|
|
|
Support BBTF
Thanks to Dock Ellis for his generous support.
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.
Hot Topics
Newsblog: Josh Hader discusses reluctance to pitch four outs (13 - 2:27am, Sep 27)Last: Cooper NielsonNewsblog: Qualifying Offer Value To Land Around $20.5MM (18 - 2:00am, Sep 27)Last: Howie MenckelNewsblog: Rays unveil statues honoring 2 iconic moments in club history (13 - 1:56am, Sep 27)Last: Howie MenckelNewsblog: Betts sets 'remarkable' record with 105 RBIs as a leadoff hitter (34 - 1:55am, Sep 27)Last: sunday silence (again)Newsblog: Joey Votto and the city of Cincinnati say 'Thank you' in a potential goodbye (24 - 12:13am, Sep 27)Last: SoSH U at workNewsblog: Baseball America: Jackson Holliday Wins 2023 Minor League Player of the Year Award (7 - 11:58pm, Sep 26)Last: Howie MenckelNewsblog: Omnichatter for September 2023 (543 - 10:35pm, Sep 26)Last:  Walks Clog Up the BasesNewsblog: Hall of Fame 3B, Orioles legend Brooks Robinson dies at 86 (3 - 10:01pm, Sep 26)Last: baxterNewsblog: How to Save an Aging Ballpark (9 - 6:18pm, Sep 26)Last: Starring Bradley Scotchman as RMcSox Therapy: Over and Out (48 - 4:55pm, Sep 26)Last: Nasty NateNewsblog: As Padres’ season spirals, questions emerge about culture, cohesion and chemistry (51 - 3:12pm, Sep 26)Last: Ithaca2323Newsblog: OT - 2023 NFL thread (17 - 1:19pm, Sep 26)Last: tell me when i'm telling 57i66135Newsblog: OT Soccer - World Cup Final/European Leagues Start (117 - 11:47am, Sep 26)Last:  AuntBea odeurs de parfum de distance socialeNewsblog: OT - NBA Off-Pre-Early Thread for the end of 2023 (19 - 10:05am, Sep 26)Last: Crosseyed and PainlessNewsblog: The MLB Trade Rumors 2023-24 Free Agent Previews (1 - 11:30pm, Sep 25)Last: NaOH
|
|
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
Contreras really needs to be behind the plate for this offense, there is already a backlog of outfielders and infielders, having a backlog at catching was an issue.
Bullpen goes to work.
Angels losing 7-6 in the 8th.
No, wait. 8-6.
his bugaboo had been walks (16 in those previous 18 IP), so has he cut down on those?
yep. ZERO walks this year, and only SEVEN hits allowed. also 22 K.
age 29, 6-foot-4, 245-pound right-hander.
of Cuban descent, and retired his first 20 batters this season.
Bizarre things are happening in Stl.
No. Conteras is cheating. Call the time violation on him and when he tries it again, eject him. This harkens back to when the ball stuck directly to Yadier's chest protector and you tried to hand wave it away as it being in the fold, which was rubbish. Cardinal pitcher's were using all sorts of goo and that's why the ball stuck fast.
The rules are clear, squared up or not, he wasn't in the box, he should be penalised and if he keeps trying that sh*t, then eject him.
the rules are clear he doesn't have to be in the box until 8 seconds, he's squaring up at 10 seconds. Please understand the rules before ######## about them. (and I didn't handwave yadier chest protector bs, I didn't have a clue about it either way)
He's playing rules lawyering, where he is going in the box, staring at the pitcher, qualifying him as squaring up well before the 8 seconds, and the pitcher is then taking that squaring up to mean he's in the box and pitching and getting hit with a quick pitch violation because it was before 8 seconds and he wasn't in the box. Understand the crap that is going on before ######## about it.
he's not cheating, he's lawyering... yes everything about lawyers is evil, but it's within the rules, and that is exactly what he is doing, he's manipulating the rules.
Mind you, the umps are probably often making mistakes based upon how close it is to within the 8 seconds he gets his foot into the box.
