|
|
|
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Hot Topics
Newsblog: Who is on the 2024 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot and what’s the induction process? (414 - 9:56pm, Dec 07)Last:  chisoxcollectorNewsblog: Yankees get Juan Soto in blockbuster trade with Padres (48 - 9:28pm, Dec 07)Last: Benji Gil Gamesh VII - The Opt-Out AwakensNewsblog: OT - NBA Redux Thread for the End of 2023 (154 - 8:53pm, Dec 07)Last:  tshipman (The Viscount of Variance)Newsblog: Carlyle’s Rubenstein Is in Talks to Acquire Baltimore Orioles (8 - 8:44pm, Dec 07)Last: sunday silence (again)Hall of Merit: 2024 Hall of Merit Ballot Discussion (191 - 7:43pm, Dec 07)Last:  Howie MenckelNewsblog: OT Soccer - World Cup Final/European Leagues Start (326 - 7:36pm, Dec 07)Last:  AuntBea odeurs de parfum de distance socialeNewsblog: Jeimer Candelario, Reds reach 3-year, $45M deal, sources say (13 - 6:21pm, Dec 07)Last: Howie MenckelNewsblog: Guardians win Draft Lottery, securing next year's top pick (7 - 6:19pm, Dec 07)Last: ZachNewsblog: Eduardo Rodriguez signs with Diamondbacks: NL champs add to solid rotation on four-year, $80M deal, per report (3 - 6:15pm, Dec 07)Last: Walt DavisNewsblog: Reports: Astros, Victor Caratini agree to 2-year, $12M deal (7 - 5:23pm, Dec 07)Last: Tom and Shivs couples counselorNewsblog: Mookie Betts will be 'every-day second baseman' for Dodgers (38 - 4:14pm, Dec 07)Last: jacksone (AKA It's OK...)Newsblog: Red Sox trade Alex Verdugo to Yankees for three pitchers (29 - 4:14pm, Dec 07)Last: Walt DavisNewsblog: Jerry Reinsdorf meets with Nashville Mayor Freddie O'Connell (5 - 3:14pm, Dec 07)Last: Tom NawrockiHall of Merit: 2024 Hall of Merit Ballot Ballot (4 - 3:10pm, Dec 07)Last: JaackNewsblog: 'I had tears, man': Brett's career on full display in MLB Network documentary (3 - 10:22am, Dec 07)Last: RoyalFlush
|
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
and Miguel Cabrera HR'd today, now on pace in 2023 for - welp, almost 3.
I think his ranking ends here, but maybe not:
CAREER HOMERS
23. Ernie Banks+ (19) 512
23. Eddie Mathews+ (17) 512
25. Mel Ott+ (22) 511
26. Gary Sheffield (22) 509
27. MIGUEL CABRERA (21, 40) 507
might be reasonable to think that everyone in the top 15 is in the HOF - if you had amnesia:
1. Barry Bonds (22) 762
4. Albert Pujols (22) 703
5. Alex Rodriguez (22) 696
9. Sammy Sosa (18) 609
11. Mark McGwire (16) 583
13. Rafael Palmeiro (20) 569
15. Manny Ramirez (19) 555
below Sheffield and M-Cab, others not in include:
31. Adrián Beltré (21) 477
34. Carlos Delgado (17) 473
37. Jose Canseco (17) 462
37. NELSON CRUZ 462 8
37. Adam Dunn (14) 462
43. Dave Kingman (16) 442
44. Jason Giambi (20) 440
45. Paul Konerko (18) 439
47. Carlos Beltrán (20) 435
48. Juan Gonzalez (17) 434
48. Andruw Jones (17) 434
(Stanton has 384 and Trout has 364)
Brooklyn is playing Chicago
In the NL there is only one other game
St.Louis and Pittsburgh with Philadelphia, Cincinnati, New York and Milwaukee with the night off
In the AL there is one game Indians vs Washington. The other six teams, Philadelphia, the Sox, Boston, St, Louis, Detroit and NY, have the night off
What year is it ?
