Rick Reuschel (1970s)
-Dave Concepcion (1970s)
-Blyleven (1970s)
-Gossage (1970s/1980s)
-Trammell (1980s)
-Whitaker (1980s)
-Lance Parrish (1980s)
-Dawson (1980s)
-Lee Smith (1980s)
-Stieb (1980s)
-Da Evans (1980s)
-Keith Hernandez (1980s)
-Willie Randolph (1980s)
-Dale Murphy (1980s)
-Jack Clark (1980s)
Gotta think some group of them is going in. It's possible that if enough of them go, that the 1960-1990 era will be a serious point of differentiation between HOM and HOF.
Incidentally, you've done a great job, Eric, of identifying the borderline groups for the 1980s! What criteria did you use to pull together this list of players? Or did you just do it off the cuff? I'd add Buddy Bell, I think (who is almost a dead ringer for Graig Netltles), and Charlie Hough (not that he will appeal much to peak voters) into the mix, but this is an impressive list.
-Simmons (1970s)
-Blyleven (1970s)
-Gossage (1970s/1980s)
and
-Trammell (1980s)
-Whitaker (1980s)
-Da Evans (1980s)
As for the rest, I don't have a strong sense about any one guy, and many of them could draw enough splinter support to be electable in a backlog year. Personally I like Parrish, Stieb, Hernandez, and maybe Nettles in that group, but that's not a guarantee of anything at all. ; )
Also if Ken Singleton or Bobby Bonds should pick up any further support, that could shift another guy into the 1970s. Oh, and Wynn's almost-assured election will tack one more onto the 1960s. Amazing that we're one or two off of the HOF for them long period between 1890-1950, then suddenly twice that for several decades.
Actually it was predictable, which I did.
At the HoM’s inception, it wasn’t difficult to see that there were three main groups that we were going to be electing many guys from that the HOF had missed: 19th century stars, Negro leaguers (which the HOF largely cleaned up last year), and Expansion era stars (1960’s to 1990’s).
Why has the HOF missed so many recent greats? First of all, they haven’t had time yet to “finish” those decades. Their “first pass” on an era takes about forty years. When the VC reformed in 2001, they had only just begun voting in 1960’s stars (Bunning, Cepeda and Mazeroski). Santo was due for eligibility in 2002. Another factor is the low offensive levels in the 1963-76 era made it hard for the voters to discern who was a great hitter.
So the HoM must again point the way to the HOF, to identify the many overlooked greats of the Expansion era.
Of course neither has a very godo chance of getting in, but just sayin'.
HoMers in bold
all HoFers with significant playing careers are included
1936
Ty Cobb, Babe Ruth, Honus Wagner, Christy Mathewson, Walter Johnson
1937
Nap Lajoie, Tris Speaker, Cy Young , Connie Mack, John McGraw, George Wright
1938
Pete Alexander
1939
George Sisler , Eddie Collins , Willie Keeler , Lou Gehrig, Cap Anson , Charlie Comiskey , Candy Cummings , Buck Ewing , Charles Radbourn , Al Spalding
1942
Rogers Hornsby
1945
Roger Bresnahan , Dan Brouthers , Fred Clarke , Jimmy Collins , Ed Delahanty , Hugh Duffy , Hughie Jennings , King Kelly , Jim O’Rourke , Wilbert Robinson