Again, it's a stupid rule, but it was absolutely not cheating, and as written, it's not even remotely possible for a person with a functioning rational brain to argue that Jansen didn't violate the rule. It's absolutely clear as ####### day.
the rule is you can't start your motion until the batter is in the batters box, that has been a rule for a long time. Jansen started his motion when Contreras was out of the batters box. The new rule is you have to square up to the pitcher before 8 seconds and you have to have your foot in the batters box before 8 seconds, those are two different rules. Contreras was squared up at 10 seconds, Jansen started pitching at 9 seconds, Contreras foot was out of the batters box.... to deny that is what happen would be to deny the 2020 election, or global warming, you would have to be a complete and utter idiot.
And again, it's a stupid rule that creates rules lawyering, so I'm not defending Contreras actions, but they are within the rules fully and Jansen is, as the rules are currently written, 100% liable for his actions.... again it's a stupid ####### way of enforcement that is easily manipulated because the pitchers are trying to comply with the rules and aren't watching the clock(I doubt they can even see the clock, so they are just reacting)
Does Greinke make the hof in your opinion? Based upon the assumption that fewer and fewer starting pitchers are matching the career numbers, I think he's a lock for me, and I assume most of us here, but still only 224 wins..
Will we ever see a pitcher strike out 1,000 different batters again???!!!
EDIT: Yes, Greinke will go in. Smoltz 213, Halladay 203, Scherzer 203. Wins aren't nearly so important anymore. I mean, if Schilling can get in ... ohhh. I mean, if Kevin Brown can get in ... ohhh. I mean, if Pettitte can get in ... ohhh. :-)
It may take him a few years, might get slowed down for a bit if he's not inducted before Verlander, Scherzer, Kershaw get on the ballot. But he's in.
And considering that 200 wins will probably become as rare as 300 used to be once the Greinke, Verlander, Kershaw, Scherzer, Wainwright generation retires, "only 224 wins" is a solid point in his favor, not an obstacle he'll need to overcome.
Which pitcher who debuted post 2010 looks like they have any realistic shot at 224 wins? Or even 200? I'd say basically just Gerrit Cole.
Wainwright is much more similar to Jon Lester, who may also hang around on the ballot for a while but never make any serious progress.
Greinke, Verlander, Kershaw, and Scherzer - who all debuted between 2004-2008 - are the last generation of starters who will get elected without needing the traditional standards lowered.
So the Cards have Alcantara.
For the Cubs Gleyber (ineligible?) or Cease (Eloy Jimenez looks less and less like a "loss" every year).
Fifteen days for a fractured skull sounds a little optimistic to me.
The Cardinals have Zac Gallen, Sandy Alcantara, Adolis Garcia and Randy Arozerena (Heck I think you could make nearly an entire competitive ball team with Cardinals that got away, depending on how many years out you go with it, add in Carson Kelly, Patrick Wisdom, Edmundo Sosa, Lane Thomas, Harrison Bader, (who knows how good Oviedo will end up being)
So I tuned into Yanks-Rays just in time to see Walls hit a grand slam to make it 8-4 Tampa.
Now taking online payments. Is your team batting in a close game? For a mere $20, I'll switch over and you'll soon be up 6 or 7 runs? No money back guarantee, you pays your money, you takes your chances but can't be a bigger waste of money than Draft Kings (it can be an even bigger waste of money than Draft Kings).
I didn't think there was, but I don't think teams like to use the 60-day list unless they have to.
DP ends the threat, and in the next 5 innings Flaherty only allows ONE baserunner - a harmless single in the 4th inning.
because.... shoot, I don't know.
On a sad note, Red Sox continue to look like the .500 team that they really are, looking to drop their 4th in a row and firmly entrenched in the East cellar now that ny decided to be NY again and start scoring boatloads of runs.
am not used to starters getting the 7th even with a huge lead. I like it !
10 K for Flaherty, who hits the showers.
The only issue with Ohtani and a huge contract, is that any injury he gets is taking basically two superstar players off of your roster that you are paying for. I know he wouldn't take it, but I would really push for an incentive loaded contract that still pays him Arod money before incentives. But at the same time saves the team 15-20 mil in a season where he gets injured. Obviously that isn't going to be the contract he gets, but it feels like it would be justified.
