Baseball for the Thinking Fan

Login | Register | Feedback

btf_logo
You are here > Home > Baseball Newsstand > Discussion
Baseball Primer Newsblog
— The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand

Thursday, September 29, 2022

Roger Maris Jr. blasts MLB, says Aaron Judge’s potential 62nd home run should be single-season record

“I think it means a lot, not just for me, I think it means a lot for a lot of people,” he explained. “He’s clean, he’s a Yankee, he plays the game the right way. I think it gives people a chance to look at somebody who should be revered for hitting 62 home runs and not just as a guy who did it in the American League. He should be revered for being the actual single-season home run champ. That’s really who he is if he hits 62 and I think that’s what needs to happen. I think baseball needs to look at the records and I think baseball should do something.”

Maris has shared his opinion on the matter in the past as well, but MLB hasn’t expunged their record books of Bonds’ 73 home runs in 2001, as it still stands to be the number to beat in the regular season. All three players, though, haven’t been inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.

RoyalsRetro (AG#1F) Posted: September 29, 2022 at 12:54 PM | 122 comment(s) Login to Bookmark
  Tags: aaron judge, barry bonds, roger maris

Reader Comments and Retorts

Go to end of page

Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.

Page 2 of 2 pages  < 1 2
   101. AuntBea odeurs de parfum de distance sociale Posted: October 03, 2022 at 10:56 AM (#6098843)
There are more plate appearances in higher scoring years, and more plate appearances for higher scoring teams. The Dodgers had 38.63 plate appearances per game this year while the A's faced only 36.15--a bigger relative difference then 162 v 154.
   102. Misirlou cut his hair and moved to Rome Posted: October 03, 2022 at 11:22 AM (#6098849)
And that difference is even bigger when you consider that the Dodgers batted in only 8 innings in 52 games compared to just 21 for the A's (home wins that were not WOs). The Dodgers did play in 4 more extra innings, but that's still 27 fewer batting innings for the Dodgers.
   103. Mefisto Posted: October 03, 2022 at 11:29 AM (#6098851)
Every player has the theoretical opportunity to play in all of his team's games. It's silly to implicitly reward a player for missing games and PAs.


By this logic we should penalize Ruth, who missed 3 games while Maris missed only 1.

ETA: What Aunt Bea and Miserlou said.
   104. Mefisto Posted: October 03, 2022 at 11:36 AM (#6098855)
As for the claim that 162 is meaningfully more than 154, that would seem to be something to be *shown* not just asserted.
   105. SoSH U at work Posted: October 03, 2022 at 11:36 AM (#6098856)
By this logic we should penalize Ruth, who missed 3 games while Maris missed only 1.


Maris missed two. He sat out one game against Hoyt and Game 160 against a lefty. However, Ruth missed four. Both teams had tie games that season.
   106. SoSH U at work Posted: October 03, 2022 at 11:37 AM (#6098857)
As for the claim that 162 is meaningfully more than 154, that would seem to be something to be *shown* not just asserted.


Really? The opportunity to play and (get plate appearances) in eight extra games needs to be explained.

Is it possible to get fewer PAs playing 162 games than 154? Sure. It's not going to happen bloody often.
   107. Ron J Posted: October 03, 2022 at 12:51 PM (#6098877)
The 1927 Yankees had 6227 PAs in 155 games. The 1922 Yankees have had 6029 in 158 (which is roughly 6220 in 163 games). Team OBP of .384 in 1927. That helps create extra PAs.

Or to bring it back to Ruth/ Judge, Ruth had 691 PAs in 151 games. Judge had 6 fewer in 3 more games. Ruth was lifted early 18 times on top of that. 723 PAs for the number 3 spot (which is the only spot Ruth batted in)

   108. ERROR---Jolly Old St. Nick Posted: October 03, 2022 at 01:06 PM (#6098879)
It pretty much all boils down to this: Everyone knows the length of a schedule without having to look it up. The idea of using PA's as an alternative standard for counting stats is crazy. Setting a minimum number of PAs for rate stat leaders is another thing altogether, but of course we do this already.

As for the claim that 162 is meaningfully more than 154, that would seem to be something to be *shown* not just asserted.

