Baseball for the Thinking Fan

Login | Register | Feedback

btf_logo
You are here > Home > Baseball Newsstand > Discussion
Baseball Primer Newsblog
— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand

Thursday, February 07, 2019

Babe Ruth is the Greatest Player Ever?—?But He’s Far From the Best

Yet another list to argue about.

“Johnson threw 346 innings in 1913, using soft baseballs the color of John McGraw’s teeth…”

gehrig97 Posted: February 07, 2019 at 04:18 PM | 8 comment(s) Login to Bookmark
  Tags: a-rod, babe ruth, mickey mantle, mike trout, rickey henderson, willie mays

Reader Comments and Retorts

Go to end of page

Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.

   1. Space Force fan Posted: February 07, 2019 at 07:54 PM (#5813507)
I don't know why I ever read these kinds of articles. They're just clickbait. They basically all have the same problem in that they never define their terms or provide criteria for making their rankings. So it just ends up as a guy pulling a list out of their ass and thinking it means something.

At a minimum, you need to identify if you are taking Babe Ruth as is with a time machine or assuming Babe Ruth grew up in this era with all the training and coaching available today.
   2. gehrig97 Posted: February 07, 2019 at 08:40 PM (#5813520)
The article decouples player skill from advances in technology and strategy.
   3. bbmck Posted: February 07, 2019 at 11:00 PM (#5813554)
"Bill James, who has thought more about how to quantify and contextualize player performance than the next best two people combined"
Nice insult to Pete Palmer and/or Allan Roth.

Walter Johnson's 15 pitching WAR in 1913 is the 7th highest, his 16.4 WAR is the sixth highest.

Stephen Jay Gould used BA to evaluating hitting because he has no idea of the basics of the game. He would have written that .500 OBP or 1.250 OPS would never happen again in his 1996 book and of course been incorrect. Just because he used an utterly meaningless stat it's still factually correct but the greatest hitting peak in MLB history came after he wrote a book explaining that outliers wouldn't occur in the future. Gould writes about the right tail and standard deviation shrinking which should also apply to a statistic which is actually relevant to baseball performance but Gould couldn't grasp the incredibly complex concept of a Walk or HR since he only possessed a PhD from Columbia.

"integration was a seismic change"
No, it was very gradual, non-whites continued to represent a very small portion of the players, a merger with a Negro league would have been seismic, 10% non-white 10 years after integration. Typical career length accounted for vastly more turnover than integration.

"Ruth, of course, is by any rational measure the greatest player to ever step on a field.", "Ruth occupied a place in the popular imagination never again reached by an American athlete."
I pick Jackie Robinson as greatest, please explain how this isn't a rational position. Far more has been written about Jackie than someone whose largest contribution outside of baseball is providing the financing for No, No, Nanette.

"With a career OPS+ of 179, Gehrig was roughly 79% more productive than a league-average hitter. Pujols, over the course of his career, has been about 52% better than an average hitter."
Just not at all correct.

"You’ll notice only four players place among in the top-10 on both lists: Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, Barry Bonds, and Mickey Mantle."
I noticed that Babe Ruth is Top 10 on both lists.
   4. AndrewJ Posted: February 08, 2019 at 08:28 AM (#5813591)
Far more has been written about Jackie than someone whose largest contribution outside of baseball is providing the financing for No, No, Nanette.

Urban legend. Frazee used the money from the Ruth sale to finance a stage play, which, several years later, was turned into the musical "No, No, Nanette"...
   5. SandyRiver Posted: February 08, 2019 at 12:46 PM (#5813722)
"Ruth, of course, is by any rational measure the greatest player to ever step on a field.", "Ruth occupied a place in the popular imagination never again reached by an American athlete."
I pick Jackie Robinson as greatest, please explain how this isn't a rational position. Far more has been written about Jackie than someone whose largest contribution outside of baseball is providing the financing for No, No, Nanette.