That makes sense, but I doubt he'd go for that. Obviously the other thing you get with Ohtani is his marketability. I'm not sure what his popularity is registering as, but surely he's got to be(along with Judge), the most recognisable player in MLB right now??? Hard to tell from here in Sydney....
This article from just before the season began claims—details aren't provided—that Ohtani's making $40M from endorsements. Judge? $4M. Of course, Ohtani has the advantage that he's a valuable marketing asset in Japan and the US.
You misspelled Judge.....
Rule 5 pick from the Dodgers, so can't be demoted unless he is first offered back to LAD.
HR
1B
BB
HR
K
FLO
BB
1B
1B
1B
BB
here comes INF Mike Brosseau, who somehow had tossed 3 scoreless IP already this year (and 4 P appearances before this season with TBR).
final is 18-1 after a groundout stops the carnage.
Varland - or whatever his name really is - 9 ER, 0.6 IP, 6 H, 3 BB, 1 K.
might be a good time to dare the Dodgers to take him back, lol
he enters and surrenders the aforementioned Knizner slam and it's 18-1 before
Which I find to be a bit weird, as they implement new rules this season that was designed to prevent position players from pitching, except in extreme situations. It appears that the Brewers have had a lot of extreme situations this season. (you can only use position players as a pitcher if losing by more than 8 or winning by more than 10...and in extra innings.)
Christopher Morel continues to redefine baseball with another HR -- that's 4 in 25 AB. Still, just 1 for 5 today, bringing his OPS below 1200 so he's slumping. Unfortunately the rest of the Cubs are playing like Cubs and we've fallen to 19-22.
The challenge with Ohtani of course is that half of him could break (probably the pitcher half) and then all you've got is a (probably still very good) DH who's worth a lot but nothing close to $50 M a year. Maybe a contract for, say, 10/$450 with a "vested dual opt out." If he throws at least X innings in year 5 then he has an option on the remaining 5/$225; if he doesn't, he has an option for 5/$150.
Anyway, as two separate players, Ohtani would easily get paid $50 AAV and maybe even $60-65. But he's 3 years older than Harper. Since it's his one shot at an insane contract -- or, with an option, 2 insane half-contracts -- I assume he'd like 12 years give or take (through age 40) But nobody signs pitchers or DHs to 12-year contracts. Still, easy enough to think Cole's 9/$324 and the last 9 years of Harper at (give or take) $225, spread out over 12-13 years (the team would also rather not do that as a 9-year contract) and we arrive at a guesstimated of 12/$600, roughly the equivalent of 9/$550. No team really wants to do that (break both the $500 and $50 barriers, the first on by a lot) but the only viable alternative I see is a somewhat front-loaded 8/$480.
Typing that out, I just don't see how it works. Even the Dodgers have to be wary of a $60 M elbow (or worse, shoulder). The insane half-contract with the vesting insane half-contract and star DH player option might be the way it has to go. I doubt the structure I suggested in 155 is what they'd go with (Ohtani won't want tens of millions riding on his elbow either)
Besides "bad luck" another factor in the Cardinals' slow start is that they've played 29 games against teams over .500, most in the NL and third in MLB behind KC (32) and Boston (30).
Meanwhile the 20-22 Mets have played just 9 games this year against teams over .500, the fewest in MLB.
- pitching: 10 x $20m with repeating $15m for top 5 CY, $8m for 100 IP and guarantee the IP bonus for next year if he throws 150. Staying healthy on the mound gets him $28m and pitching well can get him $43m.
- hitting: 10 x $10m with repeating $10m for top 5 MVP, $5m for top 5 in HR. Staying healthy gets him $10m with chance at $25m.
Total $30m base, $38m for showing up every day, chance at $68m per, so 10/$380m-$680m. That's some serious potential variability in payroll, but those are fairly reasonable incentives for a great player to reach if he's playing and only exist to drop a lot of salary for missed seasons. Play with the annual Top N numbers or IP to make it even easier to assure most of $500m, but it lets everyone feel like a safe deal with lots of headroom at the top.