Browns moved to Baltimore for '54, and the Braves didn't move to Milwaukee until 1953.
Last out of the 4th was a high pop in pretty much the exact center of the IF. It seemed as if the Rays IFs had never looked into the sun before. I suppose playing half your games in a crappy dome and most of your road games at night, you don't get many opportunities to track a ball in the sun.
ADDENDUM: Oakland is a good place to be a kid if you like collecting foul balls.
It is insane how good this guy is.
First Mighty Quinn game for the Nats all year.
Odd factoid today looked at longest Cub consecutive game on-base (hits, walks, etc.) streaks vs. particular teams. Ian Happ has reached base 48 straight games against the Pirates -- not the Cubs record which I think was 50-something by Bill Nicholson vs the Giants.
But it does raise the question of whether any player has beaten DiMaggio's hit streak record against a particular team or in a particular ballpark or in night games or whatever. Obviously not the same thing as Joe's streak (e.g. the Pirates have not been a stellar squad during Happ's career). Is there anybody who has beaten Bonds HR season-record in <162 games against a team? Per a 2015 article, Bonds is the non-Rox Coors leader with just 26 which was even just a 50-HR pace. Obviously it's hard to get 600 PA in an opponents' park, maybe impossible with the new balanced schedule.
Ohtani is hitting .433 (26-60) with 5 doubles, a triple, 10 homers, 12 walks, 4 stolen bases in his last 16 games.
He's really a force in CF
You'd also get the defensive stats debate. fWAR is 10 wins lower than bWAR, statcast gives Kiermaier only about half as many runs saved.
Anyway, there's a reason Kiermaier doesn't win GGs or get named to AS teams or receive full-time play (despite hitting OK for a CF). A lot of that is regular injuries but also because everybody knows he does just one thing incredibly well and that's play defense and that's just not that important. If he somehow manages to hang on long enough to double his career numbers then maybe we can have this conversation again.
Huh ... JD just mentioned that this is the 4th straight game the Cubs have batted around.
First cousin, once removed. Basically removed = a different generation.
Second cousins are children of first cousins. Another way to look at nth cousins:
1st cousins share a set of grandparents
2nd cousins share a set of great grandparents
Etc.
My sister recently found out that we are 10th cousins to Elvis.
Vizquel got 37% before his other issues. I could definitely see something like that for KK if all goes well
wait, now I'm confused.
wait, I think I got it now. so if Darrell Porter had a kid (turns out he had 3), those kids are second cousins to my wife. aha.
We are quickly entering capitulation stage which I hope is a cleaning house - GM and manager.
Our playbook ain't working and we need new thinking
(hoo boy)
NYY SP Domingo German - is he good?
ER allowed, since start of season:
4 1 1 4 6 1 2 1 0 4 1 1 7
the latter came tonight, in just 2 IP.
you'd think a pitcher who now has a yawn-inducing 4.30 ERA likely gives up 2 or 3 runs sometimes - ok, at least twice?
has only happened once - and that was in only 5 IP.
anyone know what's the next number in that sequence? if so, call Aaron Boone with the info. he'll thank you for it.
He'll most likely never be elected but I could see him doing pretty well if he can finish off his 30s well.
Apparently German is not as effective without using copious amounts of "resin"
Where is OSHA on these issues ? I couldn't operate a chemical plant with these kind of safety risks, why isn't safety considered at all in the parks
Vizquel isn't any kind of trailblazer. Maranville, Aparicio, Concepcion, Ozzie -- "great" defensive SS who last for 15+ years have always gotten HoF consideration. Belanger did not because he had only 6600 PA and couldn't hit a lick. And we can add Steve Finley, 10,000 PAs, 5 GG, 2 AS, a ring and even a scoreless inning pitched .... less than <1% HoF vote.
You hate to see it
Ump arguements seem to have evolved into words like "I just want you to be better". It seems to generate ejections quickly.
