|
|
|
Support BBTF
Thanks to Kiko Sakata for his generous support.
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Hot Topics
Hall of Merit: 2024 Hall of Merit Ballot Discussion (189 - 5:49pm, Dec 07)Last:  Eric J can SABER all he wants toNewsblog: OT Soccer - World Cup Final/European Leagues Start (325 - 5:49pm, Dec 07)Last:  AuntBea odeurs de parfum de distance socialeNewsblog: Carlyle’s Rubenstein Is in Talks to Acquire Baltimore Orioles (1 - 5:43pm, Dec 07)Last: Walt DavisNewsblog: Who is on the 2024 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot and what’s the induction process? (401 - 5:30pm, Dec 07)Last:  Tom and Shivs couples counselorNewsblog: Reports: Astros, Victor Caratini agree to 2-year, $12M deal (7 - 5:23pm, Dec 07)Last: Tom and Shivs couples counselorNewsblog: Mookie Betts will be 'every-day second baseman' for Dodgers (38 - 4:14pm, Dec 07)Last: jacksone (AKA It's OK...)Newsblog: Red Sox trade Alex Verdugo to Yankees for three pitchers (29 - 4:14pm, Dec 07)Last: Walt DavisNewsblog: Yankees get Juan Soto in blockbuster trade with Padres (40 - 3:55pm, Dec 07)Last: Walt DavisNewsblog: Jerry Reinsdorf meets with Nashville Mayor Freddie O'Connell (5 - 3:14pm, Dec 07)Last: Tom NawrockiHall of Merit: 2024 Hall of Merit Ballot Ballot (4 - 3:10pm, Dec 07)Last: JaackNewsblog: Jeimer Candelario, Reds reach 3-year, $45M deal, sources say (10 - 3:10pm, Dec 07)Last: Don August(us) Cesar Geronimo BerroaNewsblog: OT - NBA Redux Thread for the End of 2023 (151 - 12:57pm, Dec 07)Last:  GregDNewsblog: Eduardo Rodriguez signs with Diamondbacks: NL champs add to solid rotation on four-year, $80M deal, per report (2 - 10:39am, Dec 07)Last: DarrenNewsblog: 'I had tears, man': Brett's career on full display in MLB Network documentary (3 - 10:22am, Dec 07)Last: RoyalFlushHall of Merit: Hall of Merit Book Club (17 - 10:20am, Dec 07)Last: cookiedabookie
|
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
Cardinal assets: I'm not so sure they have a lot to sell unless they're really gonna blow things up. The main asset is 1.5 years of Goldschmidt, he'd bring a lot back. Standard pending FA players aren't that attractive a bunch -- Montgomery, Flaherty, Hicks, deJong. They can certainly find takers for the first two. Beyond that you have losers in the OF Logjam Lotto but if O'Neill was doing well they'd have a couple more wins (and Carlson is only just entering arb so, unless they're the A's now, it's too early to trade him).
Edman is an interesting trade target. DRS rates his defense as average this year, including at SS and 2B. His baserunning has also "cratered" to average. What do our Cards fans say? Edman without defense and baserunning is definitely "sell this guy before anybody else notices."
So maybe it is time for a bit of a blow-up. Nootbar, Carlson, Walker, Donovan and Burleson in the OF, maybe Gorman to 1B, Arenado probably not going anywhere but you can shop him. We all know there's not much of a pitching staff here and most of it is FA at year's end anyway.
Arenado: I've come to think of him as a much better hitter than he is. I suppose that's because he keeps churning out 7 WAR seasons so it seems like he should post 140-150 OPS+. But this year's 122 and 2021's 119 are spot on his 123 career average. Last year was his only season with an OPS+ over 133. Every other full season after his rookie year has been within 10 points of that career average. The bad news of course is that if the defense ever leaves (and DRS seems to think it's gone ... +19 last year, -2 this year) then he's just a good-hitting 3B, possibly moving to 1B in a couple of years.
Curious about Edman and Arenado, I tracked them down at statcast. Statcast so far agrees on Arenado but still rates Edman above average but nothing special particularly (+3, around 50th overall).
What exactly happened when Pesky turned around is still a matter of contention. Some claim that Pesky, assuming that Slaughter would not be running home, checked Walker at first base instead of immediately firing home, while others contend that Pesky was so shocked to see Slaughter on his way to score that he had a mental lapse that accounted for the delay. Whatever the reason, the delay, along with a weak and rushed throw home, allowed Slaughter to score just as Red Sox catcher Roy Partee caught it up the line from home plate.
Culberson hit for the natural cycle
Padres get a much needed pitcher and a chance to lock up Ohtani.
Angels extend Trouts window another year and there is no way they can sign Ohtani (although if they extend Soto maybe they have a chance )
Baseball trade values says it's not an entirely lopsided trade.