1946
Jesse Burkett , Frank Chance , Jack Chesbro , Johnny Evers , , Clark Griffith, , Tommy McCarthy , Joe McGinnity , Eddie Plank , Joe Tinker , Rube Waddell , Ed Walsh
1947
Carl Hubbell , Frankie Frisch , Mickey Cochrane , Lefty Grove
1948
Herb Pennock , Pie Traynor
1949
Charlie Gehringer , Mordecai Brown , Kid Nichols
1951
Mel Ott , Jimmie Foxx
1952
Harry Heilmann , Paul Waner
1953
Al Simmons , Dizzy Dean , Chief Bender , Bobby Wallace , Harry Wright
1954
Rabbit Maranville , Bill Dickey , Bill Terry
1955
Joe DiMaggio , Ted Lyons , Dazzy Vance , Gabby Hartnett , Frank Baker , Ray Schalk
1956
Hank Greenberg , Joe Cronin
1957
Sam Crawford
1959
Zack Wheat
1961
Max Carey , Billy Hamilton
1962
Bob Feller , Jackie Robinson , Bill McKechnie , Edd Roush
1963
John Clarkson , Elmer Flick , Sam Rice , Eppa Rixey
1964
Luke Appling , Red Faber , Burleigh Grimes , Miller Huggins , Tim Keefe , Heinie Manush , Monte Ward
1965
Pud Galvin
1966
Ted Williams , Casey Stengel
1967
Red Ruffing , Lloyd Waner
1968
Joe Medwick , Kiki Cuyler , Goose Goslin
1969
Stan Musial, Roy Campanella , Stan Coveleski , , Waite Hoyt,
1970
Lou Boudreau , Earle Combs , Jesse Haines,
1971
Dave Bancroft , Jake Beckley , Chick Hafey , Harry Hooper , Joe Kelley , Rube Marquard , Satchel Paige
1972
Sandy Koufax , Yogi Berra ,Early Wynn, Lefty Gomez , Ross Youngs , Josh Gibson , Buck Leonard
1973
Warren Spahn , George Kelly , Mickey Welch , Monte Irvin , Roberto Clemente
1974
Mickey Mantle , Whitey Ford , Jim Bottomley , Sam Thompson , Cool Papa Bell
1975
Ralph Kiner , Earl Averill , Bucky Harris , Billy Herman , Judy Johnson
1976
Robin Roberts, Bob Lemon , Roger Connor , Freddy Lindstrom , Oscar Charleston
1977
Ernie Banks ,Amos Rusie , Joe Sewell , Al Lopez , Martin Dihigo , Pop Lloyd
1978
Eddie Mathews, Addie Joss
1979
Willie Mays , Hack Wilson
1980
Al Kaline, Duke Snider, Chuck Klein
1981
Bob Gibson, Johnny Mize , Rube Foster
1982
Hank Aaron, Frank Robinson, Travis Jackson
1983
Brooks Robinson, Juan Marichal, George Kell
1984
Luis Aparicio, Harmon Killebrew, Don Drysdale, Rick Ferrell , Pee Wee Reese
1985
Hoyt Wilhelm, Lou Brock, Enos Slaughter , Arky Vaughan
1986
Willie McCovey, Bobby Doerr, Ernie Lombardi
1987
Billy Williams, Catfish Hunter, Ray Dandridge
1988
Willie Stargell
1989
Johnny Bench, Carl Yastrzemski, Red Schoendienst
1990
Jim Palmer , Joe Morgan
1991
Rod Carew, Gaylord Perry, Fergie Jenkins , Tony Lazzeri
1992
Tom Seaver, Rollie Fingers, Hal Newhouser
1993
Reggie Jackson
1994
Steve Carlton, Leo Durocher , Phil Rizzuto
1995
Leon Day , Vic Willis , Richie Ashburn
1996
Jim Bunning, Bill Foster , Ned Hanlon
1997
Phil Niekro, Nellie Fox, Willie Wells
1998
George Davis , Larry Doby , Joe Rogan
1999
Orlando Cepeda, Joe Williams
2000
Tony Perez, Bid McPhee , Turkey Stearnes
2001
Bill Mazeroski , Hilton Smith
2006
Ray Brown, Willard Brown, Andy Cooper, Biz Mackey, Mule Suttles, Cristobal Torriente, Jud Wilson, Frank Grant, Pete Hill, Jose Mendez Louis Santop, Ben Taylor, Sol White
From looking at his stats he seemed to be a steady, capable catcher (and a less than spectacular hitter ) for many years.