People voting for Vizquel aren't voting for him as a defense first player, they are voting for him in a mistaken belief that he's a modern Ozzie Smith with 3 more seasons. The people not voting for him realize he's a lesser quality fielder, lesser quality bat, lesser quality base runner, lower ranked among his contemporaries and less entertaining.
The voting field is open to a defense first guy who sticks around for a long time, but they have only ever put one in (Mazeroski) and he had a signature moment to help him out. If Andruw can't get in, then Kiermaier has no chance of consideration.
Edit: forgot Aparicio also. (Maranville was a better bat relative to his league than either Mazeroski or Aparicio) but I agree with 535 from Walt.
I wouldn't mind to see MLB enact a rule that says after 5 ejections in a season, an automatic 3 game suspension, then for every 2 ejections you get from that point on the suspension gets longer by 2 days. 5 ejections 3 days, 7 5 days, 9 7 days etc.
Writers are so ####### weird sometimes.
When he was about to become eligible, a lot of people on this site thought I was crazy to suggest that Vizquel was going to get traction, when it seemed so obvious to me that he was going to get traction that I thought people were just being blind to not see it. There are a lot of voters who legit believe he was the modern version of Ozzie Smith, and if Ozzie is worthy then it's clear that Vizquel was equally worthy. Of course as I mentioned above, that is a flawed argument because in every aspect of the game, Ozzie was better than Vizquel, and he didn't have the contemporaries who were all world while he played.(Ripken, Larkin and Yount...but not really the same overlap that Vizquel had with his group)
Huh?
Rabbit 82 OPS+; 11,000+ PA; 31 oWAR
Aparicio 82 OPS+ 11,000+ PA; 42 oWAR (11 wins of baserunning)
Maz 84 OPS+; 8,000+ PA; 20 oWAR
Ozzie 87 OPS+; 10,000+ PA; 49 oWAR (10 wins of baserunning)
Vizquel 82 OPS+; 12,000+ PA; 33 oWAR (average baserunning)
Concepcion 88 OPS+; 9,000+ PA; 33 oWAR
True, for 6 seasons in his prime, Rabbit was a league average hitter; in the other 8000 PAs, he was really, really bad.
The voters have always been kind to top-fielding SS. Now who the voters decide were great fielding SS isn't necessarily a rational process. Concepcion never came close, never had a surge, but he was on the ballot all 15 years. Of course being on the Big Red Machine helped Concepcion, all the stolen bases helped Aparicio; the flips helped Ozzie.
There was no question Vizquel would do pretty well. And given the weakness of the ballots, he had a chance. We can say, correctly IMO, that he wasn't close to Ozzie's equal but (a) 11 GG say he was and (b) Ozzie was an eaasy first ballot guy so it's not like he's a minimum standard.
Anyway, the legit point to make is: now that we quantify defense (well or not) with something other than gold gloves, defense will play a bigger part in future HoF voting. Andruw might yet knock down the door. And if Kiermaier was on track for an 8-9,000 PA career, we might be discussing him. As is, he's Belanger, Dwayne Murphy (6 GG; didn't make the ballot), better hitting version of Gary Pettis (5 GG; didn't make the ballot), Finley, Heyward, Geronimo (made the ballot; kinda everybody did in those years ... Jim Barr?, Terry Crowley, Joe Ferguson)
The Murphy non-ballot annoys me. I think it would have been the 95 ballot. Greg Gross, Manny Trillo, Chris Speier, Mike Krukow made the ballot that year.
I'm going by rbat beyond just ops+. But I think I looked at his 162 game average while looking at the career for everyone else.... So you are right. Huh? So I have to take it back.
