User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
Page rendered in 0.8138 seconds
45 querie(s) executed
| ||||||||
You are here > Home > Baseball Newsstand > Discussion
| ||||||||
Baseball Primer Newsblog — The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand Friday, April 30, 2021Position Players Are Suddenly — and Probably Fleetingly — Decent at Pitching
RoyalsRetro (AG#1F)
Posted: April 30, 2021 at 12:23 PM | 47 comment(s)
Login to Bookmark
Tags: position players pitching |
Login to submit news.
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks. Hot TopicsNewsblog: Pete Rose brushes off question about alleged sex with minor: ‘It was 55 years ago, babe’
(97 - 3:21pm, Aug 10) Last: Perry Newsblog: Quite a Sho: Ohtani ties Ruth, passes Ichiro in same game (4 - 3:20pm, Aug 10) Last: RoyalsRetro (AG#1F) Newsblog: 2022 NBA Playoffs thread (4124 - 3:17pm, Aug 10) Last: 57i66135 is a hard word for me. Newsblog: OMNICHATTER for the week of August 8-15, 2022 (141 - 3:10pm, Aug 10) Last: Banta Newsblog: Yankees DH Matt Carpenter fractures left foot on foul ball (15 - 2:11pm, Aug 10) Last: BDC Newsblog: Rodolfo Castro loses phone while diving into third in Pirates’ loss (2 - 1:25pm, Aug 10) Last: cHiEf iMpaCt oFfiCEr JE Newsblog: Ejected Twins manager Rocco Baldelli blasts overturned call in loss to Jays as 'one of the worst moments' of umpiring he has ever seen (41 - 1:00pm, Aug 10) Last: Mayor Blomberg Newsblog: Rays’ trip to Milwaukee may turn into a ghost story (10 - 12:53pm, Aug 10) Last: Steve Parris, Je t'aime Newsblog: Red Sox pitcher Chris Sale fractures wrist riding bike, is out for 2022 season (34 - 12:16pm, Aug 10) Last: Nasty Nate Newsblog: Atlanta Braves sending struggling right-handed starting pitcher Ian Anderson to minors (6 - 2:09am, Aug 10) Last: Googly Newsblog: Minor League Baseball player Solomon Bates says he is gay, has been out to teammates since 2019 (4 - 1:18am, Aug 10) Last: Banta Newsblog: This angle of Mets closer Edwin Díaz's absolutely electric bullpen entrance is so darn awesome (11 - 12:47am, Aug 10) Last: Hombre Brotani Newsblog: Boston Red Sox sign Jeurys Familia to minor league deal; ex-Mets closer had 6.09 ERA with Phillies this year (4 - 8:18pm, Aug 09) Last: the Hugh Jorgan returns Newsblog: Boston Red Sox release outfielder Jackie Bradley Jr. (16 - 7:39pm, Aug 09) Last: Snowboy Newsblog: Jason Heyward, despite another year left on contract, won't be back with Chicago Cubs in 2023, Jed Hoyer says (28 - 7:09pm, Aug 09) Last: Stop Oppressing Zonk by Investigating His Heroes |
|||||||
About Baseball Think Factory | Write for Us | Copyright © 1996-2021 Baseball Think Factory
User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
|
| Page rendered in 0.8138 seconds |
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. John Northey Posted: April 30, 2021 at 12:44 PM (#6016309)I'd love for more teams to find super-utility guys who can pitch and hit enough to be useful in both roles. Not star level like Ohtani but decent enough to use in games with big spreads to save the pen while also being useful on other days as a backup infielder or outfielder or (in a perfect world) catcher. Oh for a utility guy who can catch and pitch.
Now Trevor Megill is your standard 27-yo AAAA fodder that you expect in a blowout. (Megill might be AAA fodder.)
I haven’t watched the Cubs much at all this year because I switched to YouTube tv when we moved to this house in fall 2019. Probably for the best.