I think you'll be surprised to see that Hernandez is indeed a superior candidate to Mattingly. Here's their best-to-worst WS, adjusted for strikes, and the third line is how much of a cumulative advantage Hernandez has season by season:
KH (320 total): 33 29 29 29 28 27 24 24 23 21 19 13 13 3 3 1 1
DM (271 total): 34 32 29 27 26 24 22 20 20 14 9 7 7 0
ad: -1 -4 -4 -2 0 3 5 9 12 19 29 35 41 44 47 48 49
At three years Mattinly has a modest peak advantage, at five years it's all gone, at ten years the advantage is widened to almost a full year's worth of WS, by 15 years it's a pretty wide gap. Overall, Hernandez isn't a lot better, but he's better.
Here's their WARP1s while I'm at it
KH (110.1): 11.6 10.8 10.7 9.7 9.5 9.1 7.8 7.4 6.7 6.5 5.5 5.2 4.3 2.6 1.4 0.9 0.3 -0.1
DM (76.2) : 11.7 10.6 9.3 8.3 6.5 5.9 5.6 4.9 3.9 3.7 2.9 1.6 1.2 0.1
ad: -.1 .1 1.5 2.9 5.9 9.1 11.3 13.8 16.6 19.4 22.0 25.6 28.7 31.2 32.6 33.5 33.8 33.7
This is a much bigger gap than the one described by WS, and, in fact, WARP sees the gap as developing much more quickly (as soon as the third season), with Hernandez having the superior peak at any interval other than 1 year.
By WS
KH (320 total): 33 29 29 29 28 27 24 24 23 21 19 13 13 3 3 1 1DM (271 total): 34 32 29 27 26 24 22 20 20 14 9 7 7 0
ad: -1 -4 -4 -2 0 3 5 9 12 19 29 35 41 44 47 48 49
By WARP1
KH (110.1): 11.6 10.8 10.7 9.7 9.5 9.1 7.8 7.4 6.7 6.5 5.5 5.2 4.3 2.6 1.4 0.9 0.3 -0.1DM (76.2) : 11.7 10.6 9.3 8.3 6.5 5.9 5.6 4.9 3.9 3.7 2.9 1.6 1.2 0.1
ad: -.1 .1 1.5 2.9 5.9 9.1 11.3 13.8 16.6 19.4 22.0 25.6 28.7 31.2 32.6 33.5 33.8 33.7
WILBERT ROBINSON
"UNCLE ROBBIE"
STAR CATCHER FOR THE FAMOUS
BALTIMORE ORIOLES ON PENNANT CLUBS
OF 1894, '95 AND '96. HE LATER WON FAME
AS MANAGER OF THE BROOKLYN DODGERS
FROM 1914 THROUGH 1931. SET A RECORD OF
7 HITS IN 7 TIMES AT BAT IN SINGLE GAME.
KH (129): 152 148 143 142 141 131 130 127 127 126 120 120 108DM (127): 161 156 156 146 133 128 118 113 108 107 103 97 81
Here we see more of the expected peak/prime dichotomy, yet again, by year five, Hernandez has caught up, and he puts distance between from then on. Hernandez loses four seasons to the PA requirement, Mattinly one.
And by eqa (warp1 version), > 200+ outs (since they list that instead, same group of seasons)
KH (.301): .326 .321 .320 .320 .315 .305 .304 .301 .298 .294 .293 .287 .280DM (.290): .328 .320 .318 .307 .294 .291 .284 .281 .268 .267 .265 .257 .236
Yowza.
So several different stats and systems all show either that Hernandez is out-and-out superior, or that he's a little bit superior, but none really shows Mattinly as having a major advantage, even in the peak department.
Now is not the time to pull out all the details (that can wait until he's eligible), but I have Hernandez closely comparable in offensive value to Terry and Cepeda. Thow in his considerable defensive value, and I'd say he has a case.
Does anyone know if Uncle Robbie (Wilbert Robinson), elected in 1945, was elected as a player, as a manager or both? From looking at his stats he seemed to be a steady, capable catcher (and a less than spectacular hitter ) for many years.