Last week, here in Maryland, I saw the schedule showing Ohtani pitching tonight at Camden Yards. So on Saturday we got tickets. I figured it might be the only timer I see him pitch in person.
Then yesterday morning the Angels flip their rotation and let Shohei pitch LAST night, when I couldn't go. And now tickets for tonight are MUCH cheaper.
Tom-not-happy
It's the years part of it that I can't get a handle on. Nobody would sign a pitcher of his age for more than 9 years. I'm not sure anybody would sign a DH of his age for more than 6 years. But with 10+-year contracts all the rage, surely Ohtani is getting 10-12 years. And since he can do both, his chances of being productive (2-3 WAR) at ages 37-40 seem a good bit higher than the others so it's likely to be more than just a method to defer salary. With Verlander, Scherzer and deGrom out there landing huge AAV contracts for their late 30s, you can't expect Ohtani to just give those seasons away even if it's fairly unlikely he'll survive that effectively that long. And while Edgar, Ortiz, Nelson Cruz and a few others weren't paid big money, they were still mighty productive hitters in their late 30s. And as a pitcher-DH, the team has already committed to the idea that they don't care about the decline in his defensive value as he ages.
So if we're saying he's roughly worth Cole ($36) plus Harper ($25) right now then we can't rule out that he will be worth Scherzer ($43) plus Cruz ($14) at 38 ... which is not that different. (And we haven't added 9 years of inflation yet.) He probably won't be worth that much at 38 but I don't know that he's gonna settle for the equivalent of 9/$540 plus 3/$60 when he might be making $150 in those last 3 years. It's just crazy -- the guy really could be "worth" $700 M over the rest of his career.
Or not. I don't know the guy. He gave the Angels a pretty sweet deal the first time, maybe he doesn't care that much about money. And once you've got the first $500 M guaranteed, the rest doesn't really matter (or so I hear). And maybe he doesn't want to play until 40 or would like to go back to Japan for those closing years. Or wants to direct films and so will forego some salary for a post-retirement development deal.
By the way, anybody know what personal services Pujols is performing for the Angels this year? :-)
Ohtani said his stance/swing change going from Japan and his first Spring Training to his current stance and swing are based on Pujols', so that money's worth it!
Isn't this what goes wrong with every child star ever? Free Shohei!!!!!
With Nick "every other start is decent" Pivetta on the bump, you just never know. Only 1 hit and 2BB surrendered thus far, but we'll see.
With Kenley "the 9th inning is now a tyre fire" Jansen waiting for a possible closing opportunity, the nation waits for each out with bated breath
I had to fight with MLB all last season, ever since my IP address started showing me being in Connecticut (I'm in Boston), blacking me out from Mets and Yankees games.
But this year (so far) I've had no problems with those games even though my IP address still shows me in CT.
EDIT: Isiah Kiner-Falefa HR to RF makes it 3-0.
It always amazes me how many players haven't figured out yet that it benefits their teams AND their statlines to simply hit a homer every game. Seems pretty basic to me.
Kudos to Arenado on his epiphany! ;-)
Surely..SURELY they can right the ship, get 6 outs without giving up more then 3 runs and keep pace with the other, close to the bottom dwellers, NY and Toronto.
NY and Toronto in a tight one, 3-3, looks to be a good game between 2 good teams. The Orioles continue to roll, sinking the Angels 7-3, the dynamic duo went 0 for 8, making it quite hard for the Angels to get it done when those guys have a bad day.
No peeking.
my baseball pal and events junkie (still goes to well over 100 sporting events/concerts a year) mentioned last night that something was odd about Mets ticket prices for this game.
Verlander's first home start as a Met, yet you could get 4th row upper deck for $14 and mid-level seats for around $40. this afternoon on WFAN radio, a host/Mets season ticketholder said he was shocked at how zero the buzz was for the game. said "get in the door" price had sunk to $4.
at the time of first pitch, there were entire sections in the upper deck that sat empty and many others who had single-digit attendance. buzz indeed was zero.