Oops... I was wrong, Cardinals managed to muster 3 runs with a single and homerun. (guess it's a good thing I didn't bet)
Ozzie 262/337/328, 87 OPS+, -117 Rbat, -7/162
Omar 272/336/352, 82 OPS+, -244 Rbat, -13/162
That's all era. But it's not clear it's skill or performance just the HR-heavy context of Omar's era. Put Omar in Ozzie's era, I'll bet he hits pretty much the same ... or put Ozzie in Omar's era and he puts up pretty much the same slash line. Both guys are average OBP with no power guys. Omar's league context was a 339 OBP; Ozzie's was 328. So Ozzie a bit better than Omar by OBP+. Omar gets killed on SLG+ obviously ... but there's no way Omar could possibly have matched the league's 155 ISO ... but that's true of Ozzie as well. So to me, that's (at best) a value difference, not a quality difference.
Aparicio clocks in at -198 but at least he was well below league average in OBP (311 vs 329); Maranville was -224 with a 318 vs 337 OBP comparison. Omar seems a bit hard done by here, at least he managed a league average OBP.
For completeness, Brooks was also an obviously defense-first HoFer. His bat was fine, at times good, so it wasn't defense-only but without the glove, he's not in. With another 8,000 PAs, we might have this conversation about Ke'Bryan Hayes. (Hmmm... will I still be alive 8,000 PAs from now? I have these thoughts from time to time now.) Pie Traynor probably set that precedent. Without his 30s offensive breakout, Beltre was going to be a very interesting HoF discussion.
I imagine rbat differences with close ops+ is going to be mostly about average runs scored per game difference. A guy who is 80 ops+ for a 1000 runs per team league is going to have a larger negative rbat than a guy who is 80 ops+ in a 500 runs per team league. (using extreme examples to iterate the point)
edit: assuming same number of plate appearances of course.
Adbert trying to close it out.
I know this isn't common, but I do think this has happened more in the past couple of years (percentage to games played) than probably the 20 years previous with just AL only dh. I know the Cardinals have done it at least twice this year. Of course with the relief as they are, it's not surprising except the fact that the teams just don't have enough bench bats.
Cubs win!
Impressively about 1/3 of games are now under 2.5 hours ... compared with <5% last year or the last several years. The game time table only goes back to 1998 but the 2.37 average time is easily the lowest by about 10 minutes. I got confused by "time between PAs" but realized that's time between the start pf PA #1 and start of PA #2, not between the end of #1 and start of #2. (OK, could be time between end of #1 and end of #2, same diff.) Nothing else on the page looks very exciting but at least it's a sort of "one stop shop" next time we have the discussion.
Anyway 7 of 8 for the Cubs over the Giants, Pirates and O's. Pretty much exactly what they needed to do against the teams they needed to do it against. Finish up with the O's tomorrow, three at Pitt then it's off to London. That's followed by a reasonably tough stretch (by 2023 standards) of Phils, Guardians, Brewers, Yanks, Red Sox.
But they do really, at least unless it happens early in the game. With a required 13 position players, that's 4 guys you can pinch-hit with. The O's PH for McCann in the 6th, "double-switched" with Mateo a spot lower (who made the last out) and that spot didn't come around again until the 9th. With the unearned runner bringing extra inning games to a quick halt, they might not have needed another PH.
In fact they were quite aggressive PHing today. The first one for McCann, then they PH'd for the pitcher's spot, then PH'd for Ortiz who was at 2B today. Frazier (who PH'd for the P) would have stayed on to play 2B I assume if it had gone into extras. And the O's should have still had one bench player left. So unless the game went 13 or more, they were covered.
Has a pitcher been a ghost runner yet (not including PR)?
I thought there were rules against that, I guess with the universal dh that rule might have disappeared. But I thought (and it could just be my old man brain imagining things) that the rule was if a pitcher is the ghost runner then the team has the option to go back one more batter.
Good news is their most prolific inning is the 8th inning (in theory it should be the first inning. It's almost always the first inning for every team in baseball throughout history for logical reasons) But this team is messed up of course, 54 runs in the 8th inning, 43 in the first(their second most successful inning)
edit: funny thing, even though the Cardinals have the third best inherited runners scored percentage in the NL, they actually have the 2nd most inherited runners allowed to score with 36 (Reds have 38) the Phillies have a 39% inherited runners scored and have only allowed 35 runners to score. Cardinals 132 inherited runners is second to the reds 138 with the third place Rockies at 115.