I recognize the name because his 2013 Strat-O-Matic pitching card was really good (2-1, 1.74, 19 saves in 72 games for COLORADO!) but I had no idea until today that he was still pitching in the majors.
I would have sworn it did, given the huge thread it started here last year. Is it indeed in effect for this season?
good breeding - his Dad was Vernon Law, who won 162 games for the Pirates in the 1950s and 1960s (6th-most in franchise history), going a combined 38-18 in 1959-60 including winning the Cy Young Award in 1960.
(fyi, Vernon is now 91 years young)
When a team brings in a position player as a pitcher starting in the 7th inning, it is, in effect, waving a white flag. Given that there could be a good 40 minutes left in the game, what on Earth is the incentive to keep watching the game?
I mean, I guess it is a little like when an NFL team pulls their starting QB, but even that isn't as bad, for a few reasons: 1) At least it is still a f**king quarterback! And if it is a young QB, there is something entertaining as a fan to seeing a guy who could be a future starter for your team. 2) Gambling. Because of both the fantasy football consequences of how a blowout is handled, and because point spreads are such a big deal, there is a level of suspense that simply does not exist in any sport's blowouts. 3) Scarcity. As an avid NFL fan, this is the only chance you'll have to watch your team for a week - and one of only 16 (well, now 17) times the whole year you'll get to see your team play. You probably carved out time time block to watch the game, anyway, and the game is probably on during a Sunday afternoon or early evening, so it is not like most baseball games, where you actually have a chance to get more sleep if you cut out early.
I love baseball, but I am really concerned that the "gimmick" element is really increasing as a misguided response to legitimate structural problems to which MLB is struggling to respond. I think there is a smart approach to this, as somebody described the "Vance Law" idea in this thread. If baseball is going to start bringing in position players 10-20 times a year when ever it is 10-2 in the 7th inning or something, then find a guy who is basically like Brock Holt, plays all over the diamond, pitched a lot in high school and can throw 80 without too much effort, and tell them they are going to probably pitch 30 innings this year in garbage time.
I guess some of the extreme load management things teams have done in basketball, where stars just don't play in games toward the end of the season. I seem to recall that the NBA was trying to find ways to clamp down on that, but I don't know how well they did. Not quite the same, although it's still prizing season-level resource management over winning the game people paid money to see.
How many other sports have the sort of schedules where single games can be thrown away relatively casually? That basketball example really only seemed to happen when things were more or less decided, not earlier on when things could go either way.
College basketball emptying the bench at the end of blowouts.
Their choice was down to their goalie coach (rejected because his career had ended due to injuries) and a forward in the press box who had last played goalie when he was 12 years old. He had to dress but wasn't forced to play.
In the sense of players being used in positions they're not accustomed to by the losing team, intentionally, there's nothing remotely comparable.
I think there are two prime reasons why: first, a baseball game's length is governed by outs, not time. In a blowout in the other sports, a win/loss can be managed by taking simple measures to run out the clock (and the clock itself will have moved toward the end naturally just as much in a blowout as a tight contest). There isn't that luxury in baseball.
Second, pitching is the only position that's seen as cumulatively taxing. Pitching may not be more inherently dangerous than playing any NFL position, but the next snap in the NFL isn't seen as more likely to injure/tire than the last one the way pitching is.
Resting starters (the way the NBA does with load management, or the NFL does with post-clinching in Games 15-16) may be somewhat similar, but baseball was already using that model in most cases, as few players ever participate in all 162.
European soccer teams often play heavily rotated sides in lesser cup competitions. In England it some teams seem to intentionally tank in the lesser of the two domestic cups (the League Cup) in order to reduce the number of games they have to play. It's like the NBA's load management, but sometimes more extreme.
Nowadays they can find replacement kickers in a day or two. I think the Steelers were somewhat old fashioned back in the day and had no one to call up.
in the 1960s and 1970s, it wasn't that unusual for a position player to double as a punter.
Pat McInally of the Bengals was a punter who caught 57 passes in his career. Larry Seiple of the Dolphins was a fine punter and receiver/running back.