But as SoSH and I have both pointed out, the same logic could be used to justify admitting counting stat records from a pre-expansion PCL length season, which in some years ran to over 200 games.
   109. Mefisto Posted: October 03, 2022 at 01:32 PM (#6098885)
But as SoSH and I have both pointed out, the same logic could be used to justify admitting counting stat records from a pre-expansion PCL length season, which in some years ran to over 200 games.


You're dodging the fact that your previous comment made no sense. At any rate, the definition of "season" is arbitrary. *At some point* the extra games matter. In the specific case of Ruth/Maris (or Ruth/Judge), they don't because the difference in PAs is not substantial.

Both teams had tie games that season.


I know that but didn't mention it because it's irrelevant -- neither homered in the tie game.
   110. SoSH U at work Posted: October 03, 2022 at 01:57 PM (#6098889)


In the specific case of Ruth/Maris (or Ruth/Judge), they don't because the difference in PAs is not substantial.


So do you how do you feel about Ichiro and Sisler? Because the extra games sure as hell mattered there.

I know that but didn't mention it because it's irrelevant -- neither homered in the tie game.


That's an odd explanation, but yes, since they both missed games it's a wash.
   111. BDC Posted: October 03, 2022 at 02:59 PM (#6098899)
the definition of "season" is arbitrary. *At some point* the extra games matter. In the specific case of Ruth/Maris (or Ruth/Judge), they don't because the difference in PAs is not substantial

I can sort of see that, particularly if the longer season had fewer PAs per game (as Ron notes; 1927 Yankees had 40, 1961 Yankees had 38.3, 2022 Yankees have 38.2).

Still, more is more. Maris did have seven more PAs than Ruth. When you're hitting a home run every 11 PAs, that's an edge.

Though in practice, more didn't turn out to be much more. I think there was this fear – I dunno, fear is too strong, this faint suspicion anyway :) – back in 1961-62, that numerous records might fall. The first year the AL went to 162, the HR record; the first year the NL did, the stolen-base record. (Which was much less famous, but salient enough within baseball at the time, of course.)

But then it turned out to be nothing to worry much about. If anybody groused about Denny McLain needing 162 games to win 30, I don't remember it (though in fact I do remember him doing it early in 1968, and looking it up, he won #30 in game #151).

After lots of years of batters struggling just to reach 50 HR on rare occasions, the 162/154 thing became a kind of who-cares. Meanwhile it took another 40+ years for the Hits record to fall, and the RBI and Runs records haven't, etc.
   112. Mefisto Posted: October 03, 2022 at 03:00 PM (#6098901)
@110: When it matters, the difference should be noted. In the case of Ichiro and Sisler that difference would be obvious to anyone who sees that Sisler's 257 hits gained him a BA of .407, whereas Ichiro's 262 hits were good for an average of "only" .372. (Note that there are lots of other differences too and my view is that Ichiro's accomplishment is more impressive, but that's not the issue here.)
   113. Mefisto Posted: October 03, 2022 at 03:06 PM (#6098903)
Still, more is more. Maris did have seven more PAs than Ruth. When you're hitting a home run every 11 PAs, that's an edge.


Yes Maris had a slight edge, though mostly because Ruth missed games. But that difference was small enough that it was never worth re-defining a "season" over it; nobody thinks we should re-define a season because A got 7 more PAs than B. I get your point about concerns at the time, but those concerns never happened, as you noted, and the "two season" approach to the record book still never got reconsidered. It was all incredibly unfair to Maris.
   114. SoSH U at work Posted: October 03, 2022 at 03:19 PM (#6098910)
It was all incredibly unfair to Maris.


And this is what I think gets to the heart of the objections. Because the idea was founded in this attempt to discredit Maris, a loathsome pursuit, any kind of subsequent and benign acknowledgement of the different season lengths must be forever sidelined.

For half of baseball history (by now), you had seasons of 154 games scheduled. Then you expanded to 162 scheduled. When you're looking at seasonal counting stats, that matters. Now obviously, you can rack up as many or more PAs in a 154-game season than a 162*. But on average, the guy playing the 162-game schedule is going to get about an extra 35 trips to the plate. I see no real harm in acknowledging that in the record book. Because as unfair as it would have been to Maris to recognize that he hit 61 in 162 while Babe hit 60 in 154, it seems a lot more unfair to Sisler to just note that Ichiro has 262. But that's where we are.

