User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
Page rendered in 0.5313 seconds
48 querie(s) executed
| ||||||||
You are here > Home > Baseball Newsstand > Discussion
| ||||||||
Baseball Primer Newsblog — The Best News Links from the Baseball Newsstand Friday, February 17, 2023Scott Rolen picks Cards cap, Fred McGriff skips logo for HOF
RoyalsRetro (AG#1F)
Posted: February 17, 2023 at 03:07 PM | 29 comment(s)
Login to Bookmark
Tags: cardinals, fred mcgriff, hall of fame, scott rolen |
Login to submit news.
You must be logged in to view your Bookmarks. Hot TopicsNewsblog: OT - November* 2023 College Football thread
(255 - 2:37am, Dec 03) Last: Lance Reddick! Lance him! Newsblog: Who is on the 2024 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot and what’s the induction process? (327 - 11:15pm, Dec 02) Last: chisoxcollector Newsblog: OT - NBA Redux Thread for the End of 2023 (119 - 10:11pm, Dec 02) Last: Tom Cervo, backup catcher Newsblog: Forbes: For MLB, Las Vegas, And Oakland, The A’s Name And Brand Should Stay Put (33 - 9:21pm, Dec 02) Last: Walt Davis Newsblog: Update on Yankees’ Juan Soto trade talks: Teams talking players, but not close on agreement (30 - 8:20pm, Dec 02) Last: The Yankee Clapper Newsblog: OT Soccer - World Cup Final/European Leagues Start (291 - 6:38pm, Dec 02) Last: Infinite Yost (Voxter) Newsblog: Hot Stove Omnichatter (52 - 3:21pm, Dec 02) Last: Howie Menckel Hall of Merit: Mock Hall of Fame 2024 Contemporary Baseball Ballot - Managers, Executives and Umpires (24 - 1:05pm, Dec 02) Last: cookiedabookie Newsblog: Zack Britton details analytics ‘rift’ that’s plaguing Yankees (8 - 8:11pm, Dec 01) Last: McCoy Hall of Merit: Hall of Merit Book Club (16 - 6:06pm, Dec 01) Last: ERROR---Jolly Old St. Nick Newsblog: Jackson Chourio extension: Brewers closing in on historic deal with MLB's No. 7 prospect, per report (19 - 4:54pm, Dec 01) Last: Rally Newsblog: Sportsnet's Ben Wagner out as voice of Blue Jays radio broadcasts (4 - 3:04pm, Dec 01) Last: Ron J Newsblog: Former Yankee Luis Severino agrees to 1-year, $13 million deal with Mets: reports (25 - 1:49pm, Dec 01) Last: Howie Menckel Newsblog: OT: Wrestling Thread November 2014 (3019 - 12:21pm, Dec 01) Last: a brief article regarding 57i66135 Newsblog: Reds, RHP Nick Martinez agree to $26M deal, sources say (9 - 10:39am, Dec 01) Last: RoyalsRetro (AG#1F) |
|||||||
About Baseball Think Factory | Write for Us | Copyright © 1996-2021 Baseball Think Factory
User Comments, Suggestions, or Complaints | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertising
|
| Page rendered in 0.5313 seconds |
Reader Comments and Retorts
Go to end of page
Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.
1. SoSH U at work Posted: February 17, 2023 at 03:50 PM (#6117659)Slap in the face to the back-to-back-to-back AAU champs.
Well played, folks.
The Hall will defer to the player's wishes, if it's reasonable. So Rolen can choose the Cards, but McGriff couldn't choose the Dodgers.
Why the Hall allows the trucker cap nonsense is beyond me.
Far easier to accept than Halladay's wife deciding he should not have a cap when he seemed to make it clear he was a Jay. I figure she was bitter still over the way the Jays handled his last few years here (the GM then was terrible) but the Jays after Halladay retired were trying to make it up to him with that one day contract to end his career where it began, and other little things. Instead we have Alomar as the only guy with a Jays cap on in the HOF ...sigh... great player, lousy person.
I cannot agree with this, I was hoping for Rolen to go logoless to be honest, he had most of his value as a Philly, they developed his talent, he spent 9 years as a Phillie(organization) compared to 6 for the Cardinals, I was going to be perfectly fine with him taking a logoless cap because of how his tenure there ended, I didn't think he should take the Cardinals cap. I'm happy he chose the Cardinals cap, but I think that is a disservice to the city of Philly in a way.