Gary Collins of the Browns in the 1960s was a good WR and the team's punter for six seasons.
Dennis Partee spent four seasons with the Chargers, late 60s/early 70s, as both the punter and the placekicker. that's a weird one - because if he pulls a hamstring in mid-game....
but the athletic punter is an unexploited opportunity. Seiple for instance a couple of times faked a punt but was not the "squirrel in traffic" sort that you see nowadays on such a play - he was a legit NFL runner.
Bryan Holaday, who is currently in the Diamondbacks organization, is a backup catcher who has pitched five games in the majors since 2016. He's given up one home run, which was to third baseman Mitch Walding of the Phillies in 2018. That wasn't only Walding's sole career home run, it was his only career hit. Walding is 1 for 19 (.053) with 14 strikeouts, which has to be one of the worst career marks for a position player. And for his only hit to come off a catcher makes it even worse...
I guess the closest thing the NFL has come to using a non-QB as a QB was this past season when the Broncos started Kendall Hinton, a practice squad wide receiver who last played QB as a junior for Wake Forest in 2018 (very very briefly) before converting to receiver for his senior season, because all 3 of Denver's rostered QB's plus their practice squad QB were covid-ineligible. In his start against the Saints, Hinton completed 1 of 9 passes for 13 yards with 2 sacks, an interception, 2 rushes for 7 yards, and a QB rating of 0.0. Denver had 6 first downs and 112 total yards of offense. New Orleans won 31-3. Denver's field goal was from 58 yards and ended a 4 play drive that gained 1 yard.
Multi-position (including kicker and other position) players were common in the CFL for about a decade and a half after they ceased to be a thing in the NFL. Smaller rosters made it tough to carry specialists. With only 10 guys on the bench you often saw things like the backup QB starting at safety.
The position player as pitcher is different because in virtually every case (save the occasional Brett Mayne type of appearance), the managers are choosing to use an out-of-position player to pitch when he has players who perform that role available. Other than as part of a gimmick (like someone was doing a Bert Campaneris-Cesar Tovar equivalent on the final day of the season), I don't think that type of deployment happens in any other sport.
I'm not sure that the wildcat packages in the NFL are a million miles away - I know coaches think that they're doing it for some kind of advantage but mostly it's just to have some random skill player run it for 2 yards and is basically a waste of down. This goes double for wildcat plays where the QB is lined up at WR, where I guess the idea is that you're making the defense think that there's some kind of gimmick Philly-special kind of play on tap, but most of the time the QB just stands there or half-heartedly pretends to run the first few steps of a route.
It's different, of course, because NFL coaches are all SUPERGENIUSES who would never never ever do something so frivolous as "waste a down" and instead it's really 11th-dimensional football chess to psyche out the opposing defenses or whatever. But in reality, most of the time it's just a dumb play with guys out of position. Sometimes it works! But also sometimes Anthony Rizzo strikes out Freddie Freeman.
When I was at Louisiana Tech in the late 80's, the women's basketball team was in a run of several consecutive Final Four appearances including a couple of national championships when they joined a new conference including a school who was fielding a women's basketball team for the first time. When they visited Tech, it went about as you might expect. Tech's starters played the first half only, but they all swapped roles. Our 6'4" 240-pound All-American center hung out on the perimeter where she knocked down a few 3's and our 5'8" 160-pound All-American point guard played the low post. The second and third team players played all the second half. Tech still won by 101 points, 126-25.
He let in the first two shots by the Leafs, but then stopped the remaining 8 shots and Carolina won the game.
He got a standing ovation from the Toronto fans when he was announced as the first star.
Lou Michaels kicker/defensive end.
Lou Groza also kicker/defensive end.
Wayne Walker also defensive player/kicker
I can't even remember the last time I saw an emergency catcher.