If I were the Angels I'd do this to avoid the "they lost Ohtani discussions". If I'm the Padres I might do this. Do the angels have a catcher they can throw in? Looks like they have two minor league catching prospects that could fit
Hombre, Rally, every Angels ticket buyer, the entire Anaheim metro area, the entire nation of Japan.
MLB has become like the NFL for me – I know one or two players on every visiting team. I barely know any of the Rangers' relievers any more. I go to games as much as I ever did, I still enjoy them (especially with the pitch clock). But following the sport overall has become too much for me. Just my decline phase as a fan :) MLB hasn't changed that much in the past decade, though the move to all-play-all schedules makes the visitors a bit more random.
I actually know some of these other Angels, because they used to come in to Arlington so often. Jared Walsh, he has been good in the past but is hitting .122 this year. Taylor Ward was good in 2022 but also having an off-year. Rendon I know, and Hunter Renfroe. So I guess there's hope
C Centeno (371 career PA)
1B Beniquez, Rivera
2B Samuel
SS Uribe
3B Francisco
LF Soto
CF Pierre
RF Gonzalez
SP Marichal, Guzman, Pizarro, Padron (NeL), Nicasio
RP Berengeur, Acevedo, Agosto, Cruz, Oviedo (aka Leo Nunez), etc. (I decided not to take JC Romero since, far as I know, only known as JC)
Both Beniquez and Rivera are mainly OF but between them had about a full season of 1B starts. I don't see any good candidates unless you want to count Carlos Juan Delgado (which, understandably, the all-Juan team would like to do but the all-Carlos team gets first dibs). I won't be surprised if I missed a better catcher out there than Centeno or better 3B than Francisco.
EDIT: I'm not a NeL afficionado so I don't know Padron but the 146 ERA+ looks good and he's just slated in as 4th starter here. He apparently gave up 0 HR in 141 IP for the 1924 Chicago American Giants.
Maybe the Rangers can pick him up and shoot for the WS. :-)
You know, it's not like we had non-anonymous relievers in the past. Of course you always knew your team's closer but, unless he was a stud, it might not be the same guy as last year and he might lose his job halfway through the season anyway. There'd be 1 or 2 setup guys you maybe knew. Then we just pretended the other guys never pitched so we knew a team's "bullpen" because we knew who Lee Smith was.
So looking at the 1984 Cubs page ... one of the NL's best rotations, especially after they picked up Eck and Sutcliffe. Just 19 complete games, just an average of 6.1 IP/start. Smith and Stoddard combined for nearly 200 IP but still plenty for the rest. They didn't have a AAA shuttle, pretty much the same 4 guys filling out the pen all year. Still, it's not like anybody knew who Bordi, Frazier, Brusstar and Noles were. And believe me, as a fan, the less familiar you were with George Frazier, the lower your blood pressure. (Granted, all better known than 2023 anon Jeremiah Estrada.)
C Santana, Ruiz
1B Delgado
2B Baerga
SS Correa
3B Guillen
OF Beltran, Gomez, Gonzalez (I can't decide who plays which spot)
DH/bench Pena, May, Lee, Quentin, Garcia
SP (in no particular order, kinda all the same guy) Zambrano, Carrasco, Rodon, Martinez, Perez
That's 2 all-stars at C, an AS starting every other position, 4 AS in the rotation (not Carrasco which surprised me a bit), 5 AS on the bench and at least one in the bullpen (Marmol). I'm sure the Charles/Chuck team would be similar but that's an awful lot of talent.
And as for other clubs ... for some reason recently, I came across Dale Murray. In Sept. 1974, for the Expos, he had one of the greatest months any pitcher ever had. Just phenomenal. And pitched for a long time thereafter, a lot against the Phillies teams I followed ... no memory of the guy. :(
That LFers last name...Ibanez! But I am pretty sure it's not Raul because he looks 23ish, not 48. It's...Andy Ibanez I think.
Mark Saxon
@markasaxon
·
4h
Paul DeJong had a .987 OPS in his first 25 games and he has a .332 OPS in his last 15 games.
...........
I just shuddered involuntarily.
the Mets shipped a washed-up ex-Giants OF Ken Henderson to the Reds in mid-1978 for Murray, who became a decent workhorse in Gotham.
until 1979, that is. he was so inept that, in an homage to the "Rolaids Fireman of the Year" reliever contest of the era, that summer I dubbed Murray "The Arsonist."
any mid-inning 'fire' he arrived at, he always seemed to burn down the whole damn inning.
the Mets "sold" him back to the Expos in August - I imagine for $24 worth of beads and trinkets....
*Also applies to every large free agent the Angels sign.
Ohtani now leads the AL in homers.