And as mentioned, McGriff really has no cap that belongs to him, if you squint you can say he should wear a Toronto cap, but that is still a tough call. In other cases of logoless caps, which team do you pick, Maddux was developed by the Cubs, spent 10 Ml seasons along with 4 in the minors... his war is greater with the Braves, but the Cubs made him the pitcher that they had.
I have no problem with logoless caps, it makes sense in the era of free agency, you can't ignore the 2-5 years a player spends in the organization before they reach the majors when talking about a hof player.
It doesn't make any sense. Players don't wear trucker hats on the diamond. Picking a logo doesn't exclude the other teams he played for from their part of his history.
It just an accurate representation of him as a major league ballplayer; it's not a knockoff baseball card set that wouldn't fork over the dollars for rights.
Heck many of the logos on the mlb cap changed during the career of the player, should they be forced to choose one logo to represent a particular year? I'm just not really understanding the argument, it's a cap on a person on a plaque.
What I know you've never seen is Greg Maddux wearing a baseball cap without a logo until his Hall of Fame plaque. Baseball players do not wear them on MLB diamonds.
The Hall plaque is designed to picture the player as fans best remember him. Yes, Scott Rolen can be best remembered as a Phil just as much as he can a Cardinal. But that's a reason to choose between the two, not this none of the above option which captures neither. And "going in as a Cardinal" does not in any way vacate his years with the Phils, Jays or Reds. It's just an honest representation of his career.
BBRef doesn't show Scott Rolen hatless or logoless on his career photo (the default is the Phils, in his case).
The Hall has the power to tell Wade Boggs he can't be sporting a Devil Rays cap on his plaque. It should have told Jimmy Hunter and Maddux and McGriff that this brandless option was not available, and I'm stunned you and others support this atrocity.
That said, I can see a no-logo cap for McGriff, but why in the hell wouldn't Maddux have been depicted as a Brave? Twice as many WAR, 61 more wins, 24 fewer losses, 5 more top 5 CYA finishes, and 27 more postseason games with Atlanta than with the Cubs.
That said, I don't like logo-less caps on HOF plaques either. Feels like a cop out. Especially in a case like Halladay's when the correct choice was obvious.
But if he has to be in, I have to agree with SoSH - logoless caps are nonsense. McGriff should have an ATL cap; he may have been a better player in TOR and SD, but he was undoubtedly at his most famous as a Brave ... 3 of his 5 AS teams and a prominent contributor to a World Series championship.
If he or the Hall decided TOR instead, fair enough, no argument; he wasn't actually a great player in ATL for the most part. But he has sentimental ties to Tampa? Who freaking cares? He was an utterly unremarkable player by the time he got to Tampa, it's ridiculous that his time there would be a factor, even indirectly.
I'm fine when the correct choice is obvious and the hof letting them know that the player has little to no say in that situation. I just don't see any reason to force a logo for a player who isn't readily identified with a particular team. If Rolen would have said no logo, that would have been just as good of a choice in my opinion. Saying that Heck in the case of Rolen, the correct choice is the Phillies, not the Cardinals, but because of how things happened in Philly, I get there is a bit of left over tension and the player has a different preference, but I would get a logoless cap, it just makes sense.
I agree that Maddux's case for a Braves' cap isn't quite the slam dunk that Boggs' was, since he did have a very good start to his career with the Cubs. But as you can see by the numbers I cited above, if it's not a slam dunk then it's an easy layup.
This, right here. McGriff's career WAR is itself an underwhelming 56.2 (I use 62 as my informal cutoff line) and the most he ever got for one team is the 19.4 he logged in 578 games as a Blue Jay. (That's probably not a record, but, geez.)
Other notably low totals in FWBAHFOTIWTWTMWTEHFAST (not an exhaustive check, just going through people with comparatively low career WAR):
Rick Ferrell (11.9, BOS)
Deacon White (10.7, BUF) - schedule length caveats apply (would probably go to the Boston NA team if adjusted)
Jim O'Rourke (18.5, NYG)
Pitchers:
Bruce Sutter (18.5, CHC)
Rollie Fingers (12.1, OAK)
Lee Smith (19.0, CHC)
Rube Marquard (17.0, NYG)
Rich Gossage (18.8, NYY)
Hoyt Wilhelm (16.2, CHW)
The itinerant closers make a lot of sense here, given the difficulty of putting up big single-season WAR numbers in the role.
You must be Registered and Logged In to post comments.
<< Back to main