I don't know how football handles it, but OJ's 2003 yards in a 14-game schedule should be at least recognized alongside Dickerson's 2,1something in 16. Also, if you want to put an asterisk next to Juice's line in the record book that he was a murderer, that's quite all right.

*FWIW, the real opportunity difference is probably greater than 7. Both Maris and Ruth are credited with zero IBBs in 1961. But they didn't begin counting them until 1928, so Ruth likely was given four wide ones on a few occasions which aren't included. And for the sake of this discussion, an IBB is not a legit opportunity to homer.
   115. A triple short of the cycle Posted: October 03, 2022 at 03:31 PM (#6098916)
So whose opinion about "the 'real' home run record" does matter?

Goose Gossage. Has he weighed in yet?
   116. Mefisto Posted: October 03, 2022 at 03:39 PM (#6098919)
Because the idea was founded in this attempt to discredit Maris, a loathsome pursuit, any kind of subsequent and benign acknowledgement of the different season lengths must be forever sidelined.


I don't have any problem with acknowledging the different season lengths *when it matters*. I just think it didn't matter in the specific case which originated the practice (and for bad reasons at that, as you say).

But they didn't begin counting them until 1928, so Ruth likely was given four wide ones on a few occasions which aren't included. And for the sake of this discussion, an IBB is not a legit opportunity to homer.


That's fair, though most pitchers probably weren't thrilled by the "opportunity" to face Gehrig with an additional runner on base.
   117. ERROR---Jolly Old St. Nick Posted: October 03, 2022 at 03:51 PM (#6098921)
At any rate, the definition of "season" is arbitrary.

A season is a season, but a 140 game season and a 154 game season and a 162 game season afford different levels of difficulties for accumulating counting stats. Introducing PAs into the mix just complicates a straightforward standard that's been used forever, whether or not you choose to differentiate between 154 and 162 game seasons. (I would, but that distinction is no longer officially recognized.)

You still haven't indicated how a PA standard would be expressed in the record books without cluttering up the page. I'd like to see your ranked list of home run champions where the raw home run totals are combined with a varying number of HR / PA percentages. Just to take a simple example, who would be the home run champion if Player A had 62 home runs in 600 PAs while Player B had 61 home runs in 550 PAs, and Player C had 59 home runs in only 500 PAs?

And so on. How many lines in the record book would you need to have for that, and how many asterisks? Or would you just have one ranking for total home runs, and a separate ranking for HR / PAs, presumably with a minimum number of PAs required for inclusion? That would be like the AB per HR lists on BB-Reference, where FTR Judge now ranks third on a career basis behind McGwire and Ruth.
   118. ERROR---Jolly Old St. Nick Posted: October 03, 2022 at 03:54 PM (#6098922)
So whose opinion about "the 'real' home run record" does matter?

Goose Gossage. Has he weighed in yet?


Gossage's only quoted opinion is that George Brett should be permanently disqualified for all batting titles for using pine tar on his bat.
   119. Ron J Posted: October 03, 2022 at 04:43 PM (#6098927)
#116 And Ruth walked a lot even playing in a nearly impossible HR park during dead ball -- and before he'd established himself as a major offensive threat. Still, 1927 was the first time Gehrig had established himself as an elite offensive player. Yeah he had a really good 1926 but nothing that's change the other team's decisions. Bob Meusel would have been regarded as the number 2 power hitter for most of 1926. If I had to guess in 1927 Ruth got around 10-15 IBBs.

If you read accounts in 1923 you'll see a lot of pitchers were giving Ruth the same kind of approach prime Bonds got. Hell, he had an OBP of about .715 with a base open in 1923. By 1927 his OBP with a runner on second (only) his OBP was "only" .491 and only .436 with a runner on third. Second and third it was .722 and you only get that kind of OBP with a fair number of IBB.
   120. Mefisto Posted: October 03, 2022 at 06:06 PM (#6098944)
a 140 game season and a 154 game season and a 162 game season afford different levels of difficulties for accumulating counting stats.