EDIT: Phillies lose to Diamondbacks, 9-8, although they briefly led 10-9 on a near-HR that was belatedly fixed after umpires conferred, corrected the call to foul, which was then confirmed by replay.
Maybe there's more deference to umpires as their jobs are more challenged by automation? Or maybe small sample size. Anyway, when they hold up the game like that and do no good in the process, it's annoying.
My two next frontiers for more exciting baseball would be to abolish video-review challenge and mid-inning pitching changes. I know, keep dreaming but at one time the pitch clock seemed a dream.
Pretty sure he had at least one Topps card with a toothpick in his mouth, maybe more (cards, not toothpicks).
He won 15 games in relief in 1975 while pitching 111 innings, and put up -0.3 bWAR. I should look up his fWAR, because he had a FIP of 2.95. [looked it up. 1.6 fWAR in 1975]
The Orioles are still a rotation anchor away from being serious contenders. I can't see them winning the division with the rotation of decentish second/third starters they have now.
We are a fickle bunch ... Elly de la Cruz has one bad game and suddenly we think other players are worth talking about.
Major League Baseball and high-ranking club officials have discussed limiting how much teams can spend in areas other than player salaries, such as technology, player development, scouting and health, multiple people briefed on such discussions told The Athletic.
A real life example of a legal oligopoly at work. "You know guys, all this spending on analytics and coaching is just running up the tab for everyone. Why don't we all agree to get rid of that"
and obviously (ethical issues aside), his instincts have been effective.
but while yes baseball is a business, it also is an emotional and seasonal endeavor.
the SNY crew was noting tonight that down a run with 1 out in the 9th inning, why would Vogelbach not be up if it gets to 2 out and nobody on against RHP Holmes (and with lefty Peralta already departed)?
camera crew then got a shot of a beaten-down Vogelbach leaning somberly against the rail of the dugout. he has 2 singles in 27 AB in the last 3 weeks and has not homered since May 7. no one, including Vogelbach, has any idea why he's still on the roster (Luke Voit is now signed to AAA and presumably arrives within days, as he's a better hitter anyway).
2nd out is made, and here comes the utterly uninspiring utility infielder Luis Guillorme, who predictably makes the last out.
old, fat, and contented clubhouse vibe needs to be shaken up - but it's not clear Cohen's ego will allow it to happen.
tonight and tomorrow - both vs the Yankees - might be the last two sellouts of the Mets' sorry season.
The "separating" Giants are tied with the Brewers for the last NL WC spot, a bit ahead of Reds, Padres, Phils and Mets. There is some separation in the AL because there are some legit bad teams but the Angels are currently among 4 teams vying for the last 2 WC spots. So sure they have separated from the Mariners, Guardians and Red Sox.
By then, Oakland may have a 10-15 game win streak going !
@AnthonyDiComo
·
50m
One thing worth mentioning: Francisco Lindor has been available and accountable every night through what's been one of the worst stretches of his career, both personally and for his team. Credit to him. Many players around the league are not that way.
...............
(hey, it's something)
KCR 18-49 L 8 AL Central
OAK 19-50 W 7
STL 27-41 L4 NL Central
WAS 26-39 L1
COL 29-40 W3
DET 27-37 W1 AL Central
CHW 29-38 L2 AL Central
CHC 29-37 W1 NL Central
Five in a row before it ends
Edit: Sorry, not a sac fly, Gallo was thrown out trying to stretch a single into a double.
Jordan Walker was just tagged out at home on a play in which the catcher's foot was turned and planted between the plate and Walker, and Walker's hand bounced off the foot as he slid in headfirst. There was no "clear path" per se unless it included sliding through the catcher.
If he had slid in feet first and taken out the legs of the catcher, would there have been any consequences?
What's that, like the fifth or sixth time this year they've blown a 9th-inning lead in dramatic fashion? It's at least the second two-out 9th-inning game-tying or -winning homer they've allowed in last couple of weeks.
They began 10-24, then won 11 of 14 (or 14 of 20 depending on how you want to slice it) to get back to within 6 games of .500, but have been stinking it up since then.
In one two-week span, they were on the losing end of three walk-off losses, one of those being that other 2-out 9th inning homer I mentioned earlier.
Take away the Cardinals' single two-week hot streak, when they looked to be righting their ship (it was a mirage), they have gone 16-39 in 2024.
They are bad.
What’s the likelihood that the owners of the central division teams in both leagues have conspired in some way? They all seem to be targeting mediocrity as a ceiling.
I do think if Walker had slid feet first he would have at the very least knocked the catcher off his feet, which I'd rather see than going in hands-first and risking a broken finger.
The Cardinals shouldn't be this bad though.