This is exactly what I mean about the increased level of gimmickry in baseball as a poor response to the problems the game is facing. Look at the clip of Rizzo pitching to the Braves - Rizzo is literally giggling and smirking the whole time...it is literally a joke to the people involved. If this was the 19th inning of a game, that'd be one thing - but this is the 7th inning! It is kind of fun the first time or two you see it, but after that, it signals to us, as fans, that this game is over, and you should not bother watching the rest of it, and we are all just trying to get this over with as quickly as possible.
If this is where MLB is going, then just have a mercy rule. The point of bringing in Rizzo was to avoid using a pitcher, right? And to make sure nobody gets hurt? Well, listen to the announcers during Rizzo's appearance - they are like, "make sure you don't get nailed, Anthony!" Remember when Jose Canseco pitched an inning, and then he hurt his arm doing so?
To me, this isn't like putting in the backup quarterback...it is like putting in a defensive back who played QB in high school or something when all of your regular QBs are healthy and available. It just doesn't happen, even in a 44-0 game, because it would degrade the product.
Perhaps this bothers me, as a lifelong baseball fan, more than it should, but this communicates to the viewing public that these games just aren't that valuable. If you want to argue the opposite - that it is communicating the value of your 8th relief pitcher is so high that it is not worth using them in a blowout loss - then I guess it is absurdly-cautious managing...but it is also saying that the games themselves aren't that valuable, on a day-to-day basis. The NBA is already dealing with this lack of value of regular-season games with the increased "holding out" of start players in late-season games. It seems like baseball is increasingly acknowledging, similarly, this lack of value.
Oh they were. Bench players were rolling and high-5ing each other when Venus Lacy hit her first 3. They passed to her alone on the perimeter. After a few seconds of standing there, no one came out to guard her and the bench starting yelling for her to shoot. So she did. Even here, a key difference is that Tech wasn't conceding the game. They were trying to keep it as competitive as possible. If they would have played the game like they played Tennessee or Texas or any of the other national powers of the time, the final would have been something like 253-7.
Also, co-signing your "gimmickry" comments.
If you had to sub in a non-goalkeeper, wouldn't you rather do it in the shootout, which is mostly luck anyway?
EDIT: I do know that the NHL eventually took to running any proposed rule change past Neilson. He was a genius in terms of figuring out how to exploit rules but his own integrity wouldn't permit him to lie if asked directly about something (though he'd never volunteer the info. He'd save the exploit for a key situation if not asked)
If a team is up by at least 8 runs in the 7th inning or later, they can choose to have the trailing team play out their remaining batting innings before the leading team does.
Simple, gets blowout games over with, does exactly what we want to get rid of the lame-duck farce innings without affecting anything else, no major statistical fallout (not playing out some half-innings is the same as not playing the bottom of the 9th currently.)
Neilson is the only coach or manager I ever came across who would have his dog - Labrador retriever, iirc - sitting at his feet as he did post-practice interviews. also as smart a man who ever served as a leader of athletes.
it was a shame that he and Mark Messier clashed, because each was a delight to deal with. so Neilson had to go - and a year+ later, the Rangers won the Stanley Cup under Mike Keenan.
that ended a 54-year drought for the Rangers - who are now halfway toward reach that mark once again
but enough about blowouts and sports
As is, the easiest way within the rules to forfeit is "when a team is unable or refuses to place nine players on the field." But if there were a league-issued method for forfeiting, aka the manager telling it to the ump just like an automatic walk, maybe the perception would change over time. Of course, in the interim we'll have to hear people complain about what real men do and people not getting their full money's worth, but that will all diminish over time, too.
If I was down 16-0 ... then maybe it's time to lighten the mood a little and throw some guys a bone. But 10-0 seems, I dunno, indulgent I guess.
As long as performance-based bonuses remain in contracts, the players should fight any attempt by management to arbitrarily shorten games. (Understanding that seven-inning doubleheaders are an exceptional case that should go away once pandemic restrictions subside.)
Yeah, that's what I was thinking when I typed it. Shortening games could potentially affect players' abilities to reach bonus or contract vesting clauses based on playing time, games finished, etc.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main