"A St. Louis area native and someone aware of the rich history of the Cardinals' organization, David Freese always felt somewhat uncomfortable being lumped in with the franchise’s other legendary players, even though he did author a playoff performance for the ages in 2011.
Even though fans deemed Freese worthy of a spot among St. Louis greats by electing him to the Cardinals Hall of Fame earlier this year via a fan vote, he said he felt unworthy of such a distinction not long after his appointment. Accordingly, Freese informed the team in recent days that he would be declining his election into the franchise’s Hall of Fame. Freese was set to enter the Cardinals Hall of Fame along with player/coach/instructor Jose Oquendo and former pitcher Max Lanier on Aug. 19, but now only the latter two will be inducted.
“This is something that I have given an extreme amount of thought to, humbly, even before the voting process began,” Freese said in a release."
..................
[I kind of agree with Freese - including his hemming and hawing out of respect for the fan base that voted for him.]
I agree, but at the same time, this is how they rotate through the elder players dying off. This is a lesser honor than having the uniform number retired.
edit: double play never happened apparently(challenged), stolen base and single gives the Cardinals a bit of breathing room making it 5-3
Ronald Acuna Jr. singled (line drive to CF).
Ozzie Albies flied out (fly to CF).
Austin Riley singled (ground ball to CF). Ronald Acuna Jr. advanced to 2nd.
Travis d'Arnaud grounded into a double play (ground ball to P). Austin Riley out at 2nd.
...........
now has allowed a respectable 4 ER, 8.6 IP, 10 H, 5 BB.
MLB starts in the field for Castro:
2B 99
1B 58
SS 52
3B 47
CF 36
LF 15
RF 9
DH 9
wait, if you can play 2B-SS-CF - why ever start him anywhere else?
86 career OPS+ and 54 this year, mostly at 2B.
He is worthy. He's not worthy but the time to tell the team that would have been before they put his name on the ballot
The Cards are now the crappy team on all their schedules. Pretty funny
I think someone in the rock hall of fame did... (Sex Pistols? Dolly Parton declined nomination, Axl Rose)
:)
I believe the reference you are looking for is Mutual of Omaha's Wild Kingdom ... maybe they switched to "wild world" towards the end though.
It's been interesting watching Morel this year. Last year he was the adorable terrier, just ecstatic to be there, running everywhere. Great to watch. This year he's a mastiff -- still a joy to watch, still thrilled to be on a baseball field, but destroying baseballs every chance he gets there and the attitude seems more "I belong here."
It's just 118 PAs but 13 HRs and the OPS is still over 1000 despite a 33 PA stretch of 036/182/036. And just 3 Ks in his last 27 PA.
The Cubs at least had enough sense to take advantage of the replay review (O's reqeust) to get a new reliever ready.
Meanwhile, apparently TVNZ is going to start carrying lots of sports for free starting 1 July. The ads show NFL and NBA ... I can't imagine they'll add any MLB but a boy can dream. Anyway, if I can watch some NBA for free, maybe I will start popping up in the NBA thread.
EDIT: oh-oh, it's the unhittable Yannier Cano.
Speaking of Pham, Aaron Hicks has hit 304/418/522 since joining the O's. It' just 55 PAs but it pulls his season OPS+ up to 94, right in line with his career 96. Funny how a better team than the Yanks consider Hicks a solid 4th OF option (Mullins is on the IL).
Glancing at the O's b-r page, they've got an "interesting" guy named Ryan McKenna. Nothing special, bench OF, just 78 ineffective PAs. But those 78 PAs have come in 54 appearances (one as a P) and he's not (just) a PH, all of those have been defensive appearances. Obviously teams still use defensive replacements but I didn't know anybody was carrying a defensive replacement specialist. And it's not like he has amazing defensive numbers or anything, doesn't steal bases. More RF than elsewhere but he's got appearances in all three spots, the other O's OFs have decent defensive numbers, it's not a Luzinski-type situation.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main