For about two decades, inductees were not classified by baseball role, only sometimes as old-timers of one sort or another. It's obvious that Fred Clarke would have been elected as a player, Connie Mack as a manager, and Charles Comiskey as an executive, had election in one role or another been required. But that wasn't required, so it isn't correct to say any of them was elected "as a [role]". At least for Clark Griffith, Hugh Jennings, and Frank Chance, it's possible that broad consideration was crucial to their election.
Bob Richardson of SABR, dedicated after-work reader of newspapers on microfilm at Boston Public Library, uses Wilbert Robinson for example. He has told me that people make the "mistake" of thinking Uncle Robbie was elected because writers thought he and the Dodgers were lovable losers (ie elected as a manager), but Robinson was also greatly respected as a long-serving catcher on a great and famous team, when it was still the norm for two men to split the catcher position.
--
Amazing that we're one or two off of the HOF for them long period between 1890-1950, then suddenly twice that for several decades.
[Dan Greenia]
Actually it was predictable, which I did.
Don't mind me but I predicted it too.
For about fifty years, when Dan G or Marc S would observe that justice demands Cooperstown induct recent players at the same rate as Golden Agers (Heinie Groh and Stan Hack aside!), I would ask why the standard of justice should be ~1910-1960 rather than ~1860-1910. Why shouldn't a middle infielder be as prominent in his time as Bid McPhee and George Davis were in the 80s/90s and 90s/00s? In the outfield, Paul Hines and George Gore, Jimmy Sheckard and Sherry Magee don't make the cut. Why should we treat the gardeners of ~1960-2010 like Manush, Klein and Wilson of the 20s/30s? [Note, I don't say like giant Ross Youngs and cardinal Chick Hafey. They are probably among the mistakes, even in a big hall, whom DanG would except from comparison.]
So of course HOM-not-HOF will be full of pre-1910 and post-1960 (and Negro Leaguers from the middle period).
And HOF-not-HOM should be full of whites from 1910-1960.
Give me some slack and let me put Magee and Tinker, Cepeda and Pierce each on the side of the line that clarifies my picture instead of muddying it!
I never quite argued for the same rate. Still, I’ve never fully explained what exactly I had in mind.
I don't say like giant Ross Youngs and cardinal Chick Hafey. They are probably among the mistakes, even in a big hall, whom DanG would except from comparison
Likewise Manush and Wilson!
For the past couple years I’ve played around with a system showing how many players should be in the hall of fame for every year 1876-1991. This, in order to compare it to how many HOFers from MLB were playing at least semi-regularly in each year. The number that “should be” enshrined for each year increases throughout baseball history, quickly reaching 24 by 1889, then gradually leveling off to 38 for each year after 1981.
Without getting into the specifics of the system, we see a spike in the actual number of HOFers in the decade 1925-1934, an average of 48.2 HOFers per season. The high is 51 players in 1933. The “expected” number of HOFers for that period is 33.6, so there are about 15 HOFers per year who should not be enshrined.
Looking at the period it’s easy to identify who those 15 guys are (alphabetically): Bottomley, Combs, Cuyler, Hafey, Haines, Hoyt, Jackson, Kelly, Lazzeri, Lindstrom, Manush, Pennock, Rice, Waner, and Wilson.
Looking at HoM results, we see 15 players of earlier vintage who ought to be enshrined instead. Setting aside the "pioneers" from pre-NL (Pearce, Start, Pike, McVey and Barnes) you get (chronologically): White, Sutton, Hines, Richardson, Gore, Stovey, Bennett, Glasscock, Caruthers, Childs, Dahlen, Sheckard, Magee, Jackson, and Groh.
The system is still under development, so these may change. But for the 1960’s, there are 33.1 HOFers per year, versus 36.3 per year that should be there. So far the HoM has added Torre, Freehan, Allen, Santo and Boyer. If you knock off Mazeroski, Aparicio and maybe Cepeda as mistakes, the HoM agrees pretty well with the system.
For the 1970’s there are 31.4 HOFers per year, versus 37 per year that should be there. If the BBWAA elects Gossage they’ll still be five players short for the decade, even shorter if you set aside Hunter and maybe Brock.
I like being able to check last year's results while the new vote is unfolding.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main