IMO, a rational case could be made for both, depending on how one defines "greatest." However, there's an apples/oranges factor to consider. As I see it, Ruth brought about the greatest change in how MLB was played, while Robinson (and Rickey) brought about the greatest change in who played in MLB. Greatest effect on the nation's social fabric? Jackie. Greatest effect on the manner in which one particular sport was played? The Babe.
   6. Morty Causa Posted: February 08, 2019 at 12:57 PM (#5813726)
Ruth gave more value relative to his time and place than any other player did in their time and place. Plus he encapsulated and was the epitome of a revolution in the game and how it was played.
   7. ERROR---Jolly Old St. Nick Posted: February 08, 2019 at 01:08 PM (#5813729)
IMO, a rational case could be made for both, depending on how one defines "greatest." However, there's an apples/oranges factor to consider. As I see it, Ruth brought about the greatest change in how MLB was played, while Robinson (and Rickey) brought about the greatest change in who played in MLB. Greatest effect on the nation's social fabric? Jackie. Greatest effect on the manner in which one particular sport was played? The Babe.

This. You can consider yourself my Spokesman for this thread.
   8. Jack Sommers Posted: February 08, 2019 at 06:01 PM (#5813831)
If anyone ever puts me in a time machine I'm taking stat cast equipment with me.

You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.

 

 

<< Back to main

BBTF Partner

Dynasty League Baseball

Support BBTF

donate

Thanks to
Francis
for his generous support.

You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.

Hot Topics

NewsblogFINAL REGULAR SEASON OMNICHATTER! for September 27 thru Game 162!
(65 - 10:46pm, Sep 28)
Last: cardsfanboy

NewsblogNBA 2021 Playoffs+ thread
(4667 - 10:35pm, Sep 28)
Last: Your favorite TFTIO, me!

NewsblogNew York Mets Embark on Branding Effort to Build Cred and Win Young Fans
(25 - 9:29pm, Sep 28)
Last: reech

NewsblogThe Cardinals’ Impressive Winning Streak Doesn’t Guarantee October Success
(18 - 8:03pm, Sep 28)
Last: The Yankee Clapper

NewsblogEmpty Stadium Sports Will Be Really Weird
(14218 - 7:29pm, Sep 28)
Last: Never Give an Inge (Dave)

NewsblogThe Giants Capitalize on the First Pitch
(4 - 7:16pm, Sep 28)
Last: Ron J

NewsblogOT Soccer Thread - Transfer! Kits! Other Stuff!
(322 - 6:08pm, Sep 28)
Last: bunyon

NewsblogShohei Ohtani, on future with Los Angeles Angels: 'I want to win'
(28 - 5:34pm, Sep 28)
Last: John Northey

NewsblogArizona Diamondbacks give manager Torey Lovullo one-year extension despite 104-loss season
(12 - 5:33pm, Sep 28)
Last: Jack Sommers

NewsblogBrother HRs off brother for first time since '75
(15 - 5:28pm, Sep 28)
Last: Walt Davis

NewsblogBaseball’s Wall Street-Style Executives Get Titles to Match
(1 - 4:37pm, Sep 28)
Last: winnipegwhip

NewsblogTB progressing with Montreal Sister City plan
(55 - 2:38pm, Sep 28)
Last: Jay Seaver

NewsblogWhy Detroit Tigers, Chicago White Sox stormed the field: 'It wasn't intentional'
(9 - 1:28pm, Sep 28)
Last: zenstudent

NewsblogYus Your Illusion: Yusmeiro Petit and the Well-Hidden Power of Pitcher Deception
(1 - 12:59pm, Sep 28)
Last: CFBF's Results are Certified

Hall of Merit2022 Hall of Merit Ballot Discussion
(184 - 12:06pm, Sep 28)
Last: Dr. Chaleeko

Page rendered in 0.2503 seconds
48 querie(s) executed