As to "just competing among themselves," that's more an AL thing. The NLC contributed a wild card team in 2019 and 2021 and missed by just one game in 2022. And, until a couple days ago, have been in a WC spot all of this season too. It's true that nobody in the NLC is trying to keep up with the Dodgers and also true that none of them have produced 10 all-stars under 25 like the Braves but otherwise they are competitive with the rest of the NL.
I think folks are misunderstanding the NL this year. It is extremely balanced. Probably eventually the Nats and maybe Rox will fall away and probably the Marlins and Pirates have been a bit lucky. Surely the Dodgers will start winning soon. But it's everybody squashed between 400 and 550 winning %ages. The NLC is just -4 against NLE, -9 against NLW and -9 against the AL. That's not inspiring but it's hardly a blowout and it's mostly the Cards being -12 outside the division. Compare that to the ALC who are -30 vs ALE, -4 vs ALW and -20 vs NL (the Royals are -24 overall). The ALC has 4 of the 5 worst records in the AL and the Twins have just the 8th best record in the league (by 1 game over Seattle and 2 over Boston). Pitt being in the playoffs would be a bit "sad" but at least they have the 6th-best record in the league.
But sure, other than the Cubs, the Centrals are pretty small markets and, even worse, some have stagnant populations and tax bases so there's no reason to think it will get better.
yes, RIP.
I still remember his 1970 Topps card as one of the more dispiriting "finds" of the year. he looks like a car salesman or he sells insurance or he's a plumber - but he's definitely not a big league ballplayer.
then you look on the back for a possible tidbit of interest - and it's nothing but his entire professional stat line dating back to 1956 with the Thibodaux Senators of something called the [whites-only allowed] Evangeline League, which lasted through 1957.
I think I'd have been interested as a youngster to know (of course I found out a few years later) that he was one of three players (also Milt Pappas and Dick Simpson) sent to Cincinnati in the stupid trade by the Reds of Hall of Famer Frank Robinson to the Orioles.
And part of the reason is that the catcher and pitcher can't waste minutes whle the new guy gets ready. The Pirates pitching coach probably should have come out to burn time. But with the pitch clock, you may need to start warming up guy #2 at the first sign of trouble from guy #1.
Anyway, the new reliever didn't have much more success although he's getting nickeled and dimed. Cubs 7-5 after 6.
this deal has been a rollercoaster:
December 3, 2018: Traded by the New York Mets with Gerson Bautista, Jay Bruce, Justin Dunn and Anthony Swarzak to the Seattle Mariners for Robinson Canó, Edwin Díaz and cash.
tens of millions of dead money changed hands, of course.
talent-wise, boils down to Kelenic for Cano and Diaz.
Cano mediocre in 2019, but All-Star quality hitting in COVID 2020.
then gets suspended for 2021, which saves the Mets $24M.
Cano embarrasses himself in 2022 in 100 AB for the Mets, Padres, and Braves and he's toast.
Diaz is great in 2020, good in 2021, best reliever in baseball 2022 as Mets win 101 games, and out all of 2023.
Kelenic is bad in 2021 (72 OPS+), even worse in 2022 (55 OPS+), and now good this year.
Is that the first shift violation called?
MOST HR AGE-21 OR YOUNGER SEASON - CATCHERS
Johnny Bench 1969 26
Darrell Porter 1973 16
Johnny Bench 1968 15
FRANCISCO ALVAREZ 2023 12 and counting
so my wife's father is Darrell's first cousin.
does that make her a second cousin of Darrell, or first cousin once removed?
(he died when she was only 30 and never met him - but still)
@ByZachMiller
·
17m
Shift violation on Jeff McNeil for lining up on the wrong side of second base (really just straddling the base) was only the second shift violation of the entire MLB season.
The first was called on Elvis Andrus for lining up on the right-field grass. @andrew_tred
Reds also roll. Current NLC standings and run diffs
Pirates 34-32 -10
Brewers 34-34 -25
Reds 34-35 -29
Cubs 30-37 -1
Cards 27-42 -13
It's Lake Nogebow where everyone is slightly below-average.
bottom 10, 1 out, Alvarez Ghost on 2nd base.
Yankees playing OF at Little League depth on Nimmo, long fly to the wall, RF of course can't get to it in time.
Alvarez chained to second base because - well, he's only 21 years old. or something.
RF surrenders, CF relays it to Gleyber, who has the fielding IQ of a pencil, so his lackluster toss home doesn't quite beat Alvarez's panicked scramble to score.
weird play. Mets win 4-3
OK, EVERYBODY - MAN YOUR BATTLE STATIONS!
THIS IS NOT A DRILL - I REPEAT, THIS IS NOT A DRILL....
.........................
Daniel Wallach
@WALLACHLEGAL
·
11m
NEW: A fourth woman has accused former MLB pitcher Trevor Bauer of sexual assault in a civil lawsuit filed in Arizona state court, via @TishaESPN
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main