I guess you should therefore define "season" a different way each time: 140 games; 143 games; 154 games; 162 games; and I suppose every 1 game interval in between.
   121. BDC Posted: October 03, 2022 at 06:48 PM (#6098950)
I don't know how football handles it, but OJ's 2003 yards in a 14-game schedule should be at least recognized alongside Dickerson's 2,1something in 16

That's an interesting issue. I don't know that the NFL cares very much about its own history, or tries to manage it in that way officially. F-Ref throws all single-season records together, so Dickerson is 1st, OJ is 8th, and Jim Brown is 76th for the best 12-game season: 1,527 yards in 12 games is still pretty jaw-dropping. And now the season is 17 games and might be 18 before long …

I was mentioning this on Discord because I didn't know without looking it up: Dickerson holds the NFL and NFC single-season rushing-yards records. Who holds the AFC record? Basically, again, it's kind of who-cares unless you are a fairly clued-in or local fan. At least with Judge / Maris /Ruth we are unlikely to forget the AL leaderboard for a while yet. Though I suspect "league" baseball records will decline in interest going forward.
   122. SoSH U at work Posted: October 03, 2022 at 07:06 PM (#6098954)
I'll guess that guy from the Titans. Not the current guy, but the really fast guy before him.

Edit: Turns out he's fourth, behind the Broncos' undeserving Hall of Famer, the Titans current guy and the guy I never would have remembered.
Page 2 of 2 pages  < 1 2

You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.

 

 

<< Back to main

BBTF Partner

Dynasty League Baseball

Support BBTF

donate

Thanks to
Adam S
for his generous support.

You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks.

Hot Topics

Newsblog2023 NBA Regular Season Thread
(352 - 10:27pm, Feb 04)
Last: DCA

NewsblogRed Sox manager Alex Cora on his time with 2017 Astros, per new book: 'We stole that ... World Serie
(9 - 10:25pm, Feb 04)
Last: Jose is an Absurd Sultan

NewsblogBaseball Hall of Fame tracker 2023
(744 - 9:03pm, Feb 04)
Last: alilisd

NewsblogOrioles to decline 5-year Camden Yards lease extension, seek to secure long-term agreement
(75 - 9:01pm, Feb 04)
Last: greenback needs a ride, not ammo

Sox TherapyThe Future Starts Now (Hopefully)
(18 - 6:59pm, Feb 04)
Last: Captain Joe Bivens, Pointless and Wonderful

NewsblogOT Soccer Thread - Hi Ho Hi Ho it’s Back to Club Football We Go
(379 - 6:44pm, Feb 04)
Last: Biff, highly-regarded young guy

NewsblogMLB forms economic group as regional TV in peril
(2 - 6:14pm, Feb 04)
Last: Srul Itza

NewsblogMLB expansion: Nashville group led by Dave Stewart makes a pitch for Music City [$]
(26 - 3:00pm, Feb 04)
Last: DFA

NewsblogHow to Watch the Caribbean Series
(5 - 1:18pm, Feb 04)
Last: Jose is an Absurd Sultan

NewsblogThese MLB legends were trailblazers in Japan
(5 - 12:53pm, Feb 04)
Last: alilisd

Hall of MeritReranking Left Fielders: Results
(12 - 12:21am, Feb 04)
Last: Chris Cobb

NewsblogOT - 2022 NFL thread Part II
(330 - 11:03pm, Feb 03)
Last: Joyful Calculus Instructor

NewsblogSinclair’s Sports Channels Prepare Bankruptcy, Putting Team Payments at Risk
(26 - 7:01pm, Feb 03)
Last: Greg Franklin

Hall of MeritRanking Right Fielders in the Hall of Merit - Discussion thread
(43 - 6:03pm, Feb 03)
Last: Jaack

NewsblogJohn Adams, Who Banged His Drum in the Cleveland Bleachers, Has Died
(16 - 2:25pm, Feb 03)
Last: Barry`s_Lazy_Boy

Page rendered in 0.3160 seconds
45 querie(s) executed