Verlander allowed a 3-2 count, 2-out, 3-run HR to Paredes in the third inning, a run in the 4th, and then a 2-run shot by Paredes (dos Paredes - a jai alai joke!) in the 5th.
that brought the boo birds out of the woodwork, as it was coupled by a lifeless offense that mustered only two singles through five innings.
a scoreboard glitch left the Rays' logo on the board for a minute before that was fixed.
for the 7th inning stretch, almost no one stood up. maybe I missed a scoreboard prompt, because the song was performed by a group of disabled performers who were not standing. and then hardly anyone got up for the subsequent dopey song, either.
perhaps the worst indignity came in the 8th inning, when the crowd chose a Celine Dion song as the sing-a-long, beating out Billy Joel and maybe Journey or something.
I'd have been fine with it if it was the theme from "Titanic," as the Mets were coming off a sinking-feeling (too soon?) 4-9 stretch - all against sub-.500 teams. but it was not, alas.
something has to give with the Mets.
(rank, player, years, K, IP)
10. Greg Maddux+ (23) 3371 5008
11. Phil Niekro+ (24) 3342 5404
12. MAX SCHERZER (16, 38) 3219 2710
13. JUSTIN VERLANDER (18, 40) 3213 3180
14. Fergie Jenkins+ (19) 3192 4501
15. Pedro Martinez+ (18) 3154 2827
16. Bob Gibson+ (17) 3117 3884
17. Curt Schilling (20) 3116 3261
18. CC Sabathia (19) 3093 3577
19. John Smoltz+ (21) 3084 3473
20. Zack Greinke (20, 39) 2914 3294
21. Clayton Kershaw (16, 35) 2863 2631
................
57. John Lackey (15) 2294 2840
58. Dwight Gooden (16) 2293 2801
59. Lefty Grove+ (17) 2266 3941
60. Eddie Plank+ (17) 2246 4496
61. Tommy John (26) 2245 4710
62. James Shields (13) 2234 2616
63. Jim Palmer+ (19) 2212 3948
64. Jake Peavy (15) 2207 2377
65. David Wells (21) 2201 3439
66. Grover Alexander+ (20) 2198 5190
67. Vida Blue (17) 2175 3343
68. Camilo Pascual (18) 2167 2931
69. Tim Wakefield (19) 2156 3226
70. ADAM WAINWRIGHT (18, 41) 2154 2577
71. Dennis Martinez (23) 2149 4000
72. CHRIS SALE (13, 34) 2118 1721
73. Roy Halladay+ (16) 2117 2749
74. Kevin Millwood (16) 2083 2720
75. Bobo Newsom (20) 2082 3759
76. Tim Hudson (17) 2080 3127
77. David Price (14) 2076 2143
78. Ryan Dempster (16) 2075 2387
79. Fernando Valenzuela (17) 2074 2930
80. MADISON BUMGARNER (15, 33) 2070 2209
81. Dazzy Vance+ (16) 2045 2967
82. Rick Reuschel (19) 2015 3548
83. Orel Hershiser (18) 2014 3130
84. Dan Haren (13) 2013 2420
85. Catfish Hunter+ (15) 2012 3449
86. Andy Benes (14) 2000 2505
87. Billy Pierce (18) 1999 3307
88. Kevin Appier (16) 1994 2595
89. GERRIT COLE (11, 32) 1992 1707
Ron Marinaccio
Oh come on, this is a fictional character. I'm going with a handsome plumber who comes over to fix a leak and makes Chachi jealous on the short-lived Joanie Loves Chachi.
So Mets fans did as they should do when that idiotic song in the 7th inning comes on, which is ignore it and carry on your conversations. (or were you just pointing out the fact nobody stretched, if so, my bad... nobody should respect God Bless America, and people who do are dissing the national anthem...but if you were talking they didn't even get out of their seat to stretch, that is something else entirely)
Here's the list of 2010 debuts. That's 203 players and, just eyeballing it, I get 15 guys I'm pretty sure made it and another 11 guys who might have depending on how often they got sent up and down. Say half that later group made it and we're at 20-21. If the actual number is still a bit short of 10%, I bet a statement like 10% of those vested (43 days or whatever) reach full vestiture (10 years) would be about right. It's particularly surprising to me because even guys like Yonder Alonso and Pedro Alvarez come up a bit short. But 10 of these guys are still active, that's 5% right there.
