Baseball Primer Newsblog— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand
Tuesday, March 21, 2023
MIAMI—Team Japan hoisted the 2023 World Baseball Classic trophy to celebrate its third tournament championship with a 3-2 victory over Team USA on Tuesday at loanDepot park.
...
In a matchup anticipated by many, Shohei Ohtani clinched the game by striking out Angels teammate Mike Trout in the ninth.
A deeply satisfying finish to a spectacular tournament.
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. Hombre BrotaniPitch 1: Slider low, 88 MPH
Pitch 2: Fastball swinging strike, 100 MPH
Pitch 3: Fastball outside, 100 MPH
Pitch 4: Fastball swinging strike, 100 MPH
Pitch 5: Fastball low, 102 MPH
Pitch 6: Slider swinging strike, 87 MPH
I'm gonna need some kleenex.
All around me
Better watch that man
See him "ball" in hand
No one seems to see
No one seems to see
Better watch that man
See him "ball" in hand
What you gonna do next
What you gonna do now
Use a Kleenex
What a game!!!!!!!!!!
Phenomenal tournament though. Great games, great atmosphere, it was so much fun.
A pity that it was Mike Trout who made that last out, but here's for Mike to have other opportunities to shine in the spotlight.
We have never seen anyone like Shohei Ohtani and may never again.
Now, that's slight hyperbole: He might throw harder than Cole, hit the ball just a tick softer than Judge, and StatCast has his avg sprint speed in the top quartile (though he ranks first among DH, and fifth from home-to-first--an amazing stat considering his size).
All of which is to say... well, I think Casey Stengel said it best when describing the gifts of a young Mickey Mantle: "The kid ain't logical."
Ohtani doesn't make sense. There is no way to really quantify what this man is doing. WAR doesn't do him justice; hell, calling him a "Unicorn" doesn't do him justice.
We're so damned fortunate to be here to see it.
Ohtani had the hardest-hit ball of the WBC, 118.7 mph. He tied for the longest homer, 448 feet, and fastest-thrown pitch, 102 mph. For good measure, when he beat out an infield single in the seventh, Statcast measured his speed as borderline elite.
Shohei Ohtani: 29.9 ft/sec sprint speed beating out his infield hit (borderline elite). He went home-to-1st in 4.16 seconds.
As a hitter, Ohtani batted 435/.606/.739 in the tournament, with four doubles, a home run and eight RBIs. As a pitcher, he produced a 1.86 ERA with 11 strikeouts in 9 2/3 innings. No one pulled an Aaron Judge and dared challenge him for MVP.
A guy on the Japanese team described Ohtani facing Trout to end the game as something out of a comic book, which sounds about right.
So he's one of the Horsemen of the Apocalypse then.
I love Ohtani so much. If he joins another team next year, I may have to stop watching baseball. I couldn't take that level of heartbreak.
So I will head the other direction and declare Ohtani the Messiah. Or the Second Coming depending on your preferred irrationality.
Once again, Mike Trout’s quest for victory has been squashed by his Angels teammates.
You might be a redneck.
I seem to remember a time when people questioned whether a player from Japan would be "physically" capable of competing with American athletes. The argument being that since on average they were smaller, that even their elite athletes must be lesser, especially when you add population to the mix. And then we got Ichiro and the argument became "that type of player might thrive, but we'll never have a Bonds type of player or even a Koufax pitcher"... ignoring the fact that the best pitcher in the world at the time was probably Pedro.
The globalization of this sport has brought in so much, and it's funny to see some of the thought process about foreign players being so incorrect, and then seeing the same arguments being made when it comes to female athletes... it only takes one to change things.
i also hate how when scouting reports/prospect reports are done, they always compare player X to a player of the same ethnic/racial persuasion. what, a White person can't be compared to Juan Pierre because, WHY??????? a Black player can't be compared to hee sop choi because, WHY??? (they do kind of run into a leeeeetle trouble with Native american players - joba compared to, um, like chief bender? cmon)
i personally love that non-asian american kidz of every other persuasion want to be shohei ohtani. one small step in the fight against the stupid "every race should stick to its own kind" garbage
A problem with Ichiro as an archetype is that he was (pretty much) unique among Japanese players as well. I have read that, when he was young, Japanese baseball coaches tried to get Ichiro to change his style, convinced he could not make it in NPB either. Given nobody has succeeded with Ichiro's apprach since maybe the 1930s, it really doesn't seem a viable way to succeed at baseball.
As to size ... it was certainly true that historically, Japanese men were significantly smaller than "Western" men on average. (The average Japanese soldier in WW2 was 5-3 apparently.) Any genuine concerns on that largely disappeared as Japan/Korea moernized and should have gone out the window with Hideki (listed at 6-2, 210) and Choi (6-5, 235) if not earlier. Ohtani is listed at 6-4, 210 and I hope nobody still clings to the idea that a 6-4 guy of Japanese descent can't develop into as powerful a hitter as a 6-4 "American." But it is still true that, on average, East Asian men are shorter.
From about 1950 to about 1990, the average height of a Japanese male age 17 increased by about 10 cm (4 inches) where it has remained (and I see a recent report suggesting it is declining). American men also seemed to have gained a couple of inches (a quick search didn't turn up a detailed table). This discusses a study of country-level height changes over the last century -- S Korean women apparently have gained 8 inches. East Asian countries were among the biggest growers but they are still on average shorter than Europe/US. Presumably the changes are due to improvements in nutrition and childhood health.
And so yes, with its more global reach, possibly average MLB size would increase (by selecting the biggest/fastest from everywhere). Countering that is the declining birthrates (very, very low in Korea and Japan, even now barely above "replacement" in DR) and the expansion to 30 teams.
ugh. that's so wrong, but not every parent is born to be a revolutionary.
I'm a lot older than you, and I remember one my my many uncles - he'd have been born around 1915 or so - used to tell stories that while he was a natural left-hander, the nuns would smack his hands with a ruler to force him to do everything right-handed (The word "sinister" comes from a Latin word meaning “on the left side.” And since I am left-handed myself, I felt special resonance in his stories).
I'm 6-feet tall, and so was my father (born in 1918). All my life, I never grasped how tall he was for his era until, when he was age 90, I got him to visit a B-17 plane - like the ones he had flown in as a bombardier for 35 perilous missions over Germany 63 to 64 years earlier.
Many of the roles of the plane crew were "gunners" on various parts of the plane. I was absolutely shocked at how little room there was to fit a human being. Sure, obesity was not really a thing back then, but also for height - there was zero chance my Dad could have fit in any of them, and he was 6-foot, 180 pounds for all of his adult life. Since he was color-blind, he couldn't be a pilot (as he wanted to be) or a co-pilot. so not many options left.
as for typical heights, I have been going into Manhattan for business and pleasure occasionally for 40 years.
it has taken me a small bit of effort not to be struck by how much "taller" I seem today compared to earlier days.
The Asian and Hispanic influx of newer residents and tourists reflects that, of course.
If I'm on a line for a bus or train or whatever, I'm struck by how few people are as tall as me (and officially, I'm not exactly a giant). I can only imagine what is was like for my father to be 6-foot-tall in the 1930s and 1940s.
but yes, the bottom line - as has been noted - is just give everyone a chance to be great and avoid stereotypes (believe me, I do see Asian and Hispanic men taller than me. just not a lot of them.)
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main