Now the explosion in pitcher debuts due to the AAA shuttle won't have been included in those rates yet since of course they haven't even had a chance to reach 10 years. Last year there were 303 debuts, an increase of 100 (50%) vs 2010. Maybe 10% will appear in parts of 10+ seasons but there are a whole bunch of guys who will probably need 7 calendar years to get to 3 service years mixed in there.
I'll admit I started with "there's no way that's true" but here we are. I'm trying to decide whether I instinctively thought there are way more debuts than that (that was only about 7 per team in 2010) or did I think there are way fewer guys who make it to 10 years. The latter doesn't seem that high in retrospect -- basically a team will debut an average of 2 guys every 3 years who make it to 10 years service time.
Cub debuts 2010 and their final season (not necessarily full service years of course)
Darwin Barney 2017
Andrew Cashner 2019
Welington Castillo 2019
Starlin Castro 2021 (he made it)
Casey Coleman 2014
Thomas Diamond 2010
Scott Maine 2012
Marcus Mateo 2015
James Russell 2016
Brian Schlitter 2019
Brad Snyder 2014
If like me you're wonder "who's Brian Schlitter?" that was 8 IP in 2010, 56 in 2014, 7 in 2015 and 10 in 2019 for 81 IP and a 76 ERA+ and, unless there was some MLB IL time in there, probably no more than 1.5 years service time. We'll be seeing a lot more guys like that now.
Anyway, Castro made it. Castillo didn't really make the majors until mid-2012 and probably ended up in the range of 7-8 service years. Cashner looks to have missed by just 2 months. Unless maybe he made some team's IL in 2020 (the pandemic may have caused some guys to just miss who would have made it otherwise ... or maybe it helped push a few guys over).
A lot of moving parts in one day, but having Carlson be day to day, while trying to keep three catchers on the roster was probably not a good plan. And Walker is struggling in AAA so no reason to call him back up right now.
the song few got up for, iirc, was "Take Me Out To The Ballgame."
At first I took it as another sign of ennui, but upon noticing that the choir that sang it consisted of an all-wheelchair lineup, I realized I might have missed a prompt on the scoreboard?
The next song, the terrible one, I think it "Tarantella." that was a recording, so I can't explain why so few got up for that one (it sucking is a good reason, but typically most people stand up for it and clap along like seals).
per 187, the Knicks and Rangers have been selling out for decades at MSG, and I've never heard of a weakness like this on the secondary market. this is Mets-specific in NYC.
Ahh... so no god bless America garbage that every other team since 9/11 has been doing in the 7th inning stretch... That is good to hear, it's not like Tarantella(whatever the #### that is---googled it, still don't know) could possibly be worse than gba.
wtf
"The New York Yankees, at Yankee Stadium home games, are currently the only Major League club to play "God Bless America" at every game during the seventh-inning stretch."
normally I wouldn't be so trusting of wikipedia, but I knew your response was a huge miss, so I'll trust them here.
ok, I won't. apparently some teams play God Bless America on Sundays, or at least did as of 5-7 years ago.
found this, from 2019, after Yankees (and Flyers) stopped using the 1939 Kate Smith version of GBA:
"The accusations against Smith stem from her recordings of “That’s Why Darkies Were Born,” which included the lyrics, “Someone had to pick the cotton… That’s why darkies were born.” She also recorded the offensive jingle “Pickaninny Heaven,” which she directed at “colored children” who should fantasize about an amazing place with “great big watermelons,” among other treats."
I haven't been to a game since 2020, just going by the last few times I went and had to listen to that absolute garbage of a song. At my age, a year or two ago is just like yesterday. (or 2019...before the